01-14-85 PC Agenda GOLDEN `VALLEY PLANNING COAIl�IISSION ,
(Civic Center, 7800 Golden Va11ep 8oad)
� January 14, 1985
7:00 P.M.
AGENDA
I. APPROVAL OF MINUTES - �GEMBER 10, 1984
II. SET DATE FOR IATFOBMAL PZJBLIC HEARING
APPLIGANT: General Mills, Inc.
LOCATION: 8800 and 9300 Betty Crocker Drive
REQIIEST: Approval of Rezoniag from Open Development to Bueiness and
Professional Offices
iII. INFORMAL Pt1BLIC HEARING - PUD AMENDMENT PRELIMINARY DESIGN PLAN
APPLICANT: Charles S. McCrossan
LOCATIONs 812 Lilac Drive North
REQUEST: Approval of Preliminary Design Plan for Amendment to PUD �42,
• North Lilac Drive Addition
IV. INFORMAL PUBLIC HEARING - PITD PRELIMINARY DESIGN PLAN.
APPLICANT: City of Golden Valley
LOCATION: 7500 O1son Memorial Hi�hway
REQUEST: Approval of Preliminary Design Plan for PUD �47, Va11ey Square
Plaza
V. INFORMAL PiTBLIC HEARING - PUD AMENDMENT PRELIMINARY DESIGN PLAN
APPLICANT: Bor-Son Iavestment Properties Corporation
LOCATION: 2345-2385 and 2412-2462 Mendelsaohn Lane North
BEQUEST: Approval af Prel3minarq Desi$n Pl,an for PiJD �30-B, Medlep Park
Towahouses, Amandment �2
� -
� . . . . .. . . . . . � . . . �. 3�..:..
, _ � _.
_.. . _ �� _,.r _
� ._. .� .,. r
� ;�
i
I` ;
i VI. EEQUEST FOR �AIVEB OF �'HE PLAITING CRDINANCE
�
APPLICANT: John sad Beatrice Schroth
� LOCATION: 843 Winnetka Avenue South �
;
i REQUI3ST: Approval of Lot Division for Tzansfer of Portion of Oae Lot to !
iAd�aceat Lot ;
;
� VIi• RLPORTS ON HRA MEETINGS - DECEMBER 11, 1984 AND JANUARY 6, 1985 '
i
VIII. REPORT ON BZA MEETING - DECEMBER 11, 1984 �
I
t I%• REPORTS ON CITY COIINCIL MEETINGS - DECEMBER 17, 1984 AND JANUARY 2, 1985
i
I
I g• ATTENDANCE AT ZONING INSTITUTE ;
I �
` _ �
i
;
�
I �
j i
I � I
i �
�
i
I �
� . I
i �
i
i i
� I
i.
I
I I
i
I j
! �
I
I
I �
� �
� ;I
� i
� i
i `i
�
�
,
i i
�
{ � ,
� �
i
I
i .. .
f. ; . : , - , .: _. _,.: ... .>:. > i
`---__ _ _'_._ .._'._._. _.___.._._ .__-_"--._____-_ _-__.______'-.__..-_."'"----_.-.___ "_ ___- _---_---_.___ _- -.___-__-_--._ ._....J
MINUTES OF THE GOLDEN VALLEY
PLANNING COMMISSION
� December 10, 1984
A regular meeting of the Planning Commission was held in the Council Chambers of
the Civic Center, 7800 Golden Valley Road, Golden Valley, MN. Vice Chairman
Prazak as Acting Chairman called the meeting to order at 7:00 P.M.
Those present were Cormnissioners Leppik, McCracken-Hunt, Prazak, and Singer.
Also present were Mark Grimes, Planning and Redevelopment Director, Alda
Peikert, City Planner, and Towhid Kazi, Planning Intern. Those absent were
Commissioners Russell and Schmidt. Commissioner McAleese was not present at the
beginning of the meeting.
I. APPROVAL OF MINUTES - November 26, 1984
Commissioner Leppik corrected the minutes of the November 26, 1984 Planning
Cor�anission meeting on Page 3, Item V, third paragraph, first sentence, which
should read as "Commissioner McCracken-Hunt asked if the existing house meets
the setback requirements".
It was moved by Commissioner Singer, seconded by Commissioner Leppik and carried
unanimously to approve the minutes as corrected.
Commissioner McAleese arrived at the meeting.
II. SET DATE FOR INFORMAL PUBLIC HEARING - PUD AMENDMENT PRELIMINARY DESIGN
� PLAN —
APPLICANT: Charles S. McCrossan
LOCATION: 812 Lilac Drive North
REQUEST: Approval of Preliminary Design Plan for Amendment to PUD #42,
North Lilac Drive Addition
Acting Chairman Prazak introduced this agenda item and recognized Mr. Roger
Ulstad who was present to represent the proponent. Mr. Ulstad confirmed that
the recommended informal public hearing date is satisfactory to the proponent.
It was moved by Commissioner Singer, seconded by Commissioner Leppik and
approved unanimously to set an informal public hearing date of January 14, 1985
for consideration of the amendment requested by Mr. Charles S. McCrossan to PUD
#42, North Lilac Drive Addition.
III. SET DATE FOR INFORMAL PUBLIC HEARING - PUD PRELIMINARY DESIGN PLAN
, —
APPLICANT: City of Golden Valley
LOCATION: 7500 Olson Memorial Highway
REQUEST: Spproval of Preliminary Design Plan for PUD #47, Valley Square
• Plaza
Acting Chairman Prazak introduced this agenda item and asked staff to add any
further comments. City Planner Alda Peikert reviewed the staff report.
Planning Commission Minutes - December 10, 1984 -2-.
• It was moved by Commissioner Leppik, seconded by Commissioner McCracken-Hunt and
carried unanimously to set an informal public hearing date of January 14, 1985 �
for consideration of the Preliminary Design Plan for PUD #47, Valley Square
Plaia.
IV. INFORMAL PUBLIC HEARING - CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT
APPLICANT: Jim Lupient Oldsmobile Company
LOCATION: 900 Pennsylvania Avenue South
REQUEST: Approval of an Automobile Repair and Reconditioning Operation
in an Industrial Zoning District
Acting Chairman Prazak introduced this agenda item and asked staff for further
comments. Alda Peikert, City Planner reviewed the staff report.
Commissioner Leppik asked about the parking requirements for this particular
use. Ms. Peikert reviewed parking requirements in the Ordinance and parking
provisions in the proposal .
Commissioner Leppik then asked about the previous use in the building and if
there were any parking problems. Ms. Peikert stated that when the previous
business was in operation there were some parking problems.
� Commissioner McCracken-Hunt inquired if there is adequate parking in other
locations operated by Mr. Lupient. Ms. Peikert stated that at times when the
inventory was high enough, there were reports of some congestion of cars. Mark
Grimes, Planning and Redevelopment Director, stated that there are at least 150
parking spaces available in addition to the 74 parking spaces allocated to Mr.
Jim Lupient in the proposed site.
Acting Chairman Prazak asked if there would be any retail operation in the
building. Ms. Peikert informed the Planning Commission that the City Zoning
Ordinance does not allow retail business in the Industrial Zoning District where
the proposed operation is located.
Acting Chairman Prazak then asked the proponent to describe the proposal . Mr.
Jim Lupient and Mr. Steve Swartz, attorney representing Mr. Jim Lupient, both
introduced themselves to the Planning Commission. Mr. Swartz stated that the
staff report was adequate.
Commissioner Leppik asked the proponent about the work or materials involved in
reconditioning of cars. Mr. Lupient explained the three kinds of activities
involved in this operation, which are new car "get ready", including rust
proofing, used car repair and reconditioning, and heavy duty mechanical repair.
Acting Chairman Prazak asked if there will be any painting of cars in this
operation. Mr. Lupient stated that the painting will be done in the body shop
located at another site.
_ �
Planning Commission Minutes - December 10, 1984 -3-
• Commissioner Leppik asked if there would be any heavy duty overhaul or engine
repairs and inquired about the noise caused by these activities. Mr. Lupient
stated that there would be heavy duty engine repair and overhaul in this opera-
tion and the noise level should not have any adverse impact on the residences
which are located one and a half blocks away from the proposed site.
Acting Chairman Prazak then opened the informal public hearing for public input.
Mr. Mike Larson, 830 Rhode Island Avenue South, asked about the location of the
parking spaces allocated to the proposed operation. Alda Peikert, City Planner,
stated the 74 parking spaces allocated to Mr. Lupient will be located at the
northeast corner of the building and the access is off of Pennsylvania Avenue
South.
Mr. Larson then asked if Mr. Lupient will use the parking space on the west
side of the building. Ms. Peikert stated that Mr. Lupient's operation wi11 not
use the parking space on the west side or the rooftop of the building.
Acting Chairman Prazak asked if the warehouse/office supply portion of the
building use will require the use of the parking space on the west side or the
rooftop of the said building. Ms. Peikert stated that the warehouse/office
supply use of the building will use the parking space on the west side and/or
the rooftop.
• Mr. Larson then inquired about a sign already mounted up on the site. Mr.
Swartz stated that the sign is legal because a portion of the building is being
used for parts storage, which is a permitted use in the Industrial Zoning
District.
Mr. Larson again asked about the parking space that will be used by Mr.
Lupient's operation. Mr. Swartz, representative of Mr. Lupient, stated that the
proposed Jim Lupient operation does not have any legal right under the lease
with the building owner to use parking space beyond the allocated 74 parking
spaces on the northeast corner of the said building.
Commissioner Leppik asked whether the proponent will be using the parking spaces
on the west side or the rooftop if there is an overflow of cars. Mr. Lupient
stated that other building occupants would use the parking space on the west
side or the rooftop as needed but still parking space use will be less than
under previous occupancy.
Mr. Larson asked if there could be "no parking" signs on both sides of the ser-
vice road since a number of people park on the service road creating congestion.
Ms. Peikert stated that parking on the service road, which was a problem under
the previous occupancy, should not be a problem with the new building tenants.
Hearing no one, Acting Chairman Prazak closed the informal public hearing.
Commissioner Leppik expressed her concern over the possible noise generated by
the operation since there is no buffer between the proposed industrial site and
• the nearby residences. .
Planning Commission Minutes - December 10, 1984 -4-
� Acting Chairman Prazak asked about the distance from the proposed operation to
the closest residence.
Mr. Grimes stated that the distance is almost 500 feet and the doors of the
building are on the east side. Therefore, the noise should not disturb the resi-
dences.
The Planning Commission� then reviewed the findings on the ten items listed in
Section 20.03 of the City Zoning Ordinance.
It was moved by Commissioner Leppik, seconded by Commissioner Singer and carried
unartimously to recommend City Council approval of the Conditional Use Permit
requested by Jim Lupient for an automobile repair and reconditioning operation
at 900 Pennsylvania Avenue South in an Industrial Zoning District, subject to the
listed nine recommendations made by staff which are listed below:
1. Building area and site usage shall conform to the Partial Plot Plan and Usage
Layout dated November 14, 1984, prepared by Albitz Design, Inc. , and sub-
mitted with the Conditional Use Permit application.
2. There shall be no parking of automobiles associated with Jim Lupient
Oldsmobile Company on site other than in the 74 parking spaces designated
for Jim Lupient Oldsmobile use on the Partial Plot Plan dated November 14,
1984.
• 3. The number of parking spaces required by the City Zoning Code for other uses
within the total building shall be provided on site in addition to the 74
parking spaces allocated to Jim Lupient Oldsmobile Company as shown on the
Partial Plot Plan dated November 14, 1984.
4. There shall be no parking of automobiles in the street or on existing
landscaped areas. .
5. There shall be compliance with all requirements of the Fire Code and all
recommendations of the City Fire Marshal .
6. There shall be compliance with all requirements of the Uniform Building Code
and all recommendations of the City Building Inspector.
7. Signage on the site shall conform with the City Sign Regulations and appro-
val of the City Building Inspector.
8. There shall be no outside storage of materials or refuse.
9. Any failure to comply with one or more of the conditions of approval shall
be grounds for revocation of the Conditional Use Permit.
V. REPORT ON CITY COUNCIL MEETING - DECEMBER 4, 1984
Commissioner McCracken-Hunt provided the Planning Commission ari th a report on the
• December 4, 1984 City Council meeting.
Planning Commission Minutes - December 10, 1984 -5-
� YI. AMENDMENTS TO THE ZONING ORDINANCE RELATED TO GROUP HOMES
It was moved by Commissioner Singer, seconded by Conanissioner McCracken-Hunt and
carried unanimously to recommend that the City Council set a public hearing date of
February 5, 1985 for consideration of Zoning Ordinance amendments related to
group homes.
VIII. APPRECIATION TO COMMISSIONER SINGER �
On behalf of the Planning Commission, Acting Chairman Prazak thanked
Commissioner Singer for his contribution to the Commission and the community at
large and expressed appreciation of support provided by Intern Towhid Kazi during
his internship.
The rr�eting was adjourned at 7:45 P.M.
Respectfully submitted,
Gary Prazak, Acting Chairman Margaret Leppik, Secretary
�
�
T0: Golden Vallep Planning Commission '
� FROM: Alda Peikert, City Planner
DATE: January 9, 1985
RE: Set Date for Informal Public Hearing - Rezoning of General Mills Property
North of Betty Crocker Drive from Open Development to Business and
Professional Offices
General Mills, Inc. proposes rezoning of 47.885 acres of vacant General Mills
property located to the east of County 8oad 18 and to the north of Betty Crocker
Drive from the Open Development Zoning District to the Business and Professional
Offices Zoning District. The rezoning is proposed in anticipation of construc-
tion of one office building on either the easterly portion of the property at an
address of appro$imately 8800 Betty Crocker Dr�ve or the westerly portion of the
property at an address of approgima.tely 9300 Bettq Crocker Drive.
Staff suggeats that the Planning Commission set an informal public hearing date
of January 28, 1985 for consideration of the request received from General
Mi11s, Inc. for rezoning of property at 8800 and 9300 Betty Crocker Drive to the
Business and Professional Offices Zoning District.
� Attachment: Site Location Map
•
% �y� I
; o
I , �
� i
` s I
s�
°s �
, I /`
�
ey gsp �
• �� �o �
0
I ,J ,� '
I r�i✓ I
• �a �
�o� o ,
, sr� �� �
�s,
� o.
bm �� �
�•� „-;.n 69•oZ•9 o�r rx •N '3A� �ru•e p�r 3N008 � � ^,a r .
4
...aatl Z6'8f42....^ � .
� I 1 i►► �'. _ c>�ce ,~`�.
1 � � � /''f/ m '
\ � - /.%" ! N
1 " : �I
O I
� e / .f' �/ �o
. wJL' f �u
� �� �' .:� �v
1 '''•� / . /� . . ry,:, �
a 1 •' � l �J�/� � / h� i
,- ��� _ - t` p i
Q � � D ap Y u � J O�'
,\ � ° � � 8 / ',�' �` 7' i
x e" • `o�e�� `a�►� ►� s� to�i Q �
' p� o e ru.t� $� r A .
♦ '
,= i ��.� . st��3nv af11V�30 s�a;` �.� � �'
-=�--- --- .�
, 9 6fY K► fd� ii►��._�. �e• �f' �
� (lSlt� - � f
, �� • � y,j °' W a
� � • ' >
.� =g� ;�/�
oo� �'°. � ��e� a � t.' /'�l a�o�yi
oS� � � r�4' .��
K'!t el •& � ' � �'
> .t7i % ' (Y1li;e' e(e1Li)� � ! � �
e '
a e'• A �e' � a �
d S9�1�, J r��29.Y'� eyx// �
� � • ' ; ~ 1 / �
. w tl ^
o � 1do ° 0 ° .- a �� �
a
�eu o! ^OI►aSl• � . 0 � �
�;--------�---"� w s.3Atl N��$N3$ ,��i
e
.
,�,-_ _ _„��1
�.""".._.."_...^ t�'o4. B ' ' �
Fi►. /80 [►i G1f 6F[ Cdi�
N. � V � � � �
o a��1�15gi. _ -�- -- - - -
�;:r��6"'. H�iti 49 N Y �'�' � _ � �
!' 49 p '
�
.y . m e q�Z g �! g
��x y4 . '..`r'-�<`a _ -_ seu�:at g� • - ir.: -------�--------- -�
---------
_ �
-Y=-.. . .�,-:,_. _ szes -��� �
o •$ - °s``�' �
1 r-• ! '
. �
i
t ., �� � � • • �
� "
.� i -�,
� A ` Jb � N
N �• w Sa�4' o ,� ��
« � � . � • _ _ P � n:
.
`G` ' s o
�.
' � Y� z°'
K.. g .,� � � .
---- ...........'-'-- -_"'�' • v .
i- ���: � �
,� _ °°'�'
o F5 • � � ~ � �' 0.
n . � yd �.1 ��
� � � ": ,P�r,. 5.1�
J p
� � �`' � � 'F y4 � oy` ��N
- (L4o1 i `.`�� ,i � r
t"� � .
i zy�O` . ,o �
�,^I �� �� �\ :+`�.r 5����-E
� � ,� \ if � F� 1
. ' I 1�� �' e, � o
J� r w
' � � '^y '�ri 0.�4it
_ •1 '' i ti��°�"E �`-r��,
r , ~o. � � ; �r� ^ '�, j �
� :.� � 1� � , � o,a o 1 ;
s' s o � ' ���s r �
/� .n - •g� °�j , I
I �n ps.y fi' � i ,�
o • ` I
� � � r�' \ ' . i -.i,' ,��,. rf �Ji
I JI o I � . � , _- � �Ol. � 1
.3 x �8`,�,' N��J � � ' �.W. �F!
� �'.7„•• ` . � 1,�.6 i �
�s�' � � . I t4 lSp : � t�6 �
O�
� �� '� q "d... '
t � ,�°�'f T7VA N301DD d0 Al�� '°�
+u' I
_.�.$e•tie� ... .�•s(•�qr- M ... iPbi2-•.2:..
..i, . - `_'�4G K
-�tH-',..u�Mwi�d d0 All� ..:. --._..-•., r�4oy�
T0: Golden Valley Planning Co�ission
. FROM: Alda Peikert, City Planner
DATE: January 9, 1985
RE: Informal Public Hearing - Preliminary Design Plan for Amendment to PUD
�42, North Lilac Drive Addition
Mr. Charles S. McCrossan, current owner of the former Holiday Motor flotel pro-
perty at 812 Lilac Drive North, requests an amendment to PUD �42, North Lilac
Drive Addition. The originally approved PUD was requested by Coto Corporation,
previous owner of the property, and proposes division of the former Soliday
Motor Hotel property into three parcels, one of which would remain in
restaurant/motel use and the other two of which would be converted to office
condominium use. Mr. McCrossan provided financing to Coto Corporation for the
conversion pro3ect and has now assumed ownership of the property.
The Golden Valley City Council on February 7, 1984 approved the General Plan of
Development for PUD ��42, North Lilac Drive Addition, sub�ect to twelve con-
ditions. 1�ao of the twelve original PUD approval conditions are sub�ect to
amendment at the request of Mr. McCrossan. The two conditions addressed in the
proposed PUD amendment are the following:
1. Purchase fram the railroad and dedication by the proponent to the Hennepin
County Park Reserve District for regional trail purposes of 25 feet of
• railroad right of way ad�acent to the north property line of the PUD site.
The property purchased from the railroad and dedicated to the Park Reserve
District shall be included in the final plat of PUD ��42, North Lilac Drive
Addition.
2. Installation of a chain link security fence a minimum of six feet in height
on or within the property line on the eastern and northern perimeters of the
PUD site. Maintenance of the fence shall be the responsibility of the PUD
owners.
Subsequent to conditional General Plan of Development approval, one of the part-
ners in Coto Corporation purchased from the railroad the property required for
re�gional trail dedication. The property was not included in the original site
owned by Coto Corporation and transferred to Mr. McCrossan. In the attached
application cover letter Mr. McCrossan states that he has been unable to obtain
the former railroad property required for regional trail dedication and proposes
payment of a cash fee for regional trail acquisition as an alternative to dedi-
cation. Representatives meeting with staff on behalf of Mr. McCrossan indicated
acceptance of staff suggestion of a fee of $30,000 based on documentation in the
f i1e that the purchase price on the railroad property was $29,600. The Hennepin
County Park reserve District has the authority to condemn the property required
for regional trail at such time as this segment of the planned regional trail is
constructed.
•
Attached are eopies of the General Plan of Development without the additional
property from the railroad, of the final plat proposed without the railroad pro-
• perty, and of the approved final plat with the railroad property. As
illustrated by these graphics, the dedication for regional trail included a
twelve foot atrip of property along the northern perimeter of the original pro-
perty. Staff suggests as easement for open space purposes over this twelve
feet.
The proponent requests �dification of the requirement for security fencing to
require estension along the east perimeter of the site only as far south as the
northeast corner of the southerly two story building. There are no windows on
the east side of the building requiring protection, and the distance from the
building to the property line is minimal allowing inadequate space for fence
installation. Department of Public Safety staff concurs with the proposed �di-
fication.
Recommendation
Mr. McCrossan indicates through his representatives that he intends to complete
PUD �42, North Lilac Drive Addition, ae originally approved with the ezception
of the regional trail dedication and modification of the security fence. Based
on the conclusion that completion of the PUD and reuse of the �ildings and pro-
perty is in the best interests of the City of Golden Valley, etaff suggeste that
the Planning Commission recommend City Council approval of the amendment to PUD
�42, North Lilac Drive Addition, requested by Mr. Charles S. McCrossan sub�ect
to the following conditions:
� 1. A twelve foot strip of property along the northerly perimeter of the property
shall be platted as an outlot and dedicated by separate instrument as an ease-
ment for open space purposes.
2. A fee of $30,000 shall be paid to the City of Golden Vallep prior to appro-
val of the Final Plat and shall be deaignated for purposes of regional trail
acquis3tion. The City of Golden Valley may uae the funds for acquisition of
any segment of regional trail within the City of Golden Valley at any future
date. If the funds are not required for regional trail acquisition within
f ifteen years from the date of approval of the Final Plat, the City of
Golden Valley may uae the funds for general open space use.
3. A chain link security fence a minimum of six feet in height shall be
installed on or within the property line and outside of the open space ease-
ment on the northern perimeter of the site and on the ea.stern perimeter of
the site as far south as and abutting the northeast corner of the southerly
two story building. Maintenance of the fence shall be the responsibility of
the owners.
Attachments:
1. Site Location Map
2. Application Cover Letter
3. General Plan of Development
• 4. Final Plats (2)
.�
T
- � , � �� . � ; M o
�, j� p � a h SI
�' / d, M v �
' i0�� h m
�B 2tF J . ?i' � � � � u
.�..�~" � �• �r- �� �o �
ea . z o ,ss�
�=j �,, SL w�. W v �
t ,, oe �
;1`'� '°' 1�
5��.,,a'��� N W ss ac9 ct
Q � _ �
��ob Nl .
`1:`- • ��O��P � • � ~ �
� � + 0 0 g�o� . . u
°' ' « � Z :� �
�e i = --- - - - ---- -�-- -- - ---- - - --- 1� r
���� � --- OOey.'-- O
� oq • �
I ,y,`� ^( o N
I a Q �
� � `I "� �e N .. ?iO ►.
o N
; � h
�! � = 3•` � � / h --oEi •- �
I N� � \� � �n
1 � �I y�' � N _
1 � . `; ''� � � � � 90 6BB
, � � : _ � � p �
, • _ �(
e� °oi � � b c uG !� � � Li
v -
�II�,�,.,�f0, � � ,. ,
V �' � W G7 0
� °�sm •{ �Q � O n � a J.� .� �
,l' �'��� W � 3 S • w
n
��•�fS3 �5 � o S C� 'b� J+; 7 i!`y +
.R � e
i�'•�.��_ �z o r D�q'M 1o'I �i�9�I ��'� �+, i7
6�1ei • �..• 7Ra �n N fo
I .C$ •` � � t ° e�(SO4�,g ~ t
v
It6 /Oc ; C 'J ��.I � �
on j::1' --- -- ,r•
.� �` � .:, X a ' N w 6t j ►-.
• • •� o o � � . N.�° .n 10 U o h.� � N
�
OD 01 .� �vi • t . , I .°OS � �ro°e � � �
i'a �.�b � ��% " � �I N � ` S2!�, .
01► f�G11 � L�.d � `,�:: � � I V �
� O �
P ' E. � �e a� C� ' t � /8tb7 j0"!�b• � 1
1� � . �.+�+�i '� '---� .•'�f `��e. �� . >Cb
� ,1 �� s F f� S b t 5 ,
�� ?� n l�f ' I('1SS� �. I
'bCtf �� � QpI J i. o . v b r
C-) N
C q' ,
Q 0�. ti1M� �� •
( �.� �..� N � �� / i
� L �
I Q � .. � � � \ � i
f v o1'^ � J� � V !
O e � � � � ``� i
� � ' .�'. � ` � C �• �
C '�'r(� L •C �•
+ct +a, d •- / I
st C �0 ' a�'.
� N l- '^ ,^ �,V;
r.�i� r C7 F- � .^ ` j .
.i.r� �r„ • u ` I
0 '�'� �`� .
• I � ~ � e�+ . � I
O(I ( �
� V — —— 2!9 ' ��� (
_ �� �q��
oos � � '�
� «; ' �� 1'���ti
; V � , ; t� �e��. .� .
i �+, 'so
._'-o i---�- ' � °d itr
� ' ' .. °� 8 .
d
e i . m ��6
'N'!�'LLL•°
. `7 1 v� e► j,.:.'. � •05
.. . I ..... •s�b 8�'4l2 ..
IZ'11'BI��l'44'�aS '�07 !�/
.-• . -
.
i�vember 26, 19@4
Ms_ Alda Peikert
Assistant Planner
City of Golden Valley
7800 Golden Valley Road
6olden Valley, Minnesota 55427
RE: Variance Requested of P_U_D. No. 42
City Council Approved March 22, 1984
Component: A-4 The developer shall install on property
dedicated ta the Hennepin County Park Reserve
District for trail purposes a screening
hedge alon9 the perimeter of the north parking
lot as indicated on the approved landscape plan
dated January 25, 1984_
� Dear Ms. Peikert:
One of the conditians of the approved P.U.D_ Na_ 42
required the developer to acquire additional property from
the Chicago Northwestern Railroad far the purpose of regional
trails.
This acquisition is impossible to acquire_ As fee
owner of the property I would like to propose for yaur
consideration, in lieu of land dedication, a park fee payable
to the City of Golden Valley, the amount to be determined by
the City Council and its Park Board. The funds could be
placed in escrow or used in any fashion so desired_ In
addition, as owner, I would be agreeable to provide an
easement through the existing property as may be designated
by the appropriate body and staff_
Your consideration of my request is appreciated_
Thank you_
rel ,
. ' 'l�
C arles McCrossan
•
`�...:.
, -� ... .
� i' �__„� �
� ` � \� I
+ � _I' .. 4t"L�1 . � \��
�� I
� �•���
� _ _ , � ,.:
• , ~ \ Ti
, t � �
,
. ,, � �. A� \ � -" I
�� \ �'.4�:.� ::. � �
.. \ � .�!�� � ��Lq`i`Oy� � • {
�.�.t�'�•:',a'}+�_ �r3 �
\ � : .��r.�g,N�.4�r�»+�t';��•:• �' � i ~\ /
� � . _ .ti,�.,►!^. ',r,~ _ . \.
\ ` •,p. ; � � a�:rc-r4 Y �•
� \\ I :• .� � , �� �I�� �� ��� f
�n �. 7� r ��,�i�i�E. t,.
� � .��_� , � �` ; . 1 0
. \\ � :�.� � "}° �� �� } " �`
. R � .Y �,. �,,r� p k ;:
'��c' \ '�, , ' + `+,y•:'.x:R,`::�s'v�'�F> �
� �� \�\ °\\ - -•�t�� � '� �i��� ��F:: 6 ' .
i �a 3 g' � �i
�\ _ �,w. ..` , * �� �' •OL� � �
. �t0 \ "� +r.: _�:..�+.4 _
t V '�•f .. :� �.r y..+i �� �S
� � ;..0 .i ..;��'. `:�; ` *p1: � �' /
_ pJ . ; .`.�,'._ k�. .��..,, :y.:�a.4- �
� < ,j �� � ; r< , .!'(:!.. ;
2r 2 , t.e.�.,� r`�#. :i t. � ;'
Q i 1 / ',;�-p•• 1�4. - •'-.# :,i`-i,
2 W �fi ' .l �� - ' '.�'s�a." � j �
Qa �' ,�� � 1 a • � A i i � /
�C� � ���,''� � • .� � i_, � �• ; �
y: � V , t �- � . �
� � M ;��
2 :w., , � ; *• .+ " ,
� :..,�. I � —_ ��tti��, '. , �
..N i . .
� � I i *
I •� �
g ,�� �f ` i Q
.. I� }, � 'tl f.'��'�» d: ; '� I I � �
� �Q � ' �• � ' ' S
',� • e' ' '� � I
. i � '. :., . ' 0
� � >:
; : � --'��-- --- -- ?•�a-y F � U
I t �� i rs' 7. s � ,
. . o�J � ' ', r� �, 1 �;��fj;�F a � �i
� y . � � t .
r r'o g f-.- �i. : .;,,. . ,� .
� , � $� '''� + � � ! �•-
_ ' .��J� �� -4
I =' .� �.. `��� •
�� . i\ � i• .` 't � � i J :
� � f—fi., `' � �.,,'�' ; , r 1 – �
� � � �, � : � ,� , � a I �a �
d' � •'i.;ti.� � � 0 t i ' �� �
. e.-�, •s �, �• N �11 's.... � �' � I
. _.� . ; _ . � � - . zw-_ � � � � � I
. f � \ • I g� �' � ' j �_i �
s•_ � ��`\\\ . I � ,' ; -- --- -- ," ,�� �:�j ': �a I.
; ,�Fr• \�.\ I '�; �+�:�� '.� :• �1 J `.;;';y%•' �I� � F-'
-� �� : � ,� „',\. � � �,�, , , ;,� , , � ��
.r,., � � �y\iK , \ - '+� N . ' ,� :� ! �
Z \• ♦. 1 . ,
.� .�• A�b-\.��\ `� �/�' 4/ /r< �'� s�S'�'� I . lII
� :9 ..� .'� " _ . ...Lo%9' 1 t� Q I
. \i �� ° U ��:�.
, r •.' _ � 9.. • �
` . SI � � r D�;��\\\ �� -- ��y/i i0 �.'O ( 1 - �!Y S I � I � F-
� �a' �✓ N_ � I i O
T � \ r��r���`������` ` ti � ' ——=— i ,.i . � ' � .� Z I
����' �— \ r �1 ���� _ o' � � � '..:. + i � I
;,: I;1 - � ,.� �---a ,.' --�._ - ��� � �� � �� ,;i �
�`' :!' i� �s 1 � � 1 .�`' • ► . . , � ;.�, , I � ���
� I
�r• .�,�. O ` y '"'"` yJ �'r I • •� I�i
�r ' � '�, � ' .� I
.f�' ; ` �..�— Y� � ' if� : •' o E' � I i
;:�`� �e 2 ,� _ �� am- r�.�s' . I I ro ,
•`f � �'—_ �!� � 3�• �` rr 1,�y� � C i �II I
.4.i�::��� '�y i x $ i M i. y$ '� . I �I
(� ''
. A: ' ••••. y I
��� t �. l�a � r .`'`�'
� � ! .�—���LV�� -.� �,
— `� r. ` _ _ ; � ,�-�5 .�[_- ; :_ .;T?: � , V4i_E �'I i
• 1�/ ,�.�( _ � ��•_ {- �il��_�1�*,' ♦i■ `� --~^ ~•/i�'\�` w• ��
.. . � . �.�s_.�.. .�. � � .. .. .. •e .
' ._'. I "'"fl'iL4"" J � ,,, .:.,� \„,�� .. � ; �
g �t e �M . _��`•�'.���I i
- _ .J f� I�'I
i I' I
. 1 99'IV79 Vd 'iS 1 W b �
�" l
— _-�- �a � � i
�LL ;
1 I Z � � ` .
2
i ; O � 2�� �
G �
� N V1
� �� �
�
V 2
J?y�Q�
� 1 ��\ �Q W
I 3 0 o OC
i �
N � ,1.�r„{,vG,t-
� � j`��'77./�
I ; � � I .f37;'�4
� � 4 � '6/'�3S�o y/i�rl N do 9NI71S 3M 2N1
� � NL/M 73�y�trdONb'do1SVg138� o5'B6D 9Ni�7\\
i , O �
( ; A�'I N�oN
' � �l .g ---S/'bL�°-
� �. -- -
I � -��r - 00'91�/ ..� fr/A'l �
2 $� w�� -oo'St�-•-
� �F � C � ' ��
„ ,
� a �, ; � Q 8 �3 .? �„� .
o � ; � o �' I „�,�' ti
I . � � p 8 ; � �N �� �.•,� Q
� � ¢ � C S I I � � Q��� _D 8 W
� � �J� N riiecw �vsa . �
Z � om 3 ��� m9L 3 �'� .fisY�,s9� � �
� � � � � '� N .d�: ��ey�����— ��2� N � O
, J1 H � I � '� �� 4� .
� 3 � � �a� ^�� "o����j ��� \\ � � '
� Z � ` 2 �, a� ,},G�� �!�•• g� O
I O z � ' W' ;-�- � \��� ., i �� --
n, o�y��
� r i � Y � �_�� � \ �� F2s :p
� .� , 2 , 2 '�Oj_. __ W
I � � `: .� CI � � � g ti \� �65'd' N�N �ft
I �i a '° I � g ti 0 � ' I \_.° 4�
� n i N , .J � .
� im `� ' m ' � a Q � I i �—
�Q � ..��,... __i� 8 � � 2 � �=`;--- �
; � ,�� n g ; g � � l I
I 0 °3 L � " ' ' �
�6 � � � � I �
� � �z ; � � �J � � i
I FQ � ,3 . '' _� � i y
W Q �Q� Q� oo�S9 �U
.. I � V •�VQ m�'I M1d�ON � � 1 \
W o .� �� �� �a �� � j
> -----�-`�_ -�_?, a � l ��-`� �\ u
i °
� ,.�.��_. ��� , � \ ' ; 2
' �— , �L ��b�\ ���
�� e"�. a�. � "S�� i m �
Q 8 ;�n � V s�0,.� ���
�� ,�,� � ,. � ��:,�� ; ` �
' 2 �` ,' J ���� � �
V a �
r �
i � N � I,`` m N� i a //�
J � �• - 9 n �
S
a
; � � 8, � � �a°�.2y, --- ----- __���� i
� � ' ` N1ataN reri'Lb! � +'• �
I �y �I '�70/ 'JN :�MH Blll1S� � /e
� @ 1f I do 9Ni7 'MO��.[78g1^�V3 BN1 �
; = I � I $� i
� � , � ,
, � I � � ��?f7; G',ti' .�( t'/Y!f:�'.'.Y a'1 b'J_S
� � � � l
o � ,
� I� ;� � _ _
,
� �
' --a0�6411--- " - ��-O5 6b:
�6�L��6Z 1 '6/-�.� �3Nr.1•agM 9YL
i � -
� i N FZ
� o �., ���
c �
o� � ��
V ' �?�
''�` `�w
3 0 �o�0
J
�
NJ ,'�'•c�,-�,c,c y
� � S�`7C•7'`/1
2 n �377E:9
1y l, � (/'7�S yo b//�N/Y do 3Nl71S3M BN1
� � � 1 p � hl/M 73'7'7dcYt/CONb' doLSV91�9! a$'B6D 9M7\\
� 6��(({ ^
O ,J (�
� � .�,., ' NI.�U'N S/�bbtJ
� � � ' =F- `' OoL9/ ..� S/'OiZ
, 2 � ... ,..�.• '4i � --00'9L/••• i
' I � ' `F,,,� ,� g� �'� � +
p g •a. Q g `� I ,p r�
� � 0� . ' I3 �� N ut N �� '°�°'� , N
� � • Q .; �� 8 Z . � ` �� I o;►� ; Q
. aa � � r aQ ^ p pW
� � n Ip�� 8 4• � f-�-` -- �
� �JI : o Kcaew �v.a . . <
� � � � � W� oost 3 .SS� S' �j
� � � � m �� . �°� O� �; �vrs. N g F' !u
rW. `W�a � � I 3� .�°: '�eqy:A��2� � ��� (py � �
� 3 .l m � �ry a�� 'Q-a'l��i�'�96� bll.� 11j �
� h L � � �� O� t��/,�a�� F2g�8Y �ti(� i Y�p• a� � ��
� p � p � � �� �_�_ �' �'n� ':2 g': &�.� •!1h--
O O � L ���S i F .
Z �j ��p �'�{ ��i 1 f.1 dQ \�,�2_��,'�Oi... _
� � I a 1 ,mR V�W a '� g ia6 � \:� N�N g
� � 0 i Y� 9 p _.— R
1 � N �` V H S � ' I 3' � F2fo\\�. � H1avN
-I ;14o N � � e ��. I I:O �a/...��•%6'95... .
� r� � N �i � 2 I I0 0 a' I �
� oQR F g n � II$g
� J O ` � +
V �J � N � j � �
J 3 �, .
I �2 � :, � ^ , �
! I � � � p ' � �: w
gn
2e'� °�� � y� '- �
i SQ �p; � �ry ' ao'y9 ��� �`• O
I F. � �NQ jp m MtdbN � 1� :
� ti fli� � O� 3
� w o .� . �.1 ,� 1 �� ,P�� ,
i _ _ � .� �; � �a \\g-� o
� � '-- - -- ats ' � aq 2
i — ? �� e�' �Z��\cS_ , �Q
� I` � `
` ��Q G� ` -S-�� S�� � I m
�I � \ � �� �-o ` I � � N
,�i'ri p O s�`"`t'.�,g•�.. W ,y
n � n�
r . �y � �
�
I s' I �� "'J - O \ ,„ �
� �` o '�� m ��� \s a
I �
� ,
� � , °r` m \�N �
� Q I NN ,ih Q ��
� /
� � `�°g.,, Q �i gu�, �Q
� � I � � ` i , � 8 -- �°� -..,� _���' J
� � � �� � � � `` '-M1aO/J ebtbi-�� •• � e
'00/'JN :(M N �l b'1S j •.�
� I Q. V do 9N/7 'MO'y��'�a/91^.V3�N1 8h \
� ( � �m
�
, _ � �
� � I � 'v�7; G','L' :( t'/'✓;�:�'.�,5' �1 bJ_5
� Im ,
O � .
, Z I � ;l � :
� . . __ . __ _ _. _ - __
T0: Golden Valley Planning Commission
• FROM: Mark W. Grimes
DATE: January 9, 1985
RE: Preliminary Design Plan for PUD �47, Valley Square Plaza
Introduction and Background
PUD �47, is the southeastern parcel in the Valley Square Redevelopment area.
United Properties and the Golden Valley HRA have come to an agreement regarding
the development of Area D. Five single family homes, the Spur Gas Station, and
other vacant properties have been purchased bq the HRA for the construction of
Valley Square Plaza. The buildings on the site will be removed in the next few
months to make way for the construction proposed by United Properties.
The original Valley Square Redevelopment Plan indicated that Area D would be
developed into two office buildings totaling 64,000 square feet in floor area
and a transit pulse center at Rhode Island Avenue and Country Club Drive. The
pulse center is no longer a viable idea. The logical alternative approved by
the HRA is to increase the amount of office space on the property as is proposed
by PUD �47.
As permitted by the Zoning Code in Section 15, United Properties is applying for
• a PUD permit to build on the site. The PUD process allows fle$ibility in the
development process, especially in a redevelopment area. The Planning
Commission will first review the preliminarq design plan and make a recommen-
dation to the City Council. After the preliminary design plan is approved by
the City Council, the general plan of development will be presented to the City
Council within 180 days. In the case of Valley Square Plaza, the General Plan
will probably be aubmitted much sooner to the City Council. The Planning
Commission does not review the General Plan unless requested to by the City
Council.
Description of Building and Site
United Properties is proposing the construction of a three story, 81,500 square
f oot office building at the northeast corner of Highway 55 and Rhode Island
Avenue. The total site area is 209,840 square feet or about 4.8 acres.
The following areas should be considered by the Planning Commission in their
review of the preliminary design plan:
A. Parking. The site has 337 parking spaces which exceed the Zoning Code
requirement for office space. The Code requires one space for every 250
square feet of office space. Therefore, the minimum required by the Code is
327 spaces.
•
Of the 337 spaces, 20 spaces will be garage parking under the east half of
the building. The developer may provide another 20 epaces under the north
. half of the building if it is determined it is financially feasible and
desirable as a marketing tool.
B. Access to the Site. Access to the site is from two driveways along Rhode
Island Avenue and one driveway along Country Club Drive. This should pro-
vide adequate access and good parking lot circulation.
No direct access will be available to Sighway 55. Traffic going or coming
f rom the b�ilding must turn at Rhode Island Avenue where there is a stop
light. The new development will increase the rnimber of trips per day
generated from the site. There were about 176 trips per day generated from
the five houses and the gas station. The new denelopment will generate
about 996 trips per day. However, the staff believes that there is adequate
street capacity and traffic controls to handle the added traffic volumes.
C. Drainage. The construction of the building and parking lot wi11 eliminate a
small drainage area on the east end of the site. In order to compensate for
the loss of the drainage area, a storm sewer is pianned for construction
across the site. The preliminary drainage plan submitted by United
Properties for the site has been reviewed by the City Engineer. The pro-
posed drainage of the site must be so designed to "fit in" with the proposed
atorm sewer. The City Engineer believes that the proposed drainage plan
will work with some ad3ustments in catch basin locations. The drainage plan
will be finalized as part of the General Plan.
� D. Landscaping and Sidewalks. The site will be substantially covered with
building or blacktopped parking. However, United Properties plans to well
landscape the remaining areas around the building and parking lot.
Along the west property line (Rhode Island Avenue side), a landscaped berm
is proposed to screen the parked cara from Rhode Island Avenue and the deve-
lopment across the street. It is hoped that the existing mature trees in
the berm area may be saved. It ma.y be determined during construction that a
it maq be difficult to keep the berm and the proposed sidewalk along Rhode
Avenue due to space limitations. It is the staff's recommendation that the
sidewalk be the priority and that the berm be removed or reduced if
necessary to provide the sidewalk space.
It should be noted that United Properties will be providing the City with a
3 foot easement for the sidewalk along Rhode Island Avenue. The 5 foot wide
eidewalk is proposed to be 3 feet on Rhode Island Avenue right-of way and 2
f eet on the United Properties parcel.
Throughout the remainder of the site, the existing trees will be kept where
at all feasible. There are quite a number of large, mature trees around the
esisting houses. Some of the parking lot islands are designed to keep the
trees.
E. Utilities. Public utilities are available to the site. The City Engineer
has reviewed the existing utilities in the area and he believes that the
development ma.y be adequately served by these utilities.
• -
The Fire Ma.rshal has also reviewed the plan and with some minor changes for
f ire department connections, the plan meets with his approval.
• The final utilitq plans will be submitted as part of the General Plan.
F. Building Design. The proposed b�ilding is shown on a drawing that is
attached. The building appears to be brick and glass which is very similar
to other office buildings in the area. The building is one that would blend
in well with the area. The final huilding plans will be eubmitted as part
of the General Plan.
G. Relationship with Surrounding Properties. The proposed Valley Square Plaza
is consistent with the overall redevelopment plan for the area and should
not have any negative effect on surrounding properties or planned redevelop-
ment in the area.
To the west is Area C of the Valley Squa.re Redevelopment area. This area
has been designated for office and retail space. Presently it is used. for
Commercial and Residential uses. To the east is an apartment complea.
These apartments are to remain. The parking lot of PUD �47 will be along
the west property line of the apartments. However, the apartments will be
at least 60 feet from the parking lot because the apartments are set quite a
distance from their west property line. I do not see anq negative impact on
the apartments although the staff would like United Properties to give this
area apecial attention when preparing the landscape plan.
North and east of the site is the Trevilla Nursing Home. There should be no
negative impact on the rnirsing home itself or its residents. Presently the
� south part of the Trevilla property is used for parking in a similar ma.nner
as the PUD �47 property will be used ad�acent to Trevilla. In a indirect
way, PUD �47 will reduce the trumber of parking spaces available to Trevilla
and effect is access. Currently, Trevilla has a small parking Lot (20-30
spaces) on the PUD �47 property �ust east of the Spur station. This parking
area will be eliminated when construction begins. Also, an acc�ss to
Trevilla from Rhode Island Avenue over vacated 5th Avenue has been used
other the qears. This access has been used by Trevilla for delivery trucks
and other large vehicles in addition to parking. This vacated 5th Avenue
access is the only practical way for delivery trucks to get to the loading
dock on the south side of the Trevilla building.
Trevilla will have to make some changes to its existing parking lot to add
more epaces and to accommodate delivery trucks. I have spoken to Tom Bisanz
of United Properties about this problem. He has indicated that he will con-
tact the irursing home administrator to assist them in changes that will have
to be made at the south end of their parking lot to accommodate trucks and
additional parking.
Variances Incorporated Into PUD �47
There are two setback variances necessary for the construction of the parking
lot. They are as follows:
�
A. Sideyard setback variance of approximately 15 feet along Rhode Island
Avenue. The Zoning Code requires a 35 foot setback along streets. This set-
• back area is to be used only for landscaping. The parking lot along Rhode
Island Avenue is proposed to be aet back 20 feet. Therefore a 14 foot
variance is needed. The staff recommends that this variance be permitted.
United Properties is proposing a landscaped berm within the 20 foot setback
area which will enhance this smaller setback area and provide necessary
acreening.
b. Sideyard setback variance of 5 feet from each property line. The parking lot
along the east property line will be 10 feet from the property bine rather
than the required 15 feet sideyard setback. Since the nearest apartment
building to the ea.st is over 60 feet away, the staff is recommendiag appro-
val of the variance.
Recommendation
The Planning Staff recommends approval of the Preliminary Design Plan for PUD
�47. The Plan is consistent with the Valley Square Redevelopment Plan and will
be a quality addition to the area. Between now and the time the Geaeral Plan is
submitted to the City Council, the final details regarding drainage, landscaping
and utilitiea will be developed for City Council and staff review in a way that
is consistent with the Preliminary Design Plan reviewed by the Planning
Commission.
. Attachments:
1. Preliminary Plat of Valley Square Plaza PUD �47
2. Artists Conception of Office Building
3. Area Map
4. Va11ey Square Redevelopment Conceptual Development Plan
•
c '`° ? �4E aF ° � ��' 4�. �� �'j� .i� �. /�r� !T �-S'�a -�� �� 'w. oli�I� I 3
� v':O r� •�� 1. � 4 /) •'.. y�1 " \�^ .f.- O .n N r � a �� �
v `�'�'� Oq���� i g a----,O ~ IA . �',\`ti7,y���!� `,,,41 , �� �K � � •�
q � , �.�-
� ^ ���� S .d�. '� y�0�ti� 'i°�i ' ���� - � � ,� �
�/� ���: N F� •S � � `, I �Z..�� s U8S' s,1�"
�,// 4� "'��o .. � b —...� �� �,�; ;� ool $ ��
�� ^ :�;� 12 ,� • "��o� � ' ,�y� e� 1 p� `v�� ` ,g'k � � �
� � _ :� � �i t't•y � a m
. /. � � o • ^ . e
� ��• ``. ` :��00 � �• � �
�`
OC1�tl ,` 1 "�s� n I u (� ����
0� O. 'r' °
w
�, � Q p ` � �ry � ~ i . i � � O �
� �� �. �4'Lq' . � �w � o � ;�f r0,;� " � �` �
eial �' ; up ` '1•{iC� `�.._ 44b� -
� �. + ••o - 9 � N o .:� ... _4�55... — _.t�..�_. ,•� ' �
: � �' � w W 4 � �i: � 1'j .� N �N 3� Z n
:i ^ _ t; �O� �o �t�� ��e i •
� 0 F�'J` -� _�by, �o� • � ._,- O �
_ II � ^ ;� � .
y 's�. }�! 1 w �.+
I �o �'''� / ;�� • ;a��� y�o o� _ �° r
I / • + ;, , 11 • �
o '� . e � � o•L'Xi t
_ (,� ,�. /
o f'°l�_ %' � "F4� •� ew� M � ; ...Zo t'1�41t , e � -sr.
; �/� ' z• .r�o•v ��_
�// . 00 ' ' ' o �i. °
� - � � N:' � .�- �,.,� � ;, e ��;` ^ :S� �sp y N �� �ti se
j so�fl' v�r .�� � �' � = ; o�_ �n ,5 . ; • � ��._-�.. ^ _ ��F..
� .;-.
;r. a �� - �, _� • ,;m
a+ t�3.:� � � �' � S� � ,M� ~' -r�'—.:, � iy;f�js,�
a' �1 � 00� 001 : a0 ' ,a • � y� 8 � : S>g� .�
N i � � � 2'U� � � :I �+� �" F, ao d, �
�niaa ���3i��� -Q�ao �: ��� 4��� � . �
, e �
; N s �� .� ..
� �d '�;:;°�",'." � �:-.: o. 9E J�_6o
' P 'R wi , ' 011 011 � �� . V ': �,.a : c �
^ "^ �o� �FS iZt •NS ��..,� u , , •n ��a
,�j� � o • !�f o ��e-i I i �
N .�- �� _ Q .�- n tff h � •S
�.:�'� -
� _ � .. M � � � 1
`��• ��Yl, �` �a.� _ � C
�/: ,�a���� � �03 = �o ���: ���, 19'a� • i . _ �---�-- .
.� ' � o � �a ss�e� ��'` 0 452 . ,s,on � �_� ,� iN �o ►
,$; . r'�P o��� '��.. �.. r � �
w• �fF c �� �Q N ' $_ r.:..- • p•� t
. t •
'� L� °" �� p 1�•9 '9 �'�6� � 3 1'�I a p�� Y� ' �o wf � o O t
� � �O O
•fF�° a 16 / p' p� �• � N � � � n - - p 1
: ,�� F�� Z ^��i ^ � '^ !li.-.- - - - - � - - �O
ti, �, � o- o e L9E
O/ � ��e� � m � � w+� N �8 ��<,�'p� , o _— _"_� D aeb�
ol � � � f � ��✓i. o' •$i�, • � tr Q o P'
, Ff � �� Fy. � � .�Q,F. o,d� o ��-c� �o - �
, � .a
� Q o,i !•o .� � � �
Q ��'. . b�h3• � %i ,�"�� � v `'•,j�' ?�'�+�•6.► ,;. :�...._ o l94 44 :4£
�+ --�- ' '' „'£. o 01,4 � ' ,.�C) S ,io. ' c;o5i r:. -.-S�- ..�5'�i` 'I
�'�,, ���'� �� ,4w s; MGf,91,OM' � (.
.��. _ ' :�
' �n �r ' '^
.!E 3 h �� N ��� `{'e i �' �, -
r� �� • O Z ,� n �O �
'E,� . 4* � �; �` � `"� ^ � �
.�� � � I
� c� ��� - � ' °� 9ti lo � � ��
m a,e��r.rs S�oo� a°� sr t -o�,� �, �� I ^
�00 SIQOI�� M i O � .� � :
� �
p � M '°F �� r M A�1 M I v`
J O _ �. � ' I I � �e N ^
.'�.. � � —.r� i
t p •�„ -� � �
I ^ o• II ; a � d��� _ _ � 05 . . • :95 ' �i
° ' N �1,41.�'aS ' � a + �� a I a�o
�` � � - I I _ _ ,� �
�� � r u• � � c � � ,j, �a � I a4• i rp Q Uf tp f��s','; O�, ^�,�
� - .. --- r � .
�,•i I I � I � oy 90r s t�,
, i� �Z rm� 1__1� : ' ,
`obs� oFS. ' ozs ceFONbl1Sl.� �' .r � 6G03QOHa �oe�
� .R� b LfS �� o �S I I °� r-f• ' °S S � � - , SLS '1
Io� oS „ . : , .. " � �.��' °.�i � ��;„i a�� �• �,•'�! 0: I
� � 1[i m Of O� � cV� '3'.: �►•-,� � •r. .:0� n tD""!� P � a�; �
�, _ ""1 � 1 -� � ='i � � ,`�
.- . �
� �;p + �9 � � � � i I � � o �. I �
�.
i '
• aj °4 . .. . � .. . .. .- .. .. . .�_• _� f�ri.:°5 - _ �'�25 o I`
i °S
o�. ' •�p ZZ a� : � a/30 d � � ^
T � � � �tih,co' �� iib � �
p 0'�Sft41:��d � � r� i �."'. � CS � '
� f 4:fc4 -°-°'� --�--' � � N - ;� o �g
,�ob� o � � •a � • i� � � � � � b�
• •Q �.� ' I � I
ry1 " • ~ � b N O , • ;,� csz h
� �� N o � 1'A ; Z �` - �.:... -- 4'S25 �I �
��\�� ~m � � � O �- � m� �� � N u a� a � :� -�i � f
• � � d� . T�--� ,I
i � � � ��� �� � ;�
� ��, � ��� $ �� '
, � .��$, 0 �
� �� = a��';` (�� =�..
� c� a �� � �'-� 1�
: � ,
: . �
i �sr d �
' — f �i i
_: �� a�
: � .
' � � o--� �
i ; � , r�
� ��--� - �.� W -� D� � ,
s � �!j � --��1� �. � ��
2
i i � l,�-� '`-1' �_ ��. 0 � � i
\ ,., � �!�'; � � ��� � a ,r'
, �,O s � � d ,
\ �� ` � I � � � � /
� `; i �- °� ' __ � � `` ��
�- € _==---- — _: -__-��D_ . _ _=-�' �-�''_ ��— -� �
�= - — _
-�-_ --- ---- -- - -- ��� - - - ---______- ---------
�,, ; -.�_ _ --- -� a
. I � � :.���� B �.. i�' � e
; �'a � �� - _
� � �� , ::o 0 0 __ . - ;
_r �� �
1 I � �� o � '
• ' � 0D - - -
� I a�� ' � e e e o. — �
: ! • � - ---- ' �
i j � d 3,; � I __% r �
i i i e��� � l� '�1 - -
I / , �` ���—� `� _/ �,
��/ � � i � � 0 � � . �%
�� � �� i , e - / /
� �� � C �� �
; � �� �� � �} ' �
i 1 QQ�O � _ / �
1 � w Q �� �r� �� � / �
,� ��A� � ..�� I � I
� I t� �
i , 0 � B .�cJ� �1.� I W
0 c ; a
� -- -- _--- a � ,
' \ � � � ' � � �
� ' � � ; � � ,----.� I - ; , � ; � � �
� ' � a
i '
� � ��i �f 1 I O �
_ j I � �
; • � � � � i
� ' i
' � d e o I ' ( I ,
� � � , ` i
, I, �
' ' �� -� r
� -� -� - �
� ; �J ,���. _ �`� I
� -� � � .` �
� � ��_� �- � � , � � .
• � i gr 1 ` I
��t� ''
` �
d � � �
J ---.------- --V�� �------------
-� --------- ------------
, �a r�_" '�° r�.-.o.�'1
T0: Golden Valley Planning Commisaion
• FROM: Alda Peikert, City Planner
DATE: January 9, 1985
RE: Informal Public Hearing - Preliminary Design Plan for PUD �30-B, Medley
Park Townhouses, Amendment �2
The proponent, Bor-Son Investment Properties Corporation, requeats �.n amendment
to PUD �30-B, Medley Park Townhouses, located southeast of County R�ad 18 aad
Medicine Lake Road, to allow a reduction ia the �aumber of units and the
construction of additional garage stalls.
Background
A copy of the originally approved Medley Park site plan is attached. The first
phase of the pro3ect, consisting of 30 units of subsidized rental housing on the
westerly portion of the pro3ect site, was completed and occupied in late 1982
and early 1983. The second phase of the pro�ect as originally approved con-
aisted of 34 units of market rate individual ownership housing. Bar-Son has
completed eight ownership or condominium units arranged in two four unit
buildings on the southerly portion of the site.
A first amendment to PUD �30-B, Medley Park Townhouses, was approved June 5,
• 1984 to allow replacement of one of three tot lots with a gazebo and to allow
the construction of four addition attached garage stalls. A copy of the site
plan for the condominium portion of the project approved at the time of the
f irst amendment ia attached.
Proposed Amendments
The eurrently requested second amendment to PUD �30-B, Medley Park Townhouses,
proposes a reduction in the number of condominium units from 34 to 28 or 30
units and the addition of 14 to 19 garage stalls. The proponent e�cplains in the
attached application cover letter that the changes are proposed as a response to
market dema.nds for a different type of unit and for additional garages.
Bor-Son proposes conversion of an originally approved eight unit condominium
building to a four unit building with a new split entry design. Bo�-Son requests
the flexibility to revise the six unit building to the east to another four unit
building dependfng on market requirements. Variation in building footprint
would be minimal due to the fact that soil correction already completed for all
buildinge is limited to originally approved building footprint areas. Value of
replacement units would be higher than that of units originally approved. The
resulting change would be a reduction in number of units and density along with
an increase in value for four to eight of the units.
The proposed amendment includes the addition of 14 to 19 garage stalls. The
plans shows the addition of one garage stall each to unit 14 in the six unit
building and to unit 22 in the adjacent four unit b�uilding to the northeast.
• Potential for two additional garage stalls as required for marketin� is
illustrated for the northernmoat four unit building. The newly proposed four .
unit building has eight attached garage stalls replacing nine garage etalls in
� the former eight unit condominium. Newly proposed detached garage buildings
include a five stall garage near the newly proposed four unit building and six
and two stall garages in the northern portion of the pro3ect. A potential three
stall garage is proposed at the end of the six unit building.
Parking
The proposed amendment improves the overall parking aitua.tion. The addition of
14 to 19 garage stalls compares to loss of 11 to 14 outside parking spaces.
Number of parking spaces increases while mimber of units decreases �esulting in
a greater ratio of parking spaces to unite. At the same time garages are pre-
ferable to outside parking spaces in terms of enhancement and value of the pro-
. �ect.
Variances
Construction of the two detached garage buildings in the northerly portion of
the site involves setback variances as part of the PUD approval. The six stall
garage is located sig feet rather than the required 30 feet from the property
line shared with the Galant Townhouses. The two atall garage building is
located six feet rather than the required 20 feet from the property line shared
with the small shopping center zoned Commercial to the north. The garages
replace outside parking spaces for which lesser variances were approved in the
original PUD agproval. Required aetbacks for parking are half the building set-
backs at 15 and 10 feet.
• It 3s the opinion of staff that the two stall garage is adequately separated
f rom the shopping center huilding located to the north ad�acent to Medicine Lake
Road.
In the case of the Galant Townhouses, the ob�ective is to integrate the six unit
Galant Townhouses building into the Medley Park project site as �ch as
poasible. The easterly portion of the Medley Park Townhouses Pro3ect site, the -
entire ind3vidual ownership condominium portion of the pro3ect, is the remaining
site of the unfinished Galant Townhouses Pro3ect. Therefore, although a pro-
perty line divides Atedley Park from the Galant Townhouses, the ob3ective is
integration rather than separation. Location of the Galant Townhouse at a
higher elevation than the proposed garages minimizes potential obstruction of
views. In addition, garage elevations on the enclosed plan sheets gllustrate
construction of the six unit garage 'building into the hillside with appro$ima-
tely four feet of the garage below grade from the Galant perspective. This
further minimizes the height of the garages as viewed from the Galant
Townhouses. It is the opinion of staff that the garage building constructed in
this manner at the proposed location would not have a negative visual impact on
the Galant Townhouses.
•
Recommendation
• Based on conclusions that the proposed amendment enhances the Medley Park
Pro3ect and has no negative impacte on eurrounding properties, staff euggests
that the Planning Commission recomend City Council approval of the Preliminary
Design Plan for PUD ��30-B, Medley Park Townhouses, Amendment �2, which proposes
reduction of the irumber of ownership units from 34 to 28 or 30 and the construc-
tion of an additional 14 to 19 garage stalls.
Attachments:
1. Site Location Map
2. Application Cover Letter
3. Original Site Plan
4. Site Plan for Amendment �1
5. Preliminary Design Plan for Amendment 4�2 (Full sized plan sheets enclosed
aeparately)
�
•
•�':. t661i �iC9.10- o ch.Gov�_ _.. 261b.4�Res......
M S7 II`E �'"' !30
; ` 26 'Rl `_ 94��_ r. ° 93/3 � • ---'� .�— i0 R--�----
� � ��n ..' ° 8M3 2G R. � 9/ 3 � 90/'
I � w �• ns • � I 3�0
.r�. � � st'� o
� �` �n Q �► �'
�J ' � .'� � Q� � `� �
�
,O `iti y ' � � � � � � � � � � �
i h N • i
� 2Ty.1J .� �
� � , . �i1S7J /i0 � �. � V - �
5675 _ � 5650 �� Isio 1s2o �
M � H - - - i � ��
a, o a o.
� �+ � �;
Z�� 3 � �� qi � . i
� J�Io � i i
.o �
� n=a9'05s9" Qa �v I �
� �tiIR=2TB.67 = � I
. �1 L=239.06 � �
• ti s' r%r �� S 89°36 45"E ' _ � ' f
� ioe.sy � yq\�, .6 �i. l0 R.
i05 q` sos.ey 'o � P�`8� 114.86 � b S89°3C'S6"E 591.99 ..
�O 1� Q� W ; •
rR ,�0�� n� L A ;o :..
! ^o ° ' ; 6 c° �� �O`�� OUTLOT 2 N o 6410
2 � � h 4 5 - Q - - o
�' , o � N 7 � 2 3 50i � S d 9 3o 5 6�F9 1 0
--Fi,,�2�4. -. 3 ! 215.3 7.07 �0;4 • II �40 =R
. ���, ' 3 7. 6 `�� ,� . N89° 0'S6"W � _�u,
��.4q�P a► ;C S ° 5 . � .. � 312.i5 ,� �
ti ti a � R Z� .8 _ _j� OL. � a r /�� ,
a� � „� ��-20 . a m <<4.3`a6 �r°�'� ��
_
f
1 N 1� .2 n w � � H75��202%K � �i7,99 �
o� � p np � ��•_ Ii5 -�
� `� PA R K "Z .
� � NE9 3c'S�°n�
o' �^
2 0
V
N g (6�40) h W
�2 W N
0. • °
� �o
Z 4 •2 � :1 .5 a z°
!o ° -/263.47•• ;--iso":�' - z5i.rr -Me9°is�2z'rv
' 1 1 � q S 6 N69°S9'SO E � N
• .�,�-, £n,ci.is� ' � , K 1 N O = � o� ���� �
• CI CLE d
_; /7-/5 23/3'// � �� b
, . 14 3 1? I1 '� 9 (SZ20) 16 11 ?8 1 �J �u �i
. -� o O 15 9�O . /50 i 5�452 6�8 '
� "�' KINGS " �9 10 1 � �� NGS `�� � a�3o ��0605 �
,� -a � x. I� _ 4 �F � „� �cc?i �nc�s�
'6 js 4�� � �R �� 5�0 `'���� � 51.�1 vtj d; p• ; 23 r
�R• .0 "'?ND•?!02'M' �} � , a a 9 qv 5� � � r� � :W o 9 �e2.49
� 16 �,� � 9 9� .o' S7 S4 � ro i .°o � 01
r S � 00 9 '�8 0$° N „ �-
, , o
�� Q 1 S � a f 4 , ��qp KIRvS � S9 S3 �o m S h� • 23 �NB
�� /
n- - ��.
� `� � 2 S�O 1'.� r� � o �� �.4`s �, �01 ya� 36 a �� �yo ji:r'
.�
,:, =� 5�� �Z 145 iq o S ��F�. 6 62 2z�'` L a 3� 26784 5 9i9'SZ E �;'_
^� °� % �6 141 � ,� �. . �n 72 Z no �.
3,� � � � a o iss ,�,� 5 Q a o _D ;�� .,,
Z = � � ''' f 3 ` a°cN 39 `O � _.'o. �4.�+~
a ,n '.: . TRAIL `�i �► o VA Lt Y �np � 4g `= � �' `� p � A
.�o� 14 ° .r . ` .o" ro2-oo 1 � , , a, �'"� ,o N 4 �0 �9,� Z
3 i3 a ' ' ' '� o .0 1 g ,� e°�� 9�1 �•�= 5 �� � �' e.�l�C. O�+e O � 3 `_:
� az � 9 °; 4 - �e�od'.`� oaD�'zn�b�
� 13 ,g l2 � ;121 81 h 90 .
� � � au' . � _ � i6 � =rn �ELGIN'; " n s''4'n�e
•,.. �Q a �. 11 -Z�,122 d° �9 S� Q '.�s .' ;�' t
� � u ' � d 4 N v �a e ',4�
_ ^" ;� �%�115 116 Q � ��.� �, 88 , Q �1 a � �,rso-j� '� .,�30' �, r
� ?I?O-?P p1Yt-?6a �cP�� � � ��- �1 � 6a �4 � e ��:,� �o�s 4D 6`'�.
�, "" � tiPS-t� 2 � � -? RDA� vYEST � �� • s •, 7 iq�=
;�.2//7-I9 FI2l-P! � � +� � ,e �
i - � ! I 03 �03- w = '� s. �_..
� Ol iZ8 Z� J. � KINGS � j o� 6�p w � ,�s000 .• �zs
, � 132 31 3 2 � VALLEY S 7 3 71 �o a , o�5J �� -�
2^d ADD. : : ia- $N 2 4�&
��° ../287.9�4-- o ��i�'r°t �,.� �w
°--�„�"— — •-u — — �7.l� � � NB9d7%7 W _y �'�za°i � i� fGF�o:
= UL TH �'s ...i3s,.e- �t STREET 9/83 :��3 °�•-� q- ,
_�f l i i I I j. S a . i L 12 rot» r.,, �v.� � . ��' ::..�1 c_ 1�.�1f I�T� i � �j 0 0e �U/i Pl.
BOR-SON
� CONSTRUCTION COMPANIES
2001 KiUebrew Drive Past Office Box 1611 Minr�apdis, MN 55440 [612]854-8444
December 14, 1964
City of Golden Valley
7800 Golden Valley Road
Golden Valley, MN 55427
RE: Amendment to PUD 30-B
Gentlemen:
Enclosed is a PUD amendment application and corresponding
architectural drawings for two modifications to the Pheasant Glen
portion of this PUD. Bor-Son is requesting this modification to
enable us to redesign current units to meet the marketing
interest expressed by those people desiring to live in Golden
Valley and, in particular, at Pheasant Glen.
Our experience to date in the marketing of Phase I has identified
certain plans and amenities which are considered important to
prospective buyers and, therefore, to the successful marketing of
• the project. Those changes and amenities are as follows:
- The sales to date indicate a desire for double garages, and
alsa for a deluxe unit.
- The "older adult" market is interested in a master bedroom
on the main floor and the possibility of a larger, more
spacious townhome. Our current units have the two bedrooms
upstairs requiring a full flight of stairs to bedrooms.
This change makes it possible to proviae four such units.
- We have been concentrating our marketing efforts to include
first home buyers, feeling that the upper bedroom townhouses
would not pose any problems. Our experience to date has
been that the units were attractive and offered the kind of
lifestyle buyers wanted, with, the exception of the extra
garage.
- This PUD amendment is to enable us to provide those
additional garages anc3 also to moc]ify Phase II to be more
marketable.
The 8-plex one bedroom condominium located in the center of the
project between the townhomes and the Medley Park rental will be
redesigned into 4-2 bedroom townhome units in a quaol style
arrangement.
�
GENERAL CONTRACTORS CONSTRUCTION MANAGERS INVESTMENT PROPERTIES OfVELOPMENT
' • I o
This change allows Bor-Son the option to convert the 6 unit
• townhouse structure in Phase II (northeast of the existing 8
units) into 4 larger townhome units or to convert it to 4 units
of the same design as is .now built or to maintain the original
design of 6 units.
In order to meet the important demand for garages, we are
proposing 2-stall, 3-sta11, ana 6-stall detachea garages as shown
on the site. We believe these garages are in the best location
to service the units, maintain traffic flow, and sit atop solia
soil conaitions.
We are currently anticipating spring construction of Phase II so
that we can have these units in position for sale by the
summer. If you have any further questions or comments, please
feel free to call me.
Sincerely,
BOR-SON ,COMPANIES
Donald A. Ja obson ��
Director of evelopment
• DAJ:dp
Enclosure
�
�..�� n'„ ��M� —��—� �,���za x �
� ,�w �^a� s � �
�� :_r::,,,� � '
- - -- �1
. �
:-
. z
� •• '
�— ... ...
� ' �
� _ .
�� � � $ _
� ��
' � ' � � �� i�
�' � °
. �ti � ..,. �
•� � • - ����� • �� � ��
,,,
:,;� . - , ;� �,,,,;'� t{ _ �! �
� ��,: •.� •t_ _��_ 1 ,� `��' � � f� �� � 1
1 I '� � I ,,
� ,�,,
� MI
� L �i B
:� ( .� ( ` • � e
� � � � ' •
_ � • �: ` :
� . . ,.. .
� � � -_ � - �
O � - � ` -
. � , ,
� _• ;-- ',
I ' i_ �� � , �
� � \ � i � � �— �- — — -- -— g
, �'`\ �,\. �� I s _ .i • � _ �;
j� � T�: � ' -
�,� _ _ ._ .
, . .:
� �'�; � � . .
� � � - �, , , ; : ; _ �,: �
, '� u � ' ��� � � , ► � �
� � � ; _ _ �� � r- - - --- - �
� � � — ' + , !�
� 0 � `�✓ • �' mp —� � � �._-- __-_wN —�� �
� a ' . s�- ii i� �
Q LL�II � i � - . . � �� , � # iR �
�� �}►�}� � � �' .� � k � � ` � �
�(�� � { " tr
4..,J ' ` i �i� � • � '� , i i� �
~ i , � Y' _ � �/' .M
IIr] ^a �� � -- ��. 3 � � A - $� �
)� � ° - �
(� , .
�l I {C� I I ' / ,``♦ , T f- �
� 4¢ �, ' �� ' �
� � ��� V � � ' f �� � � � w
� �J � . .-� !�
� � ���� �� � `� � .� .. � . ,
� � �� , ��; _ : _ __
°� ��� �� -� L . .
� ----, �
� �
� ''�� �� �� � - `, � �
� ,� ���=ss ��•�+ ' ' :
� ~J � �•• ' :
L�c� � ���`� , . �, ` �
,� �e 8 \ '� L � . � .
�� � � ,� � ' '� ; ,` !
� p� � �' .
�]� � Q ~ s.' � • -'" " ��� i . ! %
l��l a t� � 'Y� � �� �:•• -- ,
�n � ,� �� -. :t
�+ O 3 �L :�� �• "� -:
A� � � ��:`��� . ' — -- •*,.* .,� , � -
• __�_ � --
.�w..r wo.p.Ou.N -
�
• , `
� • , �o.•�nt�.� wron...�
.� .
' • ♦ ..
,,• ��
��� ' �__ ' a���".' �` ��t4.MY�IM'011i*6(/bTCST�
/' '" ' �. ♦ . ��
BCALEs 1"a 30' O�� • �� � --- f` '� • --^ �9to�co�r`fu-R�°.+aFF
.e DswoTEt iRO►f►ro�l ��� "- ,� *�t ^� ' i 'y�"lsrea•s' �s' ' '..�-97.a �
,''G / / /%. " ��w.r�. �'�_- . �
_ � . � /'� � 'r` �'� - `i�"°Yo�«��,.+ `�• �.
� . `�% -•r.:e:-r— -. - — ^-'�, =- - ._'___ ..
, g,, — �,,,.o...._, - --' ,:
, �� n -'f / _____' _—_�__' ' �e�. o-� �md w r .
,' .i_ ' . �' ��—�_ 9 424.1 �� .
-' �` .. �----1 ^ -9150 .... .. . ...ui
�w.�• " � - .. . ' �
� •1, � �1 � — _ . � i �� 1_ -�'� 2�. sz2�e x .. ..:
�b` ` / . .1 I _�a� ,�.� �A ' `�
` . -_. � � ' � � I ' � '
' ' �r�.. 1
+1e {kt'1fIN(� i lONNprYSE'. � � �
,� ' ��. o- -� _; � '•o i. :--I- --- , 1 ' �: ..� � .' � _
.. .,� ' i. � —�—r ' a. - ��"°.:` � � p.. _
.,� � s , • :;.
` / fi'i ��w. ..� ...� . " �
n+rW-¢r.r. .v_ _____—� ���[s+��l ia� . . ,
u :o.r-.w-.._. .o- R_ ^�`,. �,. — . -;�.;,�1�'� �.jC »" '�• i' ' i
- rFS+�.p�3]�'_� _ � A, � • • .i
M� n i �� -,:S � � . I���W� _ •,� �� . �'�. QZ 8 ��, , ,
°�'.,� �.a. . " �[.i •� �• iI25- {
�5��..t1. v .r__ ,o�_��ee=�Tri_t,�5• �.� „ �'• '� ti Q ,A • ._
� �l� �-� �� �� ` "" :".' � / � ' � ' � ' I
�! � • ,,. • .. . � / . '
-`�i:�.��� j�� .:'4 :e. �ea '�0 � .D �
q � t^ �I� 94• �w •�•r� � ��� B' ` • • � �J
•1�B.V. . �.
" I .9il.� • Y — � t �. t A,�.e9�_�� � . • .
d�~ 1�i` � ""; _� � �'�--� .r-e I f`�=y '• _' .�. � .
� ~ s (y-.,� F �,.
i C�� •. �
��. �.�`�% � r � �',• � ::•.:i �nw� on .. � .� . ' .
{l'�: .�sl'� 3' t'°'� E ' i
I ti � `�� � @ � ��4� , ' - '
� ���
�;,. �-� • ,,. ' � �
i �:�:.r.. ' � , : , .,, g
-'1 — -.. \ 919.0 `�- � 9RD 919K
\,y�? _ I, . .. ��.1u.� " , �. =y�1 910
��o,. � � i � .1��C �:2: S^V�� ..... ,' 9 I .. . . �
�IC� — � I c�"1 , , i
"t- •---� .�✓"" ::.t, ;.:y� 9�60. � 9�3 3 1 � I
\ � '' ! �a...`:'g�.c�: :` , .I ' . -
''�� I • ��::.Y.�i. ' . . -r. ' �
\�' � ....� i_�.�_•._� � I �i," i. . ' � z
.r.B �'+r� � I '"o ."'� Qt�� $
♦
�'�, P�u.� g � / }� �''�, o/t:'� , •. • • Y i
i tiiOth �
•f � –__. � �4 .� �'r •�.t.I 41000 DLCW� '
.... , � `` y t �. ' `�\ ♦ .! . � YIALi w�/9tAt}1 � .
�f.;••t,. •� � .. 1 � C \``�� `
� ,(:'1/�'O _ �_ an 9M" � 1 � _ , , ' . `
1
\ L�� a,i == t, . � . . � ..
.�`� -_� �"� ��� ,b �• n � ' ,
. 1 I��� _w � -- oi�` � -- _- f,/ - + . .`-- `st. : - • - '°- )
z�r-r—�- -��--•--- -- ' � �/
/ -i�--"�� �'`-asb��=-,-. '— �'- --'_" -• � ' �, •—� . .
. 'L0� �^ _ K� t�.1� � ' � ��� �_{ . 4y y . '' !�.
�y
_� .l MN•OS'�b��I � . .
����.��=---- " --- — -— �„` ---- ----.---- --. � --
� � -
,, � � , ,
\ ',
V � � � PLAN^ ALTERNATE_CoARAGES ,
T0: Golden Valley Planning Commission
. FROM: Alda Peikert, Citp Planner
DATE: January 9, 1985
RE: Request for Waiver of the Platting Ordinance - 843 Winnetka Avenue South
The proponents, Mr. and Mrs. John Schroth, are a�aers of a aingle family resi-
dence located at 843 Winnetka Avenue South. The site includes two originally
platted lots 50 and 60 f eet in width and half or 25 feet of ad3acent vacated
Erie Avenue.
Mr. and Mrs. Schroth proposed to divide off the southerly ten feet of their pro-
perty for transfer of ownership to the neighboring lot at 911 Winnetka Anenue
South. Each of the two ad3acent owners received half or 25 feet of the street
right-of way at the time of wacation of Erie, Avenue. Following the proposed
division, the Schroths would retain only 15 feet of vacated Erie Avenue, and the
owner at 911 Winnetka South would own 35 feet of the vacated street.
The Schroth property conforms to Zoning Ordinance requirements following the
proposed division. The side qard setback from the proposed new property line to
the Schroth house remains 46.5 feet, which is three times the 15 foot require-
ment. The remaining lot size is �ust under 20,000 square feet, which is almost
twice the 10,000 square foot minimum lot size required.
� The property to the South at 911 Winnetka Avenue South is benefited by the addi-
tion of ten feet in width. The lot width increases from 75 to 85 feet, which
brings the lot into conformance with the eurrent 80 foot minimum width require-
ment stipulated in the City Zoning Ordinance. The house at 911 Winnetka Avenue
South faces vacated Erie Avenue, and the additional portion of vacated Erie
Avenue increases apace for yard and drive in front of the house.
A new chain link fence erected by Mr. and Mrs. Schroth on the proposed new pro-
perty line clarifies the proposal for pereons conducting on site reniew.
Recommendation
Based on conformance of the remaining parcel at 843 Winnetka Avenue South with
Zoning Ordinance requirements and based on the beneficial impact on the property
at 911 Winnetka Anenue South, staff suggeste that the Planning Commission recom-
mend City Council approval of a waiver of the Platting Ordinance to allow divi-
sion of the property at 843 Winnetka Avenue South for transfer of ten feet to
the property at 911 Winnetka Anenue South. Combination of the ten foot strip
with the ad3acent lot to the south should be a condition of approval.
Attachments:
1. Site Location Ma.p
2. Survey
•
� " ti O 3 h- �7 i� ,i. s.. � z. -r '- �p�0. - - . 0-i. • �
a o . • � n• 3P� �o p./ 18 �
•• e •ti •, N 0 sN � a. . gN 4 5. ' qb . ., �
�?S �g S GS%Y° ;p ; 771026 h � 1� N � •31.4Z 4•� , .160�� a� o.
'o 09 0 • o 1�N� va�.4., �� fa� ° �. . e
7B4O =� Q � �� :°�t•8l�2 �`Z ••�o ! . r .j �4: ,.: �
4� p►�I 5 �,}�!12 �°'eo . �!oZ'3 ,.:o ns° ._ 1���Z"' �p.� �� „
`,jil:{�titi `_ 79�� d:lO• - T.0 7700 ,_ �K.64�"� � � �O
��•��61� V; f T�20 y�^.�1�1 4.1�... � �� .:. �fj2� �� /� � �.
- 4�p .... .. Ne:I!'E�-� _� rc�I �/_
� T�Io � � \/
. � � '�► � • � .e :�r=' � ` � e 16 � 3S •.. 9c
� JTie
� , ,��, tf '� � 77Yf 8' o�s • .�. ' 1� « �A5
♦ 7BQ� �--: - ' y! �I .r. e ��, 6 b
•;�. ,� .r 460
�8�00; a 1 i; ��� t�u. � . ' �� 8 •o �7
_ :Hoo{ �����- ���«€•I�'j4, � � � sa 9 yo 1,d'a5 •vac
,�R2�,�. ,,, q 2 0� 7 0 �• � ��� �� 1 s 9z
• � _ R o ��
; 2 P�4..,ry 4_�a ` i
.� �
� o •M e 3e �o ___ .. ��—II B
__ o ��00 ; � ��M � � • �=' � � so�S
,•.N ./h/y/iC � 0 3 .�°, 8 s ° 0 3 v r6 +i�� - '' n � �a 10 g� __ _ .�� o
. • � ° ° ' g ,.ra r25 c h: ot
.. - -�9i_ � r ,Z ac.� �
L.'_.� -�- � � N °�,� � � O
, •• '� h �9550) � � p .�:�W � y• ^ � N � °t � (G h � �� h$ h•2 � �
•- N in 04� � N�. tCY1'•..' ~./.D� �" TrjO �1rto 0
; K • i- o z 7�7C' N i -�T•'le 7./0 7�1p /e� --s. r.t �l. IO � 0 I
.""' � ' � b' �aa _ :
2� -..: � .. .oa.2739�29 ..°, ,.--3l a o •-..! �� 37i o e !90 0 _ ie 9
�.
; �M'� '° w.s� �s.�.��,---�•,.T��R�"�-na n i :,° .�-. 33i.4 � 26�.56
, ^' '^ ry�.1y 157.15 e � a 157.15 � i�75 ^4 � ' `9� �
... ! ��49a•oa' . � o"` ;S, "'. 14' " -I""" �°3o in � �p� �
. � ,� �.-��- �,: - - - _�-_- -- h � ^
.. �'i�13__ _ Y ,�� _" j3'" Z •; �i�i�` � ; A
.. . ZZ -- -3--- _� ZZ 3 m � � ,; �,� �
.. . . - �� L�t —� -_� _ M _ . P b �
Zt e0
� Zl � 4 �0 ,�' 1� � 4��� • 909.8;
- -:- - - - :�� : ' S '�
• N �o
^ "S /9 - -• 5•'^°.�� �+��l�- -_I - •�-A- ��B.+i �7�G� ,
� • 01 °� • Id =� _ 7 ti '' i'�' - L - zs�`5a
'� -�-� .. . - •- -°. Q ' asa_a „ � -
• �� -� 8� . 4; - ,� -� B - - - - - - - - - ;�: c .
, - .. > . . �= }.
h l6 _ .'� 09 Q ' h �6 ' �9 � ` � z95.z� Lil—
�C0 � l5 =+ %0� � ��15 � •/o m �Z.h ' � •
ll � � � � E
a l� � � jq d �
a - - -- �- �. - - - - f- -m-- �� !io2s 1 "' '
Q o 12 r 13 ►Z �, �; � � oz. o
i . 157�5 v� ° �5'I•15 151�5 °� . "^Q,
� \� ....:y�n •+.M . .��� 1e (^ ��.
n, ;��%•I4•69.� ,r�• , �7 _s
i57. 5 /5. � ` 5�.75 /5775 M�.:'� s.
� �11 � � � ° 240 1 ° ;�
�°� -.� W � �- - - : - -� �, ;° :�� _ 3�0.0=0 (�
� .. - - - f► ai-• d eo �:
� 'M � Z ! ,� Z'��W '1 O r. 4 ,i �� .r. � e
ty w
�� - - - 1 �: -p � V a
� - �9 s ,; iii Zz 3 �`� �' � J
r
/ i
� _ _ _ •\ Rl • •_.� _ _ _ _ — '
i�° �J� s3 '� l8 _ 4 0- Zl 4 ��� o.En-�-
� ; ' � .�° �17 S Zo t75 �Za4o) �a , c • h
, ,
� F - l6 6 �M (�__
� , ,�oti°' __ 6 = s, • i9 � ,
�
� i . • i5�.15:.:�e ' o , ?0 .� • 'e550 ��5
, � ° ;"__ �s?.,5_.�-- iB 7 � � m,.� ,� • K 9 ,,
� 'o-- � r . ;o ,� , ;,�� e�3 7F00 r�s�-�� s:�,�
"� /6Jj5 _Y__157•�-- ' � 7650 i. o . o !25 �
o� �^ � �--- � � ' �:�:..... �, ..;59.oj - T500
«� ����'� �� � j � �d•Z��41' C�•21'3Z�
�q' � a � I i �Dc, i•;o' Lc��435.6
� 8•Z6'3o D•i'S°� � � ; I � o .
� a,`��`l.lol.i♦ 8S•7'oY3o• . � v �� l!��5o py.I•o�';o' �
�p �\�ZZ'15 L�•iSa.o i �'oT! di�.4 \
� Lc`69o.e i � �- i i'H
.� .N �1 � ���_ �^' S23.0...
►�ofsrt`'�'� ��`J L-"� —————-� �_ '� ----
` �_
• '�:: �6f00� `' '.i ^ 3��.4 .. t!'. - ..;bo.l ..
�' �
. _.2v.5. ..� .....- .e
(�i�. .J 'i(� ' � . `�i Ai.
t�s-:i�;F�r+T r:� �. . � •s QiP-
. _ __�_...- --- _ � . : � .
4`: _.
� �- �..__'_"_. _.�.�. . . _... �-. . .. .... _.... ..... _ _.. ' _
' ' ' �.'._' .�-L' � , ' ' F ,_.._ . � � v. .. . , . „'�
t_ ' ' t
T � � " ? . . _ ' _ ' . "__"_ .'_ . ' _" . . �
� '
� -- ; ,+� ._ �. 151.'I5"" d ;
p g3 �._'_ _J _ . 1
` - -- - _ �+, -- ---- - - - -
. � -- . -
� �-
e � ��
i � 44.0 ' -
� � ��A
� I^ - . �n 1
1 1 - N. �
- .u—_ _._'._.'_,_ j�§ .. .
i1 r ~
�� - ��
.�- ,�
�c.2 t y �� �
� —�— �
, — u;
� � N
� - � � v p �
� y �� �
c3�
�ci - - - 4r O
c� .
W ' 28.
j b5.3
- �
�• � �
/
_ . . = l.� , � d �� i
- "1 �
. a �
�'J � '` ;�
-- _ y ,r.
� �� -
__ _— - -... ___.__
. . , _ _�. ._ — .
.:� '" � . - 15��eeated �R/E AV£NdE` �V� v��L_
---- . . _ � _- --- � _ -
A
_—. --- - --�- L �- � - �:--- ��� N. 1 �� - �� - -
y,00.. r"
- 3ovth /in� . . , " �.-✓ _ �.
• - , . . _ V �. N
------ - - . - s w - . - -
_.._�3___.._ -- - a---- ----�--- --- --- •
__ _ ._ ... . . � _ .
-_ . _. .,,, .
_ � . __
: _ . _ _. -- —'�� �`f��
_ '�
�• _ - ----�... __ - _ �.. .._
t