06-10-69 BZA Minutes i �_ i�
REGULAR I�TING �F THE
GOI,DEN VALLE�' B4A.ftD OF ZONTI�G AFPEEILS
June 1fl, 19b9
The regul�r rnecting of the Golden Vallcy Board of Zoning Appeals was h�ld
Tue�d�y, June 10, 19b9., �,t 7:30 P.M. at the Go�en Va1Zey Civic C�nter,
780� G€�lden V�lley Road, Golden Valley, Minn��ot.a. Th� following Ba�rd membcrs,
consti�',uting a quorum, w�re present:
�eRoy W. Andersan
Dc�nald E. Fra.nzen
Dr. RobGrt R. Hoov�r
Mahlon H. �aedb�rg, �n �ltern�te member, was presen�. �tto D. Schmid,
Vill�ge Plann�r, and Lc�w�ll E. Odl�nd, Village Ea�.gineer, wer� pres�nt at th�
invit�tion of the Board.
I,eRoy W. Anderson, Chairmen of th� Board, presided �nd Jon L. Westlake,
Secretary crf the Baard of 2oning Appeals, ac-tcd as Sccretary of the mecting.
The first ordcr of business r�s the con�ideration of the mirsutes of th�
meeting of the Board h�1d on M�y I3, 19b9, copies of which h�d b�en distributed
to -�h� Bo�.rd. �t was moved by Robert Hoover. seconded by Doa�Id Franzen,
carricd tznani�nously to approve �he minutes, as amended, of th� m��tin� held on
M�y 13, 1969.
The Chairman then brou�ht bef ore �he meetir�g the following rcquests far
waivers:
69-6-15 (69-5-15) 3135 Z�e Avernze North (!�} Burton T. Bt�`�ZC90TI
3'he p�tition is for the waivcr of Scction
3.d7 for 1.95' of � propa�ed additi.on to a �ideyard �etback of 12.3�
off the South proper-ty linc. (Required I.t�,25 r)
Mr. Burton T. Belleson w�� prescnt to explain to the Board th�t sin.ce the
previous m�eting he has rc�duced the sizc of the proposed garage and breczGw�y.
It was moved by M�h1nn Swcdberg, seconded by Don�,ld Franzen, and unanimc�sly
c�rricd, to �rant th� waiver of Scction 3.U7 for 1.9�� off the Svuth property
line for thc proposed addition. Th� are� o� the request cxtends from �.� West
o� the East property line to 75t West of the East property line.
69-�-12 (69-5-12} �7Q5 D�a,luth 8treet (11) Super V�lu Stores, Ine. -
_ _ National Mana„�ement & Gonsulting Co�p,
The pe�tition is for thc waiver of S�ction
�.�� A for 3s� of landse�pi.ng to �, l�ndscaped �,rca of 0� off the North
�xoperty line. `.�his area of no 1and�caping ex�cnds from 15i
�Te,st of the Fast property line to 2�7� Wes� of thc Ea�t property
1ine. {ftequired 3�t)
5���� A for 12� of l�nd�caping to � landscaped ar�a of 23' off the
Ea�t prop�rt�r lin�. This area a� no l�ndseaping cxtends
Sou�h from the North prflp�rty line g��. (Requ.ired 35')
i �. i
Board of Zoning Appcals June 14, 1969 Pa�e 2
5.�5 B for 2Q� of a �r_o_�.os_e_�d addition to a present structure to s
sidey�rd �etbae o 0� aff the North property line.
(Required 20r �etback)
5.05 B for 25� of a ro osed building to a sideyard setback of 25�
off t,he St�uth properiy l-` n�.Thi� �rea �xt�nds 'from 35t West
of the East property line �0 37a' West of th� East property
Iine. (Required 50t setback)
5.�5 B for l�t of a roposed addition to a present �tructure to a side-
yard setback of lOt off the East property line of Tract B.
13.01 for l��t9 :a.rking sp�ces to a tot�l of 524 parking sp�ces on thc
sitc, ota, pa�rking required is 973 spaces, b�sed upon
7� square feet of floor area)
13.02 for 10� of landsc�ping to a rear yard landscaped �re�, af Ot
off the North property 1ine. (Required lOt of 3andscaping)
This request is on the line �hich separ�tes �`r�et A from Tr�c� B.
1.03 Lot of Record. In all of the zoning di�tricts, cver�r building
erea t�r crectcd or structurally altered �hall be lo�ated on.
a separ�te Iot Qr parcel of record, and in no c�se shall there
be more than one (1} principal building o�. any c�ne such lot ar
, parcel. The word� tiprincipal building" �hall be g3ven their
common ordinary meaning, and in the case of doubt or in a�,y
c�Zestion of interpretation, the matter shall be referred to
' the Golden Vallcy Board of Zoning Appe�ls.
Thc waivers as reque�ted �re on the proposed layout plan dat,ed July 27, 1969.
Messrs. 13oward B. Loomis, Jr. of Super Valu Stores, Inc., Dona�ld B. Semple
o� N�tiona�l Managcment and Gonsulting Corporation, Don D. B3rerly of Bycrly
Foods, and Rich�rd J. Larsen of Mastr�p Associates, Iric. werc pr��ent for f,he
r�que�t. The proponents explained the proposed layc>u� pla�n whieh would complete
the shopping eenter on Tract B R.L.S. #1239.
The Board noted thc praponent h�s purchased additions�l lsnd which he plans
to combine wit,h 3'ract B to reduce the waiver on the park%ng requirements.
Th� waiv�rs, as r�qui.red for landsc�ping, axe for �. contigtaaus parking area
�nd building for th� shopp3.n.g center.
A motion r��s movcd b,y Donald Fr�.nzen, seeondad by Mahlon Swcdberg, and
unanimou�ly c�rried, to approve the requESt in accordance with the proposed
plot plan b� Mastny Associatcs, Inc. , �rchitects, dat�d M�y 27, 19�59• This
plot plan is marked �hibit "A" in the Buildin� Department file.
69-6-22 61��.8 Glenwood Ave. North (17) Lowcll D. Kitzmann
3'he petition is for the waiver of Section
3.�7-3 for 1.�.� on a ro osed garage to �. sidcyard setb�ck of 1� vff
the East property line, cquired l�i)
Mr. and Mrs. Kitz:nann �rerc present to e�lain their request to the Board.
The pe�itioner asked to havc this matter deferred for f'urthcr stuc�y.
11 �
Board of Zoning App�als June 10, 1969 Page 3
69-b-23 935� Eaz'1 Strect (19) Jack �I. Hauglid
The petition is for �h� waiver of 8ection
3.0'j-3 for �.; of a propos�d detach�d garage to a sidcyard setb�ek of
1 t crff the East prop�rty 1in�. Requir�d 5')
3.07-1 £or !�� of a roposed d�tach�d gara � to a. frant �ard s�tb�ack of
31 t off th� 5ou h �ropert;� Iis��. Raquired 35�)
Mr. Hauglid was pres�n:t to �xplain his r�qu�s-� to th� Board. The proponent
pointed ou.t th�t th� waiver on the West side is adjac�nt to an. alley and tha�t
th� �lley is not in us� for �t,ravel.
T�he Board not,�d that th� homes in this block ar� construct�d in �ueh a� way
that ace�s� to the gar�.�� is from th� street frontage; and if the a11.e�r is
vacat�d, th� pr�posca garage wi11 canform to the �rdiz�anc�.
It was mov�d by Ro��rt Hoover, s�eflnded bar Danald F�anz�n, carried unanimouslys
to recommend that th� bui2ding permit �ie issucd and that no waiver be grar�t�d.
69-6-13 {69_�_�.3} 2?�50 Zoui�i�,na Av�nue North (ll�) Krau.se Tnv�stment Corp.
3'he p�tition is far the waiver of Section
�.05 B for 50� of a ropvsed building ta �, rear yard �etback of 501
off th� East prop�rty lin�.�his r�qu�st is in th� Nortla�ast
corner of the propos�d additivn, and not for the er�tire �st
property�,line, (Rcqui.red 100�}
Mr. Robert L, Krause of Kraus� Tnv�stment Corpor�ztion e�lain�d his
r�quest to th� Board.
Th� Board noted that this parcel of land is unique becaU,se of terrain
and the �oning of Re�idential and Institutic�nal dir�ctly to the East of this
parcel. The Board also noted thc w�ivcr as raqu�stcd is in that portion of
th� lot �ah�re th� setback of' the corner of the propos�d addition and th� �orner
of the proposed parking area �re measra..red along a radins �'rom the j�znetion of
Residcntial and Institu�Gional property,
It was then moved by Robert Ht�over, second�d b�r ➢onald Fr�.nzen, and
unanimously carri�d to approv� the request with the stipulation th�t the structure
r�main (1) one fo9t South of the West�rl.� ext�nsion of the South 1in� of the
parcel zQned Residential immediatel,y F�st of �nd adj�,ecnt to Lot 8, Block 1,
Advertising Creativ� C�nt�r.
69-6-21� ?751 M�dicine Lak� Road (l�.) Frank J, Nc�nnan
The p�tition is far the waiver of Seetion
1,�3 Lc�t of R�cord. In all of the zflning districts, every buildin�
hereaft�r er�cted or �trueturally altered shall b� loo�t�d on
� scparate lot or parcel of' record, and in n� c�.s� shall th�rc
be more th�n o�e (1) pri.ncipal buildin�; on �.ny onc such 1ot or `
parccl. �.'he words "prineipal building" shall b� �iv�n their
corrrmon ordinary meanirj.g, and in thc cas� of doubt or in �.ny
question of int�rpretation, the rnat�er shall bc r�ferred to
�he Golden galley Bo�rd of Zoning Appe�,ls.
113
Board of Zpning Appeals June l�, 1969 Page !�
Neither the petitioner or his repr�s�ntative app�ared so no �.etion was
t�ken by the Board.
69-b-(68-9-�5) 3225 Major Avenue North (3) Edward Golusky
This request was brou�ht to thc a�ttention of the Board because of an
overh�ng of thc bay window making the existing �tructurc two feet closer to
the E�st property line,
The Board noted this request was �pproved at the September 11, 19�$
� Board of Zoni�g Appeals meeting. Thc su.rvey was of the foundation, which did
not '3:r�clude the ba,y t�rindow.
It �s moved by Robert Hoover, seconded by I�ahlon S�aedberg, carried
unanimou�ly, to r�commend t�h�t t�e building permit be issu.ed.
There being no flzrth�r business to come befor� the m��ting, it was on
motion, c�uly seconded, adjourned at 9.00 p.m.
-e >> � �� � '
oy Ande son, airm�n o es lake, ecret�,r�r
�