05-21-13 CC Agenda Packet (entire) AGENDA
Regular Meeting
of the
City Council
Golden Valley City Hall
7800 Golden Valley Road
Council Chamber
May 21, 2013
6:30 pm
The Council may consider item numbers 1, 2, 3, 5 and 6
prior to the public hearings scheduled at 7 pm
1. CALL TO ORDER PAGES
A. Roll Call
B. Pledge of Allegiance
C. Acceptance of Donation - Golden Valley Federated Women's Club for Electronic 3
Reader Board
2. ADDITIONS AND CORRECTIONS TO AGENDA
3. CONSENT AGENDA
Approval of Consent Agenda - All items listed under this heading are considered to be
routine by the City Council and will be enacted by one motion. There will be no
discussion of these items unless a Council Member or citizen so requests in which
event the item will be removed from the general order of business and considered in its
normal sequence on the agenda.
A. Approval of Minutes - City Council Meeting - March 19, 2013 4-11
B. Approval of Check Registers:
1. City 12
2. Housing and Redevelopment Authority 13
C. Licenses:
1. General Business Licenses 14
D. Minutes of Boards and Commissions:
1. Planning Commission - March 11, 2013 15-27
2. Human Services Fund - April 8, 2013 28-29
3. Civil Service Commission - February 4, 2013 30-32
4. Open Space and Recreation Commission - March 12, 2013 33-35
E. Bids and Quotes:
1. Single Axle Dump Truck and Equipment - Quotes 36-37
F. Receipt of April 2013 Financial Reports 38-46
G. Establish Permanent No Parking Zones at the East Driveway to 8145 Lewis Road 47-49
13-42
H. Authorization to Sign Agreement with The Morris Leatherman Company for Resident 50
Survey
I. Board/Cornmission Appaintments 51
4. PUBLIC HEARINGS 7 PM
A. Public Hearing - Covenant Retirement Communities - Issuance of Bands 13-43 52-54
B. Public Hearing - Easement Vacations - Plats of Dahlberg Commerce Center PUD 55-62
#61 and North Wirth Business Center PUD #100 (4200 and 4310 Dahlberg Drive)
13-43
5. OLD BUSINESS
6. NEW BUSINESS
A. Approval of Plat 13-44 and Authorization to Sign Amended PUD Permit - Dahlberg 63-75
Commerce Center - PUD #61 - Amendment #3
B. Approval of Plat 13-45 and Authorization to Sign Amended PUD Permit - North Wirth 76-88
Business Center - PUD #100 - Amendment#1
C. Announcements of Meetings
D. Mayor and Council Communications
7. ADJOURNMENT
tw 6 L Y l!� ��a, '11
,1.;
� j ��':
�
��.. �` CityAdministration/Council
763-593-�Q03/763-593-8109(fax)
� ___ . _ e w _� .
�_,,s���.� � � � �
Executive Summary For Action
Golden Valley City Council Meeting
May 21, 2013
Agenda Item
1. C. Acceptance of Donation - Golden Valley Federated Women's Club for Electronic Reader
Board
Prepared By
Thomas Burt, City Manager
Summary
Members of the Golden Valley Federated Women's Club will be in attendance to present a
donation check for the City Hall electronic reader board.
Regular Meeting
of the
City Council
March 19, 2013
Regular Meeting
of the
City Council
Pursuant to due call and notice thereof, a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of
Golden Valley, Hennepin County, Minnesota was held at 7800 Golden Valley Road in said
City on March 5, 2013 at 6:30 pm.
The following members were present: Clausen, Harris, Pentel, Scanlon and Schmidgall;
Also present were: Thomas Burt, City Manager; Jeannine Clancy, Di�ector of Public Works;
Allen Barnard, City Attorney; and Judy Nally, Administrative Assistant.
Pledqe of Alleaiance
The Pledge of Allegiance was recited.
Board/Commission Oath of Office and Presentation of Certificate of Appointment
Mayor Harris administered the oath of office and presented a Certificate of Appointment,
mugs and city pin to: Gillian Rosenquist, Open Space and Recreation Commission.
Certificate of Recoanition: Eaqle Scout Ethan Meirovitz
Mayor Harris presented Ethan Meirovitz with a Certificate of Recognition. The Council
congratulated him on his achievement.
State of the Citv Presentation
The State of the City video was shown at the meeting.
Approval of Aqenda
MOVED by Pentel, seconded by Scanlon and motion carried unanimously to approve the
agenda of March 19, 2013 as amended: addition of Notification to Council Regarding
Exception to Noise Ordinance for the Breck School Project.
Approval of Consent Aqenda
MOVED by Pentel, seconded by Scanlon and motion carried unanimously to approve the
agenda of March 19, 2013 as amended: removal of Authorizing Issuance and Sale of:
$4,635,000 General Obligation Improvement Bonds, Series 2013A and $7,330,000
General Obligation Refunding Bonds, Series 2013; Authorizing 2012 General Fund
Transfer and Assignment of Fund Balance; and Bottineau Transifinray Update; and addition
of Notification to Council Regarding Exception to Noise Ordinance for the Breck School
Project.
Regular Meeting of the City Council
March 19, 2013
Page 2
Approval of Minutes - City Council Workshop - Januarv 9, 2013 and Council/Manager
Meetinq - Februarv 12, 2013
MOVED by Pentel, seconded by Scanlon and motion carried unanimously to approve the
City Council Workshop minutes for January 9, 2013 and Council/Manager Meeting minutes
of February 12, 2013 as submitted.
*Approval of Check Reqister
MOVED by Pentel, seconded by Scanlon and motion carried unanimously to authorize the
payment of the City bills as submitted.
*General Business Licenses
MOVED by Pentel, seconded by Scanlon and motion carried unanimously to authorize the
issuance of the license as recommended by staff.
*Minutes of Boards and Commissions
MQVED by Pentel, seconded by Scanlon and motion carried unanimously to receive and
file the minutes as follows:
Planning Commission - January 14, 2013
Board of Zoning Appeals - January 22, 2013
Human Services Fund - January 14, 2013
Environmental Commission - January 28, 2013
Bassett Creek Watershed Management Commission - January 17, 2013
*Rental Propertv Licenses
MOVED by Pentel, seconded by Scanlon and motion carried unanimously to authorize the
issuance of license as recommended by staff.
*Therapeutic Massaqe Certificate - Lee Elizabeth Lanqer
MOVED by Pentel, seconded by Scanlon and motion carried unanimously to approve the
issuance of a therapeutic massage certificate to Lee Elizabeth Langer at Massage Envy,
7704 Olson Memorial Highway.
*Gamblinq License Exemption and Waiver of Notice Requirement - Sons of the
American Post 523
MOVED by Pentel, seconded by Scanlon and motion carried unanimously to receive and
file the gambling license exemption and approve the waiver of notice requirement for the
Sons of the American Legion Post 523.
Regular Meeting of the City Council
March 19, 2013
Page 3
*Gamblinq License Exemption and Waiver of Notice Repuirement - Tru Breed
Motorcvcle Club
MOVED by Pentel, seconded by Scanlon and motion carried unanimously to receive and
file the gambling license exemption and approve the waiver of notice requirement for the
TruBreed Motorcycle Club.
*3.2 LiQUOr License Renewals
MOVED by Pentel, seconded by Scanlon and motion carried unanimously to approve the
renewal of the respective 3.2 liquor licenses for the applicants listed below for the 2013-
2014 license term:
Off-Sale
Northern Tier Retail, LLC d/b/a SuperAmerica #4497
Northern Tier Retail, LLC d/b/a SuperAmerica #4443
On-Sale
Davanni's Inc d/b/a Davanni's Pizza
Brookview Golf Course
Theodore Wirth Chalet
*Call for Public Hearinq - Platted Drainaqe and Utilitv Easement Vacations - PUD #63
Saturn Addition - 701 and 801 Louisiana Avenue South - 4/3/13
Member Pentel introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption:
RESOLUTION 13-14
RESOLUTION ESTABLISHING A PUBLIC HEARING ON APRIL 3, 2013 TO
CONSIDER VACATION OF CERTAIN PLATTED DRAINAGE AND UTILITY EASEMENTS
IN THE PLAT OF SATURN ADDITION P.U.D. NO. 63
AND A DRAINAGE AND UTILITY EASEMENT RESERVED IN DOCUMENT 2426056
The motion for the adoption of the foregoing resolution was seconded by Member Scanlon
and upon a vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof: Clausen, Harris,
Pentel, Scanlon and Schmidgall; and the following voted against the same: none,
whereupon said resolution was declared duly passed and adopted, signed by the Mayor
and his signature attested by the City Clerk.
*Proclamation for National Public Works Week
MOVED by Pentel, seconded by Scanlon and motion carried unanimously to adopt the
Proclamation For National Public Works Week.
Regular Meeting of the City Councii
March 19, 2013
Page 4
*Authorization to Siqn Aqreements for 2013 Pavement Manaaement Proaram
Sanitarv Sewer Repair Propram
MOVED by Pentel, seconded by Scanlon and motion carried unanimously to autharize
entering into Master Agreements for the 2013 Pavement Management Program Sanitary
Sewer Repair Program with the following companies: Gene's Water and Sewer, Highview
Plumbing, and Ouverson Sewer and Water.
*Establishinq Compliance with Reimbursement Bond Repulations under Internal
Revenue Code - Hiphwav 55 West District#1
Member Pentel introduced the following resolutian and moved its adoption:
RESOLUTION 13-15
RESOLUTION ESTABLISHING COMPLIANCE WITH REIMBURSEMENT BOND
REGULATIONS UNDER THE INTERNAL REVENUE CODE FOR
HIGHWAY 55 WEST DISTRICT NO. 1
The motion for the adoption of the foregoing resolution was seconded by Member Scanlon
and upon a vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof: Clausen, Harris,
Pentel, Scanlon and Schmidgall; and the following voted against the same: none,
whereupon said resolution was declared duly passed and adopted, signed by the Mayor
and his signature attested by the City Clerk.
*Establishinq Compliance with Reimbursement Bond Requlations under Internal
Revenue Code - Doualas Drive Street Reconstruction
Member Pentel introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption:
RESOLUTION 13-16
RESOLUTION RELATING TO THE FINANCING OF A STREET RECONSTRUCTION
PROJECT; ESTABLISHING COMPLIANCE WITH REIMBURSEMENT BOND
REGULATIONS UNDER THE INTERNAL REVENUE CODE
The motion for the adoption of the foregoing resolution was seconded by Member Scanlon
and upon a vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof: Clausen, Harris,
Pentel, Scanlon and Schmidgall; and the following voted against the same: none,
whereupon said resolution was declared duly passed and adopted, signed by the Mayor
and his signature attested by the City Clerk.
Regular Meeting of the City Council
March 19, 2013
Page 5
*Approval of Fire Department Relief Association By-Law Amendment Reqardinq
Pension Increase
MOVED by Pentel, seconded by Scanlon and motion carried unanimously ta approve the
amendments to Article XI of the by-laws of the Fire Relief Association increasing the lump-
sum pension benefit to $7,000 per year of service.
*Approval of Fire Department Relief Association Bv-Law Amendment Reqardinq
Approval to Allow the Board to Set Interest Rates up to 5%
Member Pentel introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption:
RESOLUTION 13-17
RESOLUTION APPROVING AMENDMENT TO
GOLDEN VALLEY FIRE RELIEF ASSOCIATION BY-LAWS FOR
INTEREST ON DEFERRED RETIREMENT BENEFIT
The motion for the adoption of the foregoing resolution was seconded by Member Scanlon
and upon a vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof: Clausen, Harris,
Pentel, Scanlon and Schmidgall; and the following voted against the same: none,
whereupon said resolution was declared duly passed and adopted, signed by the Mayor
and his signature attested by the City Clerk.
Authorizinq Issuance and Sale of: $4,635,000 General Obliqation Improvement
Bonds, Series 2013A and $7,330,000 General Obliqation Refundinq Bonds, Series
2013
Council Member Clausen requested staff to review the sale. Sue Virnig, Finance Director,
answered questions from the Council.
Member Clausen introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption:
RESOLUTION 13-18
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING ISSUANCE AND SALE OF
$4,635,000 GENERAL OBLIGATION BONDS, SERIES 2013A
The motion for the adoption of the foregoing resolution was seconded by Member Scanlon
and upon a vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof: Clausen, Harris,
Pentel, Scanlon and Schmidgall; and the following voted against the same: none,
whereupon said resolution was declared duly passed and adopted, signed by the Mayor
and his signature attested by the City Clerk.
Regular Meeting of the City Council
March 19, 2013
Page 6
Authorizinq Issuance and Sale of: $4,635,000 General Obliqation Improvement
Bonds, Series 2013A and $7,330,000 General Obliqation Refundinq Bonds, Series
2013 - Continued
Member Clausen introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption:
RESOLUTION 13-19
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING ISSUANCE AND SALE OF $7,330,000 GENERAL
OBLIGATION IMPROVEMENT REFUNDING BONDS, SERIES 2013B
The motion for the adoption of the foregoing resolution was seconded by Member
Schmidgall and upon a vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof:
Clausen, Harris, Pentel, Scanlon and Schmidgall; and the following voted againsfi the
same: none, whereupon said resolution was declared duly passed and adopted, signed by
the Mayor and his signature attested by the City Clerk.
*Approval of Extension of Variances - 410 Rhode Island Avenue North
MOVED by Pentel, seconded by Scanlon and motion carried unanimously to approve an
extension of the variances granted by the Board of Zoning Appeals on March 27, 2012 for
one year (expiring on March 18, 2014) for the property located at 410 Rhode Island Avenue
North.
*Approval of Extension of Variances - 7650 Harold Avenue
MOVED by Pentel, seconded by Scanlon and motion carried unanimously to apprave an
extension of the variances granted by the Board of Zoning Appeals on March 27, 2012 for
one year (expiring on March 18, 2014) for the property located at 7650 Harold Avenue.
*Receipt of December 2012 Financial Reports
MOVED by Pentel, seconded by Scanlon and motion carried unanimously to receive and
file the December 2012 Financial Reports.
Authorizinq 2012 General Fund Transfer and Assiqnment of Fund Balance
Mayor Harris congratulated staff for the budget surplus. Sue Virnig, Finance Director,
answered questions from the Council.
Regular Meeting of the City Council
March 19, 2Q13
Page 7
Authorizinp 2012 General Fund Transfer and Assiqnment of Fund Balance -
Continued
Member Pentel introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption:
RESOLUTION 13-20
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE TRANSFER OF $1,140,000 FROM THE
GENERAL FUND TO THE CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT FUND ($600,000),
EMPLOYEE BENEFITS FUND ($250,000), EQUIPMENT REPLACEMENT FUND
($100,000) AND BUILDING FUND ($190,000); AND ASSIGNING
GENERAL FUND BALANCE FOR 2013 EXPENDITURES ($60,000)
The motion for the adoption of the foregoing resolution was seconded by Member Clausen
and upon a vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof: Clausen, Harris,
Pentel, Scanlon and Schmidgall; and the following voted against the same: none,
whereupon said resolution was declared duly passed and adopted, signed by the Mayor
and his signature attested by the City Clerk.
*Proclamation for Rotarv Club of Golden Vallev
MOVED by Pentel, seconded by Scanlon and motion carried unanimously to adopt the
proclamation for Rotary Club of Golden Valley.
*Board/Commission Appointments
MOVED by Pentel, seconded by Scanlon and motion carried unanimously to make the
following appointments:
Board of Zoning Appeals
Larry Fonnest 1 year term term expires - May 1, 2014
Civil Service Commission
Roxanne Sienko 1 year term term expires - May 1, 2014
Environmental Commission
Kyle Turner 2 year term term expires - May 1, 2015
Human Services Fund
Amy Clements 1 year term term expires - May 1, 2014
Open Space and Recreation Commission
Gillian Rosenquist 3 year term term expires - May 1, 2016
Planning Commission
Rich Baker 3 year term term expires - May 1, 2016
Jason Boudreau-Landis 1 year term term expires - May 1, 2014
Regular Meeting of the City Council
March 19, 2013
Page 8
Bottineau Transitwav Update
Council Member Scanlon had questions regarding the release of the draft environmental
impact study. Joe Hogeboom, City Planner, answered questions from the Council.
MOVED by Scanlon, seconded by Pentel and motion carried unanimously to receive and
file the oral report.
*Notification to Council Reqardinq Waivinq Exception to Noise Ordinance - Breck
School Proiect
MOVED by Scanlon, seconded by Clausen and motion carried unanimously ta receive and
file Breck's notification and authorize the waiver of the noise ordinance on Sunday, March
24, 2013 and Sunday, April 7, 2013 from 7 am to 5 pm.
Announcements of Meetinqs
A Bassett Creek Watershed Management Commission meeting will be held on March 21,
2013 at 11:30 am.
Empty Bowls will be held at the Sandburg Learning Center on March 21, 2Q13 at 4 pm.
The Caring Youth Awards will be held on March 21, 2013 at 7 pm at the Minnetonka
Community Center.
The State of the City will be held on March 22, 2013 at 7:30 am at City Hall.
The next City Council meeting will be held on Wednesday, April 3, 2013 at 6:30 pm.
The Council will hold Board/Commission interviews on April 9 at 5 pm and April 16 at 5:30
pm.
Mavor and Council Communication
Mayor Harris stated that he and Council Member Clausen will meet to discuss the Envision
Connection Board and will update the Council at the June Council/Manager meeting.
Adiournment
MOVED by Pentel, seconded by Clausen and motion carried unanimously to adjourn the
meeting at 7:40 pm.
Shepard M. Harris, Mayor
ATTEST:
Judy Nally, Administrative Assistant
���� �� �
Finance Department
763-593-8013/763-593-8109(fax)
Executive Summary For Action
Golden Valley City Council Meeting
May 21, 2013
Agenda Item
3. 6. 1. Approval of City Check Register
Prepared By
Sue Virnig, Finance Director
Summary
Approval of the check register for various vendor claims against the City of Golden Valley.
Attachments
• Document sent via email
Recommended Action
Motion to authorize the payment of the bills as submitted.
is D,�y�� �✓� "rj;
y �
Finance Department
763-593-8013/763-593-8109(fax)
���;_���.�L���.. �`
Executive Summary For Action
Golden Valley City Council Meeting
May 21, 2013
Agenda Item
3. B. 2. Approval of Housing and Redevelopment Authority Check Register
Prepared By
Sue Virnig, Finance Director
Summary
Approval of the check register for various vendor claims against the Housing and Redevelopment
Authority.
Attachments
+ Document sent via email
Recommended Action
Motion to authorize the payment of the bills as submitted.
�Y�� �� I
Inspections Department
763-593-8090/763-593-3997 (f�x)
Executive Summary For Action
Golden Valley City Council Meeting
May 21, 2013
Agenda Item
3. C. 1. General Business Licenses
Prepared By
Shannon Dietrich, Administrative Assistant
Summary
As per City Code, some businesses are required to be licensed by the City. Listed below are the
License Number, Applicant, License Type and Fee of those who have submitted an application for
approvaL
#6618 Dick's Sanitation 2 Refuse Vehicles $100.00
8984 215th Street West
#6619 Dick's Sanitation 1 Recycling Vehicle $ 50.00
8984 215th Street West
Recommended Action
Motion to authorize the issuance of licenses as recommended by staff.
Regular Meeting of the
Golden Valley Planning Commission
March 11, 2013
A regular meeting of the Planning Commission was held at the Golden Valley City Hall,
Council Chambers, 7800 Golden Valley Road, Golden Valley, Minnesata, on Monday,
March 11, 2013. Chair Waldhauser called the meeting to order at 6:30 pm.
Those present were Planning Commissioners Cera, Kluchka, McCarty, Segelbaum and
Waldhauser. Also present were Director of Planning and Qevelopment Mark Grimes, City
Planner Joe Hogeboom and Administrative Assistant Lisa Wittman.
1. Approval of Minutes
February 11, 2013 Regular Planning Commission Meeting
MOVED by Segelbaum, seconded by Kluchka and motion carried unanimously to
approve the February 11, 2013 minutes as submitted.
2. Informal Public Hearing — General Land Use Plan Map Amendment—
9300 and 9310 Golden Valley Road — CPAM-53
Applicant: City of Golden Valley
Addresses: 9300 & 9310 Golden Valley Road
Purpose: To change the designation on the General Land Use Plan Map from
Commercial-Office to High Density Residential
3. Informal Public Hearing — Properiy Rezoning — 9300 and 9310 Golden Valley
Road —Z022-02
Applicant: J-HAP, Inc.
Addresses: 9300 & 9310 Golden Valley Road
Purpose: To rezone the properties from Business and Professional Offices to
R-4 High Density Residential
Items 2 and 3 were discussed together.
Hogeboom explained that Jewish Housing and Programming (J-HAP) is proposing to
develop a facility that provides housing and services to developmentally disabled adults.
He referred to a site plan of the properties located at 9300 and 9310 Golden Valley and
stated that they are currently designated Commercial-Office on the General Land Use Plan
map and zoned Business and Professional Offices on the Zoning Map.
Minutes of the Golden Valley Planning Commission
March 11, 2013
Page 2
He noted that site plans have not yet been created and that various requirements of
funding partners are necessitating the land use and zoning changes at this time.
Hogeboom referred to the recently approved Renewal and Renovation District in this area
and explained that part of that plan includes the addition of sidewalks and street lighting.
Segelbaum asked if the applicant has a purchase agreement with the current owner of the
properties. Hogeboom said yes and added that the current owner also signed the rezoning
application.
Cera expressed concern about the parcel to the west of this proposal being left an island.
He asked if there are any plans far redeveloping that parcel. Hogeboom said it is his
understanding that the property owner is unwilling to sell the property at this time. He noted
that it is guided and zoned for office use.
Waldhauser referred to the language in the R-4 zoning district and questioned why
"residential facilities" are allowed as a conditional use but multiple family and senior
housing are permitted uses. Hogeboom stated that residential facilities are more of an
institutional use and have a different level of care. Grimes added that residential facilities
also require a license by the State.
Marvin Liszt, Attorney representing J-HAP, noted that the property owner was in
attendance and reiterated that she has signed the rezoning application. He stated that J-
HAP has a purchase agreement with the property owner and one of the contingencies of
the purchase is the rezoning of the property. Grimes added that that J-HAP is also going
through the process of applying for Community Development Block Grant funds as well.
Segelbaum asked the applicant how far along they are in their fund raising process.
Jennifer Lewin, Executive Directar, J-HAP, stated that they have applied for several
government funding sources and they will be launching a capital campaign once the site is
secured.
McCarty asked about the timeframe of the project. Lewin stated that the funding cycle is
2013 and they hope to break ground in 2014 with occupancy in 2015.
Waldhauser opened the public hearing. Seeing and hearing no one wishing to comment,
Waldhauser closed the public hearing.
MOVED by Cera, seconded by McCarty and motion carried unanimously to recommend
approval of amending the General Land Use Plan Map from Cammercial-Office to High
Density Residential for the properties at 9300 & 9310 Golden Valley Road.
MOVED by Cera, seconded by McGarty and motion carried unanimously to recommend
approval of rezoning the properties at 9300 & 9310 Golden Valley Road from Business and
Professional Offices to R-4 High Density Residential.
Minutes of the Goiden Valley Planning Commission
March 11, 2013
Page 3
4. Informal Public Hearing — Final Plan Review— Planned Unit Development
(PUD) — Saturn Addition PUD #63, Amendment#2
Applicant: Penske Automotive Group/UAG Minneapolis B1, LLC
Address: 701 Louisiana Avenue South
Purpose: To allow for the construction of a Motorwerks MINI Cooper auto
dealership.
Hogeboom stated that the Preliminary PUD plan for this proposal was approved by the
City Council in February and now the applicant is starting the Final PUD approval
process. He referred to a site plan and some photos and gave a history of the current
PUD. He explained that this property is currently divided into four lots and that this
proposal will consolidate the property into three lots. The proposed new MINI Cooper
building will be approximately 29,500 square feet in size and will replace the current
Oldsmobile building. He discussed the changes made to the proposal since it received
preliminary approval including the addition of a bike rack on the northeast corner of the
site, increased landscaping and the inclusion of a snow removal plan. He added that the
applicant has not increased the amount of pervious surface since their last plan submittal
however there will be no additional impervious surface on the site as a result of this
proposal. He referred to the Planning Commission's discussion about pedestrian access
on the site and stated that because of safety concerns, staff does not support having a
sidewalk through the center of the property.
Kluchka referred to the City Council's discussion about snow removal and asked
Hogeboom if it is his understanding that snow can only be stored in certain locations or if
it has to be removed from the site. Hogeboom stated that the applicant had been storing
snow in a right-of-way area so the Council asked that they submit a snow removal
showing that snow could be stored on their property. If not, then snow would need to be
removed.
Segelbaum referred to the proposed visual and landscape enhancements and asked if
there are elevations that show the north facade. Hogeboom stated that the building is a
corporate design so the applicants have limited ability ta change it. Kluchka said he would
like to see vertical enhancements and some articulation. Hogeboom noted that the
requirements regarding articulation only apply to residential properties. McCarty
questioned the guidelines for articulation in the Mixed Use zoning district. Hogeboom
stated that articulation is a general goal in the Mixed Use zoning district, but is not a
requirement.
Nolan Redding, Penske Automotive, introduced John Corley, Architect for the project.
Corley showed the Commission proposed elevations of the building. He stated that most
of the building is black however they've added some visual interest to the walls with large
graphics/pictures showing the latest car models. He referred to the north facade and
stated that they've added lighter-colored columns, wainscoting and windows to help break
up the expanse of the wall.
Minutes of the Golden Valley Planning Commission
March 11, 2013
Page 4
Waldhauser asked about the roof material. Corley said it will be a black, flat roof.
Waldhauser asked if a lighter colored roof or a green roof had been considered since
there is so little pervious surFace on the site. Redding said they did consider a green raof
but there are poor soils and the roof would not support the weight without significant
additional expense. He said they would consider having a lighter colored roof.
Segelbaum asked the applicant if they have successfully used the graphics idea in other
locations. Corley said yes, they have been used successfully. He showed the
Commission some photos of other dealerships where they have been used and explained
that they area made out of a fabric material that are easy to change and replace. Grimes
said the graphics proposal would have to be reviewed by the sign code administrator
because he doesn't think the City has seen this type of proposal in the past. Redding
noted that other cities have limited the graphics to photos only, with no words allowed. He
reiterated that the intent of the graphics is to break up the facade of the wall. Corley
added that the proposed trees would also help break up the north facade.
McCarty noted that the wainscoting and columns look like they are a lighter gray color in
the renderings than in the samples shown. The Commission agreed that they liked the
lighter gray color for the columns and wainscoting.
Waldhauser questioned why permeable pavers are only being proposed in the medians.
Redding stated that snow and ice is harder to clean off of pervious pavers and they would
not work in the driving areas. They also require more maintenance. Waldhauser said she
understands the opposite; that pervious pavers drain better and dry quicker so it is easier
to keep snow and ice off of them.
Waldhauser opened the public hearing.
Tom Londo, 6901 Laurel Avenue, said he has been seeing a lot of problems in the area in
the past year with theft, drug dealers and trucks with drivers sleeping in them. He said this
proposal would be great for his business and for the aesthetics in the area and would be
an asset to the community. Segelbaum asked Londo if he has concerns regarding parking
for his business. Londo said they've been compromising with him and added that it is not
his land that he would be losing.
Seeing and hearing no one else wishing to comment Waldhauser closed the public
hearing.
Kluchka said he thinks the elevations have changed significantly, which was his primary
concern. McCarty said his only concern is the color of the wainscoting and columns. He
wants them to be a lighter gray color. Cera said he would like to see more pervious
surface. Segelbaum said he is pleased with how the applicant has addressed the
Commission's concerns. He said he also agrees with Londo that this wauld be a good
thing for the property.
Cera suggested adding a condition of approval which states that the applicant should use
as light a gray as possible for the columns and wainscoting to allow for significant
Minutes of the Golden Valley Planning Commission
March 11, 2013
Page 5
contrast. Waldhauser said she would also like language added about consideration of a
lighter roof color.
MOVED by Cera, seconded by Segelbaum and motion carried unanimously to
recommend approval of PUD #63, Amendment #2 subject to the following findings and
conditions:
Findin s:
1. The PUD plan is tailored to the specific characteristics of the site and achieves a
higher quality of site planning and design than generally expected under
conventional provisions of the ordinance.
2. The PUD plan preserves and protects substantial desirable portions of the site's
characteristics, open space and sensitive environmental features including steep
slopes, trees, scenic views, creeks, wetlands and open waters.
3. The PUD plan includes efficient and effective use (which includes preservation) of
the land.
4. The PUD Plan results in development compatible with adjacent uses and is
consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and redevelopment plans and goals.
5. The PUD plan is consistent with preserving and improving the general health, safety
and general welfare of the people of the City.
6. The PUD plan meets the PUD Intent and Purpose provision and all other PUD
ordinance provisions.
Conditions:
1. The plans prepared by BKBM Engineers dated February 5, 2013, submitted with the
application shall become a part of this approval.
2. The recommendations and requirements outlined in the memo from Fire Chief Mark
Kuhnly to Mark Grimes, Director of Planning and Development dated March 4, 2013,
shall become part of this approval.
3. The recommendations and requirements outlined in the memo from City Engineer Jeff
Oliver to Mark Grimes, Director of Planning and Development, dated March 4, 2013,
shall become a part of this approval.
4. Exterior bicycle parking shall be added to the northeast corner of the MINI Cooper
building.
5. The applicant shall store snow in accordance with the snow storage areas indicated
on the Site Plan.
6. The developer shall consider enhancing color contrasts in the building facade. This
could include light or medium grey wall material finishes, as well as a lighter colored
material for the roof of the proposed building.
7. All signs on the property shall meet the requirements of the City's Sign Code.
8. This approval is subject to all other state, federal, and local ordinances, regulations, or
laws with authority over this development.
Minutes of the Golden Valley Planning Commission
March 11, 2013
Page 6
5. Informal Public Hearing — Minor Subdivision — 228 Meander Road -- Meander
Woods — SU12-13
Applicant: Matt Pavek
Addresses: 228 Meander Road
Purpose: The proposed subdivision would reconfigure the existing single family
residential lot into two new single family residential lots.
Grimes referred to a location map of the property and explained that it is 1.32 acres in
size. The applicant is proposing to divide the property into two lots, both of which exceed
the minimum standards required in the City Code. Lot 1 would be 20,771 square feet in
size and Lot 2 would be 37,375 square feet in size. He explained that this property and
the property to the northwest were once part of the Perpich Center PUD. However in
2008, the State of Minnesota sold the properties and removed them from the PUD.
Waldhauser asked why Lot 1 narrows toward the rear yard. Grimes stated that the lot
narrows slightly in the rear yard hawever it is still approximately 70 feet in width at the
rear of the lot. He reiterated that both lots exceed all of the requirements.
Segelbaum asked if the location of the homes shown on the drawing is where they will be
constructed or if it is just an example of where they might be located. Grimes explained
that the drawing is an example showing that the homes will meet the setback
requirements. Segelbaum asked if this proposal will come back to the Planning
Commission for further review. Grimes said no and added that the Preliminary Plat and
the Final Plat will go to the City Council for review.
Peter Knaeble, representing the applicant, stated that the proposal is fairly straightforward
and noted that the lots are twice as big as City Code requires. He referred to
Waldhauser's question about Lot 1 tapering in the back and explained that tapering Lot 1
gave Lot 2 more space which is needed because of an easement for the power lines.
Waldhauser opened the public hearing. Seeing and hearing no one wishing to comment,
Waldhauser closed the public hearing.
MOVED by Cera, seconded by Kluchka and motion carried unanimously to recommend
approval of a Minor Subdivision to divide the property at 228 Meander Road into two
single family residential lots subject to the following conditions:
1. The City Attorney will determine if a title review is necessary prior to approval of the
final plat.
2. A park dedication fee determined by the City Council shall be paid before final plat
approval.
3. The City Engineer's memorandum, dated March 4, 2013 shall become part of this
approvaL
Minutes of the Golden Valley Planning Commission
March 11, 2013
Page 7
4. A Subdivision Agreement will be drafted for review and approval by the City Council
that will include issues found in the City Engineer's memorandum.
5. All applicable City permits shall be obtained prior to the development af the new lots.
6. Informal Public Hearing — Final Plan Review— Planned Unit Development
(PUD) — The 3.9.4 Apartments — PUD #112
Applicant: Global One Golden Valley, LLC
Address: Northwest Corner of I-394 and Highway 100
Purpose: To allow for the construction of a 6-story, 314 unit, market rate
apartment building and a 6-story, 120 unit, senior living building.
Hogeboom stated that the Preliminary PUD plan for this proposal was approved by the
City Council in December and the applicants are now starting the Final PUD approval
process. He referred to a location map of the properties and explained the applicant's
proposal to construct two buildings on the 7.47 acre site. One of the buildings will be a
six-story, 314-unit, market rate apartment building and the other will be a six-story, 120-
unit senior assisted living building.
Hogeboom referred to a site plan of the proposed project and discussed the changes
made to the plans since the Preliminary plan review. The driveway entrance on Circle
Down has been shifted to the west in order to line up with garages, rather than the homes
to the north and to be further away from the home to east, the access drive on the
northern portion of the site has been eliminated to move interna( traffic further away from
the northern property line, the garage entry has been reconfigured to add an additional
entrance and to help distribute the site traffic and the proposed east building has been
redesigned with articulated corners to move the building further away from the
north/northeast property line.
Waldhauser asked if any portion of the proposed buildings will be six stories in height
within the area that allows only three stories in height according to the Mixed Use zoning
district requirements. Hogeboom stated that a small portion of the buildings would overlap
into the three-story area. Grimes added that the underlying Mixed Use zoning district is
used as a guide, however that is irrelevant in this case because it is a PUD and can be
approved as is.
Waldhauser asked about the alley access referred to the staff reports. Hogeboom stated
that there is an existing publicly deeded alley to be used as a second access to the site.
Segelbaum asked who is responsible for maintaining the alley access. Hogeboom
explained that the developer will enter into a development agreement with the City which
will address maintenance issues.
Kluchka referred to the walkway shown on the far eastern end of the property and asked
if it would be owned by the City or by the developer. Hogeboom explained that that
Minutes of the Golden Valley Planning Commission
March 11, 2013
Page 8
property is owned by MnQOT. Grimes added that MnDOT would also have to approve
that proposed walkway.
Segelbaum asked about the scope of the Planning Commission's review since the
Preliminary Plans have already been approved. Hogeboom stated that the scope of the
Planning Commission's review is to decide if the Final PUD proposal is consistent with
the approved Preliminary PUD proposal. Grimes added that the Planning Commission
and the City Council have asked for significant changes to the plans which the applicant
has made.
Kluchka said he thinks it is important to note the differences in what the Mixed Use zoning
District would allow without a PUD. He said it is significant that a portion of the proposed
buildings that are six stories tall are crossing into a space that has historically a�lowed
three stories. Segelbaum noted that the plans as shown are what the City Council have
already adopted. Waldhauser noted that the entire building has been moved further to the
south as requested of the applicant.
McCarty referred to the articulation of the northeast corner of the building and asked if
that caused a reduction in the number of units. Gary Tushie, Architect for the project,
stated that they originally had 318 units and now they have 314 units.
Mark Globus, Global One Commercial, Applicant, reiterated that they have made a
number of changes since their Preliminary Plan approval. He stated that they have
submitted a snow storage plan and asked staff if they are comfortable with the plan.
Hogeboom explained that the applicant has demonstrated where snow will be stored and
the City Council will decide during their review if it is acceptable.
Waldhauser asked for further explanation of the retaining walls, landscaping and fencing
along the north property line. Tushie showed the Commission a rendering of what the
landscaping, fencing and retaining walls will look like in various places along the north
property line. Waldhauser asked if water will collect in the depressed areas along the
nor�h property line. Cera asked if snow would melt and drain onto the properties to the
north. Tushie explained how the drainage system will work by carrying the water from the
north to the east and the south. John Bender, MFRA, Engineer for the project explained
that the bulk of the water on the site will be drain to an underground storage facility and
some will be treated in the ponds and will connect to the City's storm sewer system. Cera
questioned what would prevent too much water from going to the west. Bender explained
how half of the site will go the storm sewer system to the west and half will go to the south
to the MnDOT system. He added that they were required to show in their plans that their
discharge is equal to or less than current conditions. Grimes noted that the City Engineer
has reviewed the plans and that the Bassett Creek Watershed Management Commission
will also review the plans.
Kluchka asked the applicant if they brought samples of the exterior building materials.
Tushie said no and explained that the renderings shown in the plans are fairly close to
how the materials will look. Kluchka suggested the applicant bring material samples when
they go to the City Council for review.
Minutes of the Golden Valley Planning Commission
March 11, 2013
Page 9
Cera asked to hear more about the changes made to the plans since the last time the
Commission reviewed them. Tushie stated that all of the changes the Planning
Commission recommended last time have been made and that the plans before the
Commission this time are almost identical to what the City Council approved.
Cera asked the applicant if he has had any further discussions with the neighbors. Globus
said he hasn't had any further discussions with the neighbors but he wouid be happy to.
Waldhauser opened the pubfic hearing.
David Webb, 5410 Wayzata Blvd, said he has a number of objections and concerns about
the proposal. He said he doesn't believe the proposal is a complete application and thus
cannot be considered for approval as a PUD. He referred to the PUD section of the Gity
Code and stated that the applicant hasn't provided an analysis of the number of cars that
will use the alley. He stated that this property is non-conforming and there is confusion
between the requirements in the Mixed Use zoning district versus the requirements in the
PUD sectian of the City Code. He referred to a letter that developers received from the
City in 2008 indicating that a mixed-use development would have to be developed an the
site. He said he has concerns about the increase in traffic and said that labeling the alley
a secondary access is arbitrary because it will become a primary access which won't
meet any of the City's right-of-way requirements. He said there is significant pedestrian
access and delivery truck traffic currently in the alley and he is concerned about safety.
He referred to the language in the PUD section of the City Cade and said this project has
numerous violations of that chapter and he rejects staff saying that this proposed use is
compatible because since this project's inception it has been an attempt to fit a square
peg in a round hole. He said he wants to keep the integrity of the Circle Down
neighborhood and asked that the Planning Commission not allow this proposal ta
proceed.
Segelbaum asked Mr. Webb if his main concern was the alley becoming a primary access
route. Webb said his cancern is beyond traffic on his property because there is a lot of
pedestrian traffic in the alley area and someone could get hurt. He also stated that
delivery vehicles to his property use the ally when unloading. He added that when the City
reconstructed the streets in the area the traffic was a mess.
Waldhauser questioned if a speed bump at the start of the alley access would help.
Kluchka stated that traffic engineers have said speed bumps don't work but it sounds like
there is a pedestrian safety issue that needs to be considered.
Waldhauser asked Mr. Webb if he has offered any alternative proposals. Webb said he
can't because Mr. Globus is the designated developer. He stated that the letter from the
City to developers in 2008 said any development would have to conform to the Mixed Use
zoning district which probably hindered many developers from coming forward. Grimes
disagreed and said he has totd many developers that the site would more than likely need
to be developed using the PUD process.
Minutes af the Golden Valley Planning Commission
March 11, 2013
Page 10
Doug Wageman, 5400 Circle Down, said he is not opposed to the development per se but
he thinks it is pretty big. He said he doesn't think the access should be on Circle Down
and asked if the City has looked into using eminent domain to provide access to the west
of the site instead of the proposed access on Circle Down. He said there is an obvious
"Hatfield and McCoy thing" between the applicant and Mr. Webb but the City has to be
neutral and make it work.
Laura Itman, 5300 Cirlce Down, said at the last Planning Commission meeting the
proposed traffic was compared to the traffic that currently exists on Regent however
Regent connects to Duluth which is a major street unlike Circle Down. A project of this
size coming out on to Circle Down is a whole different issue and 3,000 cars should not
come out on a street that isn't a major street.
John Sonsalla, 5301 Circle Down, said Circle Down cannot handle this amount of traffic.
He said there are times now when it is hard for two cars to pass each other because it is
too narrow and with more traffic there will be more problems. He said it is going to be
noisy and he will see light from the road and the parking lot and people will be walking
across his yard. He asked what types of trees the applicant will be planting and if they will
give the homeowners on Circle Down additianal insulation or new windows. He said a six-
story building is ridiculous and he will have no sun in his house until 11 am or noon in the
winter time. He referred to the power lines on the property and asked if they will be
relocated or buried and who would have to pay to bury the power lines. He said he is also
concerned about damage to houses from additional truck traffic and the use of pilings and
he hopes there is a bond issued or the homeowners in the area are covered as additional
insureds on the contractors insurance.
Seeing and hearing no one else wishing to speak, Waldhauser closed the public hearing.
Kluchka asked if the traffic study included the alley. Grimes said that a large majority of
the traffic will use Circle Down as the primary access however the City cannot stop
people from using the alley. He agreed that consideration needs to be given to improved
pedestrian safety in the alley.
Waldhauser asked if the right-of-way or alley could be shifted to the north. Grimes said it
is his understanding that the developer attempted to negotiate with Mr. Webb but it was
unsuccessful. Kluchka questioned if the Planning Commission should add a condition of
approval regarding pedestrian safety in the alley. Grimes said that the Pubtic Works staff
will decide what precautions are necessary and the City will work with Mr. Webb on his
safety concerns because the City also wants it to work well.
Segelbaum asked why the traffic study didn't include the alley. Grimes stated that it is
assumed that some of the traffic will use the alley. He said he can't address the traffic
engineering. However this is one of the most studied areas and staff is convinced that the
traffic will work to a satisfactory level. McCarty added that the total traffic count of 2,229
cars is the total number of trips when the reality is that would likely not happen all at once
given the average vacancy rates, the timing of the trips, etc. He said he thinks it might not
be as big of an impact as people think. Grimes agreed and stated that the 2,229 trips will
Minutes af the Golden Valley Planning Commission
March 11, 2013
Page 11
be over the course of a 16 hour day. There will likely be more traffic during peak hours but
everyone isn't coming or leaving at the same time. He said he agrees that there will be a
lot more traffic on Circle Down, but the street has the capacity to handle it. He reiterated
that staff feels confident with the traffic study that has been done.
Waldhauser asked about the comment regarding Circle Down being too narrow. Grimes
stated that narrower streets actually calm traffic.
Kluchka referred to the concerns about the project not meeting the requirements of the
Mixed Use zoning district and said it is his understanding that although the underlying
zoning district is a good guide it isn't necessarily taken into consideration when reviewing
a PUD. Waldhauser added that when the I-394 Corridor Study was done they were
optimistic that the City would get mixed use developments but it hasn't and the times and
markets change. Grimes agreed and added that this particular site is a difficult site to
develop.
Kluchka asked the developer how fences, trees, noise and light will be addressed at the
entrance. Globus said they have spent a great deal of time on the entrance. They've
added a pond as a buffer to the residence next to the entrance, they've angled the
driveway so headlights would shine on the garages and not the houses and there will be
a solid fence along the north property line that will help eliminate light and noise. He
added that a high level of sound from I-394 already exists in this area and it is not an
extremely quiet area as it sits today.
Grimes asked Globus if he would be willing to work with the neighboring property owners
regarding their landscaping preferences. Globus said yes he would be willing to work with
the neighbors.
Kluchka referred to the neighbor's questions about burying the power lines and suggested
a condition of approval that states the developer will show reasonable effort to work with
Xcel on burying power lines and assume the cost of the burying of their power lines and
the neighbors. Segelbaum said he would be more comfortable saying that the
landscaping plans have to accommodate the power lines. Cera agreed that the goal is to
provide maximum screening whether that includes burying the power lines or not.
Tushie said he is assuming that Xcel will bury the power lines when they bring in a
transformer for their project. Waidhauser said the cost of buying the homeowner's power
lines falls on the homeowner. Tushie said he believes that is an Xcel Energy issue.
Segelbaum said he thinks the applicant should discuss the issue with Xcel. Cera
suggested the applicant also talk to Xcel about the homeowner's power lines and who is
responsible for paying to have them buried.
Kluchka suggested another condition of approval that states that safety features in the
alley will be incorporated into the plan. Cera said he wants a condition of approval added
requiring increased discussions with the neighbors before construction starts.
Kluchka referred to the neighbor's questions about constructian insurance in case of
damage. Globus stated that they are putting a plan together for the City to review that will
Minutes of the Golden Valley Planning Gommission
March 11, 2013
Page 12
deal with any type of vibration issues. Cera noted that this area was impacted by the
construction of I-394 so residents are sensitive to that issue. He added that since there
are some issues with the neighboring property owners it would be a good idea for the
applicant to have some sort of public campaign with the neighbors to educate them on the
issues and to keep talking to the neighbors. Grimes stated that the contractor will have a
communications plan for the neighbors during construction. Cera said he would like there
to be another public meeting with the neighbors.
Segelbaum said he thinks this is a reasonable proposal. Cera said he thinks the appiicant
has made all of the changes he can. Kluchka agreed. Waldhauser said this is an
important site in Golden Valley and it is nice to see something positive. She said she also
wants to preserve existing areas as well and additional residents in the area will help
support the larger area.
Waldhauser asked about a lighting plan. Grimes said they have submitted a lighting plan
that follows the City's lighting ordinance.
MOVED by Segelbaum, seconded by Kluchka and motion carried unanimously to
recommend approval of the Final PUD Plan for the 3.9.4 Apartments, PUD #112 subject
to the following findings and conditions:
Findinqs:
1. The PUD plan is tailored to the specific characteristics of the site and achieves a
higher quality of site planning and design than generally expected under
conventional provisions of the ordinance.
2. The PUD plan preserves and protects substantial desirable portions of the site's
characteristics, open space and sensitive environmental features including steep
slopes, trees, scenic views, creeks, wetlands and open waters.
3. The PUD plan includes efficient and effective use (which includes preservation) of
the land.
4. The PUD Plan results in development compatible with adjacent uses and is
consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and redevelopment plans and goals.
5. The PUD plan is consistent with preserving and improving the general health, safety
and general welfare of the people of the City.
6. The PUD plan meets the PUD Intent and Purpose provision and all other PUD
ordinance provisions.
Conditions:
1. The plans prepared by Tushie Montgomery Architects dated February 11, 2013 shall
become a part of this approval.
2. The recommendations and requirements outlined in the memo from Fire Chief Mark
Kuhnly to Mark Grimes, Director of Planning and Development dated March 4, 2013,
shall become part of this approval.
Minutes of the Golden Valley Planning Commission
March 11, 2013
Page 13
3. The recommendations and requirements outlined in the memo from City Engineer Jeff
Oliver to Mark Grimes, Director of Planning and Development, dated March 4, 2013,
shall become a part of this approval.
4. The Applicant is assessed a Traffic Management Fee of$43,328.10 per City Code.
Payment of half of the fee ($21,664.05) is required prior to approval of the Final PUD
Plan. (The remaining half of the fee is required to be paid prior to the issuance of a
Building Permit.)
5. Prior to consideration of the Final PUD Plan by the City Council a plan for foundations
pilings, signed by a licensed structural engineer, shall be reviewed and approved by
the City.
6. Landscape screening along the north property line shall be compatible with utility
line layouts.
7. If utility lines are buried, reasonable efforts shall be made by the developer to
assume all costs associated with the buriaL
8. The developer shall create a construction communication plan with the
neighborhood that will attempt to consider neighborhood preferences for
landscaping and screening mechanisms.
9. Snow shall be stored in the areas designated on the site plan.
10. The City Attorney will determine if Park Dedication is applicable prior to the City
Council's approval of the Final Plat.
11. All signs on the property shall meet the requirements of the City's Sign Code.
12. This approval is subject to all other state, federal, and local ordinances, regulations, or
laws with authority over this development.
--Short Recess--
7. Reports on Meetings of the Housing and Redevelopment Authority, City
Council, Board of Zoning Appeals and other Meetings
Waldhauser reported on a Sensible Land Use Coalition seminar she attended.
8. Other Business
Hogeboom stated that the Planning Commissioners will no longer represent Planning
Commission proposals at the City Council meetings.
9. Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at 9:33 pm.
David A. Cera, Secretary
Golden Valley Human Services Fund (GVHSF) Meeting
Minutes
April 8, 2013
Present: Amy Clements, Hilmer Erickson, Kathryn Frommer, Katie Hart, Alan Ingber,
Diane Nimmer, Connie Sandler, Toots Vodovoz and Peggy Watkins. Also present: Joanie
Clausen, Council Liaison, and Jeanne Fackler, Staff Liaison.
Not Attending: Elissa Heilicher, Brenda Hayle.
Call to Order: Sand�er called the meeting to order at 6:45 p.m.
Agenda Changes or Additions: No agenda changes or additions.
Welcome and Introductions: Sandler welcomed Amy Clements to the GVHSF.
February 11 minutes: Erickson moved and Vodovoz seconded the motion to approve the
minutes from February 11. The motion passed unanimously.
Run the Valley: Registration is down in every event, probably due to the weather.
Sponsor Update: T-shirts and awards were delivered. Refreshments have been
confirmed. The GVCF will reimburse the City of Golden Valley for the t-shirt costs.
Volunteer Update: Vodovoz has contacted agencies for volunteers. SCS - 3 volunteers,
Bassett Creek Dental - 3 volunteers, PRISM — 7 volunteers. The Volunteer Coordinator for
the City of Golden Valley has publicized the event and has approximately 35 people from
the community volunteering that day.
Marketing/Publicity: Dave Kiser will announce on Saturday. The Sun-Post will have an
article this week featuring the event.
Duties/Assignments:
Pre-race:
AI's Coffee - Public Works will pick-up 30 cases of water on Friday from warehouse
Chiquita Bananas - Dan Blumb will deliver on Friday
Einstein Bagels - Heilicher will pick up on Saturday
Great Glacier Water - delivered to Vodovoz
Perkins 394 - Vodovoz will pick up Saturday
Perkins 55 - Clausen will pick up on Saturday
Old Fashioned Donut Shoppe - Heilicher will pick up on Friday
Valley Pastries - Sandler will pick up on Saturday
Yoplait - delivered to Brookview
Race Day:
Erickson - greeter, Frommer - volunteer check-in, Hart - t-shirts, Heilicher - same day
registration, Inber - same day registration, Sandler - pre-registration table, Vodovoz - walk
pre-registration table, Clausen - refreshments. Set up will be done by the Community
Center staff, GVHSF members will assist with clean-up.
Calendar:
Golf Classic date has been set for Friday, July 12. Letters will be going to past sponsors in
May. TCGMC: Sandler has asked Heilicher to contact the director of the TCGMG sa a date
may be set for the concert.
Other Business:
Community Foundation: Sandler gave a brief history of the GVCF, which will be 2 years old
in May, and independent from the city. Clausen mentioned that residents are confused
between GVHSF and GVCF. The Council will be looking at Envision, Human Service Fund
and Community Foundation and discussing "Where is Golden Valley going?" The city has
received $1,624 from the GVCF. This is the GVHSF designated amount collected from the
2012 solicitation letter.
Valley Days: Valley Days is set for Saturday, May 18.
The Board and Commission dinner will be held on Wednesday, June 19 at Brookview.
Invitations will be mailed the week of June 3.
Sandler reminded the members that the next meeting is scheduled for Monday, May 13.
Elections will be held for Chair and Vice-Chair. Nimmer announced that her term is up in
May and April is her last meeting. The members thanked Nimmer for her years of service.
Adjournment: Erickson moved to adjourn the meeting, Hart seconded the motion. The
meeting was adjourned at 7:50 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Connie Sandler, GVHSF Chair Jeanne Fackler, Staff Liaison
Police Civii Service Commission Meeting
7800 Golden Valiey Road
Golden Valley, MN 55427
Monday, February 4, 2013 — 9 AM
Public Safety Building Conference Room
MINUTES
Call to Order
Attendance/Rol/ Call
The meeting was called to order by Chair Kumagai at 9:05 am. Present at the meeting
were Commissioners Marshall Tanick, Gloria Kumagai and Ben Peterson; Police Chief
Stacy Carlson, Commander Mike Meehan, Council Member Joanie Clausen and
Administrative Assistant Amanda Johnson.
Aqenda Review
There were no additions or revisions to the agenda.
Approval of Minutes of Februarv 6, 2012
Commissioner Tanick moved to approve the February 6, 2012 minutes; seconded by
Commissioner Peterson. The February 6, 2012 minutes were unanimously approved.
Staffinq Projections for 2013
Chief Carlson advised there is one vacant police officer position, which has not been able
to be filled for the past couple years. The city manager approved assigning a patrol officer
to a traffic enforcement/education position for the first half of 2013. if the efforts in this area
prove to be worthwhile and successful, the city manager has indicated he will approve the
hiring of another police officer.
Chief Carlson also advised new pension fund penalties are being discussed, and would
become effective on 07/01/14 if approved. The police department currently has 1-4
employees who could retire prior to those penalties being enforced. Those potential
retirements would likely result in promotions and the hiring of additional officers.
Police Officer Recruitment/Selection Process Report
Chief Carlson advised if the City Manager authorizes the hiring of an additional police
officer, she will be seeking approval to initiate an open application process. The board
agreed to meet later this year to grant approval for this process.
Chief's Report
Chief Carlson advised staffing in 2013 remained solid. She advised overall crime has
increased, especially in the areas of residential burglaries and theft from autos. Officers
have captured a number of in-progress burglars, which is not very common. Night shift
officers continue to notify residents of apen garage doors during the overnight hours in
effort to reduce burglaries and thefts.
Chief Carlson stated the department hosted many community events in 2012 including:
Police & Fire in the Parks, Night to Unite, Police & Fire Open House, Citizen's Academy,
Bike-alongs and a Use of Force Seminar. The police department also played an active role
in providing security and other services during President Obama's visit to Honeywell in
June.
Commissioner Tanick inquired about the current gun law issues that are being discussed
and what is being done on a local city level. Chief Carlson advised staff is drafting a
checklist for schools and businesses concerning how to respond to an active shooter
situation. Active shooter training exercises are planned for 2/21 for city employees working
in City Hall.
Election of Officers
Commissioner Tanick announced hi� resignation effective 02/05/13. Commissioner Tanick
stated he has enjoyed his service on the commission and has appreciated getting to know
some of the officers better. Council Member Clausen advised interviews are being
conducted to appoint a replacement for Commissioner Tanick.
Per state law the commissioner in the last year of his/her term is the designated chair of the
commission. With Commissioner Tanick's resignation, Commissioner Peterson is the
member nearest the end of his appointment term. Commissioner Tanick nominated
Commissioner Peterson as Chair; seconded by Chair Kumagai. Commissioner Peterson
was elected Chair for 2013 by consensus.
Commissioner Tanick nominated Commissioner Kumagai as secretary; seconded by
Commissioner Peterson. Commissioner Kumagai was elected secretary for 2013 by
consensus.
Other Business
There was no other business.
Closing Comments
Chief Carlson thanked Commissianer Tanick for his service on the commission and stated
his perspectives are far and wide, and have been appreciated. Chief Carlson also thanked
Commissioners Kumagai and Peterson for their continued service. Commissioner Peterson
echoed the sentiments regarding Commissioner Tanick's service on the commission.
Commissioner Kumagai thanked Chief Carlson for her leadership and transparency.
Adjournment
Commissioner Tanick moved to adjourn the meeting; seconded by Commissioner
Peterson. The meeting was adjourned at 9:34 AM.
Respectfully submitted,
Gloria Kumagai, Secretary
GOLDEN VALLEY OPEN SPACE & RECREATION C�MMISSION
Regular Meeting
Minutes
March 18, 2013
1. Call to Order
Sandler called the meeting to order at 7:05 PM.
Present: Roger Bergman, John Cornelius, Bob Mattison, Jerry Sandler, Dan
Steinberg, Jim Fitzsimmons, Golden Valley Phoenix Soccer Club; Joanie
Clausen, City Council Member; Shep Harris, City Mayor; Rick Jacobson,
Director of Parks and Recreation; and Sheila Van Sloun, Administrative
Assistant.
Absent: Brad Kadue, Kelly Kuebelbeck and Anne Saffert.
2. Aqenda Chanaes or Additions
None.
3. Approval of Minutes — Januarv 28, 2013
MOTION: MOVED by Steinberg and seconded by Bergman to approve the January
28 meeting minutes. Motion carried unanimously.
4. Greetinqs from Mavor Harris
Harris began by thanking the Commission for their service and time.
With the new city survey coming out this year, Harris asked the Commission to think big
and creatively for suggestions and ideas to recommend to the Council to take the
community to a new level with programs and services. In an effort to think creatively, he
asked the Commission to try not to be so concerned with funding while coming up with
recommendations, leaving the funding questions to the CounciL
He also recommended a resident that expressed interest in participating in a community
group sub-committee to do community outreach and provide recommendations to the
Open Space and Recreation Commission. Sandler said he'd like to discuss the
opportunity with the Commission and requested their contact information. Clausen said
she appreciates that the Gommission is open to the idea. Sandler said it helps to get
new and fresh input and ideas.
5. Golden Valley Phoenix Soccer Update — Jim Fitzsimmons
Fitzsimmons introduced himself and stated he's been with the club for 5 years, 3 of
which he's been President.
Fitzsimmons said the demand from parents for a more competitive travel program has
increased. In an effort to do so, the club has begun phasing out parent coaches and
bringing in paid coaches for the kids in the competitive soccer program. There are
currently 600+ families involved in the competitive program, which includes 27 teams
ranging from U9-U17. There are 15 girls teams and 12 boys teams.
Minutes of the Golden Valley Open Space and Recreation Commission
March 18, 2013
Page 2
Fitzsimmons said the recreational program has about 280 kids, with 30 teams ranging
from ages 5-10. He said this program still has parent coaches.
Fitzsimmons said their goal is to keep costs down. Compared to surrounding
communities, Phoenix Soccer fees are less. He said they also offer financial
assistance.
Fitzsimmons said the different age groups require different size fields and it can be a
lot for one community to accommodate. He said they really enjoy the field space in
Golden Valley but they are in need of more practice space. He's been working with
surrounding communities to accommodate that need. Fitzsimmons said the club is
getting participants from Golden Valley, Crystal, Robbinsdale, Plymouth, St. Louis
Park and Minneapolis.
Steinberg asked about the evening summer Park and Recreation programs and
Phoenix Soccer being on some of the same evenings. He wanted to know if there was
going to be some collaboration between the two for better scheduling. Jacobson said
it's difficult to avoid overlap with all the other association's schedules with the fields
they have at their disposal. Fitzsimmons added they are doing the best they can with
scheduling around all other community activities. The nights that were chosen were
based on the consensus of what worked best for most of the families that participate
in the soccer club.
It was asked at what age the competitive league begins. Fitzsimmons said
competitive starts with U9 and goes up to U17.
Mattison asked if Phoenix feels the need for another full size field. Fitzsimmons said
yes, they are using a field in Robbinsdale. Mattison suggested Sandburg fields as a
possibility.
Fitzsimmons expressed interest in a Golden Valley athletic dome. He said a number
of surrounding communities have domes that are busy.
Fitzsimmons encauraged the Commission to visit their website at
www.gvphoen ixsoccer.orq.
6. Citv Survev Park Questions Review
Jacobson said Cheryl Weiler is looking for input from the Commission for topics for
the city survey. Copies of the Park and Recreation portion of the 2006 city survey
were distributed and discussed. After discussion, Jacobson asked the Commission to
submit their input and ideas to Van Sloun.
Minutes of the Golden Valley Open Space and Recreation Commission
March 18, 2013
Page 3
7. OSRC Work Plan
Sandler said Mayor Harris has challenged the Gommissions to be more pro-active
with work plan goals. Sandler said he would like to discuss new thoughts and ideas
for programs throughout the year. Discussion then focused on topics and
suggestions. Sandler encouraged the Commission to continue to share their ideas.
8, Updates
Jacobson reminded the Commission that Run the Valley is on Saturday, April 13
beginning and ending at Brookview Community Center.
Jacobson informed the Commission that Brookview Golf received one proposal for a
food and beverage contract. He said the proposal did not meet the needs of the golf
course and community center and that they did not aecept the proposal.
9. Adiournment
MOTION: MOVED by Mattison and seconded by Bergman to adjourn at 8:40 PM.
Motion carried unanimously.
Jerry Sandler, Chair
ATTEST:
Sheila Van Sloun, Administrative Assistant
ks L�y Rf� �i�,` +��y
r�
� ..�� .. . . .. .
� Public Works Department
�� - - -
763 593-8030/763 593 3988(fax}
Executive Summary For Action
Golden Valley City Council Meeting
May 21, 2013
Agenda Item ,
3. E. 1. Purchase One Single Axle Cab Chassis Truck
Prepared By
Jeannine Clancy, Director of Public Works
Bert Tracy, Public Works Maintenance Manager
Steve Loomis, Vehicle Maintenance Foreman
Summary
The 2013-2017 Capital Improvement Program (CIPj includes $235,000 for the purchase of a single
axle dump truck, equipment, and setup (V&E-088, page 42); and $45,Q00 from the Storm Sewer
budget (SS-26, page 79) for the purchase of the V-Box Sander for the single axle truck.
The single axle cab and chassis truck and equipment will be equipped with a swaploader system
dump body, front snowplow, underbody scraper,V-box sander with anti-icing and de-icing
technology, and associated hydraulics. Staff utilizes this equipment for snow removal and other
maintenance activities. The swaploader system allows staff to utilize various truck boxes and
accessories for one truck. The lead-time for truck delivery and equipment is seven to eight
months.
The 1998 dump truck meets replacement criteria set forth in the City's vehicle replacement policy
and Vehicle Condition Index (VCI). The VCI index is a tool utilized to assess all vehicles and
equipment scheduled for replacement and any vehicle/equipment scoring 28 points and above
meets the category of"needs immediate consideration." The 1998 dump truck due for
replacement scored 33 points.
The Minnesota Materials Management Division has awarded the following contracts:
Contract No. Item Vendor Amount
60999 International 7500 4x2 Single Boyer International Trucks $83,806.11
Axle Cab and Chassis
Total Cab and Chassis Less Tax and License $83,806.11
60353 Swaploader, SL 400, Towmaster, Inc. $125,803.00
Underbody, and Control
Equipment
Tax on Equipment 8,648.96
Total Equipment $134,451.96
60353 V-Box Sander Towmaster, Inc. $27,380.00
Tax on V-Box Sander 1,882.38
Total V-Box Sander 29,262.38
TOTAL $247,520.45
Recommended Action
1. Motion to approve purchase of one 2013 International 7500 4x2 single axle cab and chassis
truck from Boyer International Trucks in the amount of$83,806.11.
2. Motion to approve equipment purchases from Towmaster, Inc. in the amount of$134,451.96.
3. Motion to approve V-Box Sander from Towmaster, Inc. in the amount of$29,262.38.
4. If sales tax legislation is approved, the sales tax will be deleted from total payment.
. 4:'LY y V�� �ii' .
✓
�� � Finance Department
�� - - - -
763 593 8013/763 593 8109(fax)
_ . . _ Q. �
�„�� ; � f ,
Executive Summary For Action
Golden Valley City Council Meeting
May 21, 2013
Agenda Item
3. F. Receipt of April 2013 Financial Reports
Prepared By
Sue Virnig, Finance Director
Summary
The monthly financial report provides a progress report of the following funds:
General Fund Operations
Conservation/Recycling Fund (Enterprise Fund)
Water and Sewer Utility Fund (Enterprise Fund)
Brookview Golf Course (Enterprise Fund)
Motor Vehicle Licensing (Enterprise Fund)
Storm Utility Fund (Enterprise Fund)
Equipment Replacement Fund (Capital Projects Fund)
General Fund Operations: As of April 2013,the City uses $3,004,880 of fund balance to balance
the General Fund Budget,
Attachments
• April 2013 General Fund Financial Reports - unaudited (2 pages)
• April 2013 Conservation/Recycling Fund Financial Report- unaudited (1 page)
• April 2013 Water and Sewer Utility Fund Financial Report- unaudited (1 page)
• April 2013 Brookview Golf Course Fund Financial Report- unaudited (1 page)
• April 2013 Motor Vehicle Licensing Fund Financial Report- unaudited (1 page)
• April 2013 Storm Utility Fund Financial Report- unaudited (1 page)
• April 2013 Equipment Replacement Fund Report (1 page)
Recommended Action
Motion to receive and file the April 2013 Financial Reports.
City of Golden Valley
Monthly Budget Report-General Fund Revenues
April, 2013
Percentage Of Year Completed 33.00%
Over %
2013 April YTD (Under) of Budget
Type Budget Actual Actual Budget Received
Ad Valorem Taxes $11,967,780 9,821 9,821 ($11,957,959) 0.08% (1)
Licenses 191,510 61,135 101,764 ($89,746) 53.14% (2)
Permits 693,200 58,499 308,280 ($384,920) 44.47% (3)
Federal Grants 0 0 0 $0
State Aid 10,500 4,625 4,625 ($5,875) 44.05% (4)
Hennepin County Aid 24,000 0 0 ($24,000) (5)
Charges For Services:
General Government 43,560 1,375 2,257 ($41,303) 5.18%
Public Safety 151,385 6,727 44,284 ($107,101) 29.25%
Public Works 140,000 11,870 41,081 ($98,919) 29.34%
Park& Rec 423,750 62,056 185,483 ($238,267) 43.77%
Other Funds 981,500 56,939 224,559 ($756,941) 22.88%
Fines & Forfeitures 280,000 34,022 107,132 ($172,868) 38.26%
Interest On Investments 100,000 900 900 ($99,100) 0.90% (6)
Miscellaneous Revenue 227,200 17,513 65,610 ($161,590) 28.88%
Transfers In 100,000 8,333 33,333 ($66,667) 33.33% (7)
TOTAL Revenue $15,334,385 $333,815 $1,129,129 ($14,205,256) 7.36%
Notes:
(1) Payments are received in July, December, and January.
(2)Apartments, Pawn and Liquor License revenue were higher than budgeted.
(3) Building permit revenue increased with new home construction.
(4) Police Training is paid in August. Safe and Sober is billed on time spent.
(5) Payment for officer to be part of the Violent Offenders Task Force.
(6) Investment income is allocated at year end.
(7)Transfers are monthly.
City of Golden Valley
Monthly Budget Report-General Fund Expenditures
April, 2013(unaudited)
Over %
2013 April YTD (Unde�) Of Budget
Division Budget Actual Actual Budget Expend.
001 Council $286,185 51,903 117,831 ($168,354) 41.17%
003 City Manager 729,810 53,908 202,259 (527,551) 27.71%
ooa Transfers Out 444,710 0 0 (444,710) 0.00% (1)
005 Admin. Services 1,594,515 69,760 384,099 (1,210,416) 24.09%
oos Legal 135,000 13,289 25,928 (109,072) 19.21% (3)
007 Risk Management 300,000 0 11,029 (288,971) 3.68% (2)
011 General Gov't. Bldgs. 525,990 34,196 143,490 (382,500) 27.28%
016 Planning 323,750 23,694 95,680 (228,070) 29.55°/a
022 Police 4,862,455 395,018 1,535,647 (3,326,808) 31.58%
023 Fire and Inspections 1,591,200 122,945 454,148 (1,137,052) 28.54%
035 PublicWorksAdmin. 321,545 25,082 96,186 (225,359) 29.91%
036 Engineering 668,745 22,638 141,486 (527,259) 21.16%
03� Streets 1,385,115 95,920 416,609 (968,506) 30.08%
065 Community Center 72,910 4,260 15,131 (57,779) 20.75%
oss Park & Rec.Admin. 665,465 50,471 189,467 (475,998) 28.47%
os� Park Maintenance 1,006,895 70,958 238,171 (768,724) 23.65%
oss Recreation Programs 420,095 13,915 66,848 (353,247) 15.91%
TOTAL Expenditures $15,334,385 $1,047,957 $4,134,009 ($11,200,376) 26.96%
(1)Transfers will be made in June.
(2) LMCIT quarterly payment has not been billed this year.
(3) Legal bills are billed through March.
City of Golden Valley
Monthly Budget Report-Conservation/Recycling Enterprise Fund
April 2013 (unaudited)
Over
2013 April YTD (Under) %
Budget Actual Actual Budget Current
Revenue
Hennepin County Recycling Grant 56,500 0 0 (56,500) 0.00%
Recycling Charges 274,950 24,284 68,970 (205,980) 25.08% (3)
Miscellaneous Revenues 25,000 0 0 (25,000) (4)
Interest on Investments 5,000 0 0 (5,000j 0.00% (1)
Total Revenue 361,450 24,284 68,970 (292,480) 19.08%
Expenses:
Recycling 397,250 19,792 61,792 (335,458) 15.55% (2)
Total Expenses 397,250 19,792 61,792 (335,458) 15.55%
(1) Interest Earnings are allocated at year-end.
(2) This includes through March services as of YTQ.
(3) Recycling Charges are through April 2013 (City Utility Bill).
City of Golden Valley
Monthly Budget Report-Water and Sewer Utility Enterprise Fund
April, 2013(unaudited)
Over
2013 April YTD (Under) %
Budget Actual Actual Budget Current
Revenue
Water Charges 4,103,415 284,772 920,460 (3,182,955) 22.43%
Sewer Charges 3,300,970 285,348 828,751 (2,472,219) 25.11%
Meter Sales 5,000 620 2,745 (2,255) 54.90%
MCES Grant Program 0 0 0 0
Penalties 120,000 13,755 34,141 (85,859) 28.45%
Charges for Other Services 275,000 2,700 16,752 (258,248) 6.09%
State Water Testing Fee Pass Through 43,000 4,084 11,614 (31,386) 27,01%
Certificate of Compliance 60,000 7,750 21,650 (38,350) 36.08%
Interest Earnings 50,000 0 0 (50,000) 0.00%
Total Revenue 7,957,385 599,029 1,836,113 (6,121,272) 23.07%
Expenses:
Utility Administration 1,703,005 45,914 260,880 (1,442,125) 15.32%
Sewer Maintenance 2,291,115 168,767 803,684 (1,487,431) 35.08%
Water Maintenance 4,141,820 206,470 1,074,463 (3,067,357) 25.94%
Total Expenses 8,135,940 421,151 2,139,027 (5,996,913) 26.29%
City of Golden Vailey
Monthly Budget Report-Brookview Golf Course Enterprise Fund(3)
April, 2013 (unaudited)
Over
2013 April YTD (Under) %
Budget Actual Actual Budget Current
Revenue
Green Fees 880,780 28,255 30,025 (850,755) 3.41%
Driving Range Fees 105,000 4,934 5,046 (99,954) 4.81%
Par 3 Fees 180,000 4,320 4,320 (175,680) 2.40%
Pro Shop Sales 78,500 7,149 7,841 (70,659) 9.99%
Pro Shop Rentals 228,600 5,361 5,510 (223,090) 2.41%
Concession Sales 214,700 6,302 6,856 (207,844) 3,19%
Other Revenue 67,325 14,402 47,115 (20,210) 69.98%
Interest Earnings 10,000 0 0 (10,000) 0.00% (1)
Less:Credit Card Charges/Sales Tax (40,000) (101) (180) 39,820 0.45% (4)
Total Revenue 1,724,905 70,622 106,533 (1,618,372) 6.18%
Expenses:
Golf Operations 659,860 57,791 178,615 (481,245) 27.07% (2)
Course Maintenance 718,285 54,262 167,080 (551,205) 23.26%
Pro Shop 107,395 22,169 42,118 (65,277) 39.22%
Gril) 170,330 5,119 8,561 (161,769) 5.03%
Driving Range 46,645 47 176 (46,469) 0.38%
Par 3 Course 22,350 0 919 (21,431) 4.11%
Total Expenses 1,724,865 139,388 397,469 (1,327,396) 23.04%
(1) Interest Earnings are allocated at year-end.
(2) Depreciation is allocated at year-end.
(3) Course opened April 26.
(4) Credit card fees are through March.
City of Golden Valley
Monthly Budget Report-Motor Vehicle Licensing Enterprise Fund
April,2013(unaudited)
Over
2013 April YTD (Under) %
Budget Actual Actual Budget Current
Revenue
Interest Earnings 2,000 0 0 (2,000) 0.00% (1)
Charges for Services 391,915 25,562 96,544 (295,371) 24.63%
Total Revenue 393,915 25,562 96,544 (297,371) 24.51%
Expenses:
Motor Vehicle Licensing 399,915 28,093 102,460 297,455 25.62%
Total Expenses 399,915 28,093 102,460 297,455 25.62%
(1) Interest Earnings are allocated at year-end.
City of Golden Valley
Monthly Budget Report-Storm Utility Enterprise Fund
April, 2013(unaudited)
Over
2013 April YTD (Under) %
Budget Actual Actual Budget Current
Revenue
fnterest Earnings 50,000 0 0 (50,000) 0.00% (1)
Storm Sewer Charges 2,228,920 195,678 697,145 (1,531,775) 31.28%
Bassett Creek Watershed 196,000 0 0 (196,000) 0.00%
State Grant-Other 0 0 0 0 (3)
Total Revenue 2,474,920 195,678 697,145 (1,777,775) 28.17%
Expenses:
Storm Utility 1,636,425 35,764 648,983 (987,442) 39.66% (2)
Street Cleaning 121,780 9,971 17,179 (104,601) 14.11%
Environmental Control 287,845 9,741 33,047 (254,798) 11.48%
Debt Service Payments 437,140 0 381,699 (55,441) 87.32%
Total Expenses 2,483,190 55,476 1,080,908 (1,402,282) 43.53%
(1) Interest Earnings are allocated at year-end.
(2) Depreciation is allocated at year-end and. 2012 PMP and 2013 PMP are not complete.
(3) Project Reimbursement,
2013 Equipment Replacement Fund(CIP)-Fund 5700
2013 April YTD
Budget Total Actual Remaining
Revenues:
Proceeds-Certificate of Indebtedness(7) 750000 7623 7623 742377
Sale of Assets 35000 0 18855 16145
Interest Earnings(allocated at year end) 15374 0 0 15374
TotalRevenues 800374 7623 26478 773896
Expenditures
Project Number Project Name
(1) V&E-001 Marked Squad Cars(Police) 35000 5599 71715 29,401
(2) V&E-002 Computers and Printers(Finance) 60000 0 9125 60,000
(3) V&E-003 Imaging System(Finance) 15000 0 0 15,000
V&E-011 Passenger Vehicle(Fire) 35000 0 29131 35,000
V&E-047 Pickup Truck(Park) 30000 0 42770 30,000
V&E-048 Rotary Mower(Park) 95000 0 98375 95,000
V&E-054 Pickup Truck(Vehicle Maintenance) 50000 0 41194 50,000
V&E-057 Pickup Truck(Park) 53000 0 44436 53,000
V&E-058 Fire Hose(Fire) 10000 0 9800 10,000
V&E-064 Sidewalk/Maintenance Tractor(Street) 155000 0 146459 155,000
V&E-085 Utility Vehicle(Fire) 35000 0 29131 35,000
(4) V&E-088 Single Axle Dump Truck(5treet) 235000 0 0 235,000
V&E-092 Marked Squad Digital Recording System(Police) 80000 7019 93472 72,981
� (5) V&E-117 Bobcat Toolcat(Park) 50000 0 0 50,000
(6) V&E-123 Trailer(Park) 10000 0 0 10,000
V&E-124 Lawn Mower(Park) 20000 0 20845 20,000
V&E-125 Skid Loader(Street) 60000 0 60862 60,000
Total Expenditures 1028000 12618 697315 1,015,382
(1)Two squads total; includes replacement of one squad from accident
(2)Computers are replaced every 4-5 years and purchased throughout the year based on available time.
(3),(4),(5),(6)Needs to be approved and purchased.
�"t�� C1�
Public Works Department
763-593-8030/763-593-3988(fax)
�� � __� _.. ,_
Executive Summary For Action
Golden Valley City Council Meeting
May 21, 2013
Agenda Item
3. G. Establish Permanent No Parking Zones at the East Driveway to 8145 Lewis Road
Prepared By
Jeannine Clancy, Director of Public Works
Jeff Oliver, PE, City Engineer
Mark Ray, PE, Street Maintenance Supervisor
Summary
In the fall of 2012, Parker-Hannifin staff contacted the City with a concern regarding truck access
to their facility at 8145 Lewis Road. Parking is currently restricted on the north side of Lewis Road
and as a result all the vehicles must park on the south side. On-street parking demand is high and
vehicles frequently park as close to driveway entrances as possible. State Statute prohibits
parking in front of driveways, but not directly adjacent to them. Semi-truck deliveries to the
Parker-Hannifin property loading dock sometimes have a challenge navigating the driveway
entrance due to vehicles parked on the street, as indicated by the tire marks in the adjacent
boulevards.
The proposed parking restrictions on either side of the east driveway entrance (which serves the
loading dock) are approximately equivalent in length to one vehicle. Permanently restricting
parking to serve one property is not common City practice; however, due to the consistent level
of on-street parking and the geometric configuration of Lewis Road, restricting the parking will
reduce impacts to the City boulevards, improve truck movement through the area, and reduce
the potential for physical contact between vehicles.
Attachments
• Location map (1 page)
• Resolution Restricting Vehicle Parking Adjacent to the East Driveway Entrance to 8145 Lewis
Road (1 page)
Recommended Action
Motion to adopt Resolution Restricting Vehicle Parking Adjacent to the East Driveway Entrance to
8145 Lewis Road.
10th Ave N ' ' �
,,.m: .,�, - �-,
,:y . ..
�" Ztiw:.__ ,§lil[�.:.� .. . -�. +�.
� 7�'.'�7 ' 777_'_r-777�"�-17��'-��f 7-�-7T��t-�—�'=-7 '� � � ;� 7
, `�• � ��,�r � � .s 6 �;"�'`3 «,� i �
��,, ' �;
. � , � �t����-������ Y� �, 8 .2 � ,=,� �>; � -�
�. ����
� � .�. �� ��
�� � �� � � - � _ �t
� -� ; � _.'� -�s+��`" �, , _ � �.s- .� � f� t
," .:"'�' '��-i ,� �f J +�'�'�
q 1 � � •' � � +�: ':, , � .
x � �, !;,�� ., ,� � �,, �
t;: � � +�f'� .;, _ � � � � ' ' ' ,� �. �"-�'�
�. 1 "'� '",_._,�'�, -r � ,�s�, . .
� f - ;"'�'�! �
� � , �
� ,*� Tq'+ [� ""1 ���_�`� �.1�_ �_ � � , :'. .��� .,� - -�
r�
, , Q
� � , � +, 1 �y+i s i ,r'?
.
, . �'.` \
'�_ ♦ "' �.�����1����,� �.a 1 _. �� � rr
,ro'��� ,/• ♦�� ��;�•� ���9�� �I��"I� ,��� • � � /
, 1 ♦ �.,�•'� �� � � � �i� I t''�
'�' ^�`` � �� '.'�, ������i���1 ' .
� - , �A•, A,. �-+qhA �� �r;k� � ���`�
� :�� ��• ';\J� � �' ° � A,������ ` �-4�Cty�.. , �
a� y,a � :�'- !` �� .�
�d' ��':� � � ♦,. '�� _ Propos� � . � �:
, �
� .s �� ♦ , � � ���j � �- -� ��� . �,/:,� `.
� • ' �
'.� +� • a ,� °i
R � �� � � � � � � � r � �� � �
j �� . T�a��.. ; ,
J 1 � .'�_r ( �_
.♦+.
r � T�� `X �{.��►. .t -���.T �. .
��� �814 5 ---�-:�- � , �, �► �
. o� . � , . .
,�, , �'�� •. >_ ..;�� �` �,•� ��, �� � ���`�.� �i„ ,,
. '� 4 ,� ' -- ' �h,.
,� � . . �� 8125 �:� ao � ,,\,.
�..,� ,�" � ���� � :'. ', � � \
�".y�,� „a ,;�� ` � - � O O \'\
:� QiA�,��,�.W,y� � � •
� TY,��! d`+' � � � , � �
:.r� .�� �'� '1
.,; ��q ' t ; r
�b� �*,^.
.� •�\�,��q ir� y.'�� x.. , .::# �� • „�.�� .
��/ %+.r� '1!5 '�, . I �, ���•� S��t. ;� � j�,
� •� ` h e � A �,� �p � �M. J•
, ��I "h�.� ,��� 1 - � IS,�s++ � r.'�g*:.�i��'��. ,u.
j' -� ;t,:: �� � � .' '`� , � e « :
..� .��: n"��' '�"!R :e.r�
.� 1 � ; � ,� _ q +� `k �� � Y
��RS <�� -° �j��� ��' + �.p . �M"��}:L. �. �i'r y��.
�� � ,• �y '�. �w � ''� �" ..r k,,y..
��. .� ./ � � �; s y� �kl , ��r ��, . _i �•� � ,"�. °�x'� �.
��� . /� ���1� ���- � �..��l;'� � �� ' ' �� �' - �.
�.,..�� 'a..• ��. �� 'a� 'i. �ie � �
� � i;+ �'�Y �,� `�t. !'�14�,' j � y:��y��, + '+•
� 1 � . .(F� 'ti.;' � �r �f��`'i►�°�' ,��,.�..���,s�.� t.
,t � F.+ ' s :l{. s �3..'�' .d .
� . ..:
�, �` . ,�y�;:id i' ` -i: 1��" '�,'j� ^#��� .
V'" F �. t ,'.,/[ �Y� . i.,�� 3 ��� '' ..
' t 't�.
l. f �� �! T i�7� y�.
Parking Restrictions �`� ��<��w 1�, �;��'` .a�. �
� � � No Parking (current) � -_< � N ' `: ' �
' �
�r��,-:
. ,., , .
;w .�, .. � � s.. ' . . . `.T'x R f ,.,,' '�'^`. .
� Proposed No Parking � " ""�
�_
�z,. � . — .
Print Date:5/8/2013
8145 Lewis Rd S°U�es
€���l Hennepin County Surveyors Office for
`P��� � Property Lines(2012).
Parking o So ,00 Zoo
Feet
Resolution 13-42 May 21, 2013
Member introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption:
RESOLUTION RESTRICTING VEHICLE PARKING ADJACENT TO
THE EAST DRIVEWAY ENTRANCE TO 8145 LEWIS ROAD
WHEREAS, the City Council has the power and authority, pursuant to Chapter 9.06,
Subd. 2 of the City Code, to designate no parking zones and areas, and it appears that no
parking zones should be created on Lewis Road. The following parking prohibition will be in
effect: No parking will be permitted on the south side of Lewis Road within 20 feet of either
side of the east driveway entrance to 8145 Lewis Road.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the City Council for the City of Golden
Valley to permanently restrict parking on the south side of Lewis Road from a point 20 feet
west of the east driveway entrance to 8145 Lewis Road to a point 20 feet east of the same
driveway entrance.
Shepard M. Harris, Mayor
ATTEST:
Susan M. Virnig, City Clerk
The motion for the adoption of the foregoing resolution was seconded by Member
and upon a vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof:
and the following voted against the same:
whereupon said resolution was declared duly passed and adopted, signed by the Mayor
and his signature attested by the City Clerk.
�li,. y �,.d� ii;: . .
/ i i''
��„ �'�,� CityAdministration/Council
763-593-8003/763-593-8109(fax)
��!� -°� �����3�����-��������- �� ������..
f _...... �..�.....������.� ���� .- ... �
Executive Summary For Action
Golden Valley City Council Meeting
May 21, 2013
Agenda Item
3. H. Authorization to Sign Agreement with The Morris Leatherman Company for Resident Survey
Prepared By
Cheryl Weiler, Communications Manager
Summary
A community survey gives the City a great tool to help plan for the future. The Morris
Leatherman Company (formally Decision Resources, Ltd.) will contact approximately 400
randomly selected residential households and ask around 180 questions. The results are accurate
to within 5% and provide a statically valid measure of the public's perceptions regarding taxes,
quality of services, importance of city services and other valuable information. Those results will
be compared to other metro cities resu(ts and past surveys conducted in 2006, 2001 and 1999.
The Morris Leatherman Company will randomly select the residents for the statistically valid
survey, tabulate the results and present the report. An Executive Summary and tabulation report
will also be provided. The cost of the survey, results and presentation is$26,000.
Recommended Action
Motion to authorize the City Manager to sign the agreement with The Morris Leatherman
Company to conduct the 2013 Resident Survey at a cost of$26,000.
�1�� C�� '.
Cit Administration Council
Y 1
763-593-8003/763-593-8109(fax)
�:�:�
._�
��
Executive Summary For Action
Golden Valley City Council Meeting
May 21, 2013
Agenda Item
3. I. Board/Commission Appointments
Prepared By
Shep Harris, Mayor
Summary
Each year the City Council conducts interviews with persons who have applied to serve on a
board and/or commission. After the interviews are conducted the Council makes their
appointments.
Recommended Action
Motion to make the following appointments:
Human Rights Commission
Jonathan Burris 3 year term term expires- May 1, 2016
Adam Buttress 2 year term term expires - May 1, 2015
Raleigh Fromstein 1 year term term expires - May 1, 2014
Carla Johnson 3 year term term expires- May 1, 2016
Christopher Jordan �r, 1 year term term expires- May 1,�C�-2014
Deb Reisner 2 year term term expires- May 1, 2015
Andrew Snope 1 year term term expires - May 1, 2014
Ethan Meirovitz (Student) 1 year term term expires- May 1, 2014
Payton Perkins (Student) 1 year term term expires- May 1, 2014
Environmental Commission
Tonia Galonska 3 year term term expires- May 1, 2016
Open Space and Recreation Commission
Dawn Speltz 1 year term term expires- May 1, 2014
L-1��� C)� ,,,;,,,
, ,
�
� �.'�� Finance Department
763-593-8013/763-593-8109(f�x)
_, �� _._ _ _ e �. _ .
�,ro�� �= _ � �
Executive Summary For Action
Golden Valley City Council Meeting
May 21, 2013
Agenda Item
4. A. Public Hearing- Covenant Retirement Communities- Issuance of Bonds
Prepared By
Sue Virnig, Finance Director
Summary
Covenant Retirement Communities d/b/a Colonial Acres contacted the City to hold a public
hearing for them to issue 5 million in bonds by the Colorado Health Facilities Authority
("COHFA"). The proceeds of the Bonds will be loaned to Covenant Retirement Communities, Inc.,
an Illinois not for profit corporation, or certain affiliated corporations. Up to $5,000,000 of the
proceeds of the Bonds will be used in the City, together with certain other moneys, to (i) pay or
reimburse the Corporation or Colonial Acres Home, Inc. (d/b/a Covenant Village of Golden Valley,
Colonial Acres Health Care Center, Covenant Heritage House and Woodside Terrace) for the
payment of the costs of acquiring, constructing, equipping, remodeling and renovating long-term
care facilities, including, without limitation, the acquisition, construction, equipping, remodeling
and renovation of independent living and health care facilities. The City is required to hold a
hearing to follow Section 147 (f) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 as amended:This does not
constitute a general obligation or indebtedness of the City. A Resolution will be considered
following the public hearing. A representative from Covenant Retirement Communities will be
available.
Attachments
Resolution Providing for Issuance of Revenue Bonds by the Colorado Health Facilities Authority
for Covenant Retirement Communities, Inc. Authorizing the Execution of Certain Documents in
Connection Therewith (2 pages)
Recommended Action
Move to adopt Resolution Providing for Issuance of Revenue Bonds by the Colorado Health
Facilities Authority for Covenant Retirement Communities, Inc. Authorizing the Execution of
Certain Documents in Connection Therewith.
Resolution 13-43 May 21, 2013
Member introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption:
RESOLUTION PROVIDING FOR ISSUANCE OF REVENUE BONDS BY
THE COLORADO HEALTH FACILITIES AUTHORITY FOR
COVENANT RETIREMENT COMMUNITIES, INC.
AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION OF CERTAIN
DOCUMENTS IN CONNECTION THEREWITH
WHEREAS, Covenant Retirement Communities, Inc., an Illinois not for profit
corporation (the "Corporafion"), has requested that the Colorado Health Facilities Authority
("Authority') issue one or more series of revenue bonds under the Colorado Health
Facilities Authority Act, Colorado Revised Statutes 25-25-01, et seq., as amended, in a
principal amount not to exceed $80,000,000 (the `Bonds'�; and
WHEREAS, the Corporation intends to use the proceeds from the sale of the
proposed Bonds to finance projects located in the States of Colorado, Illinois, Washington,
Michigan and Minnesota; and
WHEREAS, a portion of the Bonds (the "Local Portion") will be issued to: (i) pay or
reimburse the Corporation or Colonial Acres Home, Inc. (d/b/a Covenant Village of Golden
Valley, Colonial Acres Health Care Center, Covenant Heritage House and Woodside
Terrace) for the payment of the costs of acquiring, constructing, equipping, remodeling and
renovating long-term care facilities, including, without limitation, the acquisition,
construction, equipping, remodeling and renovation of independent living and health care
facilities (the "Project"); (ii) fund a debt service reserve fund if deemed necessary or
advisable by the Corporation or the Authority; (iii) provide working capital to the Corporation
if deemed necessary or advisable by the Corporation or the Authority; (iv) pay a portion of
the interest on the Bonds if deemed necessary or advisable by the Corporation or the
Authority; and (v) pay certain expenses incurred in connection with the issuance of the
Bonds; and
WHEREAS, the aggregate face amount of the Bonds will not exceed $80,000,000,
with an amount not to exceed $5,000,000 thereof constituting the Local Portion; and
WHEREAS, the Corporation requests that the City of Golden Valley, Minnesota (the
"City'� consent to the proposed issuance of the Bonds by the Authority; and
WHEREAS, the City conducted a public hearing on May 21, 2013, in accordance
with Section 147(fl of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, on the proposed issuance of
such portion of the Bonds that will be used to finance the Project and finance the costs of
issuing such Bonds; and
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, THAT:
1. The issuance of the Bonds by the Authority in an amount not to exceed
$80,000,000, with an amount not to exceed $5,000,000 thereof constituting
the Local Portion, is hereby approved, for purposes of Section 147(fl of the
Internal Revenue Code of 1986.
Resolution 13-43 - Continued May 21, 2013
2. The Mayor and City Clerk (each, an "Authorized Officer") of the City are
hereby authorized and directed to do all such acts and things and to execute
or accept all such documents as may be necessary to carry out and comply
with the provisions of these resolutions, and all of the acts and doings of the
Authorized Officers of the City which are in conformity with the intent and
purposes of these resolutions and within the parameters set forth herein,
whether heretofore or hereafter taken or done, shall be and are hereby
authorized, ratified, confirmed and approved.
3 The Bonds shall not be deemed to constitute a debt or liability of the City or
the State of Minnesota or any political subdivision thereof, or a pledge of the
faith and credit of the City or the State of Minnesota or any political
subdivision thereof, and neither the City, the State of Minnesota nor any
political subdivision thereof will be liable on the Bonds. The Bonds will not be
issued by the City, nor will the City have any liability with respect to the
Bonds.
Shepard M. Harris, Mayor
ATTEST:
Susan M. Virnig, City Clerk
The motion for the adoption of the foregoing resofution was seconded by Member
and upon a vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof:
and the following voted against the same:
whereupon said resolution was declared duly passed and adopted, signed by the Mayor
and his signature attested by the City Clerk.
�i��y c��
�� ����
��„ ��� Public Works Department
763-593-8�301763-593-3988{fax)
� � �
Executive Summary For Action
Golden Valley City Council Meeting
May 21, 2013
Agenda Item
4. B. Public Hearing to Vacate Easements in the Plats of Dahlberg Commerce Center P.U.D. No. 61
and North Wirth Business Center P.U.D. No. 100 (4200 and 4310 Dahlberg Drive)
Prepared By
Jeannine Clancy, Director of Public Works
Eric Eckman, Public Works Specialist
Summary
The owner of 4200 Dahlberg Drive, Koch & Sons Trucking, has proposed to purchase a portion of
the North Wirth Business Center property in order to expand its parking lot to the southwest. The
Dahlberg Commerce Center PUD will be re-platted and a portion of the North Wirth Business
Center PUD will be re-platted as part of the sale of the property. During the platting process, it
was determined that existing easements on the properties need to be vacated before the final
plats are approved.
Consistent with City Code, the proposed final plats include the dedication of drainage and utility
easements on each parcel. In general,the proposed easements are similar to the existing
easements, except where modified to better accommodate the existing public utilities.
A notice of public hearing regarding the proposed easement vacation was published and posted
and letters were sent to the affected property owners along with the proposed resolution. Staff
sent a letter to all private utility companies requesting their review and comment. Notice to the
Commissioner of Natural Resources is not required for this vacation.There have been no
objections to this easement vacation.
Consideration of this easement vacation was supported by resolution of the City Council in their
meeting on May 7, 2013, and therefore in accordance with state statutes requires a four-fifths
majority vote in favor of the resolution.
�'Z��1 p�
Public Works Department
763-593-80301763-593-3988{fax)
; ���������_
Executive Summary For Action
Golden Valley City Council Meeting
May 21, 2013
Agenda Item
4. B. Public Hearing to Vacate Easements in the Plats of Dahlberg Commerce Center P.U.Q. No. 61
and North Wirth Business Center P.U.D. No. 100 (4200 and 4310 Dahlberg Drive)
Prepared By
Jeannine Clancy, Director of Public Works
Eric Eckman, Public Works Specialist
Summary
The owner of 4200 Dahlberg Drive, Koch & Sons Trucking, has proposed to purchase a portion of
the North Wirth Business Center property in order to expand its parking lot to the southwest. The
Dahtberg Commerce Center PUD will be re-platted and a portion of the North Wirth Business
Center PUD will be re-platted as part of the sale of the property. During the platting process, it
was determined that existing easements on the properties need to be vacated before the final
plats are approved.
Consistent with City Code, the proposed final plats include the dedication of drainage and utility
easements on each parcel. In general, the proposed easements are similar to the existing
easements, except where modified to better accommodate the existing public utilities.
A notice of public hearing regarding the proposed easement vacation was published and posted
and letters were sent to the affected property owners along with the proposed resolution. Staff
sent a letter to all private utility companies requesting their review and comment. Notice ta the
Commissioner of Natural Resources is not required for this vacation. There have been no
objections to this easement vacation.
Consideration of this easement vacation was supported by resolution of the City Council in their
meeting on May 7, 2013, and therefore in accordance with state statutes requires a four-fifths
majority vote in favor of the resolution.
Attachments
• Easement Vacation Sketch for North Wirth Business Center PUD (showing easements to be
vacated) (1 page)
• Easement Vacation Sketch for Dahlberg Commerce Center PUD (shawing easements to be
vacated) (1 page)
• Preliminary Plat for North Wirth 2nd Business Center PUD (showing proposed easements)
(1 p�g�)
• Preliminary Plat for Koch Trucking PUD (showing proposed easements) (1 page)
• Resolution Vacating Drainage and Utility Easements in the Plats of Dahlberg Commerce
Center P.U.D. No. 61 and North Wirth Business Center P.U.D. No. 100 (4200 and 4310
Dahlberg Drive (2 pages)
Recommended Action
Motion to adopt Resolution Vacating Drainage and Utility Easements in the Plats of Dahlberg
Commerce Center P.U.D. No. 61 and North Wirth Business Center P.U.D. No. 100 (4200 and 4310
Dahlberg Drive.
S °
A��{�
�. ;;��y�y',.i'�'•?' o-o o p �Xi'w�` .
� -,Y. S.7i':�i:. �fi. VI 07 ; p.+ � �o�y�
q .�. '.�'�S.f.a�w`f� +.+
t'�1�`,n::.jf (/1� �L L {n �8
`. �+f'Y,sii�.,��s�'•fV�(\ W U n�� TYl N
Wa ���:Vt•.•h�^'{ �94�" (�Z O N � ` N C .p' $P
� q . �#;?:(?'� o�1 ,,, s � 9
i:i:i'r:--. Y m m'J Z V � (� � m o Z �C o
!: �::t�...;,�p��:�,
��'` � ` �:i{ry:�y. C C 4).y� �, �T �j ���
V � . .. ,''t' c:Y::;cc� E 1=—,��,,� O y � C�m P J '�
�_��. . �.::i� �K'3 ++ C l� = �p�
�w��► � �4 L�,�f;/S i r� •���''<, �3 m� �� ,W a m y p c �,��
� 1:��, � • �� 0 � �
� y • _���� yl�;�K �I-t3� T �~tr^• y.V+�G� N ��a
� � W6 �^.'�� ���2 U C ^ Y �J q 'L J � W p
� � � p �,c7`W� �'-;::" Z t F- V 7 � � E V 4 J Vl 8
� C a
�.� '\ � ��'� "�� 7" �DoV e qV�� � � J � .
.O�1�j K 3t• �v>! C C p Z � "''9 c� � Z a
Mi r�1 � � `WP1 O��'J �in.f�O—O S�O. � ��V p !. W C
�\..7 '� (\ '� .�r:c. �EyQ:Np a� �� o�.� C �.
�W q � O � "%`U'.>' o v�_z v �° �"' �° z �
� • � y,<<;,'s,' �t s �m v'° � v�i x
� " E � �
!L, x ,:K"t`.e "9 C� O� � '�{, �'j��V Z Vl
I .,.�;t m a a a R �,•�, � t � Q y
�Qr` � z'f'•;':r� .�✓..�+K�K �1 .�l. �+� C� � J p .� � .
�V � �',:'', w O W N W�+ 5"k Y��- O W � �
V � q �
� W �`� `3,:.' °v2az o t�p ; w �
�C q $ �;�'Y� Q'uoU cU O. _4�� � N m � .
U };j�f �
4 � � �� ��:�s
_ �� .:,,>�
q ' �'
�y �"■ i»�oe = u��i i �ivos
�
� \ � .,.,�,�.»�
,.�w,�u.
�.,� �., J„
� r��(��i. �P vrv��yr i: ivv�i�i:: ��✓3[��
�
a �����5� ---° ; ���y'�+,, /��'
� VR, JJ � � ' ,.,''..�Y�'^`,`,� ����� /
� ��y �� '"•;t7,`:i�t+ �n'���' �u \\3 � .
� � . . <� �., �ry � .c � 9
� •,,•.i,?.e-. � _^�
. ,yN:�' r•.
_ :,�.�:sz.-;�:f:: :;`,.:�:.,.�;_� ,� i �.;�a� �a3e,N.� �� $ .�
,- . -�:,;x,,,�� �� ��;2:�.�s. ��'s /
� s : �`�- �:: , + s
� r� .�: 'ts � 't; i�"��_'.�,.J:�,,, � $ ; .__ --, `
.Y��•71 ��� � •� i�f ��Z Pa �,•��'S `,,`'•.�I ���`� _-Y•16�11M 5..U i
y.; 4 ` .1�� �{ '! �iS{ i � % ��',3�L"i,5':..., . `� ; " y��,�� .. �t
i � /d�11 •� '� � i�{,�„'� s � `�:.,:ir:�:. ;r v;.<';S'�.,��k,,;,y rr .0 ,i
:�V' `i.�/ � � ����.L� � qp�� . t`��:'§ ' :a �;:.
•�� M �y.i. 4II1 �"! f+g'� .i-p� C
A� ,, �}A . �,� jd�tyA��CS 95��8 A }� ? i�n�,. 1� �NW',� �,►f f-'
.� � �!"' , '1!��f t sJ 4 � f0'f01 � ��" j'�i� pt�-,' Y �,
t �a. .K
, � s A .•: ��t`, �1�y 1 {� :r} {1 i FTi'`t�.+'dS2-?�1���L.�f ,�'�'i� a �:t k
4 �,:P�` .,� T �' ��a�f..�..::a': �f. . .5 ..yl..
� � ��. 0 / •t,'I .y�y+�� > >�,�����,:r�%v 4� �`,s;i:S' .�.;t� r 1�' f:y:"%
; `.� � ,�.�1 1..�j;,`'• 1.'r�.� J�•'�•4..'.. v
f' . � +.114 r:�u�:�.''."�t (� .v�..�
�t • '.t;, . . a 1:•"•r:a.C•_ _�:,, \J ,
t,, �... '-�S"`.E'.' ,->... �� �
ri �'r�' � `1,':,,, ,�� 1�' '�� �� �-� ��,'.�^5,+.� l/ � ,4'••r`'
l� %'.
�� • �x' �.Y:`� �— � � ��{-`:� C— S'��
tt���j'
g�r� `p'� `��.'... °`� y'� ���y� LI, �� .�`.�j �� '��t. '.ar �>
� �� j� . 6�'�' ::J.. '; " g�j� .:2�1 � r_`�Y, �� .
�� y �� � ':,`,�.�� �� \ �x:{� � �'�s ��
F. � �;'i.;'s:. 5: k �
i -r �� l ' � . � �� �t-' - ::��� � ��
ti �.. � �`� '`.?P' �r:`t�.v m+r -, J:,•
�� `�: '�" � ��� r.,�'i� 4RaCm , r:` (�
`'� F� ,S��g,�,a: �s;;.y>� t"F;�,:;:�` �,'�';'' �C
lL � x ra:. � `c,;,,> � 8 +` .'�j!
�� /+� �� �
;?� �> {',. ��`�iy i�-�z \��' ;•�r�,��� �yr;'';'r.:,� � .5 �w, C
., � -� `�% '1 l "� '''�i'�''.�` \/ �'•"+`i� �
� `a �\,�{ 1 11 �'.;1�,. �`;:i�ts.� ,ybL,.?�
�i"
3" r: e;?�'.. ::='�{:'..' �? �; '�':i
� �e. .'�. � � .:.:•;�� :�,,,,� � ;
::*{ �:. � ��c, �t+,:.:�� .� ,;:� �,�F ��
'1 _` g3� � � �,J .;,,; Y;:�`;••:. , ii; .
,.; �— iln \ '�, � �'�` —7 ��:;=,��•:':'?�, ��`•l�•s; ` �,��.:,`•
i ��,�
dl �� � � � �¢.' L_ 'i'! �f :i.Y 'pA ; �
!,. ��+� ]�! �C p�
' :i� �� � � �r. �'-v �i� t �:��-^ '. �1','� ��Ri�S�M '.r �l � 5
''•� � _� �`''�:'<: � '-1;��;" �1�
` '! ♦ —7 ��� ��Y:. �,�� � � �<�,— ��'«�'s
`-�+,'� �- 4a.f �.si� fT` oiw..�7.•�� C� : � �
..� +�;r. 7.i7.01iYS :n �,.k- �(�• E
3'-.4 -y�` `f�'�) �'7P,`• •�, �'.:%•'A� �� A,�J�` �j�• _� � �:;�•;.; '�'l� $
_y�Y� , y�� �I �G � � Y `: �
c, :`�`,, q,� �:�,' ",. ,� 1 �- � �; ± a
�<,;�� �''��� �`"'�+u �,+ a. `b�,``, �� ��' � �
���'` �{ i'� ll �`:1�' ,`,° ;�`'' � � .� ' �
. C �,�� �::• / ;`�i..�i,�9 �•� 4� � � m
�,r�C�` 4`�� \� t•���T.l'9,�'�'�� N
c` � `�� J �'.. .O ���1 � �'Y t�V
C�'�`� .:_� �� 4. ��,, \..,� „��� �y � �
��J Q_ ,.}�:'�.� � ,���,-��,�.� �; �+�,�a �� �,�''.�'
� ` -NL1I :. .:e.;i`.:' �\ .� s:�*�;;t�t I r �
.., �._. x. .
y.3LliN.�AN�' � ' . ._._
� 3iLi,q./N �O n
\ \�� �
�
$
m
w a��
��d O p1
� � C Q V • �C L � � ��'1�
r
� w a�i E.°0..m'oa oc� � �i
�o �cWi°�p m_o° py� asv «
G��p�'` OW O7�+�Z 01 i� � S� Z C��
. �1 V � ��Y�J�z (� � �6 (j �Lv
r�+�NC��r" 4 3O J � 7
,�"'�i�. � yvt mta m � o�� ���
�� � 7�3��W� � am� M '� ����
� €
�l� 4 0°0�`"�, ° °�`« � � �$�
`1 � N=" O O m AO O U ��.
�oo� � O��N�w� S22�: w E� C Q J N g
�� o o��p�v � y5i��09 = 4�+�I I 3lV�S ��.�c � a ` _.:
C C� � �
�w�fn0��V �7 V.�.- �. Z C
�,w � W ° A
i" y a u�np� o��° o
� u � 000� � w �°�,w � � �
o+L,,ZZC0C9.L..v�i ��`�VN p � S
�Oq �cjaCiZ4J.O+c "�1; m �`�97 M � N �
� 0 d�.+m O��. :::.,.,_ ��O� � j � ��
G vaW�Eo�� �:4..; mo—° W � ��
�� $ �ro �a�� � �
o�z� ���� Lvo;
� q �acW.�ao v°i oU -a�-° � � m �
� �
W
\\ �--� __�.. � .``� '"..�� ',�:' .�...s,. �' , ,,,...,, /
(1� �`�• $ Y+g�'a,R'�� �.2,•A, /
, ':� �� �h �.�'� OiY[WY'ON'�00 a3d r /• 4
�.�� S� � LGIf�SH3 NIINYlIYM /1
f /
\ �x;� � � ����4� �s� t
��� �.
� �, �:�'�::�;�; ,.�,-; .� -4 ,..t..r:�,,..,,�..,� —,
yy' \ � )+.S_.. t �Y�~ R£• —_
�. \
�' lJ_ £r":�y f,��r.
' \ `,�. si� � r . •`-
'7+'.,7' \ �� `> ��� ���� .
�f �� �¢� � l
'.� �:
:����;. � �� ..
�, -,�: �,'� ;> ��� c� '
�.,i�. ;� _
,��.i �.r�,� c-
- �� .. yx�n�.
�'-. e;a;p,;;� �`, �
� {•� \ ;`i:ri;r��1� *_ ,
y' ��:. \.. ;n.F� \ �w/
Y� \�: �`tI:'����::�\ � �7. ��
��� �: \ `ir`:•rrt. .�. .
J i�t(LfJ`x� �
•V� \','•�L�',```• [ �R �� �'S� w/ ,
�:;a, �,"�4{'•�'�.\ �L�.
Y'%':ir't., \l� � W
,'f�����,.i�r. \ �kt.�f}.,'� �J � ^• � r ��
n�+:�rl,`�� .i � L1_ �l `
;'�ry� ` \ 'rs.'y 4�_ C7� � � L�
•�Y��fv �i. � ���r�Jl� j�
. f � �'' ���r,, \:,{y`���"�'�'••� , �
i j . �.
.� �i•j, .�f �^ �
� �;��;:-;;,�,
:'� � �., .� ,;�=;
r": �^ \j ��i t ,„•f'S�i{�;� L'J � - �
,� �� Qi � � :,r'�;:•'-`� F- ��' B
. �. ;r�.. : � g �
�� C�j . •:,;�•� �
� f: , �
rr �� ��;':f`>� �'� � � �
. �'I.. ' ) \
_� �� �,�'' ,�.:..,,'``t.;.'�- . � � .�
-� . ,� �s,.:;�,;�a< ,� .
� � _` �:{:i l6'S_t:.:� m
"�', </f •''�t`t'��f'L '�1 I.�� 'GJ �7S� � ♦A
�'p' l.� ��'•i:. d!;-�,�`��rt4"� a��� �r^ H
.� � tl3 `.',rj1[.'. .F` d
i' . �` 'f.j:e : . �(•r�J(
'd ,.;�,;s,''�,y-,;. ��� A
'�?i:l.�°;'lj i°��4.a.7�k���'��.�'•• r
,��;• '�� _���:���T'.'�.2'::�..:;'`.� � �
•-a--,r..,�.�>-.rr.s. '`%a,�'a�r.:,r..%t;"'r>' 0�: .^.i: 'C'^'d 2F3yi3: ` �
'7aM � . � .,... '
\ ,ii�.r�`};%%.
;�a" S53filS^£ F1i211��; ►�:.aa::;—�a
� � � J.
�� �
0
�
� �
=gs y �
a 8N S �6$ �1
00 �� �� � Y�� ��
zz � �g �� � la a �
� 5�5 �
U U � !d �� 5-�1-� �' � �
t� � € $s
c°°o � a� � Y-r -; =��g
�1� �� �w -
F-� !iO � �� F ia �g' .
�'U /' � �i �o i �d�
� g �^ s°
� 8 h�bl �E � '�68
• o
�
��2`L � � p
�y�y � s
o-��
�
R �
�
O �� w \
� w� ' \
C' \
K4 _ \
Q �i ��
JL 'Q� \ \ rrvi�.ivvv vir.7tyv �.
� \ `y� Cy). ..- _'�.,. \\ 3 ii^ivif�.�iJ %i i.i[�� � /� .
\ N' F S� \ ' ^ j-
[�'� .c v� 16�' . \ .
� ` \ " � � , �_ � .
\ b �.OSj61 'c�{, \��._ _���� 4
s� � N � � '`�sO �n i�n � n�-�r7-���v�
W � �� �r �b, �,,,,�., �.,�_�� „ ,��., �
r` c� ; —s� 'a---
v �' �� �ubr�ais � �&�s`—.,_
� i� �c� ,'•. / �Y" ����j e ` �-- �t5� 1
�. +b °=i ,ti•�,•' . �'�.• s�i
W �, �'�.s` � \ 98�T'�F �0� ��'�--�I-s—�Trs` �.�� ` ' �'e
� ��� ' ' / � ��;`�` e _� � � §s i bA
� �? �i ��I R AS � q)Ylp S:
� , l e. 1 � I .u�ec,r �x ��
r^ `�` � � � r�; i a°',�e,ww�%�.+a-"�'xw•'�" ��� . � $C: $"� g
�v.J � ' e �+( '&i-------=� �i � ��s� 8 �ta °i
� ,,,a,a'� e. \ •''�.Y--�. � A �
� �'�d1E� `..�•4a�.`. \ $ ���y C_��Z�._______ � � � 6 � ��
�� `''�'�� �' y % `\���� ^j � rl a ���� � 1
O e$ \ '1�,�� . ��� �\���\�y'��� � � � I � �! � �e�� � ��
� ��. �\�,/)-'a c u �� � � � �aoac'rir�.., ,ri:
�� `\ FD�q ` \ O /I^ ' s 1
� . � . \ �a,� � � � � I ` �� � 1 ��
� � `\ �\\'S i � \ �\ 0 ea1 �I ��� � �M.➢LOi.IS_..Ir �� �. .
� 4 . � � �'�, � �' �_
� �"�� \��< ,,����c-=-� ci � I 4 � g � ; ��
� �O -�`�?����' � �� �� \\``�� -� I � � � � V
;�, � ,a+�� `�•, +� I f ?� � a ,� �r
� \ \ R� � r s � �C �.
�. '��'\ ��� 4�.�j� �\y, �\ � ""� � '\ ' � • q ,.
0 ` +r '' � .
4 9\ A � � �' `b�% �t �� � S I �.a�a.i.v + � :C
\ s
� �"� t�� `�§" y? il �.' ;i
. �. \�„ \ g� 4 � `�'vyM � '` __ 1'� ^C
a,,,�e \ � � `'-
��o � ,-�-. �
ci , a � '�a z��� . � 9 �� F;
\ \�,�s. \\'?''+ �N� ti� � l ry
�
r \ � ��' %\ "a► i _>
~`��`��\ �y„6•�` ;. ,9`� � ��
: �
�� � �\ \\� ` � �� t �".�'; ?
��. t�, � � �,� `" � �''^�, .y, `
�� �, ,�� �� ,� ' I�;
��,,� `-�, �i `�' , � ;o, ... � t
` -� • C� �'�'���� ''�� �,,•py'�' {
�'�l'L�'� \ � ib� �ai
c?�'.+' f�.V �`\'�iy \ �T.
l."!�v�-7�; +�. � � � ){�;q
ii �7 �^�\ P �� . � f '`S
.4�i.��. � +p, ___OJ°' ` $�d,'t'_+,
t, _
L�� /iY6 3,L&;.7N _ �' `- . ' - �`_
` BeY[ j�
\ �\ 3[&fl.IN
\K
\ � �
W � ��` .
A
a 4g�
€ �� � �g5 �a �
$ �8 � � i IV�
Z Z � �� _� p �„ ��� �
Cici � .� .a fi �LJ ��
00 � m� �B =- �$�.� �+'�
o c � ao � $-r- � � 4
�d � �� �,� ' i o� ��s
�U � � �� � � l:Ap
3
� � �� & d$B
• o
S w
- �
R
\ ,�0�';�C:;1:.'• ;::4.�u'.c EL'�'JL:� f.'.L , � �_r�'� �
� �v�,• � 4 � `
�
r arra e�.�[:r0.is . �
` 1�\� �`----�i-------------- / S
� r ----�
, � � �
,,� ,�\ �� �� �� / F� �� 2�
�� � �� / � � .-
:� ��;' � "'� � -< <� `��i
\� � � � ��'� . �� Y�'d-
\ `°' �\L�\� I v ° � � cj �-Z o
� `\z \\�\ \\ �ca " i I �L '� �j��
\ ���\��'�,�`� _ � ! �.�- `' � �'�v'�
1 1 `�y� Y , 'w �
� \\� \_'s- �'�, �'� ��+ � � � ------ ��
, � �,'��`� \\ �. o � ti;
� � � `° s �a \ •- � � ,g � 1C------
J � � �����$...: � � � ; ,
� , ��; �'�'�3R �� �,, �
� ` � �,� ��s\� �'\� ��\ `'- `�� � w `
� � � ' $ ,
' .
�G ` \ \ ° \ \ , \ l N z
,<1 � � `° � �� � �S ,
�
V , ` � � ;';� � � <; .�,
� � . � v� '--1 �`�,"��
J \ �' � i�� _ � � � ,� -� ; 4 w_.. .t-�
� q �� �
\7'� �==� K'\\\`�\ ]N'��� wl g�a y ��`:�
\ � lt+' � \ L�
r `$ 1� ����:C\� �� w �� A �\ �'`.
` , � �s`c� _�'� y � \ ���y i
(` � �`y� '°Y'��\ �,.a �' 3 $�4� ��o� �
V `. , ���'����� �' �����`-- `,'c,�f '� \�` ' � I�4
� -�- �� - , ,
I/L// j[�p��N If91i�,e,r.tl M��-�
r �`
� r=`�'r�,
� ~ �, �r"`��.$ �i '" '� ; ,
/ t 4S �.��+°a c � �^x��r' � �-/
� ��_ � ��� �� �x+ �8'� l
/ ° ��� .�\ 4,"A � �_--p'i ' S�' � ��
,,... : � �'.d I
/ � I b,� .a`\�;�`�q�„�>� � Y�? c� � �'��• Ci
w 1 ti� '� �. �� d�^ � ;a 4 I F_
/ �g 1 ���\ ` 4,�`/ \ F' I ( `,
� ���� \ � � � _ � �, �`
� � I \� '�. \ �'� ci � '`:J � o
u � � \��,\\ \ � � + +Cj
/ � i ,, �-�.�� \� ' � � I ;�;, �� � :�
/ \ J ��
V �a r
� �C�\ LO :� r. �,C
! i � ``.�� � � i\h\��� N � I � �C
� ' \ E� `^ � a�\<.�� ' \ L--� � .•�
` � L7 \ Un � F
\ \\�� � � '�-�� •'�\�\�, \� `,C .
/
l
�\ � � �\ . / �,C
. Qr� `6 \\ �.��\Q.\ \/ \ I C, .
� \ � � ��*�\ I
a:,,�.;., �¢'�r� , ���.��ti !
��
P�?' `t �\�'S.��\\�.
�..�O'� �� �� \\` ' I i
V���' �_� v
.•`LOt. /YT6' ���'��—�
'�cS� 3.LdiY1./N ��.,�' ��C�W
�\ '�\` �:W
�
\ �. \
Resolution 13-44 May 21, 2013
Member introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption:
RESOLUTION VACATING DRAINAGE AND UTILITY EASEMENTS
IN THE PLATS OF DAHLBERG COMMERCE CENTER P.U.D. NO. 61 AND
NORTH WIRTH BUSINESS CENTER P.U.D. NO. 100
(4200 AND 4310 DAHLBERG DRIVE)
WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Golden Valley, pursuant to due notice,
has heretofore conducted a public hearing on the vacation of drainage and utility
easements in the recorded plats of Dahlberg Commerce Center P.U.D No 61 and North
Wirth Business Center P.U.D No 100, legally described as follows:
Lots 1 and 2, Block 1, North Wirth Business Center P.U.D. No. 100, Hennepin
County, Minnesota, and Lot 1, Block 1, Dahlberg Gommerce Genter P.U.D. No. 61,
Hennepin County, Minnesota, collectively known as the "Subject Property".
WHEREAS, all persons present were given the opportunity to be heard; and
WHEREAS, the Subject Property is proposed to be re-platted as shown in the
proposed plats of Koch Trucking P.U.D. No. 61 and North Wirth 2nd Business Center
P.U.D. No. 100; and
WHEREAS, the proposed plats of Koch Trucking P.U.D. No. 61 and North Wirth
2nd Business Center P.U.D. No. 100 include the dedication of easements as required by
City Code; and
WHEREAS, easements are not dedicated in Outlot A of North Wirth 2nd Business
Center P.U.D No. 100 because the ownership of Outlot A will be transferred and thus
become part of Koch Trucking P.U.D. No. 61; and
WHEREAS, the approval of this resolution is contingent upon the filing of both plats,
with North Wirth 2nd Business Center P.U.D No. 100 being filed first, and Koch Trucking
P.U.D. No. 61 being filed thereafter; and
WHEREAS, the City has evaluated its interest and use of the property and has
determined that the easements dedicated in the proposed plats of Koch Trucking P.U.D.
No. 61 and North Wirth 2nd Business Center P.U.D. No. 100 are sufficient to replace the
easements vacated herein; and
WHEREAS, the Council has determined that the vacation will benefit the public
interest because the vacation is predicted to foster economic growth in the City of Golden
Valley and, on a greater scale, the State of Minnesota benefits by the projected
measurable increase in tax revenue and general prosperity.
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the City Council of the City of Golden
Valley that said easements located in the Subject Property legally described below be
vacated:
Resolution 13-44 - Continued May 21, 2013
All of the drainage and utility easements dedicated in the plat of NORTH WIRTH
BUSINESS CENTER P.U.D. NO. 100, according to the recorded plat thereof,
Hennepin County, Minnesota, which lie within Lots 1 and 2, Block 1, of said NORTH
WIRTH BUSINESS CENTER P.U.D. NO. 100, and all of the drainage and utility
easements dedicated in the plat of DAHLBERG COMMERCE CENTER P.U.D. NO.
61, according to the recorded plat thereof, Hennepin County, Minnesota, which lie
within Lot 1, Block 1, of said DAHLBERG COMMERCE CENTER P.U.D. NO. 61,
together with the drainage and utility easement reserved in document number
5672226 and watermain easement reserved in document number 6017620.
Shepard M. Harris, Mayor
ATTEST:
Susan M. Virnig, City Clerk
The motion for the adoption of the foregoing resolution was seconded by Member
and upon a vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof:
and the following voted against the same:
whereupon said resolution was declared duly passed and adopted, signed by the Mayor
and his signature attested by the City Clerk.
(,��� ��'
Planning Department
763-593-8095 i 763-593-8109(fax)
Executive Summary For Action
Golden Valley City Council Meeting
May 21, 2013 .
"6Q Days" Deadline:June 11, 2013
Agenda Item
6. A. Approval of Plat and Authorization to Sign Amended PUD Permit - Dahlberg Commerce
Center- PUD No. 61-Amendment No. 3
Prepared By
Joe Hogeboom, City Planner
Summary
Stan Koch and Sons Trucking, Inc., located at 4200 Dahlberg Drive, has proposed to purchase an
undevelpped portion of the North Wirth Business Center property and expand its parking lot.
PUD No. 61 was originally approved by the City Council in 1992 to allow for construction of the
Dahlberg Commerce Center. Two subsequent amendments were approved allowing for
expansion of the center. This amendment would facilitate the expansion of the parking lot.
Because this property is guided by a PUD, all development within the property must be
consistent with the PUD permit and the plans attached to the PUD permit. Staff has determined
that the proposed amendment may be considered as a minor amendment to the PUD. In order to
qualify as a minor amendment,the proposal has to meet an eight point test. The proposed
Dahlberg Commerce Center amendment meets the test. The proposed minor amendment shall
not:
1. Eliminate, diminish or be disruptive to the preservation and protection of sensitive site
features.
2. Eliminate, diminish or compromise the high quality of site planning, design, landscaping or
building materials.
3. Alter significantly the location of buildings, parking areas or roads.
4. Increase or decrease the number of residential dwelling units by more than five percent.
5. Increase the gross floor area of non-residential buildings by more than three percent or
increase the gross floor area of any individual building by more than five percent.
6. Increase the number of stories of any building.
7. Decrease the amount of open space by more than three percent or alter it in such a way
as to change its original design or intended function or use.
8. Create non-compliance with any special condition attached to the approval of the Final
PUD Plan.
The City Council has the right to approve the amendment by a simple majority vote without a
public hearing or refer the matter to the Planning Commission for their input and
recommendation. Because of the minor impact of this proposal, staff does not think it necessary
to have Planning Commission or public input.
The area that will be added to PUD 61 is approximately 1.726 acres of the North Wirth Business
Center PUD#100 property. It includes all of Lot 1 (north of the railroad tracks), and portions of
Lots 2 and 3. If approved, Stan Koch and Sons Trucking, Inc. anticipates to close on the property
in June and begin construction later this summer.
Attachments
• Location Map (1 page)
• Memo from Fire Chief Mark Kuhnly dated March 11, 2013 (1 page)
• Memo from City Engineer Jeff Oliver and Public Works Specialist Eric Eckman dated April 11, 2013
(4 pages)
• Dahlberg Commerce Center PUD Permit for Amendment#3 (2 pages)
• Resolution for Approval af Plat- Koch Trucking PUD No. 61 (1 page)
• Final Plat af Koch Trucking PUD No. 61 (1 pages)
• Qescription Sketch for Stan Koch Trucking (1 page)
Recommended Action
Motion to adopt Resolution for Approval of Plat- Koch Trucking PUD No. 61.
Motion to authorize the Mayor and City Manager to sign the amended PUD Permit for Dahlberg
Commerce Center PUD 61, Amendment#3.
` *wl�take %
'a
r''f
y.-''�^.'"'.
Theadore Wirth Regiana�l Park
.>-��
�:,1'',�
----�
Subject Property ._J�,,...� ,
--������� �at:
--k �r> ,.�
s � .c�-�-,�
� ���
,4���ts�;`�,
f?a!�/b�rg F'o�rd
'�-�",-�-�._ �
�� „� =
r :�
`��� �+ ^ _. _ _ _ _ � ..r .
��,��;. ,,r,
r� �� ,
�\
f
% ��/' 0� �
,% �
,.� ` J ;
.r' 'r � �
r
� � N �
/ °' �' �
rn �
� �
. � _ . ._. .w – 1
__ _. _. ._ ._ _ _ ,_ � t �',. _ _ _ _ _ _ '�'L—
_ _ _ �'_
_. .. _ .. ,C�. _ .. _. _ _. _ � ._ _. _ _ _ _ ,. .„. _ .e. _ _. w ... ._ _. .,. _Sfate Hwy Fla.55... _ _ _ _ _ _ -° _ -� _. ...
..._,."'-`..•-_. =_. ... .,. ._ _ _ ._. ... __ ._ ._ _ State Hwy Mo.55 — _ _ _.. _.. ,.. _ _, _ �.. ._ .._ _�. _._. m_
'' `. ". _" .�rontagc Rd.. _ °.t3ison Memoriat Hwy_FronY;+gcr Rd,'s r
� � �
� � { t ' �
ro �
a`; a' i .�
� jy'.. Chatel8in T�� } �'' 1 �
w' s.
'' ���, i E� �i � � �� a�i
/ . �
a -� � Wlrt�POf�d �u
�,,r'� � it� i � 1 0`
�{ � � � �� � �
/ �� ,r'rf y��sE�Ept `- I ' � �
,� �,,. ._ _.. j �iU_,�._�� ! 1 N )
r r
� '"" f;�r `\�� �',� "�} _ _ _ .._ _. -�1Noodstock Ave� _ _ _ _ _ ._ ._ � �._ Y .�
,� � �� '�'�� � ` �` � a ! � ��
'� � � � �
� ti �� .� 1 � d
` �. 1. � � �
1 � .� ! .p � ��t A 1
; t
�. `�. w '!6 � � ;
! 1 i � ori � � �: .
BeverlyAve-�-� z
Uapaaawiw.tiArcK13 CvN';geiGttL�CdvCffi2]US � �td .r`t � , 3 Y+`.� °^- �t� I Y i . . . .
�#����_ ���X
���������f� �
�� �
+� � F�� e De�3a� tment
753-593-8U79/ 763-593-8C398{fax)
Date: March 11, 2013
To: Mark Grimes, Director of Planning& Zoning
From: Mark Kuhnly, Chief of Fire & Inspections
Subject: Minor PUD Amendment - Dahlberg Commerce Center/ Koch Trucking
The Golden Valley Fire Department has reviewed the Minor PUD Amendment for Dahlberg
Commerce Center/ Koch Trucking. Listed below are the fire department comments.
1. Fire lanes shall be installed in accordance with City Code.
2. The turning radius for the fire department apparatus access road shall be inside turning radius
20 feet, outside turning radius 40 feet.
If you have any questions, please contact me at 763-593-8080 or by e-mail,
mkuhnlv@�oldenvalleymn.�ov
�l�L Y L�� �q,, i�
✓
�l�e�
�
��. �.'� Public Works I?epartment
763-593-8030/763-593-39$8(fax)
Date: April 11, 2013
To: vMark Grimes, Director of Plannin and Development
From: leff Oliver, PE, City Engineer ,. �
Eric Eckman, Public Works Specialist �
Subject: Review of Minor PUD Amendment
Koch and Sons Trucking (4200 Dahlberg Drive)
Public Works staff has reviewed the plans submitted by Koch and Sons Trucking for expansion of
the Koch parking lot at 4200 Dahlberg Drive. Koch is acquiring the northeast portion of the
adjacent North Wirth Business Center property in order to expand its parking lot to the west. The
project is located on Dahlberg Drive just north of Trunk Highway 55. This memorandum discusses
the issues identified during the Public Works review that must be addressed prior to approval of
the final PUD plans or issuance of any permits for the project. The comments contained in this
review are based on the plans submitted to the City on March 22, 2013.
Site Plan
This parking tot expansion project includes modifications to the Koch Trucking parking lot and the
North Wirth Business Center(NWBC) parking lot. As a portion of the NWBC property wouid be
sold to Koch Trucking,the NWBC parking lot would decrease in size. Expansion of the Koch
parking lot results in the addition of 53 new spaces for Koch Trucking. Due to the new
configuration of property lines and parking lots,the north driveway for the NWBC would be
removed from Dahlberg Drive, and the expanded Koch parking lot would be accessed internally.
A Right-of-Way Permit is required for the driveway work and for all excavations and obstructions
in public right-of-way. Additionally,the Developer or Contractor will be required to obtain the
appropriate permits for all activities associated with demoiition and removals p�ior to
commencing work.
Preliminarv Plat
The parking lot expansion project involves Koch Trucking, located in the plat of Dahlberg
Commerce Center PUD No 61, and property located in the plat of North Wirth Business Center
PUD No 100. Specifically, the sale parcel includes Lot 1 and portions of Lots 2 and 3 in the North
G:\Developments-Private\Koch&Sons Trucking\PUO Amendment Review_041113.docx
Wirth Business Center PUD No 100. An exhibit showing the sale parcel for the pending iand
transaction was submitted to the City. However, a preliminary plat was not submitted with the
plan set. The owner/developer must submit preliminary plats for both PUDs, assuming they are
to remain separate.The plats must clearly show all drainage and utility easements deemed
necessary by the City Engineer and consistent with the City's Subdivision Ordinance. Due to the
number of utilities present within the sale parcel, it is highly recommended that the first draft of
the preliminary plats show all public and private utilities to assist the City in determining the
location and extent of the easements.
In addition, as part of the re-platting of the properties, portions of the existing drainage and
utility easements will need to be vacated.The vacated easements will include portions of platted
easements in both PUDs as well as easements of record within the Koch Trucking property that
are no longer needed bythe City. Upon receipt of an easement vacation application and $500
application fee, the City will initiate the vacation process and provide all public notices and
notification letters. As part of this process,the Developer must provide the City with exhibits
showing the existing easements to be vacated, along with the proposed final plats.The public
hearing for the easement vacation will run concurrent with City Council's consideration of the
final plats.
Utilitv Plan
The owner/developer has submitted a utility plan for the parking lot expansion project. There are
a number of public and private utilities Iocated under the proposed parking lo#, including unused
sewer and water services that were intended for future construction within the NWBC. Public
Works staff has the following comments:
• The water, sanitary sewer, and storm sewer services intended for Lot 3 in the NWBC PUD
must be removed as part of the project.
• The 3-inch forcemain sewer service, 6-inch water service, and dead-end hydrant intended
to serve Lot 1 in the NWBC PUD must be removed as part of this project, unless the
owner/developer has plans to develop Lot 1 in the future.
• Maintenance Agreement—There are four hydrants located within the boundary of the
Koch Trucking property (including the hydrant on the sale parcel). The owner must enter
into a maintenance agreement with the City regarding the permanent ownership and
maintenance of the hydrants, auxiliary valves, and hydrant leads (services from the City-
owned main). The agreement must be signed and recorded prior to the issuance of
permits.
The City has an Inflow and Infiltration (I/I) Ordinance that requires all sanitary sewer services in
these PUDs to be brought into compliance. The owner/developer has obtained I/I permits for the
Koch Trucking property and the NWBC property. The City is in the process of inspecting the
services to determine the extent of any repairs that might be required. The owner will be
required to enter in#o an I/I Deposit Agreement with the City and submit a financial security as a
guarantee that repairs to existing sewer laterals are completed and that any unused sewer
laterals are removed as discussed above.
G:\Developments-Private\Koch&Sons Trucking\PUD Amendment Review_041113.docx
The Developer or Contractor will be required to obtain the appropriate sewer, water, and storm
sewer permits from the City and other applicable agencies for the removal or installation of
sanitary sewer, water,and storm sewer utilities.
Stormwater Mana�ement Plan
As part of the parking lot expansion project,the owner/developer has proposed minor
modifications to the existing privately-owned storm sewer system.The work includes extending
storm sewers and relocating two catch basins to accommodate the drainage in the new parking
lot. The existing and proposed storm sewer system will continue to be owned and maintained by
the property owner.
The proposed project is within the Main Stem sub-district of the Bassett Creek Watershed and is
therefore subject to the requirements of the Bassett Creek Watershed Management Commission
(BCWMC). The proposed project will result in a slight increase in impervious surface area
(0.03 acres or 1,300 square feet), but the discharge rate from the site will remain unchanged. The
slight increase in impervious area is well below the BCWMC threshold for Level 1 and Non-
Degradation standards. In addition,the rate control and water quality requirements for the two
PUDs involved in the project were provided by the City when it constructed the regional
stormwater pond at the intersection of Dahlberg Drive and Meadow Lane. Therefore, no on-site
water quality ponding is required for this project.
Through inspections and surveys, the City has found that most of its stormwater ponds have high
volumes of accumulated sediment. Therefore, in an effort to keep the downstream regional pond
free of sediment and pollutants,the owner/developer will be required to install permanent
stormwater pre-treatment devices where possible. The plans submitted show the installation of a
sump catch basin manhote. The sump manhole must be constructed to a depth of 4 feet and
must be fitted with a University of Minnesota St. Anthony Falls Laboratory(SAFL) baffle to help
further reduce sediment loading downstream. The owner will be required to enter into a
maintenance agreement with the City for the permanent ownership and maintenance of the
sump structure.The agreement must be signed and recorded prior to final plat approval.
This project is subject to the City's Storm Water Management Ordinance.A City Stormwater
Management Permit will be required before the start of construction. The City will review the
plans for compliance with the Stormwater Management Ordinance at the time of permitting.
Tree Preservation and Landscaain�
The Developer must mitigate for the removal of any and all trees and landscaping planted as part
of the NWBC and Dahlberg Commerce PUD projects on a one-to-one basis. The City Forester will
need to review the mitigation plan in more detail before final plat approval and at the time of
stormwater management permit application.
Summarv and Recommendations
Public Works staff recommends approval of the Preliminary Plans for the Minor PUD Amendment
for Koch and Sons Trucking, subject to the comments contained in this review, summarized as
follows:
G:\Developments-Private\Koch&Sons Trucking\PUD Amendment Review_041113.docx
1. The Developer or Contractor will be required to obtain the appropriate permits for all
activities associated with demolition and removals prior to commencing work.
2. A Right-of-Way Permit is required for the driveway work and for all excavations and
obstructions in public right-of-way.
3. The owner/developer must submit preliminary plats for the PUDs as discussed in this
review.
4. Portions of the existing drainage and utility easements must be vacated as discussed in
this review.
5. The water, sanitary sewer, and storm sewer services intended for Lot 3 in the NWBC PUD
must be removed as part of the project.
6. The owner/developer must consider removal of the 3-inch forcemain sewer service,
6-inch water service, and dead-end hydrant intended to serve Lot 1 in the NWBC PUD.
7. The owner must enter into a maintenance agreement with the City for ownership and
maintenance of the hydrants, auxiliary valves, and hydrant leads.
8. The owner will be required to enter into an I/I Deposit Agreement with the City and
submit a financial security to ensure compliance with the City's I/I Ordinance as discussed
in this review.
9. The Developer must enter into a maintenance agreement for the sump and SAFL structure
proposed on site.
10. The Developer must mitigate for the removal of any and all trees and landscaping planted
as part of the NWBC and Dahlberg Commerce PUD projects as discussed in this review.
11. The Developer must obtain the appropriate permits from the City of Golden Valley for
stormwater management, utility work, and any other permits that may be required.
Approval is also subject to the comments of the City Attorney, other City staff, and other
agencies. Please feel free fo call me if you have any questions regarding this matter.
C: Jeannine Clancy, Director of Public Works
Bert Tracy, Public Works Maintenance Manager
Mitch Hoeft, Engineer
Mark Ray, Engineer
Dave Lemke, Utilities Supervisor
Mark Kuhnly, Chief of Fire and Inspections
Joe Hogeboom, City Planner
Gary Johnson, Building Official/Plans Examiner
G:\Developments-Private\Koch&Sons Trucking\PUD Amendment Review 041313.docx
Original City Council Approval: September 1, 1992
Amendment#1 City Council Approval: November 15, 1994
Amendment#2 City Council Tabled Request on August 1, 1995
Amendment#3 City Council Approval: May 21, 2013
City of Golden Valley, Minnesota
Use Permit for Amendment#3
for
Planned Unit Development
Project Name: Dahlberg Commerce Center, P.U.D. No. 61
Address: 4200 Dahlberc�Drive, Golden Valley, MN 55422
Legal Description: Lot 1, Block 1, Dahlberg Commerce Center, P.U.D. No. 61
Applicant: Stan Koch & Sons Trucking, Inc.
Address: 4200 Dahlberg Drive, Suite100, Golden Valley, MN 55422
Owner: Stan Koch & Sons Truckinq, Inc.
Address: 4200 Dahlberq Drive, Suite100, Golden Valley, MN 55422
Zoning District: Light Industrial
Permitted Uses: Parking on approximately 1.73 acres that was re-platted
from adjacent property in the North Wirth Business Center
P.U.D. #100 (Lot 1 and portions of Lots 2 and 3)
Components
Land Use Components:
1. Land uses within P.U.D. #61, Amendment #3 shall be as indicated on the
approved plans prepared by BKBM Engineers dated March 22, 2013.
Circulation Component:
1. Access drives and parking shall be constructed as indicated on the site plans
dated March 22, 2003.
Subdivision Component:
1. The final plat of Koch Trucking P.U.D. No. 61 shall be filed by the applicant with
Hennepin County prior to the issuance of any building permits. The applicant
shall give to the City proof of such filing.
Services and Facilities:
1. The grading and utility plans dated March 22, 2013 prepared by BKBM
Engineers shall become part of P.U.D. 61.
2. Any changes to the grading and utility plan shall be approved by the City
Engineer.
It is hereby understood and agreed that this Use Permit for Amendment#3 is a part of
the City Council approval granted on September 1, 1992, November 15, 1994 and May
21, 2013 relative to Planned Unit Development No. 61.
Stan Koch & Sons Trucking, Inc.
Witness: By:
Title:
Date:
CITY OF GOLDEN VALLEY
Witness: By:
Shepard M. Harris, Mayor
Date:
Witness: By:
Thomas D. Burt, City Manager
Date:
Warning: This permit is subject to all other state, federal, and local ordinances,
regulations, or laws with authority over this development.
Resolution 13-45 May 21, 2013
Member introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption:
RESOLUTION FOR APPROVAL OF PLAT - KOCH TRUCKING P.U.D. 61
WHEREAS, the City Council for the City of Golden Valley, pursuant to due notice,
has approved the proposed plat to be known as Koch Trucking P.U.D. 61 covering the
following described tracts of land:
Lot 1, Block 1, Koch Trucking P.U.D. 61
WHEREAS, all persons present were given the opportunity to be heard;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the City Counci! for the City of Golden
Valley, that said proposed plat be, and the same hereby is, accepted and approved, and
the proper officers of the City are hereby authorized and instructed to sign the original of
said plat and to do all other things necessary and proper in the premises.
Shepard M. Harris, Mayor
ATTEST:
Susan M. Virnig, City Clerk
The motion for the adoption of the foregoing resolution was seconded by Member
and upon a vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof:
and the following voted against the same:
whereupon said resolution was declared duly passed and adopted, signed by the Mayor
and his signature attested by the City Clerk.
Wb
� � � 's`5� � ��� a � .
�� � bh ° �. "=e �� .
ZZ � o� I �nn 1
00 = � E_ �—Ja �=`=.s �
�0 � � m3 = f��
�U . � :�9 0� Ia mQ= .
0 0� o� vR
• o $ �
�
� �vv�.�v.^,. �j'. .,...,.%i�±,�vr, ;�',_4,::, ;��vCP: � �
\ v � °° /—_ —
a,�,,. �.�;�,s
\ `�:,,�\--i�-------- -------�� � �
, ��',�� �� �� � �
�� , � / �s �>>
� ` ���� �� � �� `O
��� `� � - � �$� � `� �
\`� ^� \%� ._ � rywn'.�� \^ $�
q
� \� i VQ� ( i� �
� \ ,� ;�\� \ � I v, ,;
\: � � � `�, °- � �
\\��i \ -� 1 c ,
� \ \ �n�\\ �'� \ �
O \ �_ \\��a \ 11•'_ �',
�� J � �is� �
� \ \\Z `, \~ \ �' \0\ ____
\ \`� \�r���� \\ `` C�J 1�� �' \ �—__�__—__—_ .
O \ t` \:�� \°o \� � � [j
J � � �•�� :,�., � . 1 �
� \ � `''� ` �"� ` °�. � ;
_�
� �:�,�\ m\o � �>. � h •� �
� � � ,,, � ., � $ " � 1
' " � ��'a \` \� � �.
\ �> � \ � �
� \ \ C:o \� i'� .5�\ �� `t' .� " \ �, ,
V \ \ - � . \ �� ___1 �'�?
J � -�� `� ,; ; � � � ;� ; �.. t;
\�� ' �:`�\ \ 3p,`d�,�26��� s�,' \ ' J\ ' ��`<<
� � �'l ��� � 5l� �16 ys �` \ �;� �
\ �' . . \ . Q� �'�� <;
\�� `1 ��^``\\ � w A � ;` <`, '
\ 1 1 C7
� ��G �^ �, �<� i 5 \o oo°+,+ \ v�,�j�- �X'//
\ � ��•�$ '\•. `h' .� A ��'�� \ �� /
0 \ �`.;1L 1`, 3�Q�'�i'�`p �'�� -s� �` �-, �'�° �_�— � \$ ,
n ,
� > -��.� � � � �-��},'4� \
—T� i/'Li/ 3.CZ t/./N o • a � �//
/ ". / � x� ,]�w . ' � �-�{\ _.—
/ ..�. �,�v's'� ��-�L Ir �", ; � ��
�� _�� �>�`� F��W `? I�$'� „`r� �_.� I
/ � , \ '; ,\ $,,c� �'.,e3�;,?°.ye�8.� . �� I �>
o�� ��✓ � i�, ��' �°:d I
/ � � bh�`-� �\�q e �� �1 2�°� '` I °i,�, O
w a �^�0 3� �'. ���- � �e c5 �;
/ bo i����\y ������e ^ F' , I e� _I I c�
i �
�g �� 2 \\\�~ < \ Ci C) �`� I ��
� �� � � ` �� `' � � f— I ,r
� � ° ` ��\� � � .
�.I J \ ;\ \�',,`, \ I �'�.�. Cc� I :C
� i _� �\ ji\ � j/� / �j .
. / I F, �'±\\� � `\''p. ;j I '� n �.[
o�� t�>> _. \ l �" - � I '�
� � `=Z� � Y�� �, \�'.` I—_._J F�
� \\ F� ��\ \?V°; \ I =-C
�� ° � :-��.���v �`�, �/� � =�
���� m '� �;
�� � ��� � s.\ / �
� `�2 �\\� �`\ I ��
. •� \ ��� �\ \ �' �
O� ��\� �yy, � �i\ 4� "�'O\
l.?aC 4Y �2l`y \ i� �\ .�\\�t�, I
��,, ��C � ����t,
``�=o= �,. �� v I I
v�;,;`��-., .�__�"���� I I
-,�;�. i�re -- � T\ J
y ��.3,LZ,i/./N ��� ` �'1
�'�+� � -�C��a)
\�•'fn\ �'����J
� \
� � ��
� ov d o m
c- 3 0« � _
�S� o c d � vl'�"1O^"
�
`�� y�c o ��i
� ` � Z 3 c�9�(
�� C� � N �. "���j
�y � O n� N �
```` c- L � � C y u� Q J Tom
� > L� � nY��7N d C ����
`) � y � W �
�� C� � ����
C/ �� � TJ f�0 f J �VOiN
� • y E a� o J vi s�
�� `v�- L�_ � �� L�N C z _ a '���
/ „ � c� `o z
�i �� . \Y '''' � V p T } C �
G �J � � � '`
``\� �� `�" "'i� >`+�+ � � p �V
��� �^7 . w.�'. �v r .-. N 2
� � -� �,-� �� �T°� " z N A
-�! � � ��Lf �� � T� O� +L. J � �
� �N �� � y �-
�.� U F _ � oa.+m � Z � �y
}O �� L `L 3
z� 3� `s'�, - a..� a° �v�i m , ��
o �6k' p$'.�ic� � i
~ 8.0•p � � �
� •OZ��6�� � �����' r'��a� i ' �
3p �' �
- t� � �
, � �
� � �
` � � � '
� `��;, � � - � � _
.� -� < �
5:�� •� ' - �
_ ,`
,�' �
��,c�, t�• � �o$
.
a `�� / � et ,�g �.-� 'o°�`+
�j '� ' , � � a �,`.fl �
s %
� ° , _ � �,
�j ° 8+ '�� ��' � �`O.
O � � ° ` y����j � �� ' U
�, Y '�. � 7
� o ��2 �1 �,� �.;
� �r � � \� �Y `s,
V
� �*� 1'�
� � � ' ���'� �. ��
� � °p �c''-t L•�
O � � � �°��'`� ``� P�
ti �y ���
� O v 3 �L7�
a�
w � ` �'�;� c�
q � � `�� .
' �>
� , �� ��
. , �-:� c,
� � `
� � . �-
. � ;�
` � L � ��
a -7 .�L��
f l�j •
.
�
��� 1 _
� a's.
o �, o v., �s�
� C �w C 41
� o a— u� o?� \
���aei..« o j0—�c w �w°rnw� � �'m .a> � �S�
°�- �-�c o,° q °»%� o ��.°..n°0 °' c °' � ��t �r
mv o �o o d a �v�c�'i�inv.. ������o 'src'�, °i� �
m w a rnEE � d ° c � a�..in �noc �L s �c' 3
�N�� c.. a� cv a�i rn�3 Ow� c�� q'� L7� �, .
02��Y1���.L(V O�+,,�, �yr.�.G �� a.�" �`\1 S �
a r� .. c .. o � m �
C= TV OsF� o �� �N�JN�� � �'� � U � � �
am C 0 U M• fA Y1� 0�+,,�,� �a r.. �N y C,M L O C,,
= o� �. �° a°� a,ov c oN o o c � � E �.. o W . , �°�� �.
r t C OJ C � ��`. m
t�v V � To 7 � mN aw�c C�i`� O��w� c f`1 W '''
3 c��tdi o ov�n o o �= o �.o moo o n � '/1 S6 3aLl,�/./N.. -
� a,,. ind �wo.coa�.. �,� rn vyoiy — . m
cx a� o � �c d c o«., c ��._.c�o a�o �
GF- C C ;—t � y 7 ' Cw� CM � �Ihr. O vi
..z=io��� UqNd >.E � °�wv�a°�io� „= �°n Z �
o..�.°.. °ow3ya— y � o� v \ �i
� mENM . O 'fi't >'nNWd' UO Q
J �d d Y) ; �O y O�.p �N O �p m t0 C m fn � i-
W \ ,�
O U—`.L..C t U 1�7.`O'C N�C V U C.0 y O ^ Q
_O m� CM C p U� G��V C C O+� - J�
GmZ c ow c° c°ir�"�i E� a°'i c°v v°� u°� °i avi o� c iri v m
a.. Hcn o_ � o N
n
�
R
�Z��' t��
Planning Departmenfi
763-593-8095!763-593-8109(fax)
�$..�:�.
Executive Summary For Action
Golden Valley City Council Meeting
May 21, 2013
"60 Days" Deadline:June 11, 2013
Agenda Item
6. B. Approval of Plat and Authorization to Sign Amended PUD Permit- North Wirth Business
Center- PUD No. 100-Amendment No. 1
Prepared By
Joe Hogeboom, City Planner
Summary
Stan Koch and Sons Trucking, Inc., located at 4200 Dahlberg Drive (directly east of PUD No. 100),
has proposed to purchase an undeveloped portion of the North Wirth Business Center property
and add it to the Dahlberg Commerce Center PUD No. 61 in order to expand the parking lot.
PUD No. 100 was approved by the City Council on September 6, 2005 to allow for construction of
six office condominium buildings. Since then, three buildings have been constructed. The
proposed building pad sites on the northeastern side of the property are vacant.
Stan Koch and Sons Trucking, Inc. is part of its own Planned Unit Development. Coinciding with
the property transfer, the Stan Koch and Sons Trucking, Inc. PUD Permit will also have to be
amended. Further, the portion of property that will be removed from the North Wirth Business
Center must be decertified from the North Wirth Redevelopment Area.
Because this property is guided by a PUD, all development within the property must be
consistent with the PUD permit and the plans attached to the PUD permit. Staff has determined
that the proposed amendment may be considered as a minor amendment to the PUD. In order to
qualify as a minor amendment, the minor amendment has to meet an eight point test. The
proposed North Wirth Business Center amendment meets the test. The proposed minor
amendment shall not:
1. Eliminate, diminish or be disruptive to the preservation and protection of sensitive site
features.
2. Eliminate, diminish or compromise the high quality of site planning, design, landscaping or
building materials.
3. Alter significantly the location of buildings, parking areas or roads.
4. Increase or decrease the number of residential dwelling units by more than five percent.
5. Increase the gross floor area of non-residential buildings by more than three percent or
increase the gross fioor area of any individual building by more than five percent.
6. Increase the number of stories of any building.
7. Decrease the amount of open space by more than three percent or alter it in such a way
as to change its original design or intended function or use.
8. Create non-compliance with any special condition attached to the approval of the Final
PUD Plan.
The City Council has the right to approve the amendment by a simple majority vote without a
public hearing or to refer the matter to the Planning Commission for their input and
recommendation. Because of the minor impact of this proposal, staff does not think it necessary
to have Planning Commission or public input.
The area that will be removed from the North Wirth Business Center PUD is approximately 1.726
acres. It includes all of Lot 1 (north af the railroad tracks), and portions of lots 2 and 3. If
approved, Stan Koch and Sons Trucking, Inc. anticipates to close on the property in June and
begin construction later this summer.
Attachments
• Location Map (1 page)
• Memo from Fire Chief Mark Kuhnly dated March 11, 2013 (1 page)
• Memo from City Engineer Jeff Oliver and Public Works Specialist Eric Eckman dated April 11, 2013
(4 pages)
• North Wirth Business Center PUD Permit for Amendment#1 (2 pages)
• Resolution for Approval of Plat- North Wirth 2nd Business Center PUD No. 100 (1 page)
� Final Plat- North Wirth 2nd Business Center P.U.D. No. 100 (1 page)
• Description Sketch for Stan Koch Trucking (1 page)
Recommended Action
Motion to adopt Resolution for Approval of Plat- North Wirth 2nd Business Center PUD No. 100.
Motion to authorize the Mayor and City Manager to sign the amended PUD Permit for North
Wirth Center PUD No. 100, Amendment#1.
Twin tak�`:
�1 ,~�
{ Theodore Wirth Etegion�l P�rk -'`�--�''r
i'`fi=�,'`1�--',�°`
y.--'"�'` �,,-�
�:�;.�„� �.,.
..� .,.---� r
����rr—��`�/_r'.,.--'"
��.`-."'^�. � ��.��
. .+^"'"--"' „i�- :-
'✓
Subject Property �.---�.�-�-'�
r^,. `
._�y � tJanEBe�;Pona
�Vr.,--
�
�,�,^--.'`'" -.`... .., ..�
_ .P -� �"'-.. � .. .�`r
,� � � ,
�. ;�r��"" ���
�`!rf ?\ y
�� � �
�� �� � �� �
� �
-`- ..
i.�.
� t`,/`�
,.'� ,.�' p; �, ,/,'
/1• ,!� � � ff
4
_ -- f .�L �_ — 3
_ _ .. , ., ---,. � •
_ _ ._ _ _ � __ � e� , �
_M ._ _ _. _ _. .__ � . _�__ .__ _ .� _ _� _ � � � � � ._ _ _.
z�
-. _ � . _ ._ .
� � _ .. ._ ..e .� _. .a. ��
` i ww
_� .., �. �., .� .� .�_ 4 w_ .�
• �a�N,�y r�� ss__ �- -� -_ �
�,,-� � _. _ _� � t-.�� _ � ... , a
w. �. _ - ,
. .� .. �.. _ -- -. „_ state FMwf'No.ss
m.. _w � �� _. . �� �.._ _ N, ;s. __ _, -
�, l J - _ .�rontag�R�"` , .°C1Fson Memwiat Hwy=�rorrtac}¢Rd'� �
� � .
/''� � ' '
; '
, � � x
, � �. a, ; °-
-� �� � Ct?ak6lairi 7eF Nr� , �y W
z
i A �
�'.. —"".Y � �
./_, "�,. 6: 'q(t � S"�
% �'�� � � .... � �; �G��; �g'�: $ ��[� :�'C
,�' ., ,! 1 �. S-. �.. �
'f,�' � � �' aT _ y C' C ti....._ . � ) „, �. �. ���. -.)O
�, � l � 3!
,, i,, ��y „m���aa _ ti ; 4�r,� �
,5. `,Y --_� �._ _ ,- �± �,._�c•-" d
' � _
z.., �..
� y �- �- �t � � _ � .� _ _ _ � -- � � _ _ ��_
��,' ,r\ ,�., >ti�j � — "1+�+uQClstoch Ava� +��
.\t °Q �'
<< /
rv`--ti_ f., `l / 'y�,// � �` �r �+� � N 1 !�
j �, �Y � � p � � � �1
.. � ,.,.�....
/' s
.t ` > �
� f ..E..��� /�i � d � �v,,• . a .3
( ~1�i� r � ��
�
� If.,�,� / `^c 7 ! ry �
; � !II �``�-�- rf �%~`'�``��„'�,(�__ � --I --� ��:i
� § t �- �., ...�..�G Vf'f ? ,� at � .:��� . ..
t. r
a�:���,.��n��s �r�atc:r���� �'`� \, �� ;"0 Y Avs;i-�__ 4�t� I�;';i
��i i-.r�f "�A
������_� �
��.. � Fire Department
763-593-$Q79/763-593•sa�s �f��}
Date: March 11, 2013
To: Mark Grimes, Director of Planning & Zoning
From: Mark Kuhnly, Chief of Fire & Inspections
Subject: Minor PUD Amendment - Dahlberg Commerce Center/ Koch Trucking
The Golden Valley Fire Department has reviewed the Minor PUD Amendment for Dahlberg
Commerce Center/ Koch Trucking, Listed below are the fire department comments.
1. Fire lanes shall be installed in accordance with City Code.
2. The turning radius for the fire department apparatus access road shall be inside turning radius
20 feet, outside turning radius 40 feet.
If you have any questions, please contact me at 763-593-8080 ar by e-mail,
mkuhnty@�oldenvallevmn.gov
���� ��
�
��. �' Public Works Department
�
763-593-8030/763-593-3988{fax)
Date: April 11, 2013
To: vMark Grimes, Director of Plannin and Development
From: leff Oliver, PE, City Engineer , , ��
Eric Eckman, Public Works Specialist
Subject: Review of Minor PUD Amendment
Koch and Sons Trucking (4200 Dahlberg Drive)
Public Works staff has reviewed the plans submitted by Koch and Sons Trucking for expansion of
the Koch parking lot at 4200 Dahlberg Drive. Koch is acquiring the northeast portion of the
adjacent North Wirth Business Center property in order to expand its parking lot to the west. The
project is located on Dahfberg Drive just north of Trunk Highway 55. This memorandum discusses
the issues identified during the Public Works review that must be addressed prior to approval of
the final PUD plans or issuance of any permits for the project. The comments contained in this
review are based on the plans submitted to the City on March 22, 2013.
Site Plan
This parking lot expansion project includes modifications to the Koch Trucking parking lot and the
North Wirth Business Center (NWBC) parking lot. As a portion of the NWBC property would be
sold to Koch Trucking,the NWBC parking lot would decrease in size. Expansion of the Koch
parking lot results in the addition of 53 new spaces for Koch Trucking. Due to the new
configuration of property lines and parking lots,the north driveway for the NWBC would be
removed from Dahlberg Drive, and the expanded Koch parking 1ot would be accessed internally.
A Right-of-Way Permit is required for the driveway work and for all excavations and obstructions
in public right-of-way. Additionally, the Developer or Contractor will be required to obtain the
appropriate permits for all activities associated with demolition and removals prior to
commencing work.
Preliminarv Plat
The parking lot expansion project involves Koch Trucking, located in the plat of Dahlberg
Commerce Center PUD No 61, and property located in the plat of North Wirth Business Center
PUD No 100. Specifically, the sale parcel includes Lot 1 and portions of Lots 2 and 3 in the North
G:\Developments-Private\Koch&Sons Trucking\PUD Amendment Review_041113.docx
Wirth Business Center PUD No 100. An exhibit showing the sale parcel for the pending land
transaction was submitted to the City. However, a preliminary plat was not submitted with the
plan set. The owner/developer must submit preliminary plats for both PUDs, assuming they are
to remain separate. The plats must clearly show all drainage and utility easements deemed
necessary by the City Engineer and consistent with the City's Subdivision Ordinance. Due to the
number of utilities present within the sale parcel, it is highly recommended that the first draft of
the preliminary plats show all public and private utilities to assist the City in determining the
location and extent of the easements.
In addition, as part of the re-platting of the properties, portions of the existing drainage and
utility easements will need to be vacated.The vacated easements will include portions of platted
easements in both PUDs as well as easements of record within the Koch Trucking property that
are no longer needed by the City. Upon receipt of an easement vacation application and $500
application fee,the City will initiate the vacation process and provide all public notices and
notification letters. As part of this process,the Developer must provide the City with exhibits
showing the existing easements to be vacated, along with the proposed final plats. The public
hearing for the easement vacation will run concurrent with City Council's consideration of the
final plats.
Utilitv Plan
The owner/developer has submitted a utility plan for the parking lot expansion project. There are
a number of public and private utilities located under the proposed parking lot, including unused
sewer and water services that were intended for future construction within the NWBC. Public
Works staff has the following comments:
• The water, sanitary sewer, and storm sewer services intended for Lot 3 in the NWBC PUD
must be removed as part of#he project.
• The 3-inch forcemain sewer service, 6-inch water service, and dead-end hydrant intended
to serve Lot 1 in the NWBC PUD must be removed as part of this project, unless the
owner/developer has plans to develop Lot 1 in the future.
• Maintenance Agreement—There are four hydrants located within the boundary of the
Koch Trucking property (including the hydrant on the sale parcel).The owner must enter
into a maintenance agreement with the City regarding the permanent ownership and
maintenance of the hydrants, auxiliary valves, and hydrant leads (services from the City-
owned main). The agreement must be signed and recorded prior to the issuance of
permits.
The City has an Inflow and Infiltration (I/I) Ordinance that requires all sanitary sewer services in
these PUDs to be brought into compliance. The owner/developer has obtained I/I permits for the
Koch Trucking property and the NWBC property. The City is in the process of inspecting the
services to determine the extent of any repairs that might be required. The owner will be
required to enter into an I/I Deposit Agreement with the City and submit a financial security as a
guarantee that repairs to existing sewer laterals are completed and that any unused sewer
laterals are removed as discussed above.
G:\Developments-Private\Koch&Sons Trucking\PUD Amendment Review_041113.docx
The Developer or Contractor will be required to obtain the appropriate sewer, water, and storm
sewer permits from the City and other applicable agencies for the removal or installation of
sanitary sewer, water, and storm sewer utilities.
Stormwater Mana�ement Plan
As part of the parking lot expansion project,the owner/developer has proposed minor
modifications to the existing privately-owned storm sewer system. The work includes extending
storm sewers and relocating two catch basins to accommodate the drainage in the new parking
lot. The existing and proposed storm sewer system will continue to be owned and maintained by
the property owner.
The proposed project is within the Main Stem sub-district of the Bassett Creek Watershed and is
therefore subject to the requirements of the Bassett Creek Watershed Management Commission
(BCWMC). The proposed project will result in a slight increase in impervious surface area
(0.03 acres or 1,300 square feet), but the discharge rate from the site will remain unchanged. The
slight increase in impervious area is well below the BCWMC threshold for Level 1 and Non-
Degradation standards. In addition, the rate control and water quality requirements for the two
PUDs involved in the project were provided by the City when it constructed the regional
stormwater pond at the intersection of Dahlberg Drive and Meadow Lane. Therefore, no on-site
water quality ponding is required for this project.
Through inspections and surveys,the City has found that most of its stormwater ponds have high
volumes of accumulated sediment. Therefore, in an effort to keep the downstream regional pond
free of sediment and pollutants,the owner/developer will be required to install permanent
stormwater pre-treatment devices where possible.The plans submitted show the installation of a
sump catch basin manhole. The sump manhole must be constructed to a depth of 4 feet and
must be fitted with a University of Minnesota St. Anthony Falls Laboratory (SAFL) baffle to help
further reduce sediment loading downstream. The owner will be required to enter into a
maintenance agreement with the City for the permanent ownership and maintenance of the
sump structure. The agreement must be signed and recorded prior to final plat approval.
This project is subject to the City's Storm Water Management Ordinance. A City Stormwater
Management Permit will be required before the start of construction. The City will review the
plans for compliance with the Stormwater Management Ordinance at the time of permitting.
Tree Preservation and Landscaaing
The Developer must mitigate for the removal of any and all trees and landscaping planted as part
of the NWBC and Dahlberg Commerce PUD projects on a one-to-one basis. The City Forester will
need to review the mitigation plan in more detail before final plat approval and at the time of
stormwater management permit application.
Summarv and Recommendations
Public Works staff recommends approval of the Preliminary Plans for the Minor PUD Amendment
for Koch and Sons Trucking, subject to the comments contained in this review, summarized as
follows:
G:\Developments-Private\Koch&Sons Trucking\PUD Amendment Review_041113.docx
1. The Developer or Contractor will be required to obtain the appropriate permits for all
activities associated with demolition and removals prior to commencing work.
2. A Right-of-Way Permit is required for the driveway work and for all excavations and
obstructions in public right-of-way.
3. The owner/develaper must submit preliminary plats for the PUDs as discussed in this
review.
4. Portions of the existing drainage and utility easements must be vacated as discussed in
thi5 review.
5. The water, sanitary sewer, and storm sewer services intended for Lot 3 in the NWBC PUD
must be removed as part of the project.
6. The owner/developer must consider removal of the 3-inch forcemain sewer service,
6-inch water service, and dead-end hydrant intended to serve Lot 1 in the NWBC PUD.
7. The owner must enter into a maintenance agreement with the City for ownership and
maintenance of the hydrants, auxiliary valves, and hydrant leads.
8. The owner will be required to enter into an I/I Deposit Agreement with the City and
submit a financial security to ensure compliance with the City's I/I Ordinance as discussed
in this review.
9. The Developer must enter into a maintenance agreement for the sump and SAFL structure
proposed on site.
10. The Developer must mitigate for the removal of any and all trees and landscaping planted
as part of the NWBC and Dahlberg Commerce PUD projects as discussed in this review.
11. The Developer must obtain the appropriate permits from the City of Golden Valley for
stormwater management, utility work, and any other permits that may be required.
Approval is also subject to the comments of the City Attorney, other City staff, and other
agencies. Please feel free to call me if you have any questions regarding this matter.
C: Jeannine Clancy, Director of Public Works
Bert Tracy, Public Works Maintenance Manager
Mitch Hoeft, Engineer
Mark Ray, Engineer
Dave Lemke, Utilities Supervisor
Mark Kuhnly, Chief of Fire and Inspections
Joe Hogeboom, City Planner
Gary Johnson, Building Official/Plans Examiner
G:\Developments-Private\Koch&Sons Trucking\PUD Amendment Review_041113.docx
Original City Council Approval: September 6, 2005
Amendment #1 City Council Approval: May 21, 2013
City of Golden Valley, Minnesota
Use Permit for Amendment#1
for
Planned Unit Development
Project Name: North Wirth Business Center P.U.D. No. 100
Address: 4310 Dahlberq Drive, Golden Valley, MN 55422
Legal Description: Lot 1, Block 1, North Wirth Business Center, P.U.D. No. 100
Applicant: Stan Koch & Sons Truckinq, Inc.
Address: 4200 Dahlberq Drive, Suite100, Golden Vallev, MN 55422
Owner: Bank Mutual
Address: 4949 West Brown Deer Rd Milwaukee WI 53223
Zoning District: Industrial
Permitted Uses: Parking on approximately 1.73 acres that was re-platted from
adjacent property in the Dahlberg Commerce Center
P.U.D. #61 (Lot 1 and portions of Lots 2 and 3)
Components
Land Use Components:
1. Land uses within P.U.D. #100, Amendment #1 shall be as indicated on the
approved plans prepared by BKBM Engineers dated March 22, 2013.
Circulation Component:
1. Access drives and parking shall be constructed as indicated on the site
plans dated March 22, 2003,
Subdivision Component:
1. The final plat of North Wirth 2"d Business Center P.U.D. No. 100 shall be
filed by the applicant with Hennepin County prior to the issuance of any
building permits. The applicant shall give to the City proof of such filing.
It is hereby understood and agreed that this Use Permit for Amendment #1 is a
part of the City Council approval granted on September 6, 2005 and May 21, 2013
relative to Planned Unit Development No. 100.
BANK MUTUAL
Witness: By:
Title:
Date:
CITY OF GOLDEN VALLEY
Witness: By:
Shepard M. Harris, Mayor
Date:
Witness: By:
Thomas D. Burt, City Manager
Date:
Warning: This permit is subject to all other state, federal, and local ordinances,
regulations, or laws with authority over this development.
Resolution 13-46 May 21, 2013
Member introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption:
RESOLUTION FOR APPROVAL OF PLAT
NORTH WIRTH 2ND BUSINESS CENTER P.U.D. 100
WHEREAS, the City Council for the City of Golden Valley, pursuant to due notice,
has approved the proposed plat to be known as North Wirth 2nd Business Center P.U.D.
No. 100 covering the following described tracts of land:
Lot 1, Block 1, North Wirth 2nd Business Center P.U.D. 100
WHEREAS, all persons present were given the opportunity to be heard;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the City Council for the City of Golden
Valley, that said proposed plat be, and the same hereby is, accepted and approved, and
the proper officers of the City are hereby authorized and instructed to sign the original of
said plat and to do all other things necessary and proper in the premises.
Shepard M. Harris, Mayor
ATTEST:
Susan M. Virnig, City Clerk
The motion for the adoption of the foregoing resolution was seconded by Member
and upon a vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof:
and the following voted against the same:
whereupon said resolution was declared duly passed and adopted, signed by the Mayor
and his signature attested by the City Clerk.
a
APo
_ �� � o
a� t� y „
00 -= o la �� �
z z � _ F �- -L-J W _ �`^
00 _ �3 �� -T- -� �'
H� ° - '°' "a�
� ' --
�CU �< ' -
� � o o� S� - _a:z
�
� -
h �
�
O ' � \
`� \� `�'� �; \
� cy.�>> 6. \ \\ ,.� � ... .��
J ='._ ,�., _
,,,. .,,�a� �,
� --- --- . _,.,, ,�o�;.;:: �-� � �
� /�w :y, \\ i;,,_,�'t?
\ ti ,, ,�, y
� �y� ��� ��'' `� � �
� -�� �, —
� � ��pz,,b'� `^.g,� `s� D �� ��
,\'\ � -�n i�irr , n�i-���-i��vn
Q �t �oo _�i uQv I vQ_�" ii i v v /
W � � � - ' �
� —e�
U c�. � Fzs� .x.ttsi.is 1 �p7p6�-._.
� --�� � �I77S ., ��5 36
�/J ��\ � ` ,!' o .�y%I �u'i.�
� �o � ,.. �.I '�\
(� L�c�.�� /� 1�.a���'�° `-_'T '•`�j'-=.s'�e` � ` :�
�°` 1-=�1-�--r
W ;+� �'��'. , � � ,\�` m_ ; , qo� cc g�i� , §r
� . ,t$ ,., � L� �=r� ��K_' �„� b' I `,.',x.�s,am�.is-;' , „°
� �:n'�... � n�`� �i---- { o .
`fi � \ e\$ , o���I 3.S.,K i/.L--- � � ��;a o=-==8 „$ �y�
,\ ,
r, • .- � �'�y � h k
ss rV� ,/' a� /.F, � ��, n R € n� ��= S g ; :
o y�g� g�e - .a,°o:�. � �0 B �•v�"r,� �_1——`————— � �� �, >s> �p W�
� �Fv .�g� �Aj ��"^`rZ \ N 5. � °'!,� �I L .� � �B� � � .
�A
Q e a a � '9�;" �, �� d�-� \\q"�\\ I � �� R �k� �
� , e �s <, g �
�$ � � _.0 6"s� $�, � �a3� �L- I � �� � fiF� \
�\ . � � � � \
N �g �`'. � ��r. � � � g ;._���:,�___ ,
� � ` �,�'i� �' )-�. U c� � � aoza ' r�: �>
u � ``� �',( \ 0 /�," I X=v
� w'� � � �' � I �'� C�
� \ g���\�y`� e �� �� \\ � m I ��.J `•.�.wc�zoZBi.is ..l; -�� C`
� � �.� �\`-, � ++� \`e---���=y � � � � z ° � � `C
� �O ;`\y' \\3. i \9� :. \\'\ \ tr,�i '� � � k� � �e �� 'T C�
� J` `e� � G-
/� `� � \� ` a�by 'F'' �'\ ,P \\� � ' ' I � � �� 3 �.
LO j•'c.�\ � � 6ry��,Lg \\� \ `` I-' tt rl � 1\ � �$ ` N :,
.\ \� , � d+ \2 �� � w � : as�a�dw �� � eC
�'' J m 3 �:9
� \y -`�� ,, ���� gn -_ I ' j� ,;,
\;"'� � $�, ,, ; `'' ��, _° �,`'•,i� �'� ��
'�� �� � �.x_l,%�,�1;c.- �� �,�
,� 3.��.a�°.� - �y �`
�� � $s \\ �'vy � M19� °. � � y
J \ �� \� � �61� / ;�ereey � 1 ,<
\ �.2' �� \' �y.M16'�� ,\ �b '1 �V
�2� 3. \ \� ' y $�• $� 5 ��
� `�' \` � �'� ° . �
o?�r � �� 4� �.c� o•�P �y, ,
. rrq, ';' i\. \ :; = hy, I l
o� � � � B
��',,� \ s \ � 4 ` �
�"c ��-�;Y, � . �� �,\,o �\vy d .f�, �
`S�`�� (Y .\:`2 \ g ��S�,p �o�
�,-i,,;��-�� ..m�,. �� �
. �� ',' '�,A�\ r',a
° \ � /�"1.
`%-�`'��' t�'4h � ,-----�o�'•,� g;3.
�.
�-`-�y �� .. o o -�'°'�
- itse �[z,si✓N � " - - 'fl+
� '_' ��..`- 99'fC _' .y'
' \ `\ 3.CZI/./N �
\ . \ci
�
\ o v a� o m
�- 3 �« � _
0
�S� o o� 'n -��,�n
�L,\, y.N C 1�I
�� �7 � S 7 iZ ���
� Q no N N I
\1" � c_ L N y V °o'�n
J
� � _ � N �"s
� ' � o-,�,c'n � c �`4�
.. d � �=
< <�. ��� � � Ez
�� =7 4 dT�° � � ����
/ > `v` • y �� y Z J J aF� .
` — L1- �� tlI � NC ' an
r� . _--'"�� r� �� o z �' "'ma
� ' �` Y
\�� \ \,�> ' � o J � o > a°r
L,\� �� � Ay �-' 0 ��
��� �' �N� O � N =
� _� L_ . � ` £�N M � .
"� W �,?� (� y�o d Z V1
-`--{ 2 Ct� �� � ° E w " a Y �
C` �N � �T� O .L. -� p .
N
�� � Z �, a- o .� o �
� �
ro � .°�cdo3 0 � � y
J J °S+ _ ak� A �tn m , �
1 �
r-° ►6k 3 0°��� ' �
a, �.o�p � i �
� �'o2��6a� � �t�� r�i.���� � ' �
i
— 1'� i i
` � �
� r
i
� � i i
� ���3 � � � i �
i ic � � � ---.�� � —
�,�ec +' � - ��`�
Q.� p.�.
w � r � �
� d� + . °�0�.
•� i Q
� � ��i i, � a�� `; 'D�i^
�] � o + � � C` t' L� .Os �;
.� �
�I � ����� �7.
� � V e �%)'�O� � �' � ti.
CL � p -fj�y� �� � (_7_ C�
~!!!���r � ?/'� ��� --�
� � �' ,
O �
� �y` `��
W '� � a�t�. ����
� � - ' � . �`>
� �_
� � ��..� ,
Eti � ,� s �.�
o ,��' � °'�`" `-� .
� � �� '
� �J N � � �`���
� Q �
� �' ` ''° U
�
q � i � `�� �
� '` '� `�l
r� i , �`%'o '
�1 ��
` � . c;
�
. �� ��L \ `i>
� -7 �L7.
f l�> �'
.`
�
o�r� _
°'s.
° � >w ° �H ,, �S'�
'`�ca '�c�i� � ° a'n°� rn.. �w� \
���dw w � 740 O� NL � m t� N N � � l�
a�— E� rn°o �.q�. c�o c oa°0 a�i� ° °' `�2� �i
N Z V O V O C � d� c T Vl+'`�.+ U N� V..t•'a+ ��r ��� �
mV y N w °a � rnE E a�i c�i3 � a°�i �::in a°'i o c ����L �s+ �cL-� a
JN c o..-a� cv v�i °'� °�`v c�"�� m � ' �
oZ� d o�N�N ��"'"-'c.,,Ma E'���;= ��� �'.'�s+ 5p
� d �M Jt�r. C yw O ptV OCDw,a; � m `i� 'E
i� �V �i� -0 C y �N yJ—++— O > O � � p .
U `�•S� !
°.m � a�'i u'?o c o,c a°'i c p w o o c y ���� � � F- � �`n� �d
F=- G� T �= C G� O'J� N O7 � C E �� � W ` �`�_ 1 �N a
t�v °� ��o� ° HC� ° c �o �.°.v�'" c ^ t� �/1�S'6 .�pLZ,�/,/N-
.�3 � ct d o ovu> o o �= o � moo e _
C S N w' O � C y�-' U�w C � �N C OD� N O N L � w
O F- C O C 3_ N C � � _ C N� c M � N M.�+ O �
t m � O Z
�O �L N�'�� � �N yNj�E O � �a'�+ N N O J ry.. � \ - ¢.
Zx a7 O �yw OD,r,3y_ N N > p� .
� N E N m � y`t.r.. >� O W�.� �'�-o Q � e°�
�Y�tLVLp�wCC3m � V � N'O� O,f, � W m
U .✓ C y+ V 1� 7'C O�w L U C L w'' O ^ J \ n
_ OD Ort O OM� y U �. G�V�C C ��'N v .
N U 7� y
QmZ C O.. C�VM Ed N C� 4pi N d.'=+ NN O C I� O � .
u
�
0