Loading...
08-12-13 PC Agenda AGENDA Planning Commission Regular Meeting Golden Valley City Hall, 7800 Golden Valley Road Council Chambers Monday, August 12, 2013 7 pm 1. Approval of Minutes July 22, 2013 Regular Planning Commission Meeting 2. Informal Public Hearing — Preliminary Plan Review— Planned Unit Development (PUD) — Room and Board PUD #79, Amendment#4 Applicant: Room and Board Address: 4600 Olson Memorial Highway Purpose: Ta relocate their outlet sales into the existing warehouse, demolish the existing autlet building for the construction of parking and construct a second floor in the existing warehouse to be used as office space. 3. Informal Public Hearing — Preliminary Plan Review— Planned Unit Development (PUD) — Meadowbrook School PUD #90, Amendment#3 Applicant: Hopkins Public Schools Address: 5430 Glenwood Avenue Purpose: To construct an interconnection addition between the existing facility and the adjacent facility located at 5400 Glenwood Avenue. 4. Informal Public Hearing — Minor Subdivision — Intersection of Noble Drive and Major Drive — Hanson Wood Shores — SU06-05 Applicant: George Wessin Address: Intersection of Noble Drive and Major Drive Purpose: The proposed subdivision would reconfigure the existing single family residential lot into three new single family residential lots. --Short Recess-- 5. Reports on Meetings of the Housing and Redevelopment Authority, City Council, Board of Zoning Appeals and other Meetings 6. Other Business • Council Liaison Report 7. Adjournment "` 7his document is available in alternate formats upan a 72-haur r�quest.Please call 763-593-8a06(TTY. 763-593-3968)to make a request. Exampl�s of alternate formats � � may indutl� large print,electranic,Braille,audiocassette,etc, �, Regular Meeting of the Golden Valley Planning Commission July 22, 2013 A regular meeting of the Planning Commission was held at the Golden Valley City Hall, Council Chambers, 7800 Golden Valley Road, Golden Valley, Minnesota, on Monday, July 22, 2013. Chair Kluchka called the meeting to order at 7 pm. Those present were Planning Commissioners Baker, Boudreau-Landis, Kluchka, Segelbaum and Waldhauser. Also present was City Planner Joe Hogel���tim and Administrative Assistant Lisa Wittman. Commissioners Cera and McC�ity were absent. 1, Approval of Minutes July 8, 2013 Regular Planning Commission Meeting Boudreau-Landis stated that Commissioner Baker should be ad�ed to�he list of those present. a,>>�� ',, ;! Waldhauser referred to the last sentence on pag� four anc� stated that she would like it to be reworded as follows: "Waldhauser added that if the system is taller, it would likely have to be structurally stronger..." 2. Informal Public Hearing — Rroperty Rezoning — 7901 23'd Avenue North — Z019-06 Applicant: Sohan Singh anc� Swarn Singh Address: 7901 �3�a A���nue North Purpose: T��r���e t�h�e;properties from Single Family Residential (R-1) to M�lera���'��n'sity Residential (R-2) in order to construct a twin home 3. Informal Public Hearing — Minor Subdivision — 7901 23�d Avenue North — Cl�awla Estates — SU19-05 Applicant: Sohan Singh and Swarn Singh Address:' 7901 23�d Avenue North Purpose: The proposed subdivision would create two parcels with a "zero lot line" to allow for the construction of a twin home Items 2 and 3 were discussed togefher. Hogeboom referred to a map of the subject the property and stated that it is currently zoned Single Family Residential (R-1) and guided Low Density Residential on the Comprehensive Land Use Plan Map which includes properties that are zoned R-1 or R-2. Minutes of the Golden Valley Planning Commission July 22, 2013 Page 2 He explained that the property is 14,288 square feet in size and has been historically vacant. Hogeboom explained the applicant's request to construct a twin home, the front of which would face 23�d Avenue North. To accomplish this, the property must be rezoned from R- 1 to R-2. The applicant is also requesting to subdivide the property into two lots (with a zero lot line) which requires a waiver from the Subdivision Code to allow the lot width along the north setback line to be 97.1 feet in width instead of the required 100 feet. In addition, the applicant is seeking a variance from the Zoning Code requirerra�nts to allow the home to encroach into the front yard setback area along Winnetka �l�enue°due to the fact that the County will be taking an additional seven feet of right-of-w�y along 1Ninnetka Avenue. Segelbaum asked if findings are required when considering a rezon,%ng request. Hogeboom stated that findings are required for the subdivision re��est, but are not needed for the rezoning request. Waldhauser referred to the qualifications governin���he�appro�i�l,q�f,a minor subdivision and stated that the first qualification is that minor subdivisians shall be denied if the proposed lots do not meet the requirements of the:appropriate zoning district. Hogeboom stated that if the zoning variances are granted by the Board of Zaning Appeals than the lots will meet the requirements of the R-2'Zoning District. He clarified that this proposal would not require any variances if th� Cour�ty.,we°re r�ot.taking seven additional feet of right-of-way. Segelbaum asked if there ar��City��c�rcls of anyone ever attempting to develop this property in the past. Hoge#�ciom s�id�F�ois not aware of any proposed developments on this property, but he know� ther���ias b�en interest in the properties. He explained that there are soil issues on this'p�p�erty that the applicant will be required to address. Waldhauser asked if soil conditions were present on the property to the south. Hogeboom said he believes so. He added fhat he is also aware that there was some fill put on this property in the past that might need to be modified. Kluchka a�ked if the soif conditions are driving where on the lot the home is proposed to be placed. Hogebaom said no. The location of the proposed home is due to setback requirements, site lines and other requirements. He added that soil mitigation will need to be don� no matter where the home is placed on the lot. Kluchka asked if there are water issues with any other properties in the area. Hogeboom said he hasn't heard of any, but he knows the City Engineer is considering this proposal very carefully because of the known issues on this property. DJ Chawla, Real Estate Agent representing the applicant, stated that the applicants are brothers and they want to live next to each other. They considered building two single family homes, but a twin home would meet their needs and be less expensive to build. Minutes of the Golden Valley Planning Commission July 22, 2013 Page 3 Segelbaum asked who owns the property. Chawla stated that Dwayne Meier is the owner of the property. Segelbaum asked about the status of the purchase of the property. Chawla stated that the purchase is contingent on the City approving the rezoning and subdivision requests. Segelbaum asked how long the property has been for sale and how long Mr. Meier has owned it. Chawla stated that Mr. Meier has owned it for several years and he has tried to sell it many times. Segelbaum asked Chawla if he has ever developed property before. Chawla said his normal business is selling houses not developing property. Waldhauser asked Chawla if he has built houses in this area with this �ype of�pil,. Dave Gardner, builder, said he built a house last year that required soil corrc�tions. He explained that this proposed finrin home will be built on helical piers. °° �; Baker asked about the amount of displaced soil and the nurr�ber�f piers that will need to be installed. Gardner said approximately 70 piers will be installed and that�these types of piers dan't displace very much soil. Segelbaum asked if he has looked at soil conditions on other prQperties in the area. Gardner said he knows that the townhomes south of this prQperty used pilings in their construction. � �r ��� ��� � '� �� 9 Segelbaum asked if any of the neighbo� have �xpre��sed �concerns. Gardner said he hasn't heard from any of the neighbp�r�t., ���� Baker asked if there is any evidence of a structure ever being on this property. Hogeboom said no. Kluchka opened the public hearing. Ben Steinbach, 7925 23`d Avenue North, said he frequently has flooding issues and has witnessed standing v�a#er o�.�h� property in question. He said he would prefer that the area be kept singie farnFl��and��h�at a single family home be built next to him. , �° : Nick Ke�kner,,�3f�� lFa��d,�r� Avenue North, said he has also witnessed standing water on the property and he th'inks the proposed new house would be under water every time it rains and added'that the intersection of 23�d Avenue North and Winnetka Avenue is impassable in strong storms. He said that the last time he saw someone taking a soil sampl� on the property their truck sunk two feet into the ground and had to be pulled out. He doesn't s�e how this property is usable unless 42 feet of soil is taken out and replaced with good soil. Rosa Stein, 7920 Valders Court, said she has walked dogs though the subject property and noticed that there is often standing water. She said all of Minneapolis is a wetland and that there are ways to work with it. Kluchka asked Stein if she has had water issues on her property. Stein said no. Minutes of the Golden Valley Planning Commission July 22, 2013 Page 4 Annette Dreier, 2225 Valders Avenue North, said she started having problems with water and had to have her basement waterproofed after the Pennsylvania Woods project. She said her sump pump runs full time and she knows the property at 2250 Valders Avenue North has the same problems. Seeing and hearing no one else wishing to comment, Kluchka closed the public hearing. Baker asked for clarification on the criteria used in determining if a lot is buildable. a : ;: ;. Hogeboom stated that staff considers grade, slope, and delineated wefi�ands among other things when determining if a lot is buildable. In this case the lot is not in.a deline��ted wetland and is considered a buildable lot. However, there will be a signific�nt amciunt of soil mitigation and stormwater management required. Waldhauser questioned where the water goes from all of the �wmp pumps in'the neighborhood. Hogeboom said the water goes to the ponds in fi�e area and into the storm sewer system. Kluchka said he is deferential to the City Engine��'s recori��endatian whether the lot is buildable or not, and he's not sure whether it is th��,Plannin�;,Commissions purview to decide if a lot a buildable. Baker said he thinks it is�g�aod th�3�the Planning Commission asks abaut these types of issues so that;buyer� will be aware. Kluchka said he feels the buyer and builder are well aware of the soil anct water conditions on this property. Waidhauser said her concern is that this project won't aggravate any water issues the neighbors already have. Segelbaum questioned if��� R-'��Zonin����istrict is more appropriate for this property than the R-2 zoning distri�t�since��e��sale history is unknown. He said he hasn't heard justification yet for re��r��r�g the property and it would seem like "spot zoning" if the broader area isn't cori�idered: He added that he was also surprised that the Zoning Map didn't show more F�-2 zorred praperties because there are other duplexes and townhomes in this area. Hogebc��m stated that staff has received a number of phone calls over the last several years reg�r�ing the develapment of this property. He explained that some of th� existin� R-2 properties in the area are grandfathered in because duplexes were allowed at one tirne in the R-1 zoning district. Waldhauser said she is not sure she understands Segelbaum's concerns because this is a difficulf and expensive lot that could work with this proposed twin home since the awners will share the significant engineering costs. She said she doesn't consider rezoning this property to R-2 to be "spot zoning" because the property can't really be developed without rezoning it. She added that the proposal is acceptable to the buyer and the seller and questioned if the property would even be salable for a single family home. Chawla reiterated thafi fihere are other townhomes and twin homes in the area. He stated that the property has been on the market for years, and there have been offers but the cost of soil mitigation ruins them. Gardner stated that he doesn't think a $350,000 to Minutes of the Goiden Valley Planning Commission July 22, 2013 Page 5 $4Q0,000 single family home would be viable on this property since the soil correction and the price of the lot will be almast $100,000. Baker questioned if the Planning Commission feels confident that the stormwater management on this property won't adversely impact any of the neighboring properties. Kluchka noted that if this proposal didn't include a subdivision request the stormwater issues wouldn't be part of the Planning Commission review or discussion at all. Hogeboom reiterated that the stormwater management on this property will be closety monitored. Waldhauser stated that this property could pick up some of th�,:�t�rmwater already in the area which could be a benefit to the neighborhood. Hogeboom'���d he would talk to the City Engineer about the neighbor's concerns. `'�� z� Kluchka questioned how much of this neighborhood would be amenab�e to �t-2 zoning since there are other R-2 and Commercial properties nearby. He sa�d he thinks R-2 zoning is appropriate for this property considering the other us�s in the vi�rnify. MOVED by Waldhauser, seconded by Boudreau-Lands ar�drCnotion carried 4 to 1 to recommend approval of rezoning the properties f�drr� 5in��e F��nily,Residential (R-1) to Moderate Density Residential Zoning District (R-�) to ena�� construction in an economical fashion. Segelbaum voted no. MOVED by Waldhauser, seconded by Baker and motir�n carried 3 to 2 to recommend approval of the Minor Subdivision proposal in�luding the waiver request from Section 12.20, Subdivision 5(A) of City Co�e allnwing the property to be 97.1 feet in width along the north setback line for the property;at 79C�1 23r�Avenue North subject to the following and findings and conditions. Cornmi�sio�e;rs Kluchka and Segelbaum voted no. Findinas ' � ` 1. The proposed lots measu�e 97.1 feet in width along the north setback line. 2. Section 12.20, S��diwis.ion ���) of City Code requires that lots in the R-2 Zoning District measure at least 100 feet in length on street abutting sides. 3. Hennepin County int�nds to`acquire right-of-way for future needs along CSAH 156, thus eliminating the ability for this site to achieve that requirement along the north setback line (23��Ave. No.) therefore, the Planning Commissian recommends approval of a waiver to Section �`2.20, Subdivision 5(A) of City Code allowing the property to be 97.1 feet in wi�lth along the north setback line. Conditions 1. The City:��torney will determine if a title review is necessary prior to approval of the Final Plat. 2. A Park Dedication Fee of $180 shall be paid prior to approval of Final Plat. 3. The recommendations and requirements outlined in the memo from City Engineer Jeff Oliver to Mark Grimes, Community Development Director, dated July 15, 2013, shall become a part of this approval. 4. A Subdivision Development Agreement will be drafted at the time of Final Plat approvaL 5. All applicable permits shall be obtained prior to the development of the new lots. Minutes of the Golden Valley Planning Commission July 22, 2013 Page 6 6. This approval is subject to all other state, federal, and Iocal ordinances, regulations, or laws with authority over this development. --Short Recess-- 4. Reports on Meetings of the Housing and Redevelopment Authority, City Council, Board of Zoning Appeals and other Meetings No other reports were given. 5. Other Business • Gouncil Liaison Report Council Member Schmidgall was in attendance and discussed #he fo�matian of a committee to guide the City's participation in the Bottin�au Trar�sitway station area planning process. He stated that the Council would„like th'e���mmittee tti include finro Planning Commissioners to help study potential irn�pact�r.parkirig, �nd access among other things. Schmidgall explained that the Cities of Golden �✓al�ey, New.Hope and Crystal are moving forward with and emergency water supply plan which may`include wells near each reservoir in case supply from Minneapolis is ever°I��t. • Bottineau Transitway Staticin Are�;Planning Committee Hogeboom gave a brief history of the Bottineau Transitway project. He stated that Hennepin County is starting the station area planning process this fall in order to study both the Golden Valley Road and Plymouth Avenue stations even though there will likely only be one station in Go�den V�Iley. The study will include several issues including: land uses, parking, station dssign �nd �ccess for bikes, cars and pedestrians. � ,;, � After disc��iQn, the:consensus was, since finro Commissioners were absent, that they would like Ha�eba��n:to email the information to all of the Planning Commissioners and talk abou#Wha wpuld Iike to volunteer to be on the Station Area Planning Committee at the next regular P�anning Commission meeting. 6. Adjournment The meeting adjourned at 8:44 Charles D. Segelbaum, Secretary �rty �� Planning Department 763-593-80951763-593-8109(fax) , , �, . Date: August 6, 2013 To: Planning Commission From: Joe Hogeboom, City Planner Subject: Informal Public Hearing- Preliminary PUD Plan—Room and Board PUD No. 79—Amendment#4—Room & Board, Inc., Applicant . . ��`A'`�, II 1 "'k�..,« .r� 11.,. .. .. , . . -- .=..�o ru{�ad il, . , .-, ,, t�"�N,._ . w&tw t.+`a.,......, . . '`r°+�•�—`°N^'_—.�����d7l�a��k„ ., .. . Background and Description of Proposal Room & Board Inc., at 4600 Olson Memorial Highway, is seeking to amend Planned Unit Development (PUD) Permit No. 79 to allow for the relocation of the Outlet Sales, demolition of the outlet building, construction of a second floor to the existing warehouse and allow for a sign to be placed on the exterior of the warehouse to designate the entry ta Outlet Sales. The Outlet Sales would be relocated into the existing warehouse. The demolition of the current outlet building would be for the construction of parking. It would increase the parking from the current 240 spaces to about 426 spaces. The construction of the second floor on the existing warehouse would be used for office space. The proposed amendment does not affect the plat. The property is guided for long-term Industrial use in the Comprehensive Plan, and is zoned Industrial. No changes to zoning or to the Comprehensive Plan would be required for this proposal. The total PUD site is 13.07 acres in size and is bounded by Olson Memorial Highway to the south, a railroad to the north, industrial buildings to the west and a railroad to the east. The proposal would decrease the total amount of building space and increase the amount of pavemen# and impervious surface. The proposal would allow the company to continue to grow and increase employment. This PUD was established in 1998, which allowed the use of 3 buildings on one site and permitted operations of Outlet Sales on weekends. A PUD amendment was granted in 1999 to allow for a sizable office and warehouse addition, including ponding, lighting, landscaping and all exterior conditions and land uses existing today. A second PUD amendment was approved in 2004 to allow for the acquisition of land in the nartheast corner of the site for parking use. In 2006, a minor PUD amendment was received to allow for the conversion of about 8,500 square feet of warehouse space into office space. Justi�cation for Consideration as a PUD Section 11.55 of City Code states that the PUD process is an optional method of regulating land use in order to permit flexibility in uses allowed, setbacks, height, parking requirements and number of buildings on a fot. Staff has determined that this application qualifies as a PUD because it achieves the following standards established in City Code: • Achieves a high quality of site planning, design, landscaping, and building materials which are compatible with the existing and planned land uses. • Encourages preservation and protection of desirable site characteristics and open space and protection of sensitive environmental features including steep slopes, trees, scenic views, water ways, wetlands and lakes. • Encourages creativity and flexibility in land development. • Encourage efficient and effective use of land, open space, streets, utilities and other public facilities. • Allow mixing land uses and assembly and development of iand to form larger parcels. � Encourage development in transitional areas which achieve compatibility with all adjacent and nearby land uses. • Achieve development consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. • Achieve development consistent with the City's redevelopment plans and goals. In order to be approved as a PUD, the City must be able to make the following findings: 1. Quality Site Planning. The PUD plan is tailored to the specific characteristics of the site and achieves a higher quality af site planning and design than generally expected under conventional provisions of the ordinance. 2. Preservation. The PUD plan preserves and protects substantial desirable portions of the site's characteristics, open space and sensitive environmental features including steep slopes, trees, scenic views, creeks, wetlands and open waters. 3. Efficient—Effective. The PUD plan includes efficient and effective use (which includes preservation) of the land. 4. Compatibility. The PUD Plan results in development compatible with adjacent uses and is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and redevelopment plans and goals. 5. General Health. The PUD plan is consistent with preserving and improving the general health, safety and general welfare of the people of the City. 6. Meets Requirements. The PUD plan meets the PUD Intent and Purpose provision and all other PUD ordinance provisions. Recommendation Staff recommends approval of the Preliminary Plan for Room and Board PUD No. 79, Amendment No. 4, subject to the following conditions of approval: 1. The plans submitted with the application shall become a part of this approval. 2. The recommendations and requirements outlined in the memo from Deputy Fire Chief John Crelly ta Mark Grimes, Community Development Director dated July 26, 2013, shall become part of this approval, 3. All signs on the property must meet the requirements of the City's Sign Code. 4. This approval is subject to all other state, federal, and local ordinances, regulations, or laws with authority aver this development. Attachments Location Map (1 page) Memo from Deputy Fire Chief John Crelly dated July 26, 2013 (1 page) Memo from City Engineer Jeff Oliver dated August 7, 2013 (4 pages) Applicant's Narrative/Supplemental Information (5 pages) Illustration of Proposed Building (1 page) Site Plans (4 pages) i_..1 ; . Tppek��ksf' —s� �,� � �I'� �.,, «;r���,' �..--��,!�/��,r��-.-� I � � .; � 1� � �� �i i E� �.,,.-�� il��'i��4P� "N�t/Cl�,LB#��t�'6rlitl;3 � � �� � � � �i�� (4 I�� �� , � 5 � � � r l p i°',.��`-�„-�.�i� �� I a � �; � ,.,, .� �\ � j�� ��j���o YWo*�(��I���., N' � � �� � °" ,��� � �: ' )� � �y � .,�� , _3� —� �` � r�`���i���+�ry'' Twiro E�ke q. At���d�ttf°°-�a ; �' , iii� i � � a.�`�' " �,� � �� � � (II�y��;�����hUi����'���,? ' rIIG�r¢�`� ��� �: � ��� �� ._ ; �„ E����¢9���������J���y' �� � � ��� � � � � � a�`W6�h3(1 Lt7k'B � -��,�I�hl���l��l�J lo' �^ .! < t�'t`' ' :� '-� �i �7 fl . v �� 3 ` � �� � F �'�� f :���t��j� ��� . � r. � a��o . , ' ���� �,-�`k`t€st�YkCti2d�' Py�iis, �i°�iU�i��C�r�1�"�Ih�'����"*���?�N�" � �� f � -: ,, �P �� "�Frc�c3+��}Ce i�tit�th Regii�r}c�t P�C'[� �� �__�-__�`�'� � ` �.�'" ` _. �;.I `,� `1`�'�`�--� _ .-� � � r� ,` ,�y°t, _�,� ,,,.,•.'°�„�.�''`�,,''�' ���t����, ,tt��, ����_� � � ' �� �` �� �� Sub'ect Property �'-'� �� ���,��, �.�. � - �'� � At���'ftt��r3�Ut'��i'� �f 't :' J � � _`__'��.t`.,_.,. .�.,,_�.,—,...,�,_.......,_ �� ,'�' .�---f"` ___.—_— .. �, _✓��=.-%��i) ��� � -�' S[��3�`�iff!�d /r .�"'� � , `'�` C�.-- Dahlberg Arsrtti � � J� ; � ��1d��'��C�C .2 y : /li i ��i'r �' F`� �� � '�'' �'Gh,�p@!'�tN'7i9 �' , ��� ii�l fi f if��% r�i�iii� i 4 ` 7'� ��� if/ii�i�i �i� � �.... ^J � I .i;,,� � . �t( �i/����'��/; r�% /1 °"` r '.`�"� f�»:. �. '... � iri�ii � i i i i . � .3 f��i��/��i�� r�i%. i �'� �/ f,,,,_..sC('t��l�'{t�-. i�/�,��f`iifif%�/�i�ii� � � � � � �. �'f��ri��iii.�i/�i ii �, , Q: //% r %�j�,f ,r �� ,;/,%�; ,r/ � � � , � ���� �,.,;,;;;��,,;, �� /'' :,� ` ;fr'„/.,,;.r',/i'�/ ` � �� , 4 *..` i�fi�,r��j1/�/r � � � / � •, ..�.. , `C_._.� �, � p ';'/ f,�//l.�A� �./ 4� '{� ��,SF;��a±!iw'��Ip �,,°�_ �� 7 �, ,�o „ C�[Saea�9�trie�r�aE IiW*/— � ��� s � � _,. .. � , �� .� � � .� ., .: ,�, � e ._ � � � � _. _ � ��. �- `�° Pwrd C'�'�� Y---�--r Qiscr��n�oraat hl�+�y_ Stat�Hwry..No.t55.. � _ _. w. �2��_ i P�r � ° °. �° Frc�rTtz��Rd-'( - c v � ' ._.i,�i ,i T i._ ,_,. .s'S � '� � € � I.� _ .�. r � �.5� �`.. r J � '. � � j CFt;�te1 it feT v E �'� �.�����'�� / .�� /-'� � . � �� �s� �� � 'au � ^" " Y 7 . � �``y'J;,'I" `, Pc,n ►vavd�ffi[�ePnrtd� „�' �,��'� �,...�,� �: � Wirt�P�and � r �a� � '°, �- —, -' � � @ � � i� �,� � ° ���F _w;_" � � �_ � ,�:,.;—" }�w � .'Q 6 � -��-�� < � �''"C—'�' k,s� �` ._ .Wt3txttsk3Ck Atvs �_,, �., � � �°�! -- ./"� � �,� � � B cro -n� i p -�'�+ +' "�� � `` � � m ;:- {,g� r�,.`L-...a�.�'� ✓` .C_ �' ~ "` a � � � _ ���''. �� � �,rV �✓`��,�-��" �, � � $�uerrl�rAY�-^� �.. �. ,�. �. �� �` b � '``.���--'"._ ,� ��, � °`��� � � � � �. �. � cc� � 1���-`" r �i ��,�la � �;f� �' `,-�� � � ���'.~ � ` � .'' � � ����.� ,°'1�„�;`8reck�� � ��,J�nd "�_ �>' �,,.7�`�,,,Y � Papta�€�r_,�==�tar-E�r" � ""--ra". Y , ;\ � � �� � r � �zm�. � � � ���,F i r , � ��-;r �`,, N+��G�'1+�X P�)"�C� d �� � �____��..,�' -,r� � ���,x � ' ° `� ° �3-- s � �/.�,,,,r �,� , - i� � j�..,�-, � '" � _�� �,_ _.__,� �` �- }— ' / � � � ° � `� ;" 1� �'�` ` / � �a� �,�, , � �� � ti -- � � ��, —� � ,� ��_� __;�`- ,�� � ___ � � �_ .� �� , � ,e_� . _ , „ f ... ....... � -^,,, j. ,�� _ 1.�5���� �°4 � '"�, `'rRceOtwak��it€€ � ^�•.. a �� � � � 1��1 \ � ' . . L�baa f�.........._ ._. +Glerrwcxxt Pont#., �� ��� � �s������.�:;� .axr��:,�;��.�s.c�:>.�k> _,--..,},��: S � -i`-i_ i' ����� �� � � � � �� 4 h � ��4��(' 7�`�. . °` 5 �." , ^ - :-. . . '�' ...-.. . ( :%rc - ' `.... ... hl �4 �,r:: .... .. ' ': Fire Department '763-593-8079 j 763-593-8A98 {fax) Date: J u ly 26, 2013 To: Mark Grimes, Director of Planning & Zoning From: John Crelly, Deputy Chief Subject: PUD Amendment—Room & Board Project The Golden Valley Fire Department has reviewed original PUD Amendment#4 submitted back on May 9th, 2013 and reviewed the additional information that was submitted on July 12, 2013 to complete the original submittal. The drawings submitted do not detail two areas of concern for the Fire Department. As with the previous PUD amendments for this site, the Fire Department will need to review and approve the following: 1) A review of the road access up to the building and around the building. As we have done in the past, we need to review the site, determine where fire lanes shall be established and to have the established fire lanes properly identified with approved signage. 2) A review of the public and private water system to the site and the building. This review would include looking at current location of fire hydrants, wall fire hydrants and the location and routing of the water mains. 3) With fihe remodel /conversion of the warehouse into a two story office area, consideration will need to be given to the decommissioning of the smoke removal system and a review of the fire suppression systems. If you have any questions, please contact me at 763-593-8065 or by e-mail, jcrelly@goldenvalleymn.gov C��� �� �.°a� Public Works Department 763-593-8030/763-593-3988(fax) , ��. �� Date: August 7, 2013 To: /lark Grimes, Director of Planning and Development Joe Hogeboom, City Planner From: Jeff Oliver, PE, City Engineer�� Eric Eckman, Public Works Specialist� Joe Fox, Water Resources Engineer�� Subject: Room & Board PUD 3rd Amendment Public Works staff has reviewed plans for the proposed Room & Board PUD 3rd Amendment, located at the Room & Board facilities at 4600 Olson Memorial Highway. The proposed PUD amendment consists of demolition of an existing building and construction of a surface parking lot in the southwest portion of the site. This memorandum discusses issues identified during the Public Works review that must be addressed prior to approval of the final PUD plans. The comments contained within this review are based on the plans submitted to the City on July 12, 2013. Site Plan This PUD Amendment proposes the removal of an existing building on the southwest corner of Room & Board's campus. The p►an also calls for removing surrounding bituminous and concrete pavement as well as removing some existing trees and shrubs. Plans call for the extension of the existing parking lot into the space now occupied by the building. The entrance to the parking lot will remain in its present location. The owner or contractor will be required to obtain a Right-of-Way Management permit for the construction of the new driveway apron, the storm sewer work within the Olson Memorial Frontage Road, removal of the existing utility services, and all pavement restoration associated with this work. Because the PUD amendment is located adjacent to Trunk Highway 55, it is subject to the review and comments of the Minnesota Department of Transportation. G:\Developments-Private\Room&Board\PUD Amendment 2013\Preliminary Review.docx 1 Utilities The building planned for removal is currently served by City sanitary sewer and water. These services must be cut off as part of the building demolition and removed to the City mains within the frontage road. The property owner must obtain City sewer and water permits for this work prior to the start of work. The proposed PUD amendment is subject to the City's Inflow and Infiltration Ordinance. The property owner has completed an inspection of the primary building on site, but has not received a Certificate of Compliance. In order for the building that is being removed to be compliant with the ordinance, the property owner will be required to enter into an escrow agreement with the City for 125% of the cost to remove the sanitary sewer service to the City main within the frontage road. The 4600 Olson Memorial Highway building must be compliant, and the escrow agreement must be signed and the security posted prior to forwarding the PUD amendment to the City Council for its consideration of the final PUD. Storm Water Mana�ement The western portion of the PUD is within the Sweeney Lake sub-district and the eastern portion is within the Main Stem sub-district of the Bassett Creek watershed. Therefore, the development is subject to the review and comments of the Bassett Creek Watershed Management Commission (BCWMCj and is subject to its water quality requirements. Because Sweeney Lake is listed as impaired by the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency, the BCWMC review will include evaluation for compliance with the Sweeney Lake Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL). The stormwater plans must be modified to be meet City standards and the revised plan must be submitted with the final PUD plans. Stormwater calculations must also be submitted with the final PUD plans. An existing stormwater pond in the northern section of the parcel was part of a previous building expansion project on this site. This pond must be surveyed by the owner to determine the amount of accumulated sediment present and the need for maintenance of the pipes, structures, and vegetation. The survey must be submitted to the City so staff can determine if the sediment must be excavated. If fifty (50) percent of the water quality capacity has been lost, then excavation will be required as part of this project. The owner has proposed construction of water quality measures with this project. Plans call for a bio-retention basin located on the south end of the expanded parking lot. An environmental manhole will be installed upstream of the filtration basin. The bio-retention basin design includes an under drainage system to allow filtration of stormwater runoff prior to discharge into the City storm sewer system. Storm sewer will be installed from the outlet of the bio-filtration pond to connect to existing City storm sewer pipes within Olson Memorial Highway. The City will own and maintain the section of new storm sewer under the curb line of the frontage road and the developer will own and maintain all storm sewer within the site as well as the portion of storm sewer perpendicular to the frontage road that is under the west curb line of the driveway. G:\Developments-Private\Room&Board\PUD Amendment 2013\Preliminary Review.docx 2 The owner will be required to obtain a City of Golden Valley Storm Water Management Permit before construction. Review and approval by the BCWMC must be completed before a City stormwater management permit is issued. The owner will be required to enter into a Storm Water Treatment Facility Maintenance Agreement for the proposed environmental manhole, bio-retention basin, and other stormwater infrastructure owned by the property owner. This agreement will be drafted by the City and must be signed prior to approval of the final PUD Amendment. • Tree Preservation and landscape Plan This development is subject to the City's Tree Preservation Ordinance. Tree removals are shown on the plans submitted. The City Forester has reviewed the plans and determined that a permit is required for this work and must include the following information: • Identify (approximate) total number significant trees on site (significant trees are defined in the permit materials). � Identify total number of significant tree removals. Summary and Recommendations Public Works staff requires re-submittal with the following changes and updates: 1. The property must be in compliance with the Inflow and Infiltration Ordinance as discussed within this review prior to forwarding the final PUD plan to the City Council for its consideration. 2. The owner will be required to enter into a maintenance agreement for maintenance of the proposed environmental manhole, bio-retention basin, and other stormwater infrastructure. 3. The grading, erosion control, and stormwater plans must be modified to be consistent with City standards; the revised plan must be submitted with the final PUD plans. 4. The developer must perform a survey of the remaining water quality volume of the existing pond on site, and submit this information as part of the final PUD. The developer must agree to excavate the pond if the survey information indicates more than one-half of the pond volume has been filled with sediment. 5. The developer must obtain the appropriate permits from the City of Golden Valley for work within the right-of-way, stormwater management, removal of sanitary sewer and water services, tree preservation, demolition and removals, and any other permits that may be required, prior to commencing work. 6. The plans are subject to the approval of the BCWMC and Minnesota Department of Transportation. G:\Developments-Private\Room&Board\PUD Amendment 2013\Preliminary Review.docx 3 Approval is also subject to the comments of the City Attorney, other City staff, and other agencies. Please feel free to call me if you have any questions regarding this matter. C: Jeannine Clancy, Director of Public Works Bert Tracy, Public Warks Maintenance Manager Mitch Hoeft, PE, Engineer AI Lundstrom, Park Maintenance Supervisor and City Forester Dave Lemke, Utilities Supervisor Mark Kuhnly, Chief of Fire and Inspections John Crelly, Deputy Fire Chief Gary Johnson, Building Official/Plans Examiner G:\Developments-Private\Room&Board\PUD Amendment 2013\Preliminary Review.docx 4 � � May 9, 2013 ���� � �� PUD No. 79, AMENDMENT No�'' FORTIER ARCHITECTS P.A. ROOM&BOARD INC. Comm: 13-01 ARCHITECTURE PLANNING INTERIORS SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION Room&Board continues to e�erience growth and desires to maintain it's corporate headquarter in Golden Va11ey, To accommodate continued growth,Room&Board is seelcing approval of a 3'�. Amendment to PUD No. '79. It is the intent to relocate the Outlet Sa1es into the existing warehouse on the lower level. This will enable R&B to demo the existing Outlet building and increase parking from the current 240 spaces to about 426 spaces, and a11ow for the e3cpansion of office space by building a second floor within the existing warehouse. This proposal does not affect the plat. PROPOSED AMENDMENT 1. Permit the Out�et Sa1es to relocate into the e�cisting warehouse. 2. Permit the demolition of the ouflet building for the conslruction of parking. 3. Permit the construction of a second floor in the existing warehouse,to be used as office space. 4. Revise land use ratios a shown in this Supplemental Information. 5. Parking to be provided at 1 space per 250 sf. of office azea plus 1 space per employee for all other azeas,but the total pazking in aggregates shall be not less than 1 space per emgloyee; or as requested by City Chief of Fire and Inspections to relieve any congestion. 6. Construction may be phases as dictated by R&B growth, subject to approval of plans by city and securing of all required permits for each proposed phase of work. 7. Permit the attachment of a sign on the exterior of the warehouse to designate the entry to Outlet Sales. Sign sha11 not be visible from Hwy. SS and be limited to 12"letter height. ANALYSIS 1 &2. Currendy the 4utlet Sa1es on weekend mornings, approximately 8— 11 AM, fully utilizes the main parking lot of approxitnately 140 spaces and represents the ma�cimum demand conditions. T'hus Outlet Sales(19,200 sf.)has a parking space demand rario of about 1/137 sf. This is considerably higher than the underlying zoning for Furniture Showrooms of 1/400 sf. Relocating the Outlet Sales and constructing pazking in the demolished area will create a main lot of appro�mately 284 spaces. At the current peak demand of 1/137sf,this could support up to 39,000 sf. of Outlet Sales floor area While R&B does not anticipate Outlet Sales of this size, we are seeking fle�cibility in area to meet the growth in demand or product. We ask that the limiting factor for floor area of Outlet Sales be parking, and that a rario of at least 1 space per 137 sf.be maintained. Details of parking lot landscaping,lighting, storm water management and changes to the warehouse exterior will be submitted for approval as part of the Final Plan approval process. 3. In 2006,there were 164 employees and 32,449 sf. of office space. The conversion of 8,500 sf. of warehouse to office(PUD Minor amendment) estimated an increase to 200 employees by 2010. Employment is now at about 235, of which the majority works in offices. Growth is anricipated to continue and there is no room to expand outwardly. 1804 Sprinq Valley Circle, Golden Valley, Minnesota 55422-4116 Ph.763 287 8960 , s. May 4,20i3 PUD No. 79, AMENDMENT No.� ROOM&BOARD 1NC. Comm: 13-01 SUPPLEMENTAL 1NFORMATION Page 2 Given the size and structure of the e�sting warehouse, a second floor can be constructed up to 46,000 sf. in area. After subtracting for anticipated courtyards, elevatar and stair shafts,toilets,lunchrooms, etc, appro�cimately 42,000 sf.may be available for office use. At 1 exnployee per 250 sf.,this would permit the addition of abc�ut 168 employees. That is considerable growth and would not be built out in a single phase. It is anticipated that 25,000 sf. would be built starting this year and the remaining, area built out as needed in the future. Build aut area is to be liinited based on supporting parking provided. However,the entire structural flaor should be built at this time. Elevations of construction changes to the exterior af the ea�iting warehouse will be submitted as part of the Final Plan approval process. 4. Land use will change as part of this proposal but not significantly, as shown on the following table. The net impervious surface is increased by 5,907 sf. at the e�ense of landscaping and open space. Total hard surface cover rises from 84.32%to 85.36°!0; a 1.04%increase. VJhile this is a dense development, R&B is fortunate to be surrounded by undevelopable sloping woodlands,which gives the visual impression of a much less dense area. 2004 PUD 2°d. 2013 PUD Change Amendment * Proposal Site Area 569,493 sf. 13.07 A 569,493 sf. 13.07A no change Building 235,416 sf. 41.34% 216,216 sf. 37.97% - 19,200 sf. Pavement a�proved** 244,776 sf. 42.98% 269,883 sf. 4'7.39% 25 107 sf Impervious surfaces 480,192 sf. 84.32% 48b,099 sf. 85.36% 5,907 sf. Landscaped area 49,546 sf 8.7% 42,383 sf. 7.44% - 7,163 s£ Open space 27,075 sf. 4.75% 28,331 sf. 4.97% 1,256 sf. Pondin� 12,680 sf. 2.23% 12,680 sf. 2.23% no chan,�e Soft surfaces 89,301 sf 15.68% 83,394 SF 14.64% -5,9Q7 SF. * There was a Ntinor PUD Amendrnent in 2006 to increase interior office space. It did not affect exterior conditions. ** Of the pavement approved,the pavement installed is 223,959 sf. The above breakdown assumes the spaces were built as approved. 5. Employee parking is adequate but tight. Given that employees receive vacations, sick days, and travel, it never happens that all employees are at the facility on any given day. It is estimated that the typical emplayee receives about 13 days vacation and 7 days sick leave per year. Given 10 days for holidays, only SQ weeks a year are available in which to take the 20 days(4 weeks)leave. That results in ., ,, � PUD No. 79, AMENDMENT No.� ROOM& BQARD INC. Comm: 13-01 SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION Page 3 a 92%attendance ratio... and explains why 240 spaces can support an employee popularion of 235,plus visitors. Many employees are simply not there to use a parking space. We are reqnesring a parking ratio of 1/250 sf. for office space(which is the city standard for office space) plus 1 space per employee for all other spaces. By also imposing a standard of a minimum of l space per employee,we assure that existing condirions are maintained and not lowered. We believe these standards better reflect the uses of space at R&B. Many of the spaces have low density, such as photo studio and display staging wluch occupy about 40,000 sf. and account for only about 4 employees. Distribution also has a low density. Rather than try to fit a ratio to these types of spaces, we believe an over-riding 1 space per employee for the entire facility would be appropriate. 6. Construction phase approval is being sought to reflect the need for flexibility and budget control. Currently the warehouse is essenrially vacated and this is an opportunity to construct the entire structural floor without major disruptions to operation. Approximately half will be built out,providing growth in office space for about 85 employees,with the remaining half remaining unfinished space. It is, of course, unknown as to when the space will be filled and addirional space will be required. That would be another phase and new pernuts would be required. However,we aze seeking concept approval for the entire floor as office space at this time. We are also seeking concept approval for growth in the Oudet Sales area,up to the limits determined by available parking. 7. We are requesting a sign be allowed to designate the entry locarion to the Ouflet Sales. The sign needs to be adequate in size, say 12"height letters,to be seen from the main parking lot such that customers will not mistake the employee entry or e�cercise entry as the Outlet Sales entry. Given the limited daylight in winters, illumination is appropriate. The sign will not be visible from Hwy. 55. BACKGROUND In 1998(Septernber)R&B was approved as PUD No. 79. This consolidated the site, allowing the use of 3 buildings on one site, and pemutted operations of Outlet Sales on weekends. In 1999(January)RBr.B received approval of PUD 1 S`. Amendxnent. This allowed for a sizable office and warehouse addition, including ponding,lighting, landscaping and all exterior conditions and land uses existing today. Building area was 235,493 sf. on the 12.87 Acre site. Pazking standards were adjusted to 400 spaces,inclusive of pmof of parking. In 2004 R&B received approval of PUD 2"d. Amendment. This allowed for the acquisition of the land on the northeast comer of the site for parking use, an adjustment in parking standards to 323 spaces, and consent to open the Outlet Sales for one weekday evening per week. Parking provided 202 spaces and 121 spaces shown as proof of parking, including the land acquisirion. In 2006 R&B received approval of a PUD Minor Amendment. This allowed for the conversion of about 8,500 sf. of wazehouse space to office. It did not affect site conditions or parking, and the only exterior . � � PUD No. 79,AMENDMENT No..�3' ROOM&BOARD INC. Comrn: 13-01 SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION Pa�e 4 change to the buildings was the upgrading of one existing watl to inr,arporate brick and new windows. Parking was linked to employee growth rather than square footage, and is to be built on an as-needed hasis(or as requested by City Chief of Fire and Inspections). 38 additional parking spaces have been constructed along the narth side of the warehouses, in accord with the PUD 2nd. A111E21CLT11021t,resulting in the current tatal eausring parking of 240 spaces. PUD STANDARDS Raom and Board is currently a PUD and will continue to comply with all previously agreed to standards and conditions, subject only to the changes herein sought by this application. All changes to the site are intended to fully comply and be extensions of those standards. Frontage. The current frantage is well in excess of 100 ft. and will not change. Setbacks. The Outlet Sales building is currently set back 100 ft. With its removal,the main building will provide a 170 ft. setback. 'The west setback will be about 225 ft. North side setback is 60 ft. and east side varies considerably,with a minar area at 48 ft. There are no adjoining residential districts. Tree Preservation. Under the previous PUD, tree loss and mitigation was agreed to for the northeast parking area. We intend to reduce the hard surface in this area and preserve more trees. This will be partially offset by the estimated 10 trees we will lose with the conversion of the Outlet building area to parking. The 10 trees lost will be replaced at that location by more than 15 additional trees. This proposal will result in a net add of trees to the site. A specific plan will be submitted with the PIIU Final Plan. I,ighting. The expanded parking lot will be illutninate similar to the existing,using matching fixtures as available. A specific plan will be submitted with the PUD Fina,l Plan, Utilities. The building to remain are currently served and those services will remain as-is. The demolition will lead ta abandonment and removal of services. Ongaing investigations are underway to determine the best way to extend sanitary sewer service to the proposed new toilets on the lower level of the warehause,which is about 30" lower than the main building. It is possible a new sanitary sewer connection may be required. A more specific assessment and appropriate plans�r�ill be submitted with the PUD Final Plan. Storm Water. Currently the majo�ity of storm water is directed to a single large pond on the north side of the warehouse. This was constructed for this purpose as part af PUD Amendment Na 1, in 1999. We are in the process of cleaning that pond to restore its effectiveness. PUD Na 79, AMENDMENT No. 3 . . % ROOM&BOARD 1NC. Comm: 13-01 � SUPPLEMENTAL 1NFORMATION Pa�e 5 PUD 2Ila Amendment was approved specifically to add Iand and develop parking along the northeast corner of the site. This included a new pond. Construction plans for this work were campleted and approved, including watershed approval. While that work ha.s not progressed,we anticipate proceeding with the improvements as part of this construction. We do intend ta revise the pans to reduce the paved area and thus decrease the amount of runoff water. This will also increase the pand size and also increase tree preservation. A specific plan will be submitted with the PUD Final Plan. The Outlet Sales building sits atop a division and 2 sub-watersheds. Approximately 1/2 of its roof, a sizeable portion of the entry driveway, the paved areas serving the main building entrance and this associated landscaped area,all drain taward the south and eventua.11y down the frontage road. With the demolition and parking construction, we intend to maintain this amount of runoff plus the approximately 5000 sf. of new impervious service. As the pond tc�the north can under stressful conditians,back-up and overfl�w into the main parkin�lot, we will also entertain directing additional water southerly. We have asked City engineering to consider eactending the storm sewers in the frontage road to R&B, a distance of about 200 ft., such that we can connect to this system. We are fortunate that the approximate 55 ft. landscaped front yard may permit some additional mitigation. We intend to wark closely with engineering and watershed to develap a successful plan. A specific plan will be submitted with the PUD Final Plan. Attached is a copy of the PUD 2"d Amendment rnaster site plan as appraved, dated 9-24-03. Also attached is a copy of the Proposed master site plan,dated 5-9-2013. Note: As can be expected with preliminary or concept plans, specific details are subject to change with design refinement. For example, as we design a new entry and customer pick-up area for the relocated Outlet Sales in the warehouse, some parking spaces will be last and the precise amount of paving and landscaping may change slightly. .� �; _ � t �' - �� �. �. � �'� � �- � �',� `. �' ,.._,�, �. ,s w � j t..$ ,. . . _ . . , � , , i� .. � h , a'��� . � `� � � ;� �;�' :� y �� . } , ��,. � � , � ' .� +� � ' �� '�� . ,� � � � , _ . , �- 5. ,_ ..- . _�t�j� s .3::',, � � . ..-.� T T s � f . #' �� . � .. . . . : . , D t �n��l�� � �: "�. . i� , � � ,"kts.v�� � . . t 4�� ��: �s � �� ��,+i � �... P � + .� �: ,�� Y�� �. i r � � , . . ., . .. .... .: *, . ..... . . - . . � ? � , ? ' .:� 4 : , ._.. , , � � . �.:., �>..-a . �.. k,.. p�a ,R� � � �� �� l���e � �� 'Z ��� �"1�� Y a:.;�x'.. � �w °�: � ��, r^� . ��,'�'�''x' .k r�4, _ �. .-,.�..s�c�'�e'+ � +'Y�.«'-�i� � �s ° "`� r x; �'� * 7"� ' ,� �� ; �r; .�.-�.. [ � ,��c �'"��� �^.„„ ��- ,; . , t;, � - �^^ � �. ,. _. _ 5�;' ?�; r "k '€ . � 4` � , # � . ... . . .,. e ,. � �._ ...,.... � � �? � ry �x x � { � . . . . . - . � u� � ,�� � ;��. ,'� f . . . '' , � �`'• �':. l: '. . � _ �f � �' �xF, �� � � ���`` - �z:x� . . " .«.X'`:.; � �k �� r.,..��� ��' .� , �� �� a. ��`' � ;� , �w' � � �. � � �`� ' � ��x: �: �° �� r t• '`t r � � �'.y � �� � ,` �.� � � , r� � - '� '.!�.::.iu��'+�91�F,.���' ^tl�.u` ,a �� i• `� i�^� �� �:�� 4� � � �* ,�.�L. ''rt� �v Lk " �� N; !'!' p [ tiv � '�.: 4 µ �� / � � 'M ^ . •� � / s �. •� .,, � ..�����": , �?� R_ �s�� $�7��+�..ZAti• � f ��,� ` .� _ ' � t1�`��� �� ?;" � ��. Z Z�S S N W �J�3 1 1'd/� N 3 Q 1�9 Cb08-L8Z-E9L xv� �oe-cez-est �3�31 O ��� I I I I �b'MH�IH �dI�lOW3W NOS10 009b """"'°""'°""�""'"'°" um w+ ��,3��vn n3a-� "illJ A311vn �NIMdS ►081 i�r.s�,sw.r�w w.�r�ow Q � s � �r ��NI 'Q�Ib'�S '$ W�❑� .�.'::�.".:° '�NI 'S31dI�OSSd '8 �13I1�l0.� Z � �~W > o� � �-J+} J ��j o-Z+�y Q ?~ � W J Q W � W �--� lal M=� �..� aa H J O.' N � � X WY N � O (L > W QVIY aQ �. aZ � � a y � WJW v W y WJM QdQ � (.1 J W XJ a!? _ g I W V W� ~ QQ�Q� Hy � ~S Z C] ►C.1.� ""' W=a �►. ..�": W a C.WW �� Q �� � W p f � aH0 �aW �°.� 0 � O W � W O Q ?�'--'N � � W ,��1� A� Z vOF�- W � (�.�.1 Q NQ W V WO Z\aT J l.� Q :: y W� �.J.W ❑ WZ � � � � Ga0 3 W W� OaCO" CD � � N C] Q �,� �' Fa- QY N : � �QH �� y thD � O l� � l�lL = � q C7H� ��� � N a U , `� � y�p �� W �� a Z y o 00 � � O .....,... ��W a ..~r Q Q' >- �� Vl=� � C.1 l�F- 0� o O O W a' li N V7 W J d U J W ZN � 7 Vl � � � �,1N N � � OWO O � y0 � Y U}Q �Z � �p 00 ... � � N 0� ..r N f�'1 U J Z 2 �"� U l� � • � w Vl V�C� y a, y ��_ � Z � W O 4a�+ � .J..W� �J UW W� OWC Q y fW/1 Q �1� W �p�(AF W� a1 ��I d a OJ � = Fa + a"� �Q W� ❑ O �A >- � W >„ J W l7 N ;+°� � ���� oWCy WU ab�a � � Q � � �zi � � U � ti► W f~/l=W Vlo Q �y � NZ Q ❑ � F W M L] a Q � � A j�Q = 2�a �U= U O WQ' J U X U V Q ��, � WW�H H.N, v O� O U Q Q O W ¢ � _ . � f �T�T�f�T� . � � � � I Illllllllllli I { � � I � � ' ���� Itr_> � � I � I �--- � @ � ��—riiiiii � iiiiiiiiiiiiiiin� g� —� �= — i � � �/ ,�''� I � � . . ,L , 4 / ♦ � _ . V.. �'�ia • V� �-�� �a � �� � e �� � r, °,� r _ ------� �� , ' � - � t � _ ' � . � � � � 1�b'M '21H Z . . . . Z. o [�,] � • • . • ~� � , _ X � V + 1 �dP'1 ��IH Z �W N 1 la. W � � ,� . .J . � � � W `� � � � � � . . � . . .0 . J . W � +'' /� � . . . ,A � T "" Q 3 � � e �.+ ' I a R a � � � aH W � _ 1 . . . .u� . Q ��� e Q W oc � � �o � r y . . . . . � N � x , W . .. � � . � q � �r ; ' W " f � � � � � i � a'" �� Z� � � � . =a " � � i' � � � • t a vx�n si sa aun K au a sn ur sr� . n�� � �ua 7 � --__---- --- ------- —— ----_ ._ __ _ --- __ - � � � � � � � � � � � �I�� ' ( I I Z c��S S N W �il 3-1-1'd/� N 3 Q-1�� o9sa-cez-esc xv.� Z6pg-L6a-E9L �3�31 ^ �l b'M H�I H 1 d I�!0 W 3 W N 0 S 1 D 00 9 t� ,�,,,�„'„��„�,�„�, zziss na+ •��vn N3a� �•at� ���vn �aaas foei Q �� � � � '�N I 'Q�I b'0 S '8 W��� .�,�:��„�, '�NI 'S31b'I�DSSd '8 �13I1�10� r� � i '� � I ' � �� i '' � � x '�QI � J W ��� �� C3 � � ��� WJ�+1 =pl-W- q� � f� � ���Q Wa �� i�� �� � � � 5�� �����s o�Q y� �i � � a � ¢ � � � � �o r� ���}. ��� �� i bS �a a ��' t3 �J a q � Q�� ���` � _� ` ti ��� ;;� �, Aa I �� �� 4 � t�� �>� Wy �� � i � � ���` � � � ��W° Q�' >Gi�a ��� a� I � � 4p W1N1y-� ��j1Q pp�{,�= a i i N TlS ��0� RI=N N N Z�t A i�Q a 2 N '.-�.�� �� I m1 I ; °� � ; i Z � ! � � � y i i W � � } �� � � ! ; I b b� A � � � �a� � y � � � i ' �� �; � � � � � � � � � I � W » i � � � I � � I � W I S ; � � �� �� 3 �' �� � N � � — != W I I� Vj F=- l� W '. I W pC �,,, � j ! U Z � y i I d = a o i I y N y p N I � I A Z a � � `m —� -- � � x �' � � I, . II �j � � � � � � � � � a � I i F ' � / � ��s I � ¢ � � � , i � � . � _ ,� � , ; }� 1�� , , o ; i �� , � � � ~�',, a �- � a w ; � '� !�� \ i �� , W �\ \� �. ; i ,� � � ,�.. s � ;, A\ .. � � � ' � � `� ���� � � i � °+b `� I 3 y � � �~ �', I \ C � '� b � + Yf � *� +b, i I Ii \ \ ~ � ,4�; I � � � � I � I y � ' � , � ■ � � � y m I N !� y 'c ,� IIVA 71F1 Z � � � !'S � � I .� � 4 I � �IYA 'bH Z N i � ' y N ! � �� �. . . � � ' �� � � ,, �� � I �a W� � � � o�c ', r � . . ��, ,� , � � : i b �' �° ' � � � �yyy777 � �p, • i n � I ti . . �. H . N � � y � I � � ��� ° � o � � N i I a . . . .�� . ; i � N �� I � � � ; M i � � � I � � " � � I ' • � � � a � • I � � IN'S M 71 7LL a►A N 7LL/7f�Jf7�1�LL� � . I � aV/It MOMIl1� � ' � � � ; � � I � � 4 _ � � � � »� � � � iscr�A vmsar+r+in�o arvis ari eo sMVi 3Ni a3ar�n ZZbS9 NW �A3l�V/� N34�09 ��al� ^ . ' � U��' t iJ31 H�av U35N3�I1.131n0 v v1v i 1vH1 ONr NOi5�ni13dn5 ^ ^I � 4 • � I V I a� V O V V I 'O 0� NO3aN011V"JItl]ON4 N�VI.f�H��1tlHl�dN1a3JM�H�ia3Hal � � �-t.`/� L.I�I`/�I ��- ? � n � Z � SN Z UW U Q� ' � �� ��°,i �3w II a -� k °_� i C� � V Oti ¢� p�4 I Z 2 w - W�n a ti � � � � oW ZJ= .. = x y � �m Qou � � m o l, �w N a.� '�� °w �I J "lo Q wo Fo ja ¢3w =NO I �y "i> > c�• a o JS� Vj � o x�'+ Q< �p�.l pw \ w ow W N� ZI �li �O . Q O�� OI/� O� F'm� w� 2aa Oao , FO ' �n W U�W li i �LL �a ��.,�.. Q LLZa �Q KlN W2� W� OU� ZNN �p _ ,\,�,�\ > �03 w� ww �3 vYi =z_ �cjOo N � ��� a Z � p1a �� ��.. �� � w �� �� �z wso o z�w �tia � ', � x x�� _ � �, w zo i� �� aLLO o�p aax z �.�1. NZ U1�W . \ \ � \' d' ut0 �tD W�G �Ow U F �wN V W . WY 3 �\ � \. � WM yKj� F� RUO ZU a � 'r Z Q Z Q . � . LL O U 3� Z .. R W \ �....\\ 0 0�� \ W , 3a oia •• �' z wa w_ �� � �`�e ,;� � ,.- � �� ii� z zo Z O � m"0 '22� a�i , '\\ � '\``\\�,;, �� �- �Y.- � �; '� � �° 5 a`2 0 � C� . � oi. oan . � \ \ . . O �- ,_ \ � '� �, � � A �'V�\�\.., � , .. I Q . o , ' \��, ' . W � i' d , (n I �� � . �� � � � se S � � �� �V�/ � � � C9 W ,+ �� j�' ' o V� � Z U � , 9B �\ ° W O Y Q I � � ��, (� Z � � �� Q \ Q d f. � _ . yso �.. ,1°00-. . �be.._. � Z O � ,. ' � �� ' ,. �� � � � � . �� W .�\��6g� � , � (� C.J � I \' °'o � z Q � � �0 9- < . a z � md,. ��� 9ba ���ro � � --- ° Y � � y � . , '���8 �,� � � ��r� � � � � � / � 2 � yd Q Q ��� � ` � \.:,. � W d � . ... . � ' a -ti , , e65� . -- o ea� .. ..i n-- p ����� '. �� �.��,_ o���`� i p � Z i o� or � I � I ?� J 1 � � �, � �,:`�` 08 Q � � � ' ' � � . ��o ,�.� °k+ -�� d� ,. � U � X ,.. �� �`s N I— Z Q 111 �. . . ��\ \ �_ i �.\ ��V�� j_ � � II . ' W � \\�\\\ f'f < �� II � a (n ae ��, \�\�, �o., � �� � I p :A cn = r�� �' \\`�`tv � '� . w W o C,�\� ��,���, �-. � � � Q �'on ���\;;� �-, ���.� °,�i � ` �� ''I�`, m N � � .� �:j �'� �a m r H � � '- S (n \` .' , .�\ �„o � � � � -\� ` `5� " � I I I I I � � � �;� �''� _ . � � '�. � � � �'° �� � "'iY O Z �'s� w e �o •. I � •� i � � �� '�� �, o � . '.� I w � � ��\\ � � . � �. :. a �* ��� ��� ��� I � � I � / '1 �z �\� \`\• � � � _'.`Y��� �� �:� \�.�� v\�� Z L� � �'.� U Q tl \ \\. ,.� \ . (� �l \� \ -m.`.'' po �� o\ p � � `_•� �� . N `����,B .. . III p U $ 4x� �•� w � � '.Y� � � ���� � � � . . . � o �� r � �.� � � 9 0 0 � � ��,� ,��.�� � . ,, a� � ;:� � � ' � . . � o . . � . � . �- � 0 0 �me Q � � ° � i , ; � � � - o � = e � � os . . � N . N . F- . � � �.� � �e W Q O Ul (n '�� w � �j�.'� B � . J � W M � � H �yl l� �°,� 'I � � (n � U � z ��o ��� �� I I . O 2 . . W . � CO Q � . � .cs0 I I� � , � �w o � � \ I `� a Q Q � O�� �� .i � � � �O \w'9. � y V 6� A, . . . . �yJ w . � _ �0 6 � �Q . � i 3� �� �: � w� U Z / O g p �`5 y ° 4x o� � o � �� � ./ .: `�� /L C � i , _ i r / / r i � � / y� l �L� �!B .. _� ��/ �� $�; ',I \ {/� C�� !�\( �r � . � , � � .' � ' ���`�� ��J�'� �t�� ��{�C`f�� � F.i �� i ��; / �,:(� ,� � � :- $ V � c _ , k � , . - � .a F � � ���.— — � , �� ,,' � <.., y _ 4a� �� ix 1k `te � — — — — � � ^'�..+-a ... --�L = =a , ' '�. � � �� ���� _ _ _ - I - '9 �N �� ? = o0 .i i , . � � I a r` . _ b9B o ,�'L �T I R R Z � m � 0 m� i� C [ � o f i � �x:�`. �: I w o • � os � \\ � o I ''' � � . . n F � N Q . m �I�,,,` � II ;� ZZ� .. ��� �- z� "a-o .�p�� ��, . � �ao avv�N . '�, �� � ��.,, �. . . � U I NN , -i� I� i� ' �'� . LL ... I / L � I I a a� � 6 p � • � ��', . � • `�r��`J� � I ��IN I I I I I �d a I� • �� . I� U d� ZtV 'I,� . � I � �O Oi0 1 _..-. ' o e O N �� � % - Nh r ,i � '"- �:���-.. . ,. ..._ ._. .. ., . � B6 .: . __. . . _. _. _ .. �� � �� ---� �� � ' 6['73S 1/S 3N 3H1!OL>/I r1S 3H1'�'�3NI�lS3A 3H1 �-� � � � ;. __' _��.. �9B " � . ,.� ,i� . � � ... '-.-� . . � ..-„/ . , ... . .... ... _. . . � � y � •.� � . ._ "' _. bS0 .:'9£B OSO 098 29B _ � ... P ,.. 37tll8�S � 0�p � SnONINf1119 � , e9 d .-:.' . _ �90- 060-._ .. - .:.` _-,. . ... � ,. -�� -HO .- . . ' -_ . .__. :" ... ' '__'..... :... .. .. ._ .. �.. .....__ ._ ... ..____-_' .. - �._ . . .. �- _ . - _. � .. ��, ..-,- - ._.____, �. . ._ - . _ .. , .:\ ' ..,, - . ..OSB .._2S8 _ .... ,,\'�. '. , �OG2 '- � � I . .'� � '�,� � li ' \\�m `'\`\ \ , . . _ ,-8bo �, i \� � \ �. \ ��` - � .. o ` !� � � � '-� : —__ . -__-___.._._ _____ _. _.. ._ ._ . ._._____ _.. ___ .._ ._._—.• ___� __.. . .. ... . ..___ ._ .. ___' __ .._.___'__ __'____._'__".—_—..._. _ __. m o___...._. _ ._ .__._.______. ._...__ __._ __� o � £BO8—LBZ—f9L XV� L609—LSZ—f9L �3131 � a�c1l v�aorn A�aas su so s�n su�mn o i a ZZiS9 NIY '.l3'I�V� N�Q1pJ ''2l1� ,L'aTIVA �JNRldS �091 L7�UqIM QiflQJll AifW Y M I pM►pN WYyp�n{ � � � � � '�NI a�lb'08 � W00�1 ,�°,,�„���,a, �d�d S1��11H�2�b' 2��11�10� , i i i � � I �, _ _ � � � o ; � , � ; ; N J I i � � U I � � I I i � � I � m I II � � ; � � , ', � I I j � I I � � M � ( I I � � I , I I � I � I ; I �" I I � � � � i � � I I i � � ! 3 � � � I i � � i II Z I I � II Y ' � U c� � II a � � I ' ° II a I � a m w � � a � ' Q � � � � I � � i � ° � II � � ' ; I II z � � , w Z II ° w � ' F= � � I I � � , � w I I � � ' I I � � ) � -� , � � � I I � i ` � � � I I N I � ° I I N � � I I � i � � � � I I � � I I ' , � ! ° I o � 'I � � I ' i � � � � � I I i I ' I I I I � ' Q1 I I I I i � � i II ; I II I � I I � I jj � z � � I ii z i i � ; ; i i� ; " ii � U i � Q � ii � ; ii Q i ' �' i i > � J � � � ' � i i —� - i �.1 ' � ° II W ' I I j � , II � � ' II (n . � �--v ' I I � � II V--) � � II � m I Q I ' � II � � II � i i � I� � ; �� ' I � I II �-- I � O �, II � I � I 0 i � II X I � ! II W � � I ; -� a I ; � � i ; , , �_------------------ C.��� (:��. Planning Department 763-593-8U9S!763-593-8109(fax) Date: August 6, 2013 To: Planning Commission From: Joe Hogeboom, City Planner Subject: Informal Public Hearing- Preliminary PUD Plan— Meadowbrook Elementary School - PUD No. 90, Amendment 3 — Hopkins Public Schools ISD #720, Applicant . . . , .. . .. . . . _ . . . . .. .wktrr. .. . Backgraund and Description of Proposal Hopkins Public Schools is seeking approval of an amendment to the Planned Unit Development (PUD) Permit for Meadowbrook Elementary School for the construction of a small addition and the incorporation of the current Crisis Nursery Facility (5400 Glenwood Ave.) into the main school facility. The 5400 Glenwood Ave. building would be used for additional classroom space. It would be interconnected to the main school facility via a tunnel. The Crisis Nursery is moving to a new location in south Minneapolis.The 5400 Glenwood Ave. building served as the original Meadowbrook Elementary School before the existing facility was constructed. Assuming approval of the PUD amendment, construction for this project would begin this fall. The renovated and expanded facility will be operation for the 2014-2015 school year. Site Information PUD No. 90 was adopted by the City Council on December 19, 2000. The PUD was established to allow the City and the School District to build the Davis Community Center following the relocation of Turner's Crossroad and Xenia Avenue. The first amendment to the PUD was approved in May 2012, to allow a small addition to the building. The second amendment, approved in November 2012, altowed for modifications to be made to the parking area. The current Meadowbrook School PUD site contains two parcels. One parcel (Parcel B) contains the school itself, and the other parcel (Parcel A) contains the Davis Community Center, which is jointly operated between the Hopkins School District and the City of Golden Valley. The Final Plat, which will be a component of the Final PUD Plan approval, will consolidate Parcel B with the 5400 Glenwood Avenue lot. land Use and Zoning Considerations Both the existing school and the 5400 Glenwood Avenue building site are designated as "Institutional" on the General Land Use Plan Map. The existing school is zoned 1-1 Institutional, and the 5400 building is zoned I-3 Institutional. Coinciding with the Final PUD Plan approval, the applicant will petition to rezone the 5400 Glenwood Avenue building to I-1 Institutional. Public Works and Fire Safety Considerations As is standard practice for development proposals, this project was reviewed by the City's Public Works Department. The Public Works Department reviewed the proposal to ensure the site can be adequately served by public utilities and that traffic issues are resolved. A memorandum from the Public Works Department is attached. The Fire Department reviewed this proposal to ensure that adequate emergency vehicle access is achieved on the site. In addition, the Fire Department ensures that the buildings are equipped with fire protection systems. The Fire Department's memorandum is attached, and is incorporated with the conditions of PUD approval. Justification for Consideration as a PUD Section 11.55 of City Code states that the PUD process is an optional method of regulating land use in order to permit flexibility in uses allowed, setbacks, height, parking requirements and number of buildings on a lot. Staff has determined that this application qualifies as a PUD because it achieves the following standards established in City Code: • Achieves a high quality of site planning, design, landscaping, and building materials which are compatible with the existing and planned land uses. • Encourages preservation and protection of desirable site characteristics and open space and protection of sensitive environmental features including steep slopes, trees, scenic views, water ways, wetlands and lakes. • Encourages creativity and flexibility in land development. • Encourage efficient and effective use of land, open space, streets, utilities and other public facilities. • Allow mixing land uses and assembly and development of land to form larger parcels. • Encourage development in transitional areas which achieve compatibility with all adjacent and nearby land uses. • Achieve development consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. • Achieve development consistent with the City's redevelopment plans and goals. In order to be approved as a PUD, the City must be able to make findings which are specifically described in City Code. These findings are incorporated into staff's recommendation to the Planning Commission. Recommendation Staff recommends approval of the Preliminary Plan for Meadowbrook Elementary School PUD No. 90, Amendment 3, based on the following findings of fact: 1. Quality Site Planning. The PUD plan is tailored to the specific characteristics of the site and achieves a higher quality of site planning and design than generalfy expected under conventional provisions of the ordinance. 2. Preservation. The PUD plan preserves and protects substantial desirable portions of the site's characteristics, open space and sensitive environmental features including steep slopes, trees, scenic views, creeks, wetlands and open waters. 3. Efficient— Effective. The PUD plan includes efficient and effective use (which includes preservation) of the land. 4. Compatibility. The PUD Plan results in development compatible with adjacent uses and is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and redevelopment plans and goals. 5. General Health. The PUD plan is consistent with preserving and improving the general health, safety and general welfare of the people of the City. 6. Meets Requirements. The PUD plan meets the PUD Intent and Purpose provision and all other PUD ordinance provisions. And subject to the following conditions: 1. The plans prepared by SGN/Wendel, dated July 24, 2013, submitted with the application shall become a part of this approval, 2. The recommendations and requirements outlined in the memo from Deputy Fire Chief John Crelly ta Mark Grimes, Community Development Director dated August 5, 2013, shall become part of this approval. 3. The recommendations and requirements outlined in the memo from City Engineer Jeff Oliver to Mark Grimes, Community Development Director, dated August 7, 2013, shall become a part of this approval. 4. The City Attorney shall determine if a park dedication fee is required for this project prior to Final PUD approval. 5. All signs on the property shall meet the requirements of the City's Sign Code. 6. This approval is subject to all other state, federal, and local ordinances, regulations, or laws with authority over this development. Attachments Location Map (1 page) Applicant's Narrative (1 page) Memo from Deputy Fire Chief John Crelly dated August 5, 2013 (2 pages) Memo from City Engineer Jeff Oliver dated August 7, 2013 (5 pages) Site Plans (10 pages) _ _.� _�,� . . .a e � a �.�; �—� ._ � .�_ � ��� __ �..«� . .m ° . �---�_.�.—��` ._ .�-C7Pscr��Nt�m�rkat Havy " ,. _ ,� � St�t�N+,vy�1as,55 �,�''�Y 55 WB to Hrvy i pfl�g� � �'�utatt�H id �« � — �� ., �_ >. � �y �:s5 �_„----�' yI � �, ���� -......��. Z� �� ��;��y m ,�5isc�ri A9enac�riat+iwy A, �ate Nwy No 5S� �. � �" ' � � � �. �. � � f ,_ �}r�#�. � ._.... � � �}�_" - �- `, w° ! � C} / b u � � 1 � � rv �i �� a �-`� �.5 � o �`•. .,��.� w,,� r�� ,� � ti �, � ' ° ;� : � � ��--(�^� y .-�'Pcu�d�r:ood fXlfi�t�Pvrrrf �r�.� ` � ,, �1yy1 � .� � '�'� , �/�s L �� �� , .. T < � "`°�v��` �..�•� P�t#Ch t'�i`er 5�a�F6etti i�Nfd � � 'c� z �'„�a �.... °� ,,� m. _ �,. „� .„� � �� �4 �,��Y�st�ck Av� .. �. .- ... �' � � � � �,.r .. Yt)�t31[����C�C ,� " S �� �r y-� /'r� � _ '�� "�+ � � �� =,C7� \ �"a'� � r'`� .�f _...._.__ T . � � R ff� ..°«'" �,`�... /.-''`� �,,. �� � � �� ; � �. »' � y/ 1 � � ��. _t�e�r€r�g L�._ _.. �. c� § � \ _-1-� r 1 f' =--� ' �°��. � �+ �� � ' /� � �P�� �,.,�"�,'�, �' � -- �j. � � � § � `1,..• i�L� � i'„ I � `���'\ s�r � �p �,C1ti1,,.''`"i$r�ECk POnt1 � � � � �N / i c � _.-."ti—.4. '�" JT. ,� Y� \� � .� � � � / , ``5.� �-�f r�r��.., �'� �, � � .- � � ' � �ti `�-- ;� ,�„�, r� '��� ,t--� _�, � �°' �,� �..=� ����;,' ��, ; � � Subject Property ` � _._� ..__ �'��.�'- , . '; ;-%� f;,�; , �;��: �';���w � r � , / �\. � / ''q4/ / �//��/l� ": \ / � , j Cfi:` �'�Ltf7t@V5�G'i}d� +� / 'i ij ii f� "i `��. �Z ; ��. ,. } r �j.' � _ I a. �. _ , ,,. �, �d � ��,ii� r�� �,. .;� : . ; ��"�` _ —�`e��+ A.. � '�' �ij%��¢� �fti �ey�,� � _ :�..,.,,,� i �—. � ° I� a �----'a �^�� flifii��iir f,,ji%'r% � �' �` '°"-.� 1.t13�Qc Pb<.» -` 1"� �I ;�y� ' ' � � j�� � �i//����i v.!% -. ��-- �-- � �� _ � �. �:� �r�����,� ��-�- ;r,�,;;, ,�� �,��x� � ,m. �� �; _ �, M��_�_ _ � �.. ,� .� � ,/,, , � ��, � 61enw,a�crd�orad�. m� �' � !� LtuGk A�d '`I,;,/ �-�-���`{'o �,� �'��� "`- �� " , �, �- `" � �_ ,„ 4 pt,� ... . uy �__'."� �.—i�, ,�/ �` T"°--;a ��� �.����G>� C#�err�4odAVCr � � m,. M ,n �;. .M. _.�ci. �'-�,.,_ e��zavine PnnA � _�° �. K � �� � J� . _ � �� +�� � �. _.�� � � �r ��� � ��--- � *, � ��� ��., u� . '� �'�, � =�' ' �; � � � t m -�.��`r° , � �,�" w&��d����. x � � '' ,�'�'' taure!Hifls Pvrid ,;� � 9 � } r�^..���� a �� _'"�—� r � -�..1 X�r�'.�Mt7i��tiO»Pr�nt! � �i ° � � "^ ��� ,,, � � � ' � � � � �� � � �������� � � n� �. t, �,� �_* � �r--- 4 � ti P� � �d �, � Jferfia Aveu�ue l�d � �'' ��a�rti�t 17s__ _ _ .,� .- �4,'� i , .__ � � � ' ��� � � � �� _.. + r, �. � � ��4=� � � j a � _ ;� � � �.��a °a r � ' � � .�. �u�tAw��.�� .w �. � ,__ �f�,__�.�� � ._ .,, ,,. ..„ „ �., ��.f''"� � �`�,�•, _ � � � ���,����a"� �� � f `� t�i'!�`�'.�. � k�- �. "�.�. . i �� ���. � a �� . .�.,,'`�.r��..,,� S t 5'''���"�% � �., � ��r�__i_ , � /� ��s� la ! °� 1 Redi��can Rd" ,� �, ,�. ti� } :�� �`� f �� �� � � "�� .,,� �::. €� �� � 3. � � , � .. - � .q --...... � �"`. +? � r, _. _._ �- _� _w �_ . � .m _ � _ ti,���c3�Cc�n Hit�s pr , _ ,__ �. . � . SL� ��. � � � � ��1� � � � � l�_ i F--�--�r � ��r�����- .--�`�_r //�� �� � Y � '� Y �f(7�C�@ty'�/'�l«'S�� Y,� •4, I -� � ` �, � '��. � � ,j � ��j�,' �,#�r�,..-�` � L_��� T-;�.w � �' � � �� � ° G � r�r i � $� l �.».. ..,..._.... �/ b �'":r��^t � 4 ..� ���«�v�>�w..+:c�ers� �,ve a'e°k„m.���;�s a�+� � � .... - � ��4tif+Lt%�`�tutd ,ta� 1 �'� rc, t,�t - � !�€����1?i�.^I ft<( �r�Atv�rlPd�� IN?��+C(2�E°:Ii�N Sgrl wer��clel Hopkins Public Schools— Meadowbrook Elementary School Addition Project Description: Hopkins Public Schools is in the process of purchasing the building at 5400 Glenwood Avenue, Golden Valley, MN which currently houses the Minneapolis Crisis Nursery, and is adjacent to Meadowbrook Elementary School at 5430 Glenwood Avenue. The school district would like to convert the Crisis Nursery space to classrooms, and connect the buildings with an addition that would contain 2 classrooms, storage space, and a connecting hallway. The addition will be approximately 4,600 SF, and is anticipated to have a brick exterior to match the existing school. 111 Washington Avenue North,Suite 300,Mi�neapoiis,MN 55401 p 612.332.1401 f 612.332.1405 w we�delcompanies.com gi�till(���C`���itT�ry` �:KK���� ���� ��W � , �, ���, << _ , � Fire Department 763-593-8079 i 763-593-8098 {fax} Date: August 5, 2013 To: Mark Grimes, Director of Planning & Zoning From: John Crelly, Deputy Chief Subject: PUD Amendment— Meadowbrook Elementary School The Golden Valley Fire Department has reviewed the PUD Amendment#3 submitted on July 12, 2Q13 and reviewed the additional information that was submitted on luly 26, 2013 to complete the original submittal. This PUD Amendment proposes to allow and interconnection addition between the existing building at 5430 Glenwood (Meadawbrook School) and the adjacent building at 5400 Glenwood (Crisis Nursery) for a total expansion of 4,600 square feet. loining of these buildings can be accomplished but the following code items will need to be discussed and resolved: 1) Property Addresses; with the interconnection between the existing building at 5430 Glenwood (Meadowbraok School) and the adjacent building at 5400 Glenwood (Crisis Nursery), how will the buildings be addressed and /or identified moving forward? 2) Fire Sprinkler Systems; with the interconnection between the two buildings, consideration needs to be given on how the new areas will be protected with fire sprinklers. Also, a full review of the fire suppression systems should be conducted to determine if the systems should be combined into one large system coming off one riser location or be maintained as two independent systems. 3) Fire Alarm System; with the interconnection between the two buildings, a full review of the fire alarm systems shall be conducted to determine if the systems should be combined into one large alarm system or for each building to maintain independent fire alarm systems. If they are independent, how should the systems operate to meet code requirements of an Educational Occupancy? 4) The fire department still has concerns about traffic on and off the site during drop off/ pickup times and during large school events such as open house/ parent teacher conferences. This is an ongoing issue that needs to be reviewed as this project moves forward. 5) Road Access up to the building and around the building. As we have done in the past, we need to review the site, determine where fire lanes shall be established and to have the established fire lanes properly identified with approved signage. 6) Public and private water systems to the site and the building. A review of current Iocations of fire hydrants and routing of the water mains needs to be completed. Access issues noted in items 4 and 5 also impact our ability to access water to suppress a fire. There may be a need to add fire hydrants to compensate for poor access issues during critical times. 7) Code Analysis; A code analysis will be required when these buildings are combined. This information will be used during the review of this project from a Code perspective (Building, Fire, Electrical, Plumbing, and Mechanical Codes) If you have any questions, please contact me at 763-593-8065 or by e-mail, jcrelly@goldenvalle�rmn•gov ���� �� Public Works Department 763-593-8030/763-593-3988(fax) Date: August 7, 2013 To: �ark Grimes, Community Development Director Joe Hogeboom, City Planner From: Jeff Oliver, PE, City Engineer��� Eric Eckman, Public Works Specialist�� Subject: Amendment to Meadowbrook School Planned Unit Development No. 90 � , „ Public Works staff has reviewed the preliminary design plans submitted by the Hopkins School District for a major amendment to Meadowbrook School Planned Unit Development (PUD) No. 90. The PUD site is located north of Glenwood Avenue and east of Xenia Avenue. The school district is purchasing the building immediately east of Meadowbrook School at 5400 Glenwood Avenue, the site of the Minneapolis Crisis Nursery. The school district plans include an addition to the southeast corner of the existing school building and connecting the addition to the 540Q Glenwood Avenue building with a tunnel under the existing driveway. The Public Works review has been based upon the plans submitted on July 26, 2013, and addresses issues that must be addressed prior to final PUD approval by the City council. Site Plan and Preliminarv Plat The existing PUD No. 90 consists of two lots; one of the lots is the location of Meadowbrook School and the second lot is the location of a community center. The proposed PUD amendment includes replatting the property to incorporate the 5400 Glenwood building into the existing lot containing the school. The PUD is adjacent to Glenwood Avenue and Trunk Highway 100. Therefore, the plans are subject to the review of Hennepin County and the Minnesota Department of Transportation. Any comments received must be addressed prior to final PUD Plan approval. As part of the re-platting process,the existing easements within the PUD must be vacated and rededicated as required by the City Engineer. The following modifications to the existing easements must be included with the final PUD submittal. G:\Developments-Private\Meadowbrook School PUD Amendment\MajorAmend 080513.docx 1 1. All drainage and utility easements on the plat boundaries must be a minimum of 10 feet in width. 2. The drainage and utility easement on the eastern-most portion of the property, adjacent to TH 100, must be expanded to coincide with the 850 contour surrounding the existing pond. 3. The City has a sanitary sewer main on the north and northeast boundaries of the property. An easement of 20 feet in width and centered on the main must be dedicated on the plat. 4. The City has sanitary and watermain facilities near the west parking lot entrance, where Turners Crossroad was vacated and removed. Easements being 20 feet in width and centered over the facilities must be dedicated over the sewer and water mains, hydrant lead, and hydrant. 5. The drainage and utility easement on the north portion of the property must be modified to incorporate the base flood elevation of 845 feet above sea level. Site Access/Circulation Access to the Meadowbrook School site is currently provided with two driveways at the 5400 Glenwood building onto Glenwood Avenue, and two driveways onto Xenia Avenue. The eastern driveway onto Glenwood Avenue includes a driveway extension in the northeast corner of the parking lot into a separate parking lot located east of the school. The northern driveway onto Xenia Avenue provides access to the parking lot utilized by school busses, and the southern driveway provides access to the existing student drop off and community center parking. There are no proposed changes to the site access as a result of the PUD amendment. Meadowbrook School and school district staff have been working with City staff for a number of years to address site circulation, congestion and pedestrian issues within the community center and drop-off parking lot on the west side of the site. This parking lot is currently the only student drop-off location for the entire school. Congestion results in this parking lot in part due to school policy that all preschool and kindergarten students who are dropped off or picked up in this location must be accompanied by an adult to their classroom, resulting in extended periods of cars parked within the drop-off area. It is anticipated that the congestion and circulation issues discussed above will be reduced with the PUD amendment. The proposed remodeling of the 5400 Glenwood building wi(I include all preschool classrooms, and the addition to the existing building will be the location of the kindergarten classrooms. The relocation of these age groups will allow parent pick up and drop off to occur in the 5400 Glenwood parking lot, which will greatly reduce the number of vehicles in the western parking lot. The layout of Glenwood Avenue adjacent to the 5400 building appears to be sufficient to accommodate the access to the Meadowbrook site and there are no congestion issues anticipated. However, staff reserves the right to require Meadowbrook School to modify the access to this portion of the site if and when issues develop. Public Works and Police staff will continue to monitor access and traffic circulation at the school following build out of the addition for access and safety issues. G:\Developments-Private\Meadowbrook School PUD Amendment\MajorAmend 080513.docx 2 There is existing sidewalk and/or trail on Xenia Avenue and Glenwood Avenue adjacent to the Meadowbrook School site. There are no additional facilities identified in the City's Comprehensive Transportation Plan at this location. The driveway apron that is being removed for the proposed building additions must be replaced with a City standard commercial driveway apron. In addition,the pedestrian ramps at this driveway must be upgraded to comply with all applicable accessibility standards. A City Right-of- Way Management Permit must be obtained before working on the pedestrian ramps which are part of the City's sidewalk and trail system. Because Glenwood Avenue is a county road, the contractor will be required to obtain a permit from the Hennepin County Public Works Department for the removal and replacement of the driveway. A copy of the county permit must be submitted to the Public Works Department prior to the issuance of a City Right-of-Way Management Permit. Utilitv Plan All the buildings within the proposed PUD amendment are currently served by City sanitary sewer and water. While there may be an increase in flows to and from the 5400 Glenwood building, there is adequate capacity within the municipal systems to accommodate the flows. The 5400 Glenwood building is compliant with the City's Inflow and Infiltration ordinance. The existing school building at 5430 Glenwood Avenue has undergone a partial inspection and repair work has begun, but the building is not currently compliant with the ordinance. The school district has been working with the Public Works Department on completing an inspection of the school's sanitary sewer system, but a number of significant obstacles, including buried demolition debris on site have limited the extent of excavation needed to access the sewer service. The school district has submitted a plan to complete the I/I inspection and perform any repairs identified in the inspection as part of the addition to the school. This plan demonstrates a commitment to become I/I compliant and is acceptable to staff. However,the school must be I/I compliant prior to issuance of Certificate of Occupancy for the school addition. Storm Water Mana�ement The PUD project is located within the Sweeney Lake sub-district ofthe Bassett Creek Watershed and would disturb over 10,000 square feet of area. Therefore,the plan must be reviewed by the Bassett Creek Watershed Management Commission (BCWMC). Based upon the scope of the proposed improvements, the BCWMC water quality requirements do not apply to the proposed addition. However,the plans must be submitted to the BCWMC for their review and comment. Sweeney Lake is listed as an impaired water by the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency, and the BCWMC has completed a Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) study for the lake. At the time the existing PUD was approved, the school district was required to install an environmental manhole to provide water quality treatment for the western portion of the site, and enter into a maintenance agreement to sweep alf of the parking lots on site a minimum of two times per year. As a means to carry out the agreement, a letter of understanding was executed between the City and the school district requesting that the City perform the required maintenance of the G:\Developments-Private\Meadowbrook School PUD Amendment\MajorAmend 080513.docx 3 environmental manhole and parking lot sweeping, with the costs billed to the school district. This letter of understanding must be modified to include parking lot sweeping for the 5400 Glenwood building that is becoming part of the PUD. As part of its review, staff visited the parking lot at 5400 Glenwood and noted that the catch basin inlets and the pipe outiet which convey runoff from the parking lot to the pond are clogged with debris and sediment. Staff recommends that these storm sewer facilities be cleaned as part of this project. In addition, staff recommends that the school district survey the pond on the east side of the PUD to determine if it has adequate water quality capacity or other maintenance needs. Although water quality improvements may not be required with this proposed addition, staff recommends that the school district explore the possibility of adding water quality treatment or pre-treatment facilities on the east side of the PUD to assist in removing sediment and pollutants from the parking lot runoff. The plans submitted for review must be modified to include a Stormwater Management Plan prepared to City standards and specifications. The proposed improvements will require that a City Stormwater Management Permit be obtain prior to the start of work on site. The permit will not be issued until the BCWMC has approved the plans. Tree Preservation and Landscape Plan The proposed PUD amendment is subject to the City's Tree Preservation ordinance and minimum landscape standards. Therefore, a tree inventory must be included in the final PUD submittal. A permit application must be submitted and approved prior to any work on site beginning. Summarv and Recommendations Public Works staff recommends approval of the preliminary design plan for the Meadowbrook School PUD No. 90 Amendment subject to the comments contained in this review which are summarized as follows: 1. The existing easements within the property that run in favor of the City of Golden Valley must be vacated as part of the platting process and rededicated on the final plat for the PUD as discussed in this review. The public hearing for the easement vacation must occur at the same City Council meeting that the final plat is approved. 2. The School District agrees to work with City and Hennepin County in the future to address access and site circulation issues that impact adjacent City or county roadways that may develop following opening of the 5400 Glenwood building and the school addition. 3. The plans must be modified to utilize City standard details for all watermain, sanitary sewer, storm sewer and right-of-way related construction items. 4. The Grading, Drainage and Utility Plan must be modified to be consistent with City standards and specifications. G:\Developments-Private\Meadowbrook School PUD Amendment\MajorAmend 080513.docx 4 5. The existing school building (5430 Glenwood Avenue) must become compliant with the City`s Inflow and Infiltration Ordinance prior to issuance of a certificate of occupancy for the addition to the school. 6. The existing storm water maintenance letter of understanding must be modified to include sweeping of all parking lots and driveways within the PUD including those for the 5400 Glenwood building. 7. Staff recommends that the school district explore the possibility of adding water quality treatment or pre-treatment facilities on the east side of the PUD to assist in removing sediment and pollutants from the parking lot runoff. 8. Staff recommends that the school district inspect and clean the storm sewer system on the east side of the 5400 parking lot as part of this project. 9. Staff recommends that the school district survey the pond on the east side of the PUD to determine if it requires maintenance as discussed in this review. 10. Approval is subject to the review and approval of the plans by the Bassett Creek Watershed Management Commission. 11. Approval is subject to the comments of the City Planner, Deputy Fire Chief, City Attorney and other City staff. Approval is also subject to the comments of other City staff, Hennepin County, MnDOT, and other agencies. Please feel free to contact Public Works staff if you have any questions regarding this matter. C: Tom Burt, City Manager Jeannine Clancy, Director of Public Works Eric Eckman, Public Works Specialist Mitch Hoeft, Engineer Joe Fox, Engineer Mark Kuhnly, Fire Chief John Crelly, Deputy Fire Chief Gary lohnson, Building Official/Plans Examiner G:\Developments-Private\Meadowbrook School PUD Amendment\MajorAmend 080513.docx rJ I� �� �� � ��L� _ -- s�ooy�s�gqnd sui�doH � ��9a p �FQ_ � �oq� � � � � �; �� � 6€sg � � ' , O yN � ` �� s�q�� � uoi�iPpd u�ooassel� E�OZ ° Q I 4' €���� - � . . � W� � �� �g g = _ _ m � � �oo��s �,e�uau�a13 �ooaqnnopeaW ����s g o � � � s 133HS 31111 ro�v'�� ¢ U a 0 S U _ ._.._...._-__ il . I � I --_...._�___�—_— _.... ..._._- .. _._r. � — ..._Na M1e�PVeN..._... .rhCZ�veN 9 �u '- � � '`i'w, } Otlaxa arr N I a ��� Nf * � . ' � �ih��.;. �'�. � � - $ ... ° � O U x a � � O� W Y^� � �� > ,m i ; � Q � ■ � I �° ,�,_R,�, � �- ��N W ` 4�,'�" � vou���c� _` y' s � E ''�pyy :' � A, i c E - W ; J e.e`' N Q � Q _sa�o, . � � �. , � > � ne,�, � � ! Z pb�W a yg , '^ w p � � nemHn��, Ot1 J � J �f'z II � o � I Q ° i U� `V >; O 0 � � � � z — ; I% � � > � , ' �, �i � � � � ��� J , � -Q�— � ' _ i � o � � N o � p � � i � ,��� � L ' � � ' W � � �/� � � � — � Q V! 3 � �. 0 U o �, z. � z � � w � � � (n � (n o z g � Z g � z � � � � ,�, J I� a U � Z a :,� � �o � � i � X q �.,.' a � � �ZzJ > d �� d Z � � W LL W�� z W O �0 Z � � � � � O O � Q U Z � v�} Z � O J � gJ O LLZ J > ^ w = O U s.i � ~ w > � U � O aQ LL cn v~i� U � I � � O r Z � �� Y Z Y ,�, 'oo�o o g �� ° � � = g � � � � Z U O � � O �..� �'�. O O �. � � � � O N L.L OU — � � � a) N o a, c°�c°� ; Y � � c�i c�''�c�.� o � ¢a � cwn _ __ I C� _-- _ _ _ _ _ _ � _ ____ � ° } � ¢ ' � a--F �� J� H w N � N W w � Q H v O °� w �� p � _ � � Qoo U ?~� � o� � w� � w � w � N wQa � � ZW � � U �in w >� wN > g Q � � �n Zo¢� U c�� � I— cncnM w a �w � Z z c7� '�' �"'zz w a'�' z Z c� �,r, Y o� ¢c� o >= O � �zOZ zQ� � w o = � � Q � r �n p ow z- � w � w -U � w � � F—. m QZ O � J Q � J J(7 C/) w� JaiS Q!n � C7�Cn ,J�,. ��i� � � Q � W gQ F— wz J zWw � zJ Q z = J d= m Z > gcnQC7 ] Uo- p Z�7w � � �p U� � � O �� �C7N � � wz � oo = z wZC=noa Z - ° j �N � a Zww� a �,(n' �z - z pp� W � �� ow �wQr�� wc�� w V - Za Qwwo¢ ��Z wIY = Y I00�� U� o � � 2� w Zm � Z - w =ZZZW p za � a �w =�� ow� �� c� z � � z � � �,o �g � Z �c�c��z �ogo c��o �zz�o �c� � � ? a ,�,= � a � — wzz � — U Ox � = cn �cn �nc� aw�� t7 Qcn �cn� c�cnvcn cna �n � �ww � � , ,____ __ - ___ _ _._ __ -_ I i i � � Z I, O ' H � Q ' - ------ > w , � o m z 0° w � ¢ C� J � w p J m J � I Q J � �i w a I � � � i li � } � Z L! �z;m�v„ LLJ U = o � U� � S W _°°m� � � Z � � � O � o a > �mZ�� N z ' = a a> � Q O = } �� Wo a°z� ,� Z a 3�;��� / O U � �Z ��C m � O o " J w Z ��w �o�= = o M � �,� � �— Z � v �o � J w i� � 1� � � o�� V'I > O p� � w � � ''"z� � � � � � �� dw O -= ' jj�f3 " U `�'r°ma � W m �� O vw-i a�a � Z W °i � r�aL � � O w � O 5 � V I �p O U w 7 Z a a F u _o t��E J � � � � G U W g O � i � Q w u a � ?=�w u p WO o LL - �''' ,r w z � �n � � WC J �/A� Z wm°~z � O > _ - _ � °_ ,`^`�'J � o I'A1 r�� o z w Q G W V 1 � Z �r�v=i� U V I u C o 0 0o U �ap� '��o o' a - 1 v ` O Z LL o � � � , 2 � � � �' � UJ � � d / _� ,,� __9s� —ssg� �m� OPaaa;o- �h^�B esa-�� s / �a L'� �P 9)0 /3.r� `-._- 'o e� �6 y`� R / - �' ,�_ "_n`'_t�l. �� '�^o�o �-lyb- \a �, a^ 0y9 T_X 0 �O' So / //�\�� �'9� '� . S'o z z o N �m O �m � / / ;-OSB/-s � � o� m� Um � �,�� � , �a9 � a,, v;�, m`sa ��� � m_ a^aa�ne S y '9 � 9rN151%3 � � �� � � `L�3 � �� . �sa�� ��a �°y �_ � -� �� =� �� � � c�M E�� �� �m m�o _ � � o'�,o a �� % , r m � � �z i � , � � - � � �e, � e=� ,�,-��� � � m �°_ ,� �� � _ - s �� � � m � , P � 0`'P w / ss8\ � ` ` i se (t e d r. bZJ I m f�e a��� � � t Ba5- // �� .. � `. �_��r ' � L 'LL .��£SAO OOk .-�--=; A`�` qqqvc�� h S �� \ �O Cb � e`a mN �'3�b1 . � � aLS���` -� -�._- �. / � 'V � �� � e B- _' //051 3 0� n _:.¢W_6���SB=6r� ro '�06� L.V3�5 ��,�y/ 0{O[ �^m � __ �� ��` Q�` w - / � y��0 6nBe � 05�' 0 9B- �_ / "1 h0 ��. � Q�'�. �3 Osg 50.� . V� . 0 � / I / �W � � S e�p �.���� 6Sg � � .. . 85Q ' . �� p �2 �B� '�7 d�' i'1 m� �I I G �„t eNGE 960��U�a I � �° 9�ro al �NO� � �y��� yh b69 I �� A A �� �f��-- `� , �rF�N. � + ��:� ���`�� I h " -- ...� noNiuni� . . �.� % i0�6 , ,C r_ `�r \ � / _ -�.� � �., � _..... � � �.�, �ezro ai�z� I',-_ re r' � � , \ �P �y'� e . -...__ i � g, Y: . --` niaa s ^ e o,^� � � ' 9Y � � R�� � � x 1ai eE '�` 7_-_____ W ' . � _---- h n m m �/m� m m m��. w m , �� � v y 0P� ^p� // + j � b" O�OP �'e 0 m a3d . n� On J-� �- P �N � / 1 � �r�'�� �� t . �w �k� .�� oo�oo� �� " � �`°'� � -.� _T �w sd3���ypo°ss3a�w _-. � �h a � 0 �_ -r . �:. b , V e cz� // . � ?� � � , 0bD/� -g69 � OW���13b�N� y-� �m xn _ � r W � 3.aN� i � - 'L ' � �� �� ,� � on leg �s � � ¢�e^���y�.,�� � � `a. _ 0 LL � b O`� "z 9�"'_/_':". �y ..0`O6. � _ � 856 $:� . . 0 "n 066 � =w - UK`=�a'-���� � a'¢ � o,.� �._,.u , I w � � p + // .3 R . . �w p� � ,_ � w V . � 0 0 ��6 1 �����.,^ Z � `� �� � � i y � ��� m �� m 3 ' � �^��� �i a.���� � �� �� � / �� � " , ' �� I�' ' , m ����0 � N � Q � / LSB � ��k �N h •_ . �.0..N �� u �� // Nz � m�l � IW .6S"�p. 0 r ' W i 7 II 60 5 � 0�' / m ,. ._ - w I^ ��m� _ u� J �.o eb °mo h - q Y o � � i � m / a 6 0 0 m � � `S . a . �' 0 - c�< . . . � �68 R 0 �� u h� ��� a � � . / a � o� ta , `Pa' _ w� o^ �C 06 y.'� ,�1 a�m . ,� ¢� / z� � . w Z °t Im � 4'� �P�� \ a''° e5�+�a� 4-' / �,� _ �,/� R, o �. \ 96,��� �0 �°� F�o �, o C� �"w ? �Q�eR e , // �h^ � 06.. � W e55 �� o.. � ��'�62 p ��'� J � ��,I a��o � � � Py 0 e�ti .�p r 96� � _ . 0m a .691 l ° a �m r '- �y�r� 0' �r �ti ' J " � � e ' �0^ _!w �_�� �� �/tum� �o � � �- � m� � IJ� � � ° � `� _ -� �.� ,, -�� �� �/ � �� m • 5 i� Jo � o ° £ - - ��W ��,' ��� �/ � z ,�o +��� -�, y5 � �� ,�6 e. � - Im ,� � �� 3 � _0 ."/¢ :r.- A a�' ,.,/ �� m - � � � �- oo F , . i � - � • / c'�/ �a m� �9 � m` IY my x m e,� /„ / �; 5� 050F� � . . - . 0 i o a U �o ..e'12 / `�'I m m � � h ,86 / a ..;: � � _ � O � o F � o- h I � / � l �a �I � � . ry_- �� � �I m3 mt� a ,ebo 00 � ese � � g �o'� �� o �I � � �� � . a � � w� � w ` n a m m �m � 5 c �3 .� �* / � "� a �� � m m ,, � . ,es . sm'` mo � � �._ '�� ° ° � . ,� a irzvd anmo snoni � � r� h�nae ° � 3�� - 0 w y ._._. _ --'a�/ > � �. 6 a'4 �°' /P / B5 � � B5q �_ J 'Ux . .. ` nl �4 U oo � ��� a°s � i� �� m m ,�� � o�d d � . ^�d zv n / u_ti a O�= O� / / ��i.. �9 � � ttF � � � , � . ��LL� � � -L� � . � � 0-��ii. y O x � BD(PJ��'JND � �9° / \�a � '�x o E �a m, - i �� 960� o i9e ,. _.. 7��v �_ �� I'. ra 3�SOOOO.V � a° o� � - o � 588ai _1,3C � a � �/ mA�� ,,, IL'9s _ �0y0� � /' �, o _ _. . 'a �A � .. h o� �m �e a o _;w�sL�`� � � I / o v . p ..66a' O° _ � at {- \ p f � L � / i g� 1 �1 .', / . . .Z � �, _ �p �(1�` L@ �Q�,y x^ � i �� � �� .� / � I � 0b = .� �O. �� m � � I `,� i o _ gy4 5 £ �e m i�Q f`_ , �� �' � �Y / �' �� �- o. �0�66 . ��ro g :� _ _ [gg� - � ae�'` ? m Q � o � � v" ' I y — anro�1az�r+o� � ee��N �z h �� � ' � . �i°�o�� , oaj 'i /� � � '�� - mm �\ •_ �� umm �- Q � z� � �w Sibno�AVie�snowwnlie �K� _" � i o � � '-� �� �� � � � I� I I m � � o� Q J i � ( � � �� � 6� < � �� � /, � � o � . � � �- m �' � �� �- �o � ° �,��y� i ¢ s��� / � �� � ' ._ �2 00 0 .w � m � � �o I I a� , u_ `�o �'� <d .. � e t ^ �. °m m N uw °� N� £�mm� n �� � / � � o��„ � ,,I � I � � �' eS° �� uo�zl-� � �� �� 3 �I I � c�v� mZ�gH9 � � --�- E98 �� _ ��'w � __ ~_�_ � �h �� / � � �W � I � ' _ �Q 499q999 -�-se 9B. ����, m � w m � � �� � �l � � i> .I� I z � m � c9e u m,.� � m/°� �� VJ m �� I � I ,n�I e0 � L98 - � ��z s �° �'^ � '. h� �.;� � � m � o��. ', � g m n�rvae ..- w' ? °m s�m � � � -�V�, . �m' I �I " . m u�,> /�� ���/� n � � z U v , l a� I � I � , _ _h a e � �6° m\ —I--I I s \S � , � o /,� � o e Q ��� \ � I I � , �a � ' w e9e ai� a = � ' u� °o �, p� I ,1 m � z - s ��� � � � � � .� \ *2 ffi �•���, � i �� �� . � i � �_ A � � .9Iz��. m ,� a. � �w o '�\ � � I.a! � . a oLL o� bma Ic� o � 3� zon .�l'Or" \ ��\ � . , , \ � o$ _ °m �.� mmm 0h �� � �`e: � sa'Z t'�o +.���. . dVd �`m � uot� � 'v�� s�\v`r o \,"'i b315dUf10 �� z ? �'ci � � a 3 / �� � �� '.� �e � . — .� � � b0� �� 4� �' � . � i,�V�� m pye. om a� A ��mmq� � . � � � ��� �� u p (� . . - � rv .. � " �¢i ,� I �J � SN34bV� d�� � � W �Ci \. .. I . _ F, � . . 3 I\ � lgg���� - ��. ��� oaao � 0 0 . � / � � �,-___ --�z. � � 9 woo tt ..�,�� . . V lp, � (0 � m �I�.`y ye m 9B __ 99Baa. _ `� ` ` .O��_�v __ � � � / / � 02 �°m i� i°)� �og � � _ - s�> � �� ��d B'� tL��P� �o . � M ; �.'�-a. i co w � B` � e 0`�4� .^ Wo� . S a f /m , ry� ,\� .. . o�z mmm ��. �� � �� �� S � � . . � � �� r �` �_..�. _ ,_ � � �... .. V ��si ,�� � � . ,�m Q � . � ��d..f��. l . i �t n :o e' � ' � o�n � ILv� � � �o q .65g55� - o ;_.oss_ -�lm =� F�`.. �ro�-__,_598-: . sa 00. �' _ `` zj� `.�` °,� � �0'6.10 �p �ao ` 3 — — z� ° \ `• r- � ' �do°� ��: ��_3 -: 60'ES �� `.�o. � .. ry g c� // ��\ \'M mr m? o a ' o ' x'(� � o� �°r�i .m Bh s � M�.ESAOa00S .N �� . . � ac��m / o -w '� �� � �� mmm�. mm ��a3 i �- .... � - z n i � � a� �\ _ � m I°�� o:? �o� � �u n n. z ii u ; dJ?J„9E �� aL'> �� /• -o�£� mi � i �S "-� `__� \ /9 uiK� ._ � _ U'. _ _ --.-- _- . � ��ft/ �_-=-.�4'�.-- -_ -- --. �6 . x\�� � 0�_ e -a.-y- ^ £ .'.� i . _ .. . - - .�p -. 1 � . _-.-. . �.06.0� .. .� I` � o� Ip i . _ 1 ' u ' ; o . ,, e ,6i+ p'98>_X . -_�-, . __ � � o a i 3> � �,. m a _ ... „�� I Q�� � � o �� 3 q. �� �� o ,.208S,S 7 ' ° /m ._ a 1 Q . � g m ', ___...._ s�' 2= .o s.o., - y fn o . � � aaro�N D �� �� �-='� �` - o J �� I � � , � � . r� ,u'^ p � � �J ' .J� ^ ��5 � �w'�i" ^ - .. ��: -' . _- .- _ _ — 6 u`�i G�p � i I�� ��',2 `r.\ yo �O u5 �( 6sa � °�3 mm� II� om � �U�� i `° 9c�¢� ��t�•'°u�� � � �- � " � � ' I 17 m m � .ul r � � � o � � y m� oi � ooa .r�>� o�iz Fm ��a � �z .. 1�i e ��� -'o �'.. - �t ,u - ry c�� � � s fl'£.�m���� mmm 3� �mm Pp .� ooJ � ' �\eg9 . �' '� .`\. o `" I� m `J a nz N�� U v�� iD<v.v �mm � \\m`�u�o fg Q � 1. N �.1 � �dVCO�n a� Z�t Z 0 m�0m m� m r �'�> \�rpQ %m�'j\U g 6 � . j0 � �s 1.9� z od �r0 °m a � �6 �� yo . o n ' w .m ' � a 3� � o m V w " an mm� `^� `fl '�_�. 1 o mU ^ .o I m o' a; oma a3 �=x =sz�i = Z� o�� �'�,o£i���m�� �� °a'� `°\ ? ..\� �y mEimrv�.:., o �� o�'.� v �O� f.p3�� 3 �� mn'z� ,� ,A _ z � .. o \ Ya� � '". " � z°oo �� -�za G�i LLO�m O > � o r� ° \w �o,� � � "'� °o �����s wU wa„x¢����i, n w aa � �o�v a6 \ �..b n n° I .2 °� xN_. w z r,.,<F w m�„z m=J o g r z i m m , d m \� �z o -. � m . � .o . VN I W >icaooa�wo,a�„��oF `^a �fu ��z `� �" s\ � � � �' ��m m � 1 � � 5`N� �- U- + - � iowc��Zp �s.-�? rr W�z . �"� \ \ I - ,uo£i'z_ m �oz �I �'si , _ --- \ / . 1 ¢� � Z E>a-�¢�ZO¢¢ pJ omm � oa° � W ,:, a�l . Z 3QF-OwF�i�HpQ00 ~w Oa ' Z - _ � 98�� \ bP g �W I o�i� m�; - � �ZZ��n�<= �z^�r oYN u=Q a 3 0�£ � - . �\ \ 0 y a a-. �°Q3�N3���po�o 0=w �~° i xw � � ' ' � - e � � "'b,� � �11J �I �mo z i � "' � m �e .a - i.w �,�� � ,- � � �Q�owWoo�o o�o o_o °o o � „� � m � ��u�io�x��w��avHi ��w z�� .o z� o� ��\ -, �- .� \ i � � "' I v �i o � oZ,'�„�,�wQa���iww �-v~i3 �a�Z., o av�i �m� I�(J � oo ., �i � o\ `.�, / ;y;' ��..i� 7 �i c co ~ ° � ��� %J\� �� Y\ 'm . � - L al n � �zw�wx�oaazu FQ z�i Opti m �z a�>i �`m 3 �� ��m ,s e n� y��._. oo�r �yf�O �oi Z o>YJ zz=F-�Jotir--'� o�'� ON aH u,o� � r ''� ;n �m , � �� u . � ����Q LL S<�>�'�z�c ��� Y O u �z � � o u �ss 1 ti +� . - - / qa� � � �� � . ° p ��,�o�,�oo�<���oa w�Q � m*ffi o uo +� �� A- �e 8� / � � � O��O�zOp� i�a Ju3 a �Z a w� _ _ o � � . .' _ � ` z , a°�� � I i�_ o _ H� � o��a�,>�o�aY���� r�u 2 oz� � �� 'o �ti� `Z � o�� `�,�,•csa �g- i� r - i�, � O., .�- v w zLL��u'�z�¢�aOw�� ��i U ¢���++ w ,�un mm o- - �j�� �� ��,� s �� � - �.� - � ��wo� oawo� �o< 'z 3 � ,.',a o � o �� `� � � � � � z i�xzFxzox zz�z ar w ��¢� o d� m�' d�� �����\� x \ . � r- r»r»r?OOvi�3 ��O m � � � � . sm- �m�� �ro� m� _.� � u' y�d'° :� `���� ���� Q�W o l�ll $ i i "? � } / 3 �O� � Y_ p�...- z � 3 � � .� 4t I v�;!I o�yr- >� � Z � � W �O b� .o\ �\ \ 1 P�'��I '99�� I o O M J J Q Y f' � \ SC3Y . � ,-� � V�1 � o z w � � o o w � i �� � _' _ 6's � � � >> W m d Z � � ~ �o w u a p 7� w � �� o o � o wN �� d � � � � � � z �� ��°� ��U I zz � y�� � a °�' °�` - �'"r z 5�z a � m z s ��mo �s �z i i o� OLLw�w a >O� H ��~a wo r m � 3 � � w'u O� � - zs ��'� ��� � � a �s� . o° _"-_ mmro� � �' � c o °° �od E � a < aoz � ° Cw= � s¢; � �� � � �zi+ti__,; ��»� 0o a � _ ow prZQ o ��Z � �EN� � os° - 0CQ � �ox5 $baW wfp �d� � azz_, o'� -w � � i a � z � I � u - �P! � 9 'b _ . �o a a � Nw� pw aF�Q �. °�< � , __ - 3'I . ,cy sE, z �°„ 3 � S g� f o> z N o z I o = a� 26 � s � F am mi � H �� 'L'FOwt-v~i ��� a,�i� ���3 , J � -mm I � ��''�v .o�� � - . .� , p6 p wi u< o o � zizso� z� � Q�`-'� �otid�sd� � _ y � �mm Z go 3 � �o z� ��Y �.� � �t �o � - °� ° w oz° �'a ��x �cz allo3 N =�� � ' oNb�,�n 'a � a' i g�> Z o> °� 3 3 SQ N isn0 �?� uF w0 3= ° � z Q�m imm N��s �Nbd ��__ �Q... 0 - °� B o Z Z.� F w�� � �, m� Z� � � _ e a� �i'/ . - W O O O vi H vi O H> a O O - . 30 . m z y, r O J 3 K `n°( -z � U �. F' °�� °' io io so F� Foo3�^� N o="'Z F� ,.,�a� �� z� � x � u�'_ �1 �a. zo ..so m� . n' pF � -" -" -� O axx x� w � �a a pLLwa � � � a W m a � 3a z � � d w @ @ � �'^N�rN � o z�.,v_, z� z o0 oa � - LL � r w u w o� \ �� - U '�� oo - °f oE �E Z 0¢��"�s O z . OxO� �� urio �z �nw > im � o 'oow_Q (ivy�� �m = �6 w ya Q° - - -y Z ?O�i OZ Z y GO vsi= ODOU �1-~O '=E �=� � W s u > � � �i ° +G� ddJ�.. � . J , �mm p �� � ' ' w Hr .rp �' w°'lio U� �ai� � zOZ� � a ° a � � �= �ui � �a Nieti�. �� � se 3 9 QE> ��; J w� � - _ _ � w��'oz z w Oo �r z,� F-S i,V-��¢ Z p Q oE 3 3 i u u u � 7 r w u 3 v . . r�i�� �6 __ W W �m� 7 3� wZ w wz W . v „u ,,, q a c a;u Q �a � � w � _ c _ -.n �r d w d �c u V7 06 O ��¢ 02 SZO V W • � n. b n a � 3m C..2\ _ �� c p u v �° o _ �_ ` _- - -- m � ° � LL � w �c s< r s� d� '= w wz��d= v�i wp �Z a= ~�ao � ° � � of _- . - , i J a _ �n LL� v�60� � 6° _ _ " � 3ot x � o 0 i a -_-____""'.� + � � '�.a�� �.o-.--'"�. _' Z O Z �} #Z���?c W U m �� � �i d�°m� Z ° O w� � L Q Q ��Zryry� Z ; ZQ � r w Z`�^ } �I ��T� Z 3� O V � � � �za 9 � � � o � ° w �^a� o � Wt ;��� �� ° m ° N3��c Z J Z �o � _�9a IA � � �' °" C/'1 Y W O �'� ,., � Q Z „ a r N/ 0 00°0� � > Z� �= o -ada �a o 1�'}' O `° � > � � � � ~ YNZ> = U Z � N ' Q =EJaI�IIv i J V � ' W � Q Q Q � Z U w O � �I�O � U _ a A�` \�t? �^I U z � N o � � � Z QO°O F- O LLTII > ., � °AS ��P'� ol Q J � � i u I W " ���'�� s � In O Z o � M � � a = u u U 11l � `^ v `a_� YI LL d f + �°p � - �� �o o d� V � � � � � � i d / �P): 958 �-SSB/ p-R�R � iJ [SB 459 . / �0P . / LS9 _ ' ,�P ��� ,.� / ,,,�\ � ^E� �O / _ / // ,� _`��\ 09` / O / '/ / � � a3 . i �� `��, ss � �Nia��na / i��3' i � � ����� s��� �. �NUSixa � � � � ; �� � � a . � �O♦ � // ���.¢�G��,�02 �i �� `Re� :\ � � � o � � m � i P`� � � �� � /,� � � � _� � �. ,�_ —�--- � m m � � �l� � � �s,p !te e n�1oz) � � E<9 � � � L 'LU �ES.00..00N � -��-�_ ����� i / , �i `�� `�� I i/- .fi/ � '0"� i^' .�.2 .. � 'usi�.. j '�06��` tv3 vE31ipPyrry4_ 0�01 Y^m � / � 0� 90 �098--._� �8�97�v/u�lbC�- m`D ' �� � O . / .��E.. e e5q �6a v � � ���ey/�y5� � � 10� ��> � �P-�� P�, .� — _ ; �� �; � _ � ��a _0�h-��I v , .� �, � � - � ` + � , � a� � �e ��' �� � �� � --- 1�� �`P .�/� ' " ---- - ---- �� ='� � � � , _ ,� ; - o, �� �I \ pA¢�'R � x ��� �� _ �iw , �,�� - ` ` - , � °i�l' � 0�°m ^ � � m� m � m ,a� ',w 0 /�//'' \ m JI � �P-1 . - / 91 / i'��'� t l O �� . �b�h �bi � .�N '�00 53rJ�Nl � /I � ' fG� . � .�-Ff A�1 .// :.� m 'OQ%�; . I . � ro 0� . . /�--Lf W35v3 55321`J3 5 � . I ry b �J / � C� � Op 04 � � � � , i 0 �x ' �e"� I�65 � �, � - _�-�a���� X�� � . � � 65� ' m 0 2 , ¢_ � p - � / LL . O� e9 'i' I �.0 0 0� 0�y,,. 0 �' . r�"• I W - � � , . u " � . �' � .+ /� i '�� �_H66 � 9�a�h .� �� � O � '� Ax � ej I � '`i -• 3 ,�o� �^6 ~li �� ' �� i/ i . ��. , ro � ..i..,ee� -m' ,�r ���� � Q�- Q "� i , i . �� � �__, m L7��e�o � �e V �p � /����` I ik pr h I 60 � ��0.+�I . - . � � . . . II � S�-.- (� GV I 1 V r �'/:�� ,a . . � / I . . . �' / , 1 . �- II\ ♦ 5` w i I ^O / ^ ' `� ^ . !��� A I . � / . .. / �,� / �`` � ,, i - - o i gbq o� i y � . � i i o 6'8 [ / - } ¢� /� �` i i � `._.Ji I�o^ o��j o �� � ' �I �'' �// `�Py / �' � /�� /( / �� I j .... _' � .. � g�� w�m II � m� �J/ ro m/ 1 � �� � ��-R� ,f ,/„�,� °5 , ,,� '� ! 1� �> �w�o � J�`�Pi � tig6' �� �i ..� � �i � w m � w� "�� �� �� y!� _. �' ��� . m j',� 'i �� . . � ..:i� �n "�� � �o� :. s�� � �� �� �5 J � ' °' ��� ti i + 5 i �o o �- o A5 � m_ W � 1 '-�U� - _� � h � �� �� ,9 � " l� 1 o I J °- po� ;,�j� ,�� � j � e�'+ �' 1 � � � �� . �l� : ( � l / � / � � � � � � � '.� �, .� i � ' ./ �� o ���� -k . ' � �m o- �_ �� ' � a � .� a � X +�� i! o � . , `� , �„ �,�-'-m- _ `m � / � �: / , � � ronae - , i, � - �g .. ��a 4'��t, a \ � . / . , '``` 4 y . � I 3� � •__ `/ * , � �\ , �X I � II O�'j ' —.I� <!g ' 0��1 / I 0`\ �b"Itl " o/ � \ � _ I U\\ �� - . . , //,��I��, . .��S,OOo00N o ° � `a eci �c' � ,- i /E��9 � �� , I Q . � �LL . o� - ega �, �S� \ .�� � , / � "' ` i--o `�----' , � ; . m o -� i,2, p� j y�� �� � - i ... _ � _ � �� , -o�a ..i� /°` � �"� � � � x ' � � a 1 ��� � � Q� � � � , � � , � � ; — � � �, I �/I / , • ``` / , ��T� � ��.e / � / Q � � r � V � �� �� � � ' (� � �9a `� a6� ? �� y � . � _ __ - � j � _- , , ��� �� . ,T _. � I I a�� � � ;� � � ' �w . �' / _ � ��_ � Q � � z,� . . i ��� � I - -"" ' i o� '" `i J ./ ' l ��I Q i x� i�� oro � � w� �' � J �- �" °o� ° � / / �/ ° I - � _ -' " , �m � � o� �� � � �/ 's�� � ;' ' _� h �� i �� _ - I ��� � � ;> i - � �m m�`. / � � Q � � � i� � �� � / ___- �=�—qe- _ -- � 1� �n W �w � e:/ � / �� � � _t--'-' � � �I v� z c9e � ��' ��'� - (/') - w � �'/ W � '� �I � �� I . _' 9e9999 �� - '"-_-_ 1 w ' m / � ( I Z T I I�;„' �� / . I:I:m '- . . i O . �� _ ��r I / � `� � � �g I I � / � / �� o«'"j�� � � � H�nae i I_ � --- orti ��� - ; I / � � I� I _ � � - '� l� �kw O o !' -- I I V I � � � � / �M �� / m '{� � I � � _i- i � • o / � 8 � v' �� . I I �� " , l i'i � _ n w ` \� \ a. � z `- � -------- __ � a¢ee=aaa � �� A .. �a 2 \ � �, I w.�o? � i i -' _� _,_ ` .9/zt � a '� � � \\ I zt I � �a � I '-----'" " °.mo ` -_, b0 a r � / �3� --� _ ` �i�I � ��'�i - � .'�m 0� �° �a � .t` u" �- t w N� `"`-�� Q: .�e �� � ��� - ovo � � � '' o� ;� � . ae1�o ��� ' � � a a � \ Z �' o �; 'W W W � b0� � 4 �\ .. �je m � '/i� p 0 ,. � � o� � ( g o 0 8 r� � � > 0 f� ",�� . � i °� w o �_$ ��mh srv3aav� /%u�� / o� �\ ., � � P $omw �� . ��0� rv' � °� � v � � ��, � ts N> $h°m='�n�x"' i �/ / m� � i � � ' x , a - � \ °mz���= IrI . - � �� � � ` �. '�,� � � _ � � � � q ^ ' „� \ � � $ s9e . .1 �� n ` J7�0.00.005 -9B'Of � NO ��� � h / � . • � .��..\� �.`.` \ /id " � y / / � � � I4y � Q,Nq Wo\\ SF-�.fl' � � \ '_ __' �.'\` . �' e \2,.P . 5. 7 OV� �n��+� cd' � . . : . . V . ; -` �1 ` ` _ ' \ \ tW i o a , e a od � � m � I N � � � . '��`7'' �----��la, � � �� � --- a � o'" ? � �,� 0 m � s � � , � i, �o�-_ �_-s9a-� 6,. ���� '6 � °� � �\Ow�no �� — — / _ _` o \ __ g� �m � a � � =- ro ss - '-, ��� '�� u _---- � 2 0 �a — � � M„ES,OO.,OOS � �-- � � �� V �� _ , � � �� e I &�, ��� 6 0 �C a, . � p o� 4: �. �� �� ```i . 2 �/O/ � ___ i - q d��.,SE �� . � -',c� \ `� .� - _- ..� � � , �.l _ __9,�-- -_.__ -"_. -- -__ _- .--.-- -- '__.--._ �.___. ____. _- _'" . � _ . i . . � _�i ,° � ���'OgY_� __, , �..�.\. -�-� � � - -=T�� i o m I ot J - O d �� 92,. _ __' ` o �+ P .. o . . ..20 G 7� . � � �� a: �°' r�� . i �. � U � a i mm _ _ ��SoS2>D �� �� LP �r ----p`�� � � �- �� ��' � a �- tB. '°.J\ Ln .� °9 _� ? �� . mm �6 ' . . �9 I. d-� V O 1y. O . Qy \��� _ , I .9e — __ .— �a'� Y;�� a J � a� Q �m __ �� ���� ��\e Q U�� Ll� � L, i� , \J e e9a W Q 1 U �O! i��. ' . 0 w m m .. QQ ` �� ^ � 6 z ou o iQx u `�' 'o�� ` �� �� � � � m �o di a3 �zi i�z�z 3 z� o�� � °rn� � � � �w �, .��� � -�:.I :o � z v� ��' �03p� �� � _ \ ` 1\ `�2 � � � ��, .P .Q Zw O °o �zaG:LLow� o r ���� � � �0 � 1 �Q - u �� � y'e a o� � wN wZiwmr��� n u, c Q ac�s� � p a 6 ..\ � 4�y. . �/vl . n� . 1 �2 � ��� a� a F�vi a� °'�z�=r O� V V V Q N Z m \ \� �� �.�I�1 ``i I -�� N U v wUVi � \ � ��y � ' b w °'��i,rg�z i� a°c rd �� ¢a¢ �v�� o A � � � \ , b 3 a H >'�i����wdw�m°5 ii az ���n m � w ' s� �� ��� � � iow ��zo�F �� r� ���_ aa° o A:A � iw �� �� �� � - �� warv „ Z <-�a�zoaa ,��� _ -. , ___ �- � ,� i o �o � �a�,"Ow3� �- zt�z �w �i �� a � � I ca., oli Oz^ z 3 z��n�¢= �°a00 LLLLLL �roLL � 9e �\ `O B�f � Y 00 zz i r�^ ❑�� � - �� � /1� � �� 0 ea � �'W �� �:c �' , ��`� > 3 �' �a3 3�� og�o o�w dddd ���d ,� li � � � ' �s �� I�� �e m � L{,J �I om� b � J ,vi,�¢�O� O p � 0 0 - rnmon� LL LL r, �� -J \�i.a\ \ mi m .i _p-, i�m I w �uN iONxu�w�n V av~i w�w � �m w� �� . o °C < ewoM .. m �� `�j� c� � � i,� °� � � �.. � I � � rn < � o°�, � awx�>w'� �� . _ in dd� � � � Z �m o � z„' "'"'a ���z_r owa vi wm�� Q m,.,,., a° �,/f� N � � �,� . 1.� i �� z� � � � �zw Jdxroaazua Ja Z�z Q o W �cn,v o v v� ;oe , oN . tin ' I oZ Z p>Y_"'�� O F--� od� w d' am �n¢ � T\ .' � _ / y,b " � 1 0-> li ¢ sz-HO= ru iluuu u .n � Am . Y O � >>��aLL�a F>�'�z�z ��� K Q m`n° I=-z �L Z� ��� S9e 0�1�-} � 'a`� � � o.s� a E � ���noz�oz°zoZUwaZ3 Ja'a" a � n nw om ��. �. - - /o� . � Q � � m�o; � Zw l7 �owo?woz �yQ�oz o= Z "' �^ l7 �� !Y .�o� . ,i�\ ��sg.� � � zz� �a • O � = o�Z w �-s w zLL��-���a�QO��� ��i F am�a O a Z oW �s� / ���d° f s a�,a,':° xl��� , I^�I � i Z �a� w� � =��o=wo�wo� �oa z�3 � �zz� � rr� Z �� o � � . � w ° �, px Z i�iz�xzaxzzzNZw <�LL x ada� � ��� � Q �� � �.o � O tto � r,�H»r»r_00 �3 ��O w � d � N <d � ' , m o �� \ 9q�n I� - ��� 9 \ � di 1� Ql�m ' O . <a � 4 4 ` \ ' k 3 �.� � w ?_ � �i �i I � MH Z = �2 WO ��\ KI �V 9� - O r m w 2 j � c �++ Q � c�. . Q\ 5031 � I I� e z a oe x O - u 3 w � e�� � Y� � z J� w � � � � s : � � `� W ,U �o o°�� o°,- o=r °z S�z a oo=Q V� z o i ~ o F W m z z � , . � . veaJ°` ;I J o°o ----- �Y i °z o� O �h-� ¢ ¢ O � a z H Q �> � m a a � �o � zs ����- �. � �� i � `o �s = o __ �o ow � 'za � Naoz wo � LL � 3 G o aa �� y' � �.�� I • �LL = ' � °W °~z �°.� ��z = °�v~i= i o � a Q�;`�� o �e� �8� W �w� - o� - '^ d a a� i=gao� �� zi z u O p: � y9.,2$ . � � ; z x x' E o>� � �w a�ua o . 0 �..� _- _ fi5'il�J"� sse >�., �� o z P � � a � 2 `�� o am m� L � � �� ��o��� j�G <N o0�3 . eti� :s� l� 4 ` w; �'-- = up o 0 0° ziz �� co V V r °p V� °,�d�sd o' � -�/�� y � � ° °0 3roQw� ��i 3Q No= x �� �O'>i,.!'1 'N� Z po �� 3 3 30 .. OO?�'�� VwF- w� 3 3 � O E s (N- b� � e � � ._� � �F °.� o o ga Vl zZ6�N� LL =�0� m Z=mO iN Y f „� F b� a �"_ ':� o� . W o300 0 ~w~~ \� w�'� ` ° ° ° ��' " � �I �-- � �`, _ i o f o i o � 1-O O w=� N � p s�i ~� E° �� z� �n i � �oj�. �o . � �ya�. O ..___ � d� w < < � � � �r�� � o Zaw z� �LLw� o0 oa J z "' � F W w m Uw �� � �� I'a F Q�V i Ou' � �2' .m s N '^� oo - '� °�. °� �, oZOFOi O w� pxo� °z� ��i°a �a � `> `z m � p o i �- /tiyo oii = w y- a< - _ mZ z ��zr Z d H"�w oo Fo aF� zax � z � w.�`> a� a�$ . a - Z O zp m i J� �� � � r o�, d 0 oc 3 W r Hm .rZ } w F ou UZ Yh- � �� Zz � H � H � z W � �x Z � J y a 3�' 2 � Z Q � �o V O � K Q Z � Q Q N �N r J Q w�Q �b\. .,gf�. J WQ W - U W ���oQZ � 3^ wZZ`^ w a LL w Z W oa of 3 3 x U u u � S r,.,u 4b1bM, . . .. QQ., �3 ��; oHC Q �" �o - � �n o° p a o , rpQw z Z u v °'O z\ ~ --- W� Z � °o sa r dr >= d= w �?��a� v=i -� °ao� a= ~��o � ° . �:y • � n<� o p d o £ � � o . `a,- �� � � � � --- ----- o---- � _ .� � q�s� � _ - s�ooy�g�i�qnd sui�doH ��� � I -a 4§ � v.d'p°y a E & �� U yr, � �- = o�� _ � uoi�ippd wooassel� £lOZ ' �/^ F° E l •) � ! � > V ���` � 2 �� �i m � Wr � €Y :gz�m ¢ � o _ � � _ �ooy�s �Ge�uau�al� �IooaqnnopeaW N`dld 340�/�13�1 - --�� . _ _ -- - -- _�,-�� - � ; �ww z ,� _ —��i - � ❑ Z � N O J �il... - � � w ��~ � > � W � w Q O __ . J Q (n CA(A i,.. � w� w �o� ' � ' a �� �-' c�v co i �' �r- Q � r: ..--�� �_: ZO ��Q �_ - — �o� wQ° � ��� Q v�cn cn w i000 n � Q)N N Q M�V � I_ . � `-I ____ - -s�" __._ ' ___ _ .- _� � .__-J I � I i r' I M LL . Q N I �7y���--y i w � _�.�� �. � � � Q � ~ II �'! ^ ..;_ - - �- .___ _.F`°'I ^� �'•�. ,� __.1-,...-I-.--�__���-,- _,--�_._..:�.-♦ . . . i•u�` -_ __, _ . ' ,I .-.- ���r ♦����• �� � , � � , ' Y i - �����-.��"":r"''^\.("�,, ,m J � rr� .I.n � � � ^ Jl-: ;l ... ����� ;` ---ga.�r_ ......rem�1 __....rn-rs i _._ . � _ - _ _ -_S , , � .— -_ _-� . - .- -.. . .��-.� _ �� � . � . . - - — ' --i--i�.-_ - _.—�i�-,-.. � :.......�...� � � � l�� l . . _ _ _ - . � ♦ �_aL � • � • • I I � • �1� _-L. v�i -,, -i • � � - j N ...._.--.,,:_ . .. ... � i I � c Q N -'1 =�=r--��-� • • { • � I - � °r�' ��-` q f �`� � � .b•1 Q � ����,r � �=—_ - - ��.„ � a � �� ,_ �— '�, , I _ � ''�� '� , �i — '� � '; �,i _�==;, � � ��' � � ___,__� , , , � N o o � o ��— � o � ; o � � 11 � J �� � J �'�' O � Z O � Y Z � � � -d, .. �1 1 LL � O a l.L � � 0- cn x p � cq X � N . � � M LL (n � N � Cn . ' _ �'� W W � � W � � � W � C� J a � } Q J � � W � _ 'i r LL w — w Z i¢ � u� � w > w Z W LL `n � Q � W �' �' �' O M OH W �' d.' �' Cn N � -, . _ . , W N a a Q d Q N � (n d d Q d a O) � Cn - n iA I O � J (n W �! � � O � W (n W � = N � _.� �� I Q N J O J J Ur c�7 O Q ¢ � Q = 2 � p Q Q � Q = = I r � � w w w c� �- � � w w C? --_�� _ .,_I U U O � � d' J W U U � � � d' J W qq � Z � J U J Q CO = Z � J U J Q (.'C1 = � a � Q Z ¢ J Q J W U Z y W H H � � Q� � U Q Q � � � i� �IU O Q � O U J U �U O Q � O U J U � � Q O U m ¢ H ¢ ¢ C Q O U m ¢ F- ¢ ¢ ¢ �il� � � � r � � � u� v� �n I� � � � O I.L � O LL Q � � W � � W � � W � � W � � W � � W I I I � J I I � J 11 � . o � Y o � Y o � Y � `n Z o `� Z o � Z � � O a LL � p a � � p a N x O � � x O � � x O � I � � � W � M � W � M � W � W W � � m J d' � J � - Q Y Q LL O � m Q Y Q O }2' m Q `L Q LL O � � I- W W Z W C/) M O W w Z W lL M O W W Z LLJ (n M O LL,� W d' d' � o F- W d' Q' � N H W �' � � o F- � a d ¢ a Q N } � cn d n}. ¢ a Q o � cn a a ¢ a Q � � O F- J � J M � � Q F- W N J M = � _ � w � J pp = � � m N J J U C� O Q tn ¢ w 2 C7 p a � Q � w 2 � p Q � Q � w 2 N J r � � � � w w �? > r= � w o w W c� � F � w � w = c� Q U U O � � � J W U U O � J � J W U U � � � d' J W Q I U Z � J U J Q m S Z � J U J Q 00 2 Z � J U J Q CO = • Q �a � ¢ z J Q � Q Na � ¢ z J Q � Q �,.>a � Q z J Q � Q W � I � �IU Z V Q ¢ � p � ¢� rn U Q ¢ � O � �U z U W Q = � _ � �U O Q � � H � � uJ U Z cn W � � � H �n F F- � � � O U J U �U O Q � Q U J U �U O Q � O U J U w � Q QO U m Q H Q ¢ Q QO U m Q H Q Q Q QO U m ¢ H Q Q Q J � I � i ,� �� � �€�.g � _ � a = __ S�OOI��s`�I�qCld SUI�aOH wooyewCUg��a�ssauu r ! I .�Y ,' __ }6 � ��9� � ° � 8588'£LL'LL9 J I I I ., �= q� a � i � ' � �� ���� " ° , 9ZL9S NW'mqne�oyg � � , ' , � _ � ��� E ..,, Nno�eBPVH LZSb � � Q I �, I �� '1;, i '. `$��'� � � UOI�Ipp� 1.L.7OO�ISSGI� VYOZ � 6upaau��3�Upa��UeFINPueapg w (n � ', . ��i , � � a x�� _ ' z ;; m T! - �, . � ��� L� . �8��� K c°� n` o S � � I � � , � � `� � ° Y ° �oou�s �Ge�uau�al� �ooaqnnopeaW �, ���d 'Buuaaui6u3�dS ° :. a d :a � E _ � � > _ � � � �I � � II � - ''� � ;?- II �� _ ' / - � . �� �; i w - v`� d1sl /, s J � - - oti a �o � 2 ji /� O 4 Z - W b5 O �i�� M NN���� �� .✓ � . . _ - / `�\ _Fa / � . . � . / z �\\ ' .... . . / � _ 6 ` ``\ �j � „^�� I,I ti.. \J•� . �,-�� / , �g /i -�� `\ ------- -- .' . � / '�`�•✓ �, . .�/� � /�' / _ �/ �;, (/ ,'. ` � �'. / / / �854 � � ya/ . ✓��V �� /� '/ // /irc�� / ��I� / yE�_ ! I1��' � � I �a11U �Npl��l�l� .. � ��:��( S � �� �s4- �i% / .�, 1 �,.� /I �„n y ry�n g R _ � �e �i i�i.� �, /� � � , / � � � l � l t� i ,/� , 1 / � � v�* �� . , � ib / / .. �` l � ! � �i�aS i _� � j� ;�� � i i � �' � � I 1 �i � � ,1j,��i,,: . . -. � _j � / � � _e��/ � � ,�: � �/ f�oi �� � t—i � `�" � /°?�" � � / �// . / �� �.'tl66� �W,....I l��m^ ,: (u / � '��/� / � � � !`� lfj` � ,I w .._Ci�9� tl�� (_"�� �� P� � .���� .,��� y��1..� � _.._ _ /� l -/ �T ��'C�"' �_ �a :�^' �'^�� t - i�ii�i.� C ,�� i (� s � <m ` �.,e�e k �� � ,iif // � S� /'g � R, +� f,f,�"} ,�'m"�/ //� / ��i � }�o ! /� ��`�e W_� 6b �.;� � T- . ' �: .. �" . iiii,. v.���'��.� .. / �, /([[y�� J t�'/ �� �.�� Q.. ��� .�� �i;�: �� :7 i k,i " - _. -- m I � yY'/ J . ' .Y'/ � X }_e �� .v{8 i ( ' ;,+ t rl/// �//l�// /n. i , z r J 'I � '' .C/ / /�7`" �i C� �tl',H' � � # iY �,'� � -j e"� �, '� �i � r .a� i/i� , �.' ' � 1 es5� _�C 5��.. � : .. -sia,� i% �`i��.Y`�' .. � . � '...1 / �� }� / - i� /l . � -i ,' .�' � � ii- . . �y.1`.� / �. }}Y - r � %ii..��� � �,` ` _"�.J �/ ,.u�°� }�` ,��/ _� !r�.,.�}� �_` I f � . � / �'��. / �.c L} ..._.,.'" � � /Lh/ ,w!n� ���ry� S ��I � ��,wa�{'' �/i �''� ,S /./� t 9 7 � � � ZY.�� // d�,/' / IG�`�`�� � a . p \ � n \( ... �✓ � L � 1�Y ,�.. ��A � �.y _ "- � S�� � y".'' � �i � �� \ � �� . i � , , '�.� / -- � _ ", . - :: _�.� - -' ,�o'" ... � _. l .:.LS-'_.� . _ � � �. , _� }� 1 I .. � �,aa�-.aw�-� c=� ° / — ��� `�' }� � � ��. --�� m �e- � ��-ias---' � � " � . C — -'��n /� 1 �� � / /, � '� � .��- � � )/�� � � �I � .� / 3 s, .. � � � a � � / �--' 'f� - �' . . �: _ i �\�\��� � �� / i-/q ,�'����3"�� N'� -�„��ae��� I+- / . ;��.� '��\ i� W �-�l Y:'�,Y�,/�5��-����1��� t� �_ ��s«��mc�mft ., f / :� \, 1 /� � J '�, �s.nnos:-ie�xrnie ' � � i•. i; tfm � §V � ,� /•/ � �i�'I �1 � � m � � �{7,�o g � rd� ,° .� // ti ��11\ t1 i � �� 1� � '.� '`�� •�t� c� �r �w . �� �W � j % � � � ' �1\ � �i' / �a -a __ � c _ 4i u; � � ��j �1 � + 1` : ��.�'I��\11'�I /!� / �/ ��'�Se�� `-�'1�.—��°vsve-��`� �W w R `W� / �i.� � ��V 1�1 �' � ��- � ����� � A��W�se Q-- � ,- 1 I (' ,`; �s��� 5 - �`�''� - � �.�; I�� I I�I, d � �� � �Rm���t��m«���n��.�R��Rm� � � �.� i : �I 111�f� � � � ��. `ti r�..` � � _ ' � 1 I I 1 '1 � � ` �.� �1r �, ,�, /;. . ��'i+� i i'���s � � � i "r '��- �-r _ �� �,�.. . ����ii n ti� i i m ,ri� �`� � �, �� � ��E�� �`` ��� � � i��t �i �i i s� ? �m , ' �, � ��II���'�I��� yl � � rl;lf �a`�i���v;>��vil��u,»vv.v � �� � `� �� �Y,�.� � r T E ;��'I �I(t� �� ��R� � �� ��ll t �!� 7 1 ��. � � � . I �,� �� � � 1 ..9g� -,. � � ' , - � ��� � �»� � �»iv���i�v' I m � `It \ � ��'. . � q� \ � + ' r ar �� � +-� \. � �,,: / ���� � l�y,x . ��*,.� �1`���,.. ` ��� v Y.,..`�'�a.� l�a i ��r._,�_� 3iei-'�^�.;�.�. (/ �r i � ...�e . , , . � . . \ '_ . ,�.�' -w.:�-.,-.�.,.-."'.W�'/�,..:�. . .�-;.... :� ,�,;i�.�K� � ���������'`��tgt�1D'°►.. � / '.w �( � � �y � ,ti I - _-�QF�$. \y � F�X� 4� \ �n _� j � �� �___ . ,... _ f' SR 'Lh :.} �x :/ � �e? . .�O \ �� 5..� /,ti l.�Go� \ � �= ` r � m i a r, � �t; �� :��.y .'iz. � \ .�� . \� � ��� �� # �i ` Ff i 1 �{6em 53 ,..-. `� � a� ...• � y�� ' .w m ,., �' ��' _ -_.--. . ` � "\ ' �.�_ _ . - ` ___ __ - . _- _-_..__ -__ _ ._- -� ' -�� \ � � � - "' _ ��.c z _ _ha ----- w a ��-q; -� �.. � � �� - i � � _ l s . � � "�dd� '� r m - �'�. � �� �y� � :'''3+ � �` i d3�;.��i'"�='�° �� }� �„� `\ `� ill � �. ^ U _ ..i� �$ sg� :_ �o'.z iz ��� , cd .` � � � ,�- �wa ��% � � _ , \ � g . 4 � � __ . � t' ;� ��� � � � a, °N� � �,7» �, � t��, �YG a � •� ��, 1l�` mt 1b � ��m� _. ����.. s1'S ��`` I � - ,.,c ` i� �:a>� ;� '" . --- 1, �� �. �� ess,� ��`�� _ � `;`�" ` �`� h.�'�� �. �'' �� . . ��'^ � V'�i ��V� � � . , �� � �� �"l.,\�� �. �•bk`t� - -���� ��, } ° - ,��`;< � �'�,� s ��� '�,:, �x�� � H�= ��,� ' .�� ,��'�� � ``\ ��� � y Y�� ���y \@:, ���% � \ `h ����2 ��������. � ��� �� � �/�� m�z � .�_ ���_��. �y��}�' �a� . z�� �(K]��'��Ib�t� \ ' � Np � u� , �� � a �'�b ' tab�u M u�\ � S�' lD�'S vS c z x ��.2��\\ i __ _ ;� . _ ]' _1___ ��....._.,.. '� .. T - - __-- ---- , I ,� �� �E S = � a � sl����s��Iqnd$u��d�H , wao��ewt��aa�savu � �i 'I �e � �� � ��°� _ � , sass��z-a4s _ N �� $ � � sz�ssN�v'�,����s 1- Z ' 0 I 6 � B� � �E t- E � I V�o^J eBp46 1Z56 J a � �I �n� � '� _���� _ = uoi�ippb' u�ooassel� �lOZ � B� �� � � � a ��a � � i � °� w f 3 u� ��a euv a as ( , � "�xa� = m ° ` I ', V . t g D�N p � o o � � �ooy�S �Ge�uau�a13 �ooaqnnopeaW j ���d'Buuaaui6u��`dS o ___: _ - -- - III -- �� F z ;Z !I _ _ - �� _ � _ _- �, _ _ n w z Q �O¢ ¢�m mmo -_ I , 2 W�n X�Q -_� _viv�F - _ _ �. �f a- - - o�a ��-� u�+t� r o3 �ZO� w3oF = aa .. I Q �',.. m o3z_ -- _ � a3u' Z - p 3'a _ W 3 _ __ ��� J a � Z F5a O � -- - >�o z "£ � - �� - o �Q�`� _ - ° I ' � �3� _ - F- _�d ? � -� �� �_� g � 1 � w s� ooa - wa���w�a w --���.� - � i � w m � o o � , � o ��.. w � O�G �1S'�S' � � J W oo�� � rt y" i _ o � z � b�' � �� � P � 1 O Jb� M���0 .: -.�..' . �� ,.�__!__ � � �� �a, �: `. ',, ; , , ,' 1� � .' ,, ' � . ' �(. � � /� � �� �� � � I � � I i �� � �� I ;? i ��_ 4� �� �.' ;� � � �l � 1 �l I t r � -- � � , � � i _��-� � �� � � i � t �� � � i � � � � � c� i � � _ � � � � � h�` 5' i �j � 1� �N�–�— � � �;� r v7i -� z-— � � 4� _gC� I �2j_� -, k, � �X� �� � � r �cv � �� 6 5�_� � �� oi Q � �L ' ' � � r� Qi \- ,� �cv 9 't' �9 �'� �,1�'���� � I ,�t� � �{ , � '/ - � , 66"'� �"_--� ` ;,* � \ i �� _ ,-, �� ``�� �� 8 , � \I � . �����~ I �,`� � � ;�� ' i� � �,_�,, � �w i ����o �b �'��1�, � ���� �� N d� W � ��. --/�'- ; -- j� + c�a w �1 � _ `o�z m� � � ��'��'`�W�' ���',��I " �i r � � - , ��-.' I �— i Jf Fr �.,_�� � t---___-�6 ''' --�� � � �� rl�r`Sb � . _rn���� i , � i z� r� ' � � �� w �� � � �,�,. � �, , t � -- � � � � ` , . ..� � V � � i i������_ �fi��� i -- �Q � o=� � � ._-65��- � ��\�� g ,-�• ,'" i r� , w � Q m ii ` ` --- � � ��; � � -- � � X �� '�� '� II , �( � a i� z ___-�- w \, `t •' O cc i'' �--} � � x�� t t �' I . .. . C.� � y L�' _ d.8 �,Ci�6 ;�• :Q� � � � G a I I i � , Z � (Y ! O ,j� li� � c�� tf� _ ___ . } X _�— Y / Q � � � ` � � / II O' Orn c� �p� , � y 'i I / LY i1. � � � 1 � > Q N J CO Z J� �� i S Z � i �r i �°,-- ��// '�/ -- I-����� �� -- a a�0 .�., '���w �`� �� � ���� ��, ��- � �� Q � (r � �- � �-- �'> ---- Ca`�' o -- - `brO� � , --`' �/ `; > c~n W �� m Q N '� �� t� - �, � j; � � � � � � ' � -; � �_� ww im = r�yau, �,,�,� . 5 ,, � U� i ��J� _� 2 . �w C'� �. , �. c�z , � � � r / ----- - - , __._! l� l � / Z�' � .� i� _ � L � i; � ' Z �� � .�1� -- � ��� -��- �� �� � - I�- �� � _ � ,� � �� � . i / � / !� (n i � � 5 , � �� � � � � � � x � �'" L � I � ,r �� t : i - - _ . l.�� � _ � � _ �� � - �! ' � :,. ,.. l,. . � f- i , I `� ->--+-i - � ' .. . � _ � � ;� ---._ -� I f-� ' - �,�i���/ �-;--- " S� � �� LL' i .. � - m .. ._�r... - - � � � - ' . . .. �����_ � . � ��� J( � , ( z :� . C�1 , _ ._._..____ _..� I '_' ., � n o _ LL� �' ' r, �/ "x) ..._ - �� � — � � I (1 � �s\ . �„ �' "� .u' - ' I �,� ��./ � h � 1 � �J �' u�' �J ( 1 U�, � �✓�r l ___ ��o o I. ,r . � '�� / � � � / Q I � , a t cQ ' _ U) _ . : � � - ,.� � ' Ce� � � I �� x � ����- ---- ---- -----�... G � ��-����/�F ____ / --.__ i � II �� �_--� ' 1 i -- _ _- . -- — �� - ' Q s- ,/L , tr_ w, z ' U ,// � ... ..�' -. .----- U)CC � ��..�._. � � � : .. /-_`\ ;��� ��. a . ,� .�/ �/' � CJ � 1 . f � � o �'a . '= ,., � t/ ,;; .-'� f ��'. .� 1� � 1 � �' �i ..I , i - ��l ; ._......__. �,. , � , � �._. _ ....._ ; nw ... ` . r " _��yA- w 1 . � ��� �� ...----- �r�� ! . 1\ .. .: .�:��`` /r� I �(! � >> , ,„ _ , m � �� � - A , �' �� � �� 0 , ., . l i I P i � _.__ - , �- --��' �E�� , - � � � � � � 'i� . o � - J . m _ - , ��� ��� � , ,- - - -� � � ,� �/I , . � <: � - r _ � '� � �� _.. ... �'.-. .. r/I G,� \�,;; � / .... � -F � � J _ +� /�.. il �\ .. \ ��` ������ ;�\� ¢3 �i ` ' /.I { =.' � i _ � . _ / /,/� � \ ���� � . .�' ._ I . � . . . �\ _ , _ ���� 1� � / � ,� I� '-1 �-."-'-" � +�f • __ � iin �a� / � . _ �� �_.�i Y— � 't � ��'���� �� '/ �^ �� I �_ � �— � � � t i E � �- '1� �^�_--;��'��' ` ��� � I � �` `` �� /- , � � � �� � l__--I j � � �����/� �� � � _"% � \ �� � I � '--'-- -, � � � � j 4� ' _ � � � % �� j I �f / �r ..tG � � � `�- -1_ - �`II � s � I �,> �=;;_ - ��, � _.;� ��� _ - , . �, , _ "_ _� - `�il f f� / / -- ' r _ ; �t(,(� t� � :�-�� � � n ; ll � � )c� �� �� � � � �_ � ,i in i,, � / l ' � � '�� (XJ� , � � I� � � : ��� �����_ '`;a r �� i� � I � ' ,_ It �� � ' � = � � ' � } ��� \ �Y�.',� � c� , / t _.. �� � ;��/ ; � - �� ... �-'-�'-� . /.��� � ��/ � , °- ,�; _,����.�.. � :. i `r- �1�.. . , ,� , ,`� �I , �� �_ . � , �_ , t' , � `---.._� _\,�. . • -�. ;.., ., a� �t, - ti, -- _ , . . .-- �i i. .� ...�t.:. . . . . . IA'. � . _..._- .. .. o m U U -_ _-... __ .. �� � �Er� °g o � a � s�ooy�g�i�qnd sui�doH II wooyewtH��a�ssauu ��\ ' ;�° �� ,� '4 ��E� $ d Ili i 6588'£LZ'Z49 �� ) �, � 0 9Z15S NW'Melne�o4S w Z • � I i ��o ,s � a�s� � '�� yno�eBPYB ILSb � Q I .���.. '1° 4-� $9€�� � g uoi�i p p y �uooasse l� E L O Z Buµaeu�u3�AqBd�liaFilVDueayS � � I I. W� � r° ����� � _ � m o � ' v �� a�g�o � � � s� $ �oou�s �e�uau�al� �iooaqnnopeaW �„d ����aa��6���es : � ., a � x : � _ ° ° � L s .. -"a�� �' � a oo � � i -- --- --- -- -- — — >� a �_ - __ _ - - d�� 03, � 3w- - � �rc � � �ow - J I �� - s W � a a � _ - � a . ; o�F Q F I _�s� � � I ; ; � _ -a o aa I '�` x � � �'_ - ` �n - `n - � m 3 w � �,�°„� �i w o I c �. K I � _ i �� � V O w � a I �'d�o� p3G�° Z � I Za i _ ��~O J J - ��� II � a ^ -_ ja _ - _- 3 -- LL�? j N � _ ? - _- III i I w ' g 3� ° - m _ a�p � �o \� ��ts� J 3 � _ �n ° - 3� � �; a J z ' - z r � _ � 5' ° r 3 � Oo a3J � � J � O`l" �jy _ o £ _ _ � LL ?3 _ _w �°- � _ � �3n S� a - w �O J �, i � u�n -,. tt V N ~ C� _ _ C� _ w _ _£a LL �5�' Z tt�z � z _ F � - - _ �� _ _ o�� � oi _ � _ � r � r u m b�' � ° Z �. .x . v�� ��� O I I � � II I � 'u a _ _ - _ � �3� � p � M 61 !1 ,. ; �J OP N C � I I I w � �s ° ,r . _ ,� z�o `� s �LLF�� `� � O I I �� b_ M���5 x a � � � � � � . _ . � s � � �� ❑ ,,,m�,� w � �' � � I � � � � r ,� � -_�- / � � ...., - - � �O / �' I � � 1 ! � � _.J�,� � / I 7� ', � '� � �� �� ��� � � �` l t ��.�i � � �� j"1 � �� �� � i� ' � � i � � � i�� r � i �- � � � / I r I � � � I i I ` ! � I � ` � � � / C� / / i i 1 I � �/ 1 ! �,�65�� ` -�'�5 , l �_--1�� �/--13 �N � ' ' � �'_. � __�x�• � j�� � �_� �� �� �'g � \ �'�--�� �� °j �p�1'� �`L�� '�, � l � ,�`1 �i I � �� �� / � `�6�' - � -��7/ � �� �'� ���\ I �'����/� � /� �� - -- _ I I � � � {�; � � Q � / � � r � -- 1 � Q 4� � � � !1� W�j �I 4 � Lill�3 � . ���"1� � .., A� ��U h S CO I�,. , � � C�W �� � CJ i ��1 ' � � � � I� `� «7 ^ ` ` - a� � -�� �� � � � � � - ---A �.� �_ m �ti� � �-y ti� � 4^�Wry�4 J �� PJ�;i ---- � � 1 _ . � �..-` �-� �Ej� � �/ J j i � � o �. ' -t� j z I I _.. —� ._. ----I � � �� ��� � A _ .._ � � � tY�� � � �� �� i ,,� i� �;T�N Q . t I— �� �� � cJ � � � '� � ��" x . :.- �L-.. � � `� f li,���� �,�� r . � � � � � • . � t .:�� —___ ----.—. � .. :/ � m � -_� �_���_� ���3���,�����:�. � � ``��y�-'� I � , a �� � -�6S � ,.A��� � � ,n F y . �.�`_ {�7 / X !i a � � iI�' '�•: � ,� I � �� � z �-�-t' �� � \_ ��� �-+ ���'����q ' �`e�..� � i C��"`� G]. ,4 cK) ' � F . �'�,� .� � � I _� � � , � ;,x� . � � /� O --�' - �6'b� � � �L�7 J c4 �� �t�_ C� �� � ��I � � ��-� � O . L� ���� � �� � � i __ 4 i_ i Y �� II O��. O 6� C� � �� � � i � � A � � � �> �c�t �co Z � ;\J � � 3- I Q-� -� � -- � / - '� � . �w �� ti cY C� . � . 1,. i � � -��'6 � �7'>'��� A��W � 1-] -) �,�`� `/ 2 I > ��e�' o �6k ----' o ��" � �> �� m ; Z� � # r c� IJ w 't� � '� cn l�a65 / I z :�(�� �,� �`.' c� �' , , �� —�7 � � ��� - �� , � � f c,� � O � �� ` '., � ' ; � /i � ' � �, � � i � �� �� . . . �. -� � � . .� � ��J � / � � � -- 1 � � �If} � �� �' , m . w _ _ � � F- i � � .. od � . � , / _� CC7 -- - o ... a r- 3 a..r� � �� � ' O i ,-_ -" ' �;. N - - r- i. ' I � � lt:.� _ - � i � r- / � ;j� ,'' � I � - /"'� �� i - = W � � d ° ` �. . i�i � rto _ �F��% —Z�-} j I � ���,\ c, j � � � �'V � o0 � � G �Y � I I ! o-„ s ��� � z � II ..._s.=._� 1 c� U -- W � � �'f ���. I _ . � . Q __ - �� � w �� � �1 - ��� - - - -- - � � �.� � l � <n Q� � --� i L I I ---� I 1 � ���♦�� � _ — _ _ _-- — _ � � i l j �� '�� ;, > �� �� - ��`� � �� , � � � � � - � rc � ���.� � ;'i '/ � � / ----- Ct�� __ ,.�.!_� � , �♦ �,, � � �� �;; -. � "� a �ti � � r I r � � �� ���'�� �� � � „ i � 1 �` ` .� � ., �, - ;� �, �+i ..----J � '��. � � .. r- _�� 8�4 r' + , ,� '� I ' �' � �� � ��. . N I ` _ � ' '� r � . a � � � � � � � � �� , �� I 0 ..��, LL , ��" � i �� �: � , �� � - l� r5 ,'i � - - - -� �„. -- -- � � _ ,� _.. _�-, �" � _ I �, , �� ����i � ,� \ � . �. , �. . � � �-------- /i LL �' - �� � � � ��s � � , �_ __�_� �.� �Z�H . . . �e 9 ,:��f� � .¢a � !d ,6��� �� ' � �� � - y � `(., / � � \ � �.wr.��' a� �% ,e � / , � / f.8 // � - - ��/ g ,� f - � ----- _ _ � 1iTi 4 8� o� I � �� �`�1� � l ''i���� I h� �a� / a � � , � � -. z � _ , r o ,�F � • - /' � ' � *' `n �� ° � � ���� Jl°<a r ���(. --� - I i \``' �, ,�J, i< 1/ � � � �� :�1� �� - � i , � �l � il i i � 1 �o `— 1 �'f�, \,rJ `;: � - � ,>,� ,�i � �� ,r-� r II �n r ., ` _ . � o_ � � ����/ �� _��` - � � � ,� c,i , ;//� r' ,. �� ��-u�) QN- .. � , a /� `� �t� � n �-¢ � / �, ( z � _�l I t�— �co ��.A\\\\V`.A���°��� -r,� � �`-� �� � � II � ,, ��.` i m �� � � �� �, �� ,r�� � � � � -_ � �-w ��� ��� ;w• � �` , � � - _�� � � �' . � �� ��� ��� � - �`' �.��'-�--� .��� -� / ` rr � f� �` ����'' '��v 99fS ' / � r ����������C� . ` 11�L��\,' � !(U � .,t fI =�r. �� r'� r`% � � �� � � �- ' � • � \,y'' f,� �7 '��� < r 1 � : \I � � (1 r I � � � p � �i�:1 \y, � �_._ W � c�� - i / <.:�'l ,� Jj ,y ' ... I l�, �_ � II ,� ., �">� ��.� �.� h U. "C =' u � I� _ >,� � � � -��� /,% , , -. � I�,�r > � ; ;,`��? �, / �f w � - ,.i� V � �'� , i � r-� . � �� � ���.� � _ � ` = s�ooy�g�i�qnd sui�doH :�� o � woa•�ewfi��a�ssauu — � }� $ �g�9 � ` s5as-c�z-z�e J f � Q a' � o� .. 0 9ZL5S NW'M6�nB�04S Q w '�z �; ., �E q� � u�wa eG649 IZSV � w � � � � = uoi�ipPb' u�ooassel� E GOZ � �3 � ���w,eP �S w = � =a. �� .� � �,� ,c e B ��o W' �a��� 4 > >. � : ����� E � � � � � �ooy�S �Ge�uau�a13 �ooaqnnopeaW ���d '6upaaul6u3�b'S ° � V _ � o � � �QF � � ;w - a�o =Qa a�� a� �t aa m -N� _ � o =�a= � __ _ T N = �o- - a � o = o < n ��, � � � _td - � z _ � ., _ .�.�. �� � vtiev�ca�.zi Z � „� � 3 ` � H U ��� � 5' N � Q a�'w Q � m vwH a Y� (� - W � J� Q � z O r �Q � -' � s o U � . . Q � w w �h��- U �,i Z 1 �7 � a �' ` m . � Z �o z s�d,a 3.�;__s. I O a v � O - _ - - , . � W Q w _ _ �� � pQ Q No�3 - - °� ocva:a o� U - } __ ` °z � � u�a - «_ � ���� �A°�. W� �s ��� �� �� U CJ ���� Z Q v � 4� bl <`I . �`� � . O Q - � � 4� a� ,. � � -� � � �< �� �� ',��',-_', m� - _ � fr . �� � a7 ���_ - � �- - - - _ ¢�� � i� �i . .. �; �. _ = 8 ii�i z < ,� "� � � o ��, � �g �i i�i F �---� ;� ,a 3 ; a w� 'I I�I I > ;� U U � I�- < r� _ � � - .o _ W� � I I II�I ` o V-� j �F � II� � N� �.� JH g� I�.I w �� � _ ' _ _ _ - T� �Z � � . � �� �� € Y �I o �s . �/� �6 ;� � � � �=� �LLo-; �� � � ;;��'�� ° ���� �> _ r . � , � � �� ��\ oa� '� Q� ��� � . �j��� >� � • ��� w= _ �f 3� T , - , i _ � \ . < � - � � - - a y a ;� _ ���i�� a �� `� i _ n; z F�� - ', ° _ � 3 gg �'�, W� " � , _ o �o0 4 - _ _ . a 4,°0 9°0 � "_, _ R a8o�°o�b°o�b°° m �K � p - � � , o$oogo�bg�o�b �_ _ 3 � � o $o $o a w � - > - w ° � � _ �� o0 0 0 0 � �° m ; 3 � ,'� w ooga�bga�b$o� _ � 00 oago w a z o$o��o�g�oo o� � o d LL LL �; � w o $g�g �z \ ,_ ° � � - � � 0 ¢,ogago �Z �3 �; _ � \ 8o`bp�7 oogao - - /i� > - aORoQ o0 Q� �//� ; } o� � " ��\�' - �' 0 o Q U w ?� \���\% � Q \o �o � � ;� //\\/ - � O �'a d''�y � � „ W� � >� a� �.{ %�tHiw a � �j� r �Z F 3£ �� II�.V /i�/i�Bl F� U �`� W D�d.(. � I ��\�j LL �� � I �j x U I �����H��°a � �F3 o � ��. ��\�\U o£ �� �W \ - �� r�d \��\ \��� � ;4� .9 ..0-.f /�� % _ 3 NN 3m FN �� 3 i. _ _ _ --- � -- 6 a3 a �� � �� s�ooy�s�i�qnd sui�doH � , �Of � �� b ��E� � N �1 � U � < �* � 8�.—..5 .. � O ��� ��, �� � `- �� � ����� � � uoi�ippb' u�ooassel� £lOZ ' � �a � Q � � � W� , �g��` � = m = �ooy�S �,e�uau,al� �ooaqMOpeaW Nd�d �oo�� Ls��� � �� $ ��s g � � s =���y � � o � -- - _�__ _ _ , _� � a s � � d 'I. a � � �----� ~ o .__ =�_:�... .:- � �I----__:. ,�. / - _ Z 0 � + �� � -�- — � � I � � , J i I % � I W Z W ti U' `� Z a I�I�I I � �� _- '� � � °o �V �' � J �_- - I LL � ___— ---_ _-- -- _ ___ __ _� / � �I / � '� % �/ % / , /, i; ; � �' j m m � %+ -- ____-- - - -___ . - i — - - — __ _%% �1% V a i� 7 �i � + H � _"__..__--"_ _"__'_"_._'_ ... ... -__. ._ . ___. -"__'_--- . ___. ..._._ ' J ` �, _� -- .. . �, - - - - - - — � � — -_ _ __ � , � Z ,� Z � � �° � m m � a° ' o �v�i 3 � �"' � F w - w rn N ?U Z Q / Y U / Y a � �—— _ � � i � � r � � % I � i I � I � r L-- � � I � Q �- � a � i /' /' � ��__ � i — / O I I LJL � i � /' �'.o I � � � �� �w _ :j � �� g s�ooy�s�gqnd sui�tloH i I k� �� � �°°�5� � � �I I O �; � ` 4. �do�� � E uoi�ippb' u�ooassel� �IOZ Q �� � g� �a�$� � o = & � � � �ooy�s �(ae�uau�al� �ooaqnnopeaW Nb'ld 2i001� aN0�3S - --� � � � �_�. _ 0� i �_. ��-� -: �-.-: = =�_� � ' � ,o � ..�,.,�.. Z 0 � I � -'� o � n � a � o � � �� , � � i � 0 � � o LL 0 Z N 0 0 �I / w �a'�� � i N W H � Z J � W Z W C� Q J � � � 0 J L.L � �.-1��� ��,�. Planning Department 763-593-8095/763-593-8109(fax) Date: August 7, 2013 To: Planning Commission From: Jae Hogeboom, City Planner Subject: Informa) Public Hearing- Minor Subdivision of Property at PID# 180292442p033 (Hanson Wood Shores)—George Wessin -Applicant Summary of Request George Wessin is proposing to subdivide a vacant parcel (PID# 1802924420033) that is located at the southerly intersection of Noble Drive and Major Drive into three separate lots. City Code requires that each new lot meet the required 10,000 square foot minimum lot size standard set forth by the Zoning Code. The developer has submitted a site plan that demonstrates that each of the three newly configured lots would exceed minimum lot size requirements. For this proposal,the lot area measurements are: • Lot 1—50,150 sq. ft. above OHW • lot 2—38,600 sq. ft. above OHW • Lot 3—38,078 sq. ft. above OHW City Cade also requires that at least 80 feet of width exists at the front setback line of any newly established interior lot. Lot 1 would meet this requirement; however, Lots 2 and 3 would not. The developer is requesting a variance from the Subdivision Code to allow for lots 2 and 3 to be served by an outlot that would connect to Noble Qrive. However, staff believes that a more appropriate development pattern could serve this site as well as adjacent vacant parcels. Therefore, staff does not support the variance. Without a variance, this lot could be divided into two separate parcels. Qualification as a Minor Subdivision The proposed three lot subdivision qualifies as a minor subdivision because the subject properties are part of a recorded plat. In addition, this proposed subdivision will produce three lots and will not create a need for public improvements, such as street construction. The applicant has submitted the required information to the City that allows for the subdivision to be evaluated as a minor subdivision. Staff Review of Minor Subdivision City Engineer Jeff Oliver, PE, and Public Works Specialist Eric Eckman have submitted a memorandum dated August 7, 2013 regarding recommendations from the Public Works Department concerning this request. A copy of the Public Works Department memorandum is attached to this report. Qualification Governing Approval as a Minor Subdivision According to Section 12.50 of the City's Subdivision Regulations,the following are the regulations governing approval of minor subdivisions with staff comment related to this request: 1. Minor subdivisions shall be denied if the proposed lots do not meet the requirements of the appropriate zoning district. The three proposed lots do not meet the requirements set forth by the R1 Single Family Residential Zoning District. 2. A minor subdivision may be denied if the City Engineer determines that the lots are not buildable. The City Engineer has not determined that the proposed lots are buildable. 3. A minor subdivision may be denied if there are no sewer and water connections available or if it is determined by the City Engineer that an undue strain will be placed on City utility systems by the addition of the new lots. Utility connections are available in this area. 4. Approval of the minar subdivision may require the granting of certain easements to the City. The final plat must show all necessary easements as required by the City Engineer and City ordinances. 5. If public agencies other than the City have jurisdiction of the streets adjacent to the minor subdivision,the agencies will be given the opportunities to comment. The Department of Natural Resources, which has jurisdictional authority over Sweeney Lake, has been given the opportunity to comment on this proposal. The DNR has not yet made contact with the City. 6. The City may ask for review of title if required by the City Attorney regarding the dedication of certain easements. The City Attorney will determine if such a title review is necessary prior to approval of the final plat. 7. The minor subdivision may be subject to park dedication requirements. In this case, a park dedication fee of$13,200 will need to be paid prior to final plat approval. Recommended Action Staff recommends that the Planning Commission provide a recommendation to deny the Minor Subdivision proposal for Hanson Wood Shores, finding that the proposal does not meets criteria established in City Code Section 12.50, and therefore recommends denial of the petition. Attachments: Location Map (1 page) Memo from City Engineer leff Oliver and Public Works Specialist Eric Eckman dated August 7, 2013 (2 pages� Memo from Fire Chief Mark Kuhnly dated August 6, 2013 (1 page) Sketches of Subdivision Options (2 pages) Preliminary Plat/Site Plan (2 pages) 1 ' 'x V,-t,7 �.. = f'� ' l.__J� ��''" ��/ s, l�`Afi�a►reaqua#�d ��~^�- �.,�� � �s.. ._ .� _ ... ,.� . , � z d r� �., ( � `'� �� �,�'r ,�� J�' �. .� �- �, ° �.,_- � ..� �� � ��.,^. t3rchv�y.,sc_� � �y- ,,-' - � -. ��., � `- ,r � --� . �` , �-�y' r �z� �, � `~,-'��:--,. "---y�°,.� �` '°. �'« � �, �m �_�"��.. �' � � -`-"---..�_...... �vA. � �. ' �..� � � �� �rr �-^� •.._� Q� .5 �,� l+'�E3tbcrnd i7d� ' ��� � _---I p` ...... _ �a= � � �� / � � ` f�.,. �' �-i - _ �r� �okd��WaitQy FT '�., �.. �,,, a� ,� ��_" � I ; �� :--� _ �, . '�y"-"t� r�� ' v T ,-_' ��� � '�:� '� � � �, }c�c.��t�'"`� tL � ""^,,/ ` `� I � g � b". �L._- ff : _� _): �l � =r� --�- , e � _ _. .1 v r-^� ` --. »� �''� 'Setr�lE,�v�. _ ,� ;r �.� _ �,--.—�: ; � �f � � � � r �.''' �� ` � ,�` � � � � � � y��',F��"d�°�,sS`,, i ', -''"-. � � ,,t� a�c � .r.+' �Jt$'� �.� r,"�/� � "'""° �F�y ''� � ^�,� � .�r ''.s .��� � �'°.`,� t y - i �t i�r�i9 ti.� C' "^�.,.� ,««..o.� �`� �� � '�: 1 ^�,.,+,�� 3������Ili��j���a o a(s{�n� � T ,� � ,.�r '` ,� t V���y�ii��l N,''�`i r� i r� .�: � � �"''� 'C a� �o- f ���I���,�s""� ����� � , . ` _ � /�//. ,�ry, 4a. �.' ���'.... t� y: � i ��X h :({{ �l r� �(/ � '4 11 . �. .. .,'d.� . ....,_„ -T ����'.���i��R �� \ �� � ..� —��f�r � �� . �... � ,, �� � `�s_ �---_ 1 � ,�`. °� , `�.� ° -�'�� Subject Property ���� �., ,r�- ��`�-.'. _. ---a _.. '#� �'�..� / t-'��. •.'� .�-- �;�, Y�`., `� j',�'*, "'M �7 �.�,,.r' � �, � � �•�`" .,,,�"^, `-' t �.� � �ti —..\ 7 `'l. �`�7�. 1 f �/ � ~'�'�, '�, �f'�i�'��. i`� �4 r���� , � --� _.. w� � � � � _ .. 'm��----� ,� � � � r R��� t``�f .-�_._t..._..._�..... a� � i r�',i f",:� l'1 e�ri Lr�1Y€►a F01rd���`� /�`�``\ �^�,.` - t ."�+-,. ti_._...--�.. I i� � � �' �. , a1�'� . r F. ,.� � �;.... _.. ,_ �-Y i�!>��i - � � � 1 �, , _��_,, �t Gfta'sX RlS�e hl_..=:..,., � fi��ii ri 1 �`. `t� +� � �,� I g� Cfk z . iif r��r�f .- �i . � �^....�'��i,t f, . .,�Y � ' s E^yi //�fir/� i�'���`"� ._ �_ ,� o ,� `\ � - -- _--. �.. -- , a� Gs.!.........._ ii�ff,% ,, .�„ . ,��^y �. � � " � = �r��;� ,_ F� ,. 1{ �, ti.��`�/ � c�� �� Po'fddee�t tak�8 l�crnd:ZA" } ��`.,�y,��` t _ --- _ ,JN:�� . '� �-�\ f`��t� _ e���t�a. ��� � � . .m V�+i�sc��a�t°�, ,� A_ � m. ..�o .�.� -� � � �x ��klid�lem t�Arra�s#�'ov�d 28� l=� mr n � � f�°�-=� �' ��-. 4��°� ! *�s_ I `< <k � .i}�e .�. � 4\ . i�it�� ti � � 4 �� �°•, ', f C_.: n��7'�..��... f� ��� �.'," f a � .� � � I)i�„� ti'`'` � I�q. f �� �t� � � a & . �`,, . .✓ `a �i � / `� 4 � w'�, T(J1edU/',Ar�geFO POeatf 1J `�` . �4 � J "�va I��� �d �,�' � �„ J v > V �'` � � � ' t r a� � � � � ��� �4 °d ��y�^~•.���•M1 � 1��IiW'U��'Mi Bj!�T�"`-" � X i y M11 r,�.,.__.I')GC�'LtBd'��lu�/OFl�G.�.�". � ,� � a� � �� � i d ��"'�----� � -JjI �, , �j.,�/� ��� Y d at�;�i p a� / ����;�(ry�� - //f� � —� 1ti �Y/f.{ �� �� �Yt) �� �`�`�oo �/ � ���m�� �`��� ���,���f,l\ \ � jda4�,�firg�;t c� �_ ; Y rl��`�� i f 4�_ f� � S �� �'"_ fiD �..,_ � '` N��� ��+y 1 � �' � ��`wFtr C�+e � � _ , � �, . ��� � �� f : �- ,. + ,< °AFtr�t€&�d - `, + i, � �! �''- ` a �, �^ � 1`h�Odc�re Wit�h i��i+�tt3t i��Ck �'� � , ,� , "''� � ��� ��� ,����ti � ,i4i,`�a�„ �(� � �,� � k t 11��`'19Ii�i�.���I���II��S����s���� . . L ��4��� � (. �qii (, ` i �t�a:��w�i;wc�u� urTM�,�;>a����c�s�ss ' �3�a10u!��, � a., �q�IV��a: �fi 717#t 1 Cl�"�1' Q� ����� � � � � � � � � � � � ��, �� Public Works Department 763-593-8030/763-593-3988(fax) � , P. � _. ,_ � ,� � Date: August 7, 2013 To: Mark Grimes, Community Development Director From: Jeff Oliver, PE, City Engineer� �"'�, Eric Eckman, Public Works Specialist� Subject: Hanson Wood Shores Subdivision Review Public Works staff has reviewed the plans for the proposed Hanson Wood Shores subdivision. This proposed development is located on Sweeney Lake at the intersection of Major Drive and Noble Drive. This proposed subdivision consists of dividing one large vacant parcel into three single-family parcels. This memorandum discusses issues identified during the Public Works review that must be addressed prior to resubmittal of preliminary plans. The comments contained within this review are based on the plans submitted to the City on July 1, 2013. Public Works staff has performed a preliminary review of the plans and recommends denial of the proposed subdivision as shown in the plans submitted to the City for the following reasons: 1. Lots 2 and 3 do not have adequate frontage on a public street. • The plans propose the platting of a 30-foot wide outlot containing a private driveway which would serve Lots 2 and 3. The preliminary utility plan shows the extension of watermain and sanitary sewer main to serve these two iots. If these utilities are intended to be public (City-owned), staff requires access to these facilities for maintenance purposes via a public street.The only way the outlot and shared driveway could remain as proposed is if the utilities are privately owned and maintained, and a private utility maintenance agreement is executed outlining the ownership and maintenance respansibility. 2. The preliminary grading plan must show proposed contours. It is difficult to determine the overall grading impacts and disturbed areas as proposed. 3. The preliminary utility plan must include a profile view, standard details meeting City standards, and use of appropriate symbols and line types meeting City plan standards. In addition, it does not appear that a professional licensed engineer has designed the utilities or signed the utility plan. G:\Developments-Private\Hanson Wood Shores\Subdivision review.docx 4. The parcel being subdivided is heavily wooded, and therefore must include a tree inventory and preliminary tree preservation plan for review by the City Forester. 5. Stormwater quality improvements must be shown on the plans. • Sweeney Lake is included on the federal list of impaired waters and a Totai Maximum Daily Load (TMDLj Implementation Plan has been approved to guide water quality improvements within the sub-watershed. Based on the size and scale of the development, review by the Bassett Creek Watershed Management Commission (BCWMC) is not required. However, consistent with the Sweeney Lake TMDL Implementation Plan, the City's Stormwater Management Ordinance, and requirements for past developments on Sweeney Lake, the developer would be required to, at a minimum, dedicate to the City a conservation easement which establishes a natural or native vegetation buffer along the lakeshore. In conclusion, Public Works staff recommends denial of the proposed subdivision as shown in the plans submitted to the City. If the Planning Commission or City Council approves the subdivision as proposed or with minor modifications, Public Works staff requests the opportunity to further review and provide additional comments based upon those decisions. C: Tom Burt, City Manager leannine Clancy, Director of Public Works Mark Kuhnly, Chief of Fire Gary Johnson, Building Official John Crelly, Deputy Fire Chief �e Hogeboom, Planner AI Lundstrom, Park Maintenance Supervisor and City Forester Joe Fox, �ngineer G:\Developments-Private\Hanson Wood Shores\Subdivision review.docx ����� ��� �� � . �� � , G �tiu�� ��� �d �a � �����u� ��� , . ��w. Fire Department ��3-s�s�-$o�s/���-s��-so�s (f�X) Date: August 6, 2013 To: Mark Grimes, Director of Planning & Zoning From: Mark Kuhnly, Chief of Fire & Inspections Subject: Minor Subdivision - Hanson Wood Shores (previously Wessin Property) The Golden Valley Fire Department has reviewed the Minor subdivision for the Hanson Wood Shores project. Listed below are the fire department comments. 1. Lot 1 as proposed appears to be aceeptable based on Minnesota State Fire Code. 2. Lots 2 and 3 as proposed do not meet the requirements of Minnesota State Fire Code. The following need to be addressed: a. The private driveway is approximately 290 feet in length. A fire road that exceeds 150 feet shall be provided with an approved turn around. b. The drawing does not detail the clear width of the private road and to what standard the road will be constructed to. c. The fire hydrant appears to be 90 feet off of the road way. The distance from the edge of the road to the fire hydrant shall not exceed 10 feet. It appears that the fire hydrant may be 20 feet off of the edge of the other driveway d. The plan does not indicate the size of the water line supplying the fire hydrant. A 6 inch water line is the minimum size line to possibly be considered If you have any questions, please contact me at 763-593-8080 or by e-mail, mkuhnlv@�oldenvallevmn.�ov r I Hennepin County GIS-Printable Map http://gis.co.hennepin.mn.us/Property/prinUdefault.a � Interactive Property _ _ nnaps Map �n �.: � �. � � � . ,n+" �,�` .. J t �r. ` r t �����,°� �,'N ,��� +�_ � -a��5�=��k„ � �'s+�&' �.. Y�.Pqr Y � ,P+.�.: .�* .+, j �. �a�s. e . � � �� . %' '„ ���, �� �~`l `� ,��"", 1 '� - _ ' � '`��r�r, ;, � � �. � �� ` � ! Z �''���' �'� � .�.,.,,�� 'iw`� ,'` ` y � � "�'� '� ��� - �_ i. �1�15 ` .� '. ` , ,n , �`�;'x. ,,b,. �. �-. ;°' _* . $ t�;;2 �4� r_ � � .,� ,�,���q. ,�;,,* �f �_ . ' '.�. ` � � '�".,,� •� � 4Ki. . �_.i , K Y �� ry+ �. • �Y e E . �r - � �y :'��•`� F'1. �...ra.�-y� ir••o. ��_ � �4 "ly 7 L� �... k..q� . 4 A�t A, �`'' � �� *�-.� �� t� <�..�,,;w:' . � � t'�� �� � �� � .-��� ��. *w _.� TM. � �<;�" ;�2 i � � i� �� � +x� "`� x��„ , � � �. � � ���, „ � � '"�, �"s`"a.;�< .. y�1� j) � . . Y • � �y.Y . � �v �'. a r� .> .. ��„�I`�I �'��. ; . #..s •$4: . 'y.,'+k' ~�I. �i. ° . �y .. ' .. �'�2 ��`. . �"+!'�!`P�' . ya_ ��'r i� ���� .t .'.i�i.'' . � . A �. ':,3. �'�.M�,� y.r., .. . , . . . 4 ''R.rt.{. ' �'"*`x r �� T � • � . �u, j��il�I Irv I'i � ��'. a �'�d . .. �, �yy��#,�h .. .. . w`"w'•'�P.� un, Yd �,. �;��� « ,1 � , ��xX`:c, , «i tr . � e"'��. �,:„ �i � � �.��. ., � � � ,. .r5 ,+.y.. �'` & ::..k "' •�: �, . . ♦ � .r, � : b . �i5. : ,... ,;�y:. �"4��� ��'.. ,�, � .x_ �a '4'� ��. ... . � y � ' * _ �� ^'.- � . s ,�t'�`s.� �..' �� � . . � ����e°"v"�,.:.„ t.��' �';' .��. S. -�� �"' �; t _ �� • � � '� � , �,. ;- . . .y� '� '�:� � �- �,�,.�R'+� �"t ��y '� ' .. 4. - ' .. . �i.S�T� .�"�_.'r �r c ,...$!�" ,� -�'. , . M NOTES: Map Scale: 1"=100 ft. �� -Enter Notes Here- Print Date:4/9/2Q13 -�--�-+- ' ^ � E� r r �A�e.�' E� This map is a compilation of data from various sources and is furnished"AS IS"with no representation or warranty expressed or implied, inciuding fitness of arry particular purpose, merchantability,or the accuracy and completeness of the information shown. � � COPYRIGKi 0 HENNEPRV COUNTY 2013 2t, " : aen; � _-----_ _ ____.______._.. .._ .,___.__ _ F lennepin County G1S- Printable Map http://gis.co.hennepin.mn.us/Property/prinddefault. �.,� Interactive Property M�p� Map ,� � �� �� ��� ;� ,�:t�� � � � _� �. _ '�' ,`� �� � ..; ,�, . ,.�= ��� . �,.,� , t . ' r�. ,. „ _ � �� , � � e � �,. z , � � � ��� �-.'�e� ��=`: � �+. � � 4,�� � �"� �4 I �� - �, ;w � ?E, �'�+. �` .�w . .�.�, i�� ° �, u � � � � � a K �.,* `S � , a �« "�-_ '��.. ..� �=„�� -�_ „y,��,� �.4...�� . . �. . . . _ ��F ��qy ~� :,�, �� '�± �•� li � M � •�.�°?ya, 3 ,SP •� ` � ..�� 2t�4'. 'K ��' _.. _ y'iU �F YT�[ ,�TW{ ;. �-a.. �r, ��`��P« �.O ��� �t`� .<�.V i, �� c�. . �� -V`�.. � 'a � � ��. � : '� -y� . � 3��z�:- ,:�.� � 'S <+- � •? ��� a:- .� ,���` - ' `�' 'r^�'x.' `,. �_��.�. ,tA� ��� .. ;,,,;�,� . - $ ` "��' �� �F�`` " � �"�_�,� "� �.�,.^' � -�',:, ��: a � �� �� � ��� � � � � ° � �� � � '�: - �Y �. w�� . �. � ��"YT � . � . � � � �� ����,',� - � � ` � ��, ��y._ : � " ; , � � �` �..x ,'� � �,�x .. - �+'w �� ..rf .. � �, �p5'*' y`,= . - , ��k�.:. � � �` � r.�-� +t35 M.�� , .'•�..'!j .�a� `'. „�''� ' rnsSA y n� �i � ' ,� .� �,,,�'� a� �'` .. ,� � .... ��'�'. `Y�., � Y � � }�, q i`e ,�-1!)x0.R�..�' � y�+���� � ���.. � Y i �4+�i� � ��� ��.�.�'} �:, �, m � �, � ,.. ` �. 7r � �� , �-� „�,. � �� , , �_ �--'� -� � r� , � 'i� `. ` r,,� � L � � . `�4�. . . � - `�„ '°.�:. '�,� i ��� � � •�'4 �� '�. � �. ,_\ - �` t. .. . ..8.:�' ..s � .. � . .. 3 � . . � ... o NOTES: Map Scale: 1"=100 ft. tJ -Enter Notes Here- Print Date:4/9/2013 � �'A f'T' i°A.Q C E"� This map is a compilation of data from various sources and is fumished"AS IS"wdh no representation or warranty expressed or implied, including fitness of any particular purpose, merchantability,or the accuracy and completeness of the information shown. � COPYRIGHT�HENNEPIN COUNTY 2013 � ' �j - . . -_,-c£r: �f�II 41��76�X1/d � �ti6ti-£Lti-ZS6�3NOHd� � � � tl39lNfIN 35N3�f1'NNNY E' _�31tl0 ' 9.�£9S NW`3�it/'1 JNO'1 3ARICI MO��IM'N S't�i+ Z�� S213NNt�1d aNb''1'S210J13A21fIS�NVI`S2133P11JN3 ll/11� ,os�„� •�ossuu�W�o���o�,ei� M�a � � iepun�oRenmg pue�pasua��F�np e we�ieip pue � '�NI S31dI�OSSb� � Ja38N021J ��-t-t uo�r�,,oa�s�,yaw,sPun,oaw�y�,ea�,asem sNavwaa xa 31V4 3.w uodaio'ue�d'Ranmss�4tle41N4ia��q�yl 3NJIS3 �JN��.S���� � Q W � � � OC Z ° t/'� �� O � r- W c �, � � � � � m +=�� i � • � � � �� ♦A � �/1 Z Z m� �y�, C E V� \/r � �� m$ m >,� w � W � ��� �.� � � � � o Q /� V/�/ � � ++ y w- O L (p � U N . Y� ■ � � � c N�� > � a � ' � � � � w ~�C � n� � C � � a m� m�-' v r ON �i z a � � � °ca�i o $' �; w 4i. � ,;,� LLO o�� o a�ni ° �� n w a M /� � .. Z ,�uj'o �-�o u,3 � N � � W V � aOV �'= m c �� � O o Z ,c^ � `,,.. ~ m�n N m o� 'o � ?�o C� w ° � C � V Z U a2c t �O �Y �i3 ��� z � � O � � � � ,� oQ, -� � o �J� � m Q �,J O i( — W �a= �Q..E � �c v�, w Z ^� a o v ♦^ W � W o a�=� � a�im � �a� y vi�g c7 � � � —� m,� 7.Q�,C O O X � �W a—j Z W v♦ � � � � Q O� N V O `-=W L W�2W �... (7 U.;,, y � a � as p ui �' m �W cV� c� R' Q � �J J H QZ I�-� N • � �m OUe �= W Q O — f_ `� 2 � 2 '�,�„ � z��z�'��,,,,� By �nr�. �7S,� Ec�` � ��Bt B2y�%<J �tu/�gl�'O^�J/y.. . . /�� °'y 0'l�i y. N 7as! eW y���' �� -a�,o �rE��,� sl�e "��y��u�� � ��ie�ie, �' �"'es���t ��� a'�•�, '"'eu �Nto �'�e '�'�>>o �\\ p,� �fo��rtq��S!p� 89 � � � � re e����JW��� �� e4�H �/ � �%o �� ' � � � �° .��N � � .�e ° ��.�� � ,� g8� v� 5 , � - � ;�°�'° W ���� ' M�`"sb� M , , � ,� � S s , ° ����� e � ��� I - / �°� ,°� '� / ' / � � � � � / / � 1 \ �\ ��gs�� o/��as F�bS r�, ;-.. � ,, ��,� � �,,� .`�, �'dF�s,� (/ �� •' � � �— '� � s�-e«s, s,o -a a� �s /� `�`` � � \ \� � � � ��`z�'W�/y�3��bp \ i°on /� \\`\ \ . \ / \\ \``\�� �\d I�s _ \yJ C` �\ � ` O � � � � ��-`q� ���` �� \ �3• , �� �*%--_� �� � � ��� \ � r �` �\ �/ y \ �---, �� � � �`` / � `�� �� � � ����� � � � \ � � ,�� - : ,;��( � � \ � � / \ \ 1 � �/l —�y_'_ � � � "b£\ � � �\� ,� ~ \ � � =oo /// I � �(/���__—�,---1 �=�� \ \���\���b\ J \ l 'y I I � �1 � � �' \ Q \ � . 'zi� I � � � / � !-i�—g�� \� � l ��,.*�y � \\ l . � � ��_ _ °'�� + � I �% �' I� •..:'•�� ���� ' � �� �� � W ` S` �T-o i ��/ � ,--� ��l �` .�' I . \�� � ° ��,�� �/ i / � l � - •� � y � �` \� ��4 �� � e\ 1 w � / .� �� / / • \ / \ �� ` \\�/ A� �G m �� �w �o / ' I I � . � ' I � � ���\ � � 2 � .'�', g(�po\e � � Z I ��I��� ( � ¢� ���-��•, ' ��� / �r \� � � � \� . + � � , �n�e � � , �__'� � � �r, N o � � �� / � �� � � �� / _. 0'�Cd�e�� ' ,� n� _ \�/I y�-\-y� �� /l s ��� � \ . II P1$,O / � o�`� � _ J 7 _' t��_ ��_ _�J 9 � / � \I \t �g� 2� ` ^J.�—�__ . _ �t __� �1�. -+SS� � � � � � / / � �� � 0m _ �=� — L`� ,� �_J , __ !� -� � i �� . aj � _ br � -,, -+oei—�' � _ � � �,°�. � •�s�ezo �`� � n� —--�' __��� -�—--� �°:��g � .. �--�-----oze�r--- 9 --__ ' � + oe�a�o�ia��°w � 8988a21 � � •,�;�L8'SEI= �` �!.____—,_ .. . I . "ry,uosuyoJdry y ' y� .e /' c i ��. // . °ro ".�, ssro z� -M �o aiv a ioar i I .. I s�s.�Zs�alf �S - sM 'S ba"J � � " �� . - N ��� I � . � u�; .: _ I I �l' . \� -- - -• • I I � �\ -- ------------- 1-------1--- , , �----------------- -- -- —o —1 . , � � i ' . � � I •- � I � �.i i � ,-: I � � 1 ------------� � I I � N W 4 .a "�t�$"£Lf�-ZS�6�X�d� . 41►G1r'£L1►-ZS6=3NOHd � �r a3�Y�N 3SN3�11 NNWY ����va 99��5 P��Fi`��IV`7;91d0"I 3AI21Q MO��IM'N S'i►V �� � ° S21efNNV'ld C'i�1�°I`S2101i�/�21f1S UNtll`S21H3PlI�JN3,llal� As-�.t •eioseuuiw w=teis aW lo s�+el ay� Nnnvaa •���� i . r� �,,/ n /�� n �� �.,� �apun�o�(anmS We'1 Pes�a�!l�InP e we 1 te4i Pue SH21V W321 A8 31Ha ������J���Y � �✓���1`�o�J £�'l'L � uaswadns�WAw�apun�oawRqpa�eda�dseM ' �w uoa�,�o•��a��Nnss�wuw��aa,�i 3NJIS3 SNOISI/��2J � , � � �/ � � —� Q j.L. a ~ d' 0 z Z � � � � � � T W � � � '� � � m �o � . Z �i � d3 � -a � � � • � Z m� ��� � m c� W Z g �_ �° � �. � W Q , W m�o �� � m � � o Q � `" (n �'�m 0 �.U � C Q N O � � � � L �- C N ��(0 C f6 1 Z LLJ ha; C � p„� � C � —� F— � v�� mo = � � w Z a Nm � ca� o c � c� cv w � � O o�� omo C9m°.$ � n W O " � Z -CWO �°-a°� �� > � � � � W O O �O� �= � c+, � om� � qC O o Z � � " � � ��" m Z C) � � ~ V a Yaa�i 3�> '� ai° � nm v� �- Z w r- J � � U Q= C LQ'� NNU'd'03 W�'J Z � J � Z W t�Q= >.fl.,E m m mN ys 3WQ � Q Q Z � � ,� o. � m=� z� m � �� �.o�, �mZ � ; ° � � W J .. .. � � � � Z � �o� N.�o 0 owa`a= ��ZO � � � �� N fA A N Q�'J � � � � � Z � J F- Q_Z F-'�6 (6 • ° � ��m 0 C��C� W ¢ � � Zz W a - _ � = J W � a ��6(� M4&R � � Z��Z[ �f�� . .. � . �cnp� e���tqa, �7Slo�6t�t . '"'�e�t el@�,�� /��v��N-�r ���\\ � °'vs ��N•Zf£gZB�.,N��y�91� �����t�jQt . �l ��\ :,,� �����f�,�eN� M�h.f&,�_ g�'/' ��reqp°>!o `� �°�� Sto�rtq1�0�'�S�p� 88 . � \� �a��,�qp�,���� � ,, �j�b, � � �� � , ,. � ; �� o .��N .y � �� S �_' � /�8 0, W M` �.6p�2S � � ��:, �� Ms / ���n o� � � / � �°�° � ,� / � � \�� � � � � � � � � �� � � � � �� s,� a`'':�£°�S / � _�\ '�"' �s ���```,,��-. � / ��i� � \ �`_ � e� B� s �ya� s �.` � `t 09 � � \ �� ^ ` ���g�b��YO \ 'e°a . \ � � � ��/ `���gM ' vu _ �� , ,,�, _�— _ � — �� , ���` \ ,��- , � \ •.i___ � � —� �n � �\� � � '\� \� •�3' ! y do�p�M--- �\\ �e�\� � / �� \_� \ \ �` � �� '�L� �� � \ \ \ \ \ � � \ � � �/l — ,�t �� / •"0E` \\�\/ �\�� �~\\� \— 1 0 � f 5� __� � � ���i� � � � \ \ � L_ �_�1 �• � �� � / �_� ) f � � ti � 's � � � '�� �� � a / i s � � � � �' �'� ' �'� � � � �� � � ��"'_ a°� � � \� � a� �� � �se �i // � \ � b � '�--�--.-J �_ > o�� �( r+� o�. �� -r- '�� '��'~/ /\ °' 6�\� � a�v-� i �c i �o �� �� a �� �.,t / , • �/y � a �, �\� g . , , I . e\� � ��1L ' � ��O l�i � � � . �.F / � !�'�j .�/ i.\ . Q-�G 3 � ,F.^� z I � I / � � I � .r 2 \ 1 � � N � b � �.,7 ' B�De\e � Z I �WI��Z l �/ ��/ �- � ' � /��.� / � \� \ \ \�/ \� . I ei �an�e o �_� ` � � � �/ M%/ // / o a�o� � � \/ � .. p�`Cd�p� ' a� ` \ /� / �u/ �/ b�� W � M , � � \ I P;�\ � �� \ _°w�,y �\_/o< /J � � � ; � ' \ �g� 2° . . , ,>:--�------� o ''�� �_ o�� � �� � � / / a tl �� � j/ 1 m�m y L� � �_J � �;�.�, � � � / '�, ——�X .— �a �� -a e , ���� . . • �7� " -•�`i•,.. NW S�R:.�_ � � ,�—'� c eb 2� rc_ E . . _��r4 3 ,,,._� -.,�vaa 1f3M3S�3S6dO�d .DOZ p3 ,� ` —J�96, p -"�R6 �° . . - . ..._—i�__ SS'CxH Y108 ' �_ 9g O Z=Z'I �'� .'"�a�ss�_ ..— oa°1T05•w » 3� i .. obuo� ..�C O lai�nry � / . � I ,p Suyo�g y I d� ,� A � _ _ �. x / � UMo I s'S v saosss°s ��$� � Zl 9 -a � ss Mdisv�be�os� p i . . � I . I su S�yss�os �rc? ku �� ".xp �`S� bHS)b O r ( N �a� .� � . � � � � ;.._.., o� �_ . � � : _ \ - .. .. I I ` '�\ �--- --1--- I----- ---------- --------------------o — � — � I � � � � " I � • : � � I �-----------� I I I � N W q M i p ♦ i�